
The best cod and haddock alternatives for your fish supper
A chart displays the regulars – cod and haddock – but below are a number of options. Hake is advertised as 'a mild and slightly sweet-tasting white fish, similar to cod or haddock, slightly firmer flake, but great sustainable alternative.' It also shows plaice, hoki, rock salmon (also known as huss, it's 'not as flaky as cod but has a mild, sweet-taste'), calamari and scampi.
Owner Ryan Harrison, who opened the award-winning chippy in 2021, says cod and haddock are by far the biggest sellers. But other fish are slowly making inroads. Harrison sells up to 10 species each day, which might include fillets such as hoki or plaice. 'It's still very small, but people that have ordered rock salmon, for example, are reordering it, because they like the taste. Hake is similar to cod, but a lot of people don't like to change from something they've always had.' Perhaps customers are less resistant than he thinks – M&S reports that sales of hake are up 125 per cent on last year, a sure sign that the gap is narrowing.
Soaring cod prices
Chip shop owners like Harrison are coming to terms with the environmental impact of overfishing. Cod prices reached their highest level ever late last year, forcing some chippies to remove it completely. The war in Ukraine, climate change and lower quotas due to declining stocks – which are largely fished by Norwegian and Russian firms – have all been blamed.
This has encouraged operators to look for other options, often more sustainable species caught in the UK. Harrison was part of a delegation led by Andrew Crook, president of the National Federation of Fish Friers, which visited Newlyn in Cornwall to meet Cornish fishermen. It spurred him to trial alternatives, and though he says cod and haddock will always be top choice, the fortune of alternatives is rising. With cod prices soaring, they are not always more expensive. Harrison sells haddock for £7 and cod for £8. Rock salmon is £8, hake £8.50, Cornish haddock £9.50. All are roughly the same size.
Creatures of habit
Britain likes to think of itself as a seafood-loving nation – witness the prominence of fishermen in the Brexit debates – but in truth it isn't. We eat a narrow range of species, 80 per cent consisting of the big five: cod, haddock, salmon, tuna and prawns. Much of our seafood, some of the best in the world, gets exported. Enjoying langoustines and scallops in a sunny Spanish resort? Chances are they came from Britain.
Britain's cooks, from chip shop owners to Michelin-starred chefs, hope to reverse the situation. Last month, The Caterer announced there has 'probably never been a more interesting time for seafood in this country'.
Branching out
One restaurant working closely with environmentally conscious fishermen is Beach House Falmouth. It has a long-established relationship with Ned Bailey, who has fished Cornish waters for decades. For Bailey, it is crucial chefs – and customers – broaden their horizons. 'It puts less pressure on the stocks of 'favourite' fish and shellfish, which is great for helping sustainability but also increases demand for less popular species, which would hopefully increase the price fishermen get for it,' Bailey says.
Beach House Falmouth's head chef Jack Frame enjoys the challenge. 'It's important to push people out of their comfort zones, it's better for conservation but also just exciting to try new things.' Frame says hake is popular, while monkfish and gurnard appeal to those seeking 'firmer and meatier' fish. For fish and chips, Frame has used mullet, hake and sole. 'Luckily these are easier sells, as it's battered.'
Not everything is a hit. Some find cuttlefish, similar to squid, 'a bit scary', although Frame cooks it into familiar classics, like a cuttlefish ragu, and guests 'always end up loving it'.
Championing the underdog
Jack Stein, chef director at the renowned seafood restaurant group founded by his father, Rick, has long championed more obscure species. Last year, he launched an 'Unsung Seafood Species' campaign promoting lesser-known and underappreciated seafood, including cuttlefish, cockles, whelks, megrim sole, razor clams and more. Stein recommends hake, coley and ling instead of cod and haddock, and oily mackerel over tuna – though only if it's caught with a line and hook. Red mullet and gurnard, both 'sweet and delicate', are also favourites of his, while the little-known and 'absolutely delicious' weever fish 'deserves more recognition in the UK' despite its venomous spines. 'Fortunately, our guests tend to be seafood enthusiasts, open to exploring new flavours,' he says.
