Seven & i risks becoming buyout target again if turnaround fails
'If the stock price drops significantly, there might be a possibility of tender offers or hostile takeovers,' said Takamasa Ikeda, senior portfolio manager at GCI Asset Management, an investor in Japanese stocks.
While Seven & i shares are higher than they were before Couche-Tard's interest became public in August 2024, they fell after the proposal was withdrawn this week and are down by more than a fifth this year.
Newly appointed chief executive officer Stephen Dacus is under pressure to convince stakeholders that sweeping reforms will deliver, especially in the US and Japan, where inflation and weak demand are weighing on profits.
Seven & i is taking steps to bolster its shares with a five-year, two-trillion-yen share buyback.
So far, that has not done much, with the stock down about 7.8 per cent since the repurchase was announced on Mar 6. Some of the funding for that was due to come from an initial public offering of the US business, but Couche-Tard's exit has raised doubts over whether that plan will remain intact.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Further investor-friendly efforts will be harder to enact, given that Seven & i has already taken drastic steps to overhaul the business, according to Taku Sugawara, an analyst at Iwai Cosmo Securities.
The operator of 7-Eleven stores is on track to sell its less-profitable retail operations in a deal that will close in September, part of the package of sweeping changes announced since Couche-Tard's approach.
'Obfuscation and delay'
The Canadian group's campaign, which if successful would have been the biggest foreign takeover of a Japanese company, ended in acrimony.
In a 1,500-word missive, Couche-Tard said Seven & i's founding Ito family had never been open to talks and blamed the board for a 'calculated campaign of obfuscation and delay'.
Seven & i responded by saying it was disappointed by Couche-Tard's decision to walk away, and disagreed with what it called 'numerous mischaracterisations' in the letter.
The remaining path for Seven & i is to pursue greater growth and profitability in the convenience stores business, which investors have been clamouring for. Two years ago, activist fund ValueAct Capital Management pushed for this strategy and unsuccessfully sought to replace Ryuichi Isaka, the prior CEO.
One issue is Seven & i's underlying performance. While operating profit for the March-to-May period rose 9.7 per cent year on year to 65.1 billion yen, it was the second-lowest quarterly result in the past decade. Domestic same-store sales remained almost flat, lagging behind competitors. The US operations squeezed out profits thanks to cost-cutting measures, but revenue remains weak.
'We are closely watching how far Mr Dacus can go in supporting and managing improvements in performance,' said Takahiro Kazahaya, a senior analyst at UBS Securities.
The CEO is due to give an update on Seven & i's turnaround strategy in August, with a focus on how he plans to improve the core convenience store business.
Giving in
Seven & i has a long history of enacting reforms under external pressure.
In 2016, concerns raised by activist fund Third Point over executive appointments resulted in the exit of former chairman Toshifumi Suzuki and Isaka's appointment. ValueAct's pressure campaign helped fuel Seven & i's decision to sell its Sogo & Seibu department stores to Fortress Investment Group in 2022 for 250 billion yen.
The latest reforms were accelerated by Couche-Tard's approach, according to Kazahaya.
While Couche-Tard may have stepped away from the deal, its decision to provide a detailed explanation in a long letter may tempt other potential bidders, activist investors, or even rivals, to join the fray.
One investor pointed out that the Canadian operator of Circle K stores could have issued a one-line statement, but chose instead to disclose details of its discussions with Seven & i, including the amount of the termination fee – US$1.2 billion – and alternate merger scenarios that were discussed.
Artisan Partners Asset Management was especially vocal during Couche-Tard's campaign, pressing the company to engage more deeply with the Canadian retailer.
In a letter sent to the company's directors in March, the US investment firm cited concerns around potential conflicts of interest and the board's 'failure to pursue the path that offers the best future for the company and maximises value'.
Another possibility is the resurrection of a management buyout by Seven & i's founding Ito family.
A nine-trillion-yen proposal to take the retailer private imploded in March after the buyout group, which included Itochu, failed to secure financing.
