First Nation seeking court ruling on Alberta ending coal mining moratorium
In an application for judicial review filed this week, Siksika Nation says Alberta failed in its duty to consult when in January it lifted its moratorium on new coal mining projects on the eastern slopes of the Rocky Mountains.
Siksika Nation, 95 kilometres east of Calgary, says the effects of coal mining in the Rockies threaten Treaty rights and the land that supports its livelihood.
It's the second time Siksika Nation has challenged a United Conservative Party government's coal mining decisions.
When Alberta lifted its long-standing coal policy in 2020, Siksika challenged the move in court, but proceedings were discontinued the following year when public outrage spurred the province to reinstate the policy.
That policy flip-flop prompted coal companies to sue Alberta for a combined $16 billion, arguing that the reinstatement and effective moratorium amounted to expropriation of land.
The province recently reached settlements with two companies involved in the lawsuit for undisclosed amounts.
Energy Minister Brian Jean's office didn't immediately respond to a request for comment.
-- Jack Farrell
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 4, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Information sharing with Alberta has improved since Kearl tailings spills, says N.W.T. minister
The N.W.T.'s environment minister says communication with the Alberta government has improved since a pair of oil spills several years ago. "The information sharing from that point forward has been really good," Minister Jay Macdonald told reporters Friday afternoon. The news conference at the Explorer Hotel had been organized at the end of an annual meeting of environment ministers from around the country – a group called the Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment – that had, this year, been held in Yellowknife. Rebecca Shulz, Alberta's minister of environment and protected areas, was among those at the summit. "Our transboundary water agreements … are working quite well and allowing us to have that communication," said Macdonald. "We don't necessarily agree on all points but we're certainly having regular conversations and working together to finding solutions that work for all of us." Last year, the N.W.T. government had suggested changes to that bilateral water agreement so that the territory would be more aware of spills that could flow downstream into its waterways. But at the time, the territory was still waiting for a full response from Alberta. Macdonald did not mention on Friday whether those changes had been made. Communication was a sticking point between the N.W.T. and Alberta, particularly after two releases of toxic oilsands tailings water from the Kearl mine in northern Alberta in 2022. It took nine months for Imperial Oil and the Alberta Energy Regulator to tell First Nations and other governments about it. Shane Thompson, the N.W.T.'s environment minister at the time, had been shocked to learn about the spills from news reports and said it was unacceptable and a breach of the territory's water management agreement with the Alberta government. Schulz on Friday agreed that communication after those spills was unacceptable and said that Alberta's relationship with the N.W.T. is one the province takes seriously. "We know that there [are] a lot of eyes and a lot of focus on oilsands mine water specifically, it's something our government has made a priority, and I have committed to Minister Macdonald that we would have an open line of communication about what we're doing there," Schulz said.
Edmonton Journal
2 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
Varcoe: Smith, Moe welcome PM's confidence that oil pipeline will make Ottawa's major project wish list
Alberta Energy Minister Brian Jean says a new oil pipeline from the province to the Port of Prince Rupert would cost an estimated $20 billion to $25 billion to build, and he's growing optimistic about it being included on Ottawa's new major projects list. Article content Premier Danielle Smith is welcoming Prime Minister Mark Carney's comment on the weekend that it's 'highly, highly likely' such a project will be put on the fast-track list for approval — and she hopes to have a proposal backed by private-sector proponents in place by this fall. Article content Article content And the premier's pipeline concept would be linked with a huge carbon capture network in northern Alberta, proposed by the Pathways Alliance group of oilsands producers, also making the federal list. Article content Article content 'I really like the optimism of the prime minister, recognizing how important this project is,' Jean said Monday on the sidelines of the premier's annual Stampede breakfast at McDougall Centre. Article content 'We've got indications that it's going to cost somewhere around $20 (billion) to $25 billion — that's not a big number, as long as the conditions are right.' Article content On Saturday, Carney said it's likely an oil pipeline to the West Coast will make the list of nationally important developments on the major projects list, which is being assembled by the federal government. Article content Under the newly passed Bill C-5, the federal government can accelerate necessary approvals for such initiatives. Article content Article content 'Given the scale of the economic opportunity, the resources we have, the expertise we have, that it is highly, highly likely that we will have an oil pipeline that