logo
Aadhaar, voter ID, ration card can't prove voter eligibility, not valid for Bihar electoral roll revision exercise: EC tells SC

Aadhaar, voter ID, ration card can't prove voter eligibility, not valid for Bihar electoral roll revision exercise: EC tells SC

Time of India2 days ago
In its response to the Supreme Court, the
Election Commission of India
(EC) has said
Aadhaar
,
voter ID
card, and
ration card
cannot be treated as valid documents for verifying entries in the
electoral rolls
of Bihar under its Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise.
The EC submitted a detailed affidavit to the court, opposing a petition filed by 11 opposition parties, NGOs, and residents of Bihar. The petition demands the scrapping of the SIR and holding the upcoming November state election on the basis of the earlier rolls revised in December.
Explore courses from Top Institutes in
Select a Course Category
Cybersecurity
Public Policy
PGDM
Degree
Healthcare
Others
Data Analytics
MBA
CXO
Artificial Intelligence
Finance
healthcare
Project Management
Data Science
Operations Management
others
Design Thinking
Digital Marketing
MCA
Data Science
Leadership
Product Management
Technology
Management
Skills you'll gain:
Duration:
10 Months
MIT xPRO
CERT-MIT xPRO PGC in Cybersecurity
Starts on
undefined
Get Details
Citizenship not affected by exclusion from voter list
The Election Commission clarified that a person's citizenship does not end if their name is missing from the electoral rolls.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
When the Camera Clicked at the Worst Possible Time
Lintmit.com
Read More
'Under the SIR exercise, citizenship of an individual will not terminate on account of the fact that he/she is held to be ineligible for registration in the electoral rolls,' the affidavit said.
It also added that the SIR process does not violate any law or fundamental rights of voters, and urged the Supreme Court to dismiss the petition.
Live Events
You Might Also Like:
ECI firm on Aadhaar, ration card exclusion ahead of Supreme Court hearing on Bihar voter revision
Voter ID and Aadhaar not enough for verification
The EC defended its choice to not rely on the Electors Photo Identity Card (EPIC), Aadhaar, or ration cards as proof of eligibility.
'The conceptual and procedural integrity of a de-novo revision would stand undermined if EPICs, which are merely reflective of prior entries, are used to validate entries in a roll that is required to be constructed anew,' the EC said. 'The EPIC, being a by-product of an earlier electoral roll, cannot substitute the verification process mandated for fresh preparation.'
On Aadhaar, the affidavit stated, 'Aadhaar is merely a proof of identity of a person. A person who seeks to claim a benefit can utilise an Aadhaar card to show he/she is who he/she claims to be... There are restrictions on usage of Aadhaar to check eligibility under Article 326.'
Fake ration cards a concern
The Commission also raised concerns about the authenticity of ration cards. It noted that due to the widespread presence of fake ration cards, the document was not included in the list of 11 documents accepted for verifying voter eligibility.
You Might Also Like:
Bihar: Election Commission shares list of people not found at addresses with political parties
'There are a large number of fake ration cards floating around in the country,' the EC told the court.
The EC further stated that the SIR exercise does not invoke Section 9 of the Citizenship Act and does not affect the legal status of any individual as a citizen.
By distancing the SIR process from citizenship determination, the EC aimed to assure the court that exclusion from the revised voter list does not mean loss of legal rights or nationality.
Aadhaar can't be the only ID for benefits: Meghalaya HC
Meanwhile, in another case, the Meghalaya High Court has said that Aadhaar alone should not be treated as the only valid proof of identity to access government schemes. It issued an interim order asking state authorities to accept other forms of identification from people who either do not have or do not wish to share their Aadhaar number.
Other documents like PAN and voter ID must be accepted
The court stated that individuals must be allowed to use alternative valid documents such as PAN cards, voter ID cards, or passports in place of Aadhaar to access schemes like post-matric scholarships or financial assistance for SC/ST students.
The bench pointed out that the Aadhaar Act of 2016 does not insist on Aadhaar being the only form of identity proof. Referring to Section 7 of the Act, the judges said that if a person does not have an Aadhaar number, the authorities must provide other ways to confirm identity and deliver the benefit.
The court also observed that the Aadhaar Act applies to 'residents' and not just 'citizens.' A resident, under the Act, is defined as someone who has lived in India for at least 182 days in the previous 12 months.
The case, brought through a PIL by activist Greneth M Sangma, challenged a state rule that made Aadhaar mandatory for availing benefits. The High Court has scheduled the next hearing on August 12, when it will review the Aadhaar Act further in light of existing laws and previous Supreme Court rulings.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