The lacklustre share price also makes Seven & i a prime candidate to be taken private by insiders. BLOOMBERG
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
9 hours ago
- Straits Times
Trump, Carney to speak in coming days, Canadian official says
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: Canada's Prime Minister Mark Carney arrives at a press conference to make an announcement on recognizing Palestinian statehood, in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, July 30, 2025. REUTERS/Patrick Doyle/File Photo WASHINGTON - U.S. President Donald Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney will likely talk "over the next number of days" after the U.S. imposed a 35% tariff on goods not covered by the U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade agreement, a Canadian official said on Sunday. Dominic LeBlanc, the federal cabinet minister in charge of U.S.-Canada trade, also told CBS News' "Face the Nation" that he was "encouraged" by recent discussions and believed a deal to bring down tariffs remained an option. "We're encouraged by the conversations with Secretary Lutnick and Ambassador Greer, but we're not yet where we need to go to get the deal that's in the best interest of the two economies," LeBlanc said, referring to U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer. The trade minister said he expected Carney and Trump to speak "over the next number of days." "We think there is an option of striking a deal that will bring down some of these tariffs provide greater certainty to investment," LeBlanc said. Washington linked Friday's tariff announcement in part to what it said was Canada's failure to stop fentanyl smuggling. It was the latest blow in a months-long tariff war which Trump initiated shortly after returning to power this year. Carney says Canada accounts for just 1% of U.S. fentanyl imports and has been working intensively to further reduce the volumes. REUTERS
Business Times
11 hours ago
- Business Times
US dollar tumbles;traders bet on more US rate cuts after weak jobs report
THE greenback dropped on Friday (Aug 1) and was on track for its biggest daily loss against the yen since January 2023 after data showed that US employers added fewer jobs in July than economists had expected. At the same time, last month's jobs gains were revised sharply lower, leading traders to ramp up bets on how many times the Federal Reserve is likely to cut rates this year. Employers added 73,000 jobs last month, below the 110,000 expected by economists polled by Reuters, while the unemployment rate edged higher to 4.2 per cent, as anticipated, up from 4.1 per cent in June. Job gains for June were revised down to 14,000, from the previously reported 147,000. 'It's worse than anyone expected and the kicker is that downward revision for the prior month too,' said Helen Given, director of trading at Money USA in Washington. The dollar index, which measures the greenback against a basket of currencies including the yen and the euro, was last down 1.23 per cent on the day at 98.80. The euro rose 1.37 per cent to US$1.1571 and was on track for its biggest daily gain since April. The single currency reached US$1.1389 earlier on Friday, the lowest since Jun 10. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Against the Japanese yen, the dollar weakened 2.23 per cent to 147.37. The greenback earlier reached 150.91, the highest since Mar 28. The Fed has indicated it is in no rush to cut rates due to concern that President Donald Trump's tariff policies will reignite inflation over the coming months. Fed funds futures traders pared bets on how many times the US central bank is likely to cut rates this year after Fed chairman Jerome Powell on Wednesday offered a hawkish outlook for monetary policy and declined to indicate that a cut in September was likely. But they ramped up bets on cuts again on Friday after the jobs data. Traders are now pricing in 63 basis points of cuts by year end, up from around 34 basis points on Thursday, with the first cut seen in September. The dollar extended its drop on Friday after the Fed said governor Adriana Kugler was resigning from the Federal Reserve effective Aug 8. Trump on Friday also ordered that the commissioner of the Labor Department's Bureau of Labor Statistics Erika McEntarfer be fired after the weaker than expected jobs data and downward revisions. Whether the Fed cuts in September may now depend on the next jobs report for August. '(Powell) did say on Wednesday that we were looking at holding rates steadier for longer, but that we were going to get two sets of employment data before the next Fed meeting. So as this first set has been so decidedly negative… the labour market is clearly, clearly cooling, that's going to raise the importance of that September figure as well,' said Given. The August jobs data will be released on Sep 5, with the Fed due to meet on Sep 16-17. A more dovish Fed would likely be negative for the US currency, even after it has appeared to find its footing in recent weeks following a rough first half of the year. 'Our forecast for the dollar to strengthen in the second half of the year relies in large part on our view that the US economy will remain resilient and the FOMC keep policy on hold until 2026,' Jonas Goltermann, deputy chief markets economist at Capital Economics said in a note. 'Plainly, that now looks less probable; in a recession scenario the dollar is likely to weaken against lower yielding currencies such as the yen and the euro, even if it may rally against other, riskier currencies,' he said. The dollar had gained earlier on Friday after Trump imposed new tariff rates on dozens of trade partners. The Swiss franc was among the hardest hit as Switzerland now faces a 39 per cent rate. The Swissie fell against a range of currencies in response to Trump's hefty duties and to his demand that pharma companies – key Swiss exporters – lower the prices at which they sell to US consumers. The dollar was last down 0.9 per cent against the Swiss franc at 0.805, after earlier reaching 0.8171, the highest since Jun 23. The Canadian dollar strengthened 0.43 per cent versus the greenback to C$1.38 per dollar, after earlier easing to C$1.3879, the weakest since May 22. Canada was hit with a 35 per cent tariff, instead of the threatened 25 per cent. The dollar had also gained against other currencies due to drivers other than tariffs. The yen was earlier headed for its largest weekly loss this year after the Bank of Japan signalled it was in no hurry to resume interest rate hikes, prompting Finance Minister Katsunobu Kato to say on Friday that officials were 'alarmed' by currency moves. REUTERS
Business Times
2 days ago
- Business Times
World economies reel from Trump's tariffs punch
[WASHINGTON] Global markets reeled on Friday (Aug 1) after US President Donald Trump's tariffs barrage against nearly all US trading partners as governments looked down the barrel of a seven-day deadline before higher duties take effect. Trump announced late Thursday that dozens of economies, including the European Union, will face new tariff rates of between 10 and 41 per cent. However, implementation will be on Aug 7 rather than on Friday as previously announced, the White House said. This gives governments a window to rush to strike deals with Washington, setting more favourable conditions. Neighbouring Canada, one of the biggest US trade partners, was hit with 35 per cent levies, up from 25 per cent, effective Friday, but with wide-ranging, current exemptions remaining in place. The tariffs are a demonstration of raw economic power that Trump sees putting US exporters in a stronger position, while encouraging domestic manufacturing by keeping out foreign imports. But the muscular approach has raised fears of inflation and other economic fallout in the world's biggest economy. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Stock markets in Hong Kong, London and New York slumped as they digested the turmoil, while weak US employment data added to worries. Trump's actions come as debate rages over how best to steer the US economy, with the US Federal Reserve this week deciding to keep interest rates unchanged, despite massive political pressure from the White House to cut. Data Friday showed US job growth missing expectations for July, while unemployment ticked up to 4.2 per cent from 4.1 per cent. On Wall Street, the S&P 500 dropped 1.6 per cent, while the Nasdaq tumbled 2.2 per cent. Political goals Trump raised duties on around 70 economies, from a current 10 per cent level imposed in April when he unleashed 'reciprocal' tariffs, citing unfair trade practices. The new, steeper levels listed in an executive order vary by trading partner. Any goods 'transshipped' through other jurisdictions to avoid US duties would be hit with an additional 40 per cent tariff, the order said. But Trump's duties also have a distinctly political flavour, with the president using separate tariffs to pressure Brazil to drop the trial of his far-right ally, former president Jair Bolsonaro. He also warned of trade consequences for Canada, which faces a different set of duties, after Prime Minister Mark Carney announced plans to recognise a Palestinian state at the UN General Assembly in September. In targeting Canada, the White House cited its failure to 'cooperate in curbing the ongoing flood of fentanyl and other illicit drugs', although Canada is not a major source of illegal narcotics. By contrast, Trump gave more time to Mexico, delaying for 90 days a threat to increase its tariffs from 25 to 30 per cent. But exemptions remain for a wide range of Canadian and Mexican goods entering the United States under an existing North American trade pact. Carney said that his government was 'disappointed' with the latest rates hike but noted that with exclusions, the US average tariff on Canadian goods remains one of the lowest among US trading partners. 'Tears up' rule book With questions hanging over the effectiveness of bilateral trade deals struck, including with the EU and Japan, the outcome of Trump's overall plan remains uncertain. 'No doubt about it, the executive order and related agreements concluded over the past few months tears up the trade rule book that has governed international trade since World War II,' said Wendy Cutler, senior vice president of the Asia Society Policy Institute. On Friday, Trump said that he would consider distributing a tariff 'dividend' to Americans. Notably excluded from Friday's drama was China, which is in the midst of negotiations with the United States. Washington and Beijing at one point brought tit-for-tat tariffs to triple-digit levels, but have agreed to temporarily lower these duties and are working to extend their truce. Those who managed to strike deals with Washington to avert steeper threatened levies included Vietnam, Japan, Indonesia, the Philippines, South Korea and the European Union. Among other tariff levels adjusted in Trump's latest order, Switzerland now faces a higher 39 per cent duty. AFP