In London, renowned Borough Market seafood restaurant Applebee's relaunched in February and executive chef Frankie van Loo is committed to expanding Britain's repertoire. 'Lots of people might not realise their usual favourite suspects aren't always available from UK shores, and that we're in danger of overfishing certain species.' Aside from classics – think dover sole meunière and fish and chips – van Loo aims to educate customers about seasonality, why certain fish shouldn't be caught during spawning periods, and how widening our choices allows stocks to replenish.
Following the Cornwall Good Seafood Guide, van Loo opts for the likes of monkfish and sea bream. 'We know scallops, sea bass, tuna, prawns and salmon will sell, it's what people know. We try to balance our menu with a combination of these fish and some lesser-known varieties such as red mullet, gurnard, cuttlefish and whiting.' Currently, a butterflied red mullet in bouillabaisse sauce is popular, and the chef hopes to swap cod and haddock for other species for fish and chips, such as whiting and pollock.
Diversity is key
Seth McCurry, UK & Ireland senior commercial manager at the Marine Stewardship Council, says: 'Diversifying the types of fish we eat is important because by eating different types of fish and seafood, we're spreading out the demand, giving some species a break and encouraging fishers to catch a wider variety. This helps make sure we aren't putting too much pressure on any one particular species.' McCurry says 37 per cent of global fish stocks were overfished in 2024, but the volume of pollock and hake sold has increased, while brands like Birds Eye are diversifying their ranges, including the little known silver smelt.
Getting people to switch isn't always easy, says Ben Champkin, chef patron at Catch at the Old Fish Market in Weymouth. The likes of herring and sprat have a 'distinctive, robust taste' and oily texture that some find overpowering. Their appearance can also be less appealing than more familiar trout or cod, says Champkin.
Back in Cornwall, Bailey would like to see more Britons eating spider and velvet crab, which mostly are shipped to Spain. 'Post-Brexit costs have made exporting much more expensive, so a lot of smaller firms have ceased exporting.' Eating a wider range of seafood is not only environmentally beneficial, it can help British fishermen, too.
Four recipes to try
Hake
Pollock
Mullet
Cuttlefish
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Exclusive: CEO of Russia-backed Indian refiner Nayara resigns after EU sanctions, sources say
NEW DELHI, July 25 (Reuters) - Russia-backed Indian refiner Nayara Energy has named a new chief executive after its previous CEO resigned following European Union sanctions that targeted the company, four sources with knowledge of the matter said on Friday. Mumbai-based Nayara has appointed company veteran Sergey Denisov as chief executive to replace Alessandro des Dorides, the sources said. Denisov's appointment was decided at a board meeting on Wednesday, they said. Nayara Energy, partly owned by Russian oil major Rosneft ( opens new tab, did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Des Dorides, who joined Nayara Energy in April 2024, did not immediately respond to a message sent on LinkedIn. Denisov has been with the company since 2017. Nayara Energy has condemned the EU's "unjust and unilateral" decision to impose sanctions. India has also said it does not support the bloc's sanctions.