2006 Mumbai Train Blasts: Supreme Court Stays HC Order, But Frees Accused Stay Out of Jail
2006 Mumbai Train Blasts: Supreme Court Stays HC Order, But Frees Accused Stay Out of Jail

Time of India

time4 minutes ago

  • Time of India

2006 Mumbai Train Blasts: Supreme Court Stays HC Order, But Frees Accused Stay Out of Jail

/ Jul 24, 2025, 01:44PM IST In a major development, the Supreme Court has stayed the Bombay High Court's recent order acquitting all 12 accused in the 2006 Mumbai train blasts case. The top court intervened after Solicitor General Tushar Mehta cautioned that the High Court verdict could set a damaging precedent for other cases under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA). The Supreme Court clarified that the High Court ruling will not be treated as precedent. Earlier, the Bombay High Court had set aside the 2015 trial court verdict, citing lack of evidence, invalid confessions, and failure of the prosecution to establish guilt.#supremecourt #bombayhighcourt #mumbaitrainblasts #711case #mocca #terroracquittals #indiancourts #711verdict #justiceforvictims #scstayorder

‘We are going to come for you': Rahul warns EC officials on alleged lapses
‘We are going to come for you': Rahul warns EC officials on alleged lapses

Hans India

time4 minutes ago

  • Hans India

‘We are going to come for you': Rahul warns EC officials on alleged lapses

New Delhi: Accusing the Election Commission of India (ECI) of not doing its job, Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi on Thursday called it a 'serious issue', warning that poll panel officials can't get away with this as "we are going to come for you". Speaking on the possibility of boycotting Bihar Assembly elections over alleged lapses in Special Intensive Revision (SIR), Gandhi told reporters outside Parliament, 'Today they have made a statement, and this is complete nonsense.' Claiming to have caught 100 per cent cheating by the ECI in one seat in Karnataka while adding new voters aged 45, 50, and 60, Gandhi said, 'I want to give a message to the Election Commission that if you think you are going to get away with this or if your officials think that they are going to get away with this, then you are mistaken. We are going to come for you.' Gandhi said, now we have 100 per cent proof of EC allowing cheating at a seat in Karnataka by way of voter deletion and addition. Earlier, BJP leader Amit Malviya lashed out at INDIA bloc leaders for raising doubts over the SIR of electoral roll in Bihar, claiming its success and public response is a big blow to Rahul Gandhi and Tejashwi Yadav. He said that INDIA bloc leaders' comments amount to conceding defeat before Assembly elections in Bihar. 'Tejashwi Yadav's idea of boycotting the elections proves that he has accepted that the voters of Bihar have completely rejected his campaign against SIR (Special Intensive Revision),' said Malviya, who is the BJP's IT cell chief. The BJP leader said on X, 'Earlier, Tejashwi boycotted the voter revision, thinking that the people of Bihar would stand with him. But the exact opposite happened -- the people are enthusiastically participating in this SIR festival of democracy.' More than 98 per cent of the voter revision work has already been completed. This is a big blow to Tejashwi and Rahul Gandhi, he said. All their hard work has gone to waste. Not a single voter from Bihar joined them in their campaign against SIR. This is a clear indication that Tejashwi and Rahul are hyping a baseless issue, Malviya said. There is a saying, 'As soon as the head is shaved, hail falls.' There are still two-three months left for the elections, but Tejashwi, sensing his slipping ground, has already started running away in desperation, said Malviya. "These failed sons of Lalu, fearing the electoral test, are now seen looking for a way to boycott," Malviya added.

Amid Bihar SIR row, CEC Kumar says can't allow dead or permanent migrants on voters list
Amid Bihar SIR row, CEC Kumar says can't allow dead or permanent migrants on voters list

New Indian Express

time4 minutes ago

  • New Indian Express

Amid Bihar SIR row, CEC Kumar says can't allow dead or permanent migrants on voters list

NEW DELHI: Facing flak over voter roll revision in Bihar, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar on Thursday asked if the poll body can come under influence and allow the dead, those who have migrated permanently or have registered themselves as electors at multiple places be included in the voters' list. His remarks came amid stepped up attacks by the opposition parties which have been targeting the poll authority over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Bihar's electoral roll. The Opposition has claimed that the move will disenfranchise crores of eligible citizens. "Isn't a pure voter list being prepared by the Election Commission through a transparent process, the foundation for fair elections and a strong democracy?" he said, according to the EC. He said allowing ineligible people to vote, first in Bihar and later in the entire country, is against the Constitution. "On these questions, someday or the other, all of us and all the citizens of India will have to think deeply, going beyond political ideologies," he underlined. During house-to-house visit in the ongoing SIR of electoral roll in Bihar, poll officials have so far found that more than 52 lakh voters were not present at their addresses and another 18 lakh have died.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store