Times
an hour ago
- Times
Trump's Scotland visit could be awkward for Starmer — here's what to expect
President Trump's first official trip to the UK since his re-election is highly unpredictable. The White House has nominally described it as a 'private' trip, which ostensibly involves visits to his golf resorts at Turnberry on the Ayrshire coast and Menie in will inevitably be about much more than golf, though. Trump will be accompanied by the full apparatus of the US state — Air Force One and his state car, The Beast. • Trump's links to Scotland — from golf courses to family history Thousands of police officers will be present and the full cost of policing the trip is likely to be more than £10 million, based on previous Trump Keir Starmer will meet the president at Turnberry on Monday, with a formal bilateral meeting and lunch. The White House expects them both to head to Menie, where the US president is expected to play a round of golf to mark the opening of his new course. Given that Starmer has little or no interest in golf, it could be an awkward affair. And as ever with Trump, it is a case of expecting the unexpected. At the centre of the agenda for talks between Starmer and Trump will be trade. The White House said that it wanted to 'refine' the deal hammered out between the nations this year, but what does that mean in practice? Starmer has two priorities, the first of which is removing 25 per cent tariffs on steel exports to the US. There has been a disagreement about the types of steel that would be covered by a zero-tariff quota system, with a discussion over whether imported steel should be covered. The US has also been seeking assurances over British Steel, still formally owned by the Chinese Jingye Group, amid concerns that it could provide Beijing with a back door into the US market. Officials say there has been significant progress in both areas and a deal is expected. The other significant issue is pharmaceuticals. Trump has threatened to levy import duties of up to 200 per cent on drugs coming into the US. Given that the UK exports pharmaceuticals worth £9 billion a year to the US, this is a major cause for concern. A top priority for Starmer will be to ensure that Trump follows through on his dramatic shift of position towards Ukraine. A few months after his disastrous Oval Office bust-up with President Zelensky, Trump is now condemning Russia and saying that he is 'very unhappy' with President Putin for failing to honour his promises. 'He talks nice and then bombs everybody in the evening,' Trump said recently of his Russian counterpart. Trump has now pledged to send 'top of the line weapons' worth 'billions of dollars' to Europe to help defend Ukraine, while threatening tariffs on countries that trade with Russia. Given Trump's inconsistency, Starmer's priority will be to ensure that this rhetorical shift translates to reliable support for Kyiv. Trump has recently been increasing pressure on Israel to shift approach after reacting badly to what the White House described as 'pictures of starvation of women and children' in Gaza. He has shown clear signs of losing patience with Binyamin Netanyahu, months after tweeting an AI depiction of him relaxing with the Israeli prime minister in a 'Trump Gaza' resort. This presents Starmer with a question about how much political capital to deploy in persuading the president to help force a ceasefire. This week the prime minister described the situation in Gaza as 'intolerable on so many levels' and is facing increasing pressure from the left to do more, including recognising a Palestinian state. However judging how far to push Trump, given the president's long-standing support for Israel, is a delicate calculation. Trump has repeatedly raised his fears over migration in Britain and more widely in Europe, saying that mass migration had created a 'total mess' that the US should learn from. He has said that London in particular is 'no longer recognisable' due to immigration and that it was 'changing the culture' of Europe, including could be asked whether he still considers parts of London 'no-go zones' — a claim he made in 2015 as he said that parts of the capital had been so radicalised that police were afraid to go there, which would reignite his longstanding feud with Sir Sadiq Khan, the London mayor. • What Trump protesters are preparing for his 'welcome' to Scotland In the present climate Trump may have a view on the protests outside asylum hotels and the broader issue of social cohesion. Downing Street will be wary. Trump's administration has deep concerns about the state of free speech in the UK, with officials accusing Britain of 'trampling democracy' and becoming a 'hotbed of digital censorship'. The White House has 'monitored' the case of Lucy Connolly, who was jailed for social media posts over the Southport riots, while JD Vance, the vice-president, has criticised bans on praying outside abortion clinics as infringing religious rights. Vance used his Munich Security Conference speech to claim that 'freedom of expression was 'in retreat' across Britain and wider Europe', directly singling out Online Safety Act, which comes into effect on Friday, has been a particular target of criticism with the US State Department saying that it had 'concern about the spill-over effects that impact free speech in America'. For the president, golf is a serious business and that poses some tricky challenges for Starmer, who does not play. For a start, Trump faces lingering local anger outside Aberdeen over claims he never made good on promises of lucrative development made when he bought the Menie Estate in 2006. Then there is the diplomatic headache of Trump's demand that his other Scottish course, Turnberry, host the Open championship. The British government is said to have interceded with golf's government body the R&A on this issue but will be wary of lobbying for special favours to please a foreign head of state. Unlike Finland's president Alexander Stubb, who wowed Trump with his golf prowess, Starmer has been unable to rely on his putting skills to forge a relationship. Indeed, the only cabinet minister with a serviceable golf game is said to be Lord Hermer. The attorney-general and international law enthusiast, who is unlikely to gel with the president, is not being deployed on the links.
.jpeg%3Fwidth%3D1200%26auto%3Dwebp%26quality%3D75%26trim%3D221%2C0%2C2219%2C0%26crop%3D&w=3840&q=100)

Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
How premium logistics can power Scotland's exports
Mark Rosenberg | Supplied Ask a Scot to name their finest food and drink export and you're likely to spark a fierce debate, says Mark Rosenberg, Chief Commercial Officer, Ports & Terminals, at DP World Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Whatever their preference, everyone can agree that the sector is a phenomenal global success story. The numbers speak for themselves. Last year, Scotland's food and drink exports were valued at £7.1 billion. That's up from £4.9bn in 2014, an increase of roughly 46 per cent over the past decade. This is driven by a strong appetite for its premium produce, such as Scottish salmon which had shipments topping £844 million in 2024. More than a key contributor to the UK economy, Scotland's food and drink industry has become a global benchmark for excellence. However, despite extraordinary market growth, exporters are not immune from trade challenges. Post-Brexit border friction, fluctuating global tariffs and shifting consumer expectations have all made the operating environment increasingly volatile in recent years. The good news is that new trade opportunities are opening routes to growth at a critical moment. Most notably, the UK-India Free Trade Agreement, which was signed yesterday (24 July). By cutting levies on 90 per cent of the produce from Scottish exporters - and those elsewhere in the UK - the landmark deal will transform the presence of the UK's exports in India. This is especially promising for food products like Scottish salmon, which have faced prohibitive 33 per cent tariffs. Once they are lifted, exporters will have access to the world's third-largest fish market and a middle class that is expected to grow to a quarter of a billion by 2050. Understandably, many are preparing for significant long-term expansion into the market. Logistics to power exports | Supplied Premium produce requires premium logistics While the potential for growth in both nearby and distant markets is clear, capturing these opportunities depends on the essential but less glamourous matter of logistics. Ageing infrastructure can increase costs and add complexity. Scotland has felt these constraints acutely. However, the challenges also present opportunities for strategic partnerships that can deliver far greater efficiencies across the supply chain. At DP World, we're not shy of the challenge and have invested to ensure UK exporters can seize the trade opportunities of the day. Our deep sea container ports connect exporters across the whole of the UK with overseas markets. In 2013, we opened London Gateway - the UK's first deep-water container port for more than 20 years - and have committed to its growth ever since. Just a few months ago we began work on a £1 billion expansion of its port facilities and rail infrastructure and announced a further £60 million investment in the Port of Southampton. Both will boost handling capacity and improve direct rail services, offering Scottish exporters fast, low-carbon routes to global shipping networks. As exporters hurry to capitalise on the new opportunities, undoubtedly there will be many pitfalls to navigate, whether that's complex regulatory challenges, untested consumer appetites and cultural nuance. That's where the right logistics infrastructure becomes a critical enabler. Labelling and packaging requirements, for example, vary by market and can create bottlenecks if not handled with care - something DP World supports through advanced, market-specific compliance services. Untested consumer appetites also mean shipments need to be agile, fresh and first-class. In this case facilities like The Chill Hub, our temperature-controlled warehouse at London Gateway, are indispensable for high-value perishable goods like Scottish salmon. Alongside connectivity and adaptability, exporters need flexibility. With rail or barge connectivity at 95 per cent of our 20 European sites, Scottish producers have the necessary options to move goods effectively and on schedule should congestion occur. This is an area we continue to invest in, helping to build the resilience that traders will need for the decades ahead. Scotland's food and drink exporters have a long and proud history, but with new trade agreements opening doors to major, high-growth markets like India, this feels like the start of an exciting new chapter. By strengthening the logistics networks and alliances that move goods from A to B, we can help the blue-and-white 'Made in Scotland' label find new admirers around the world. That's an opportunity we can all raise a glass to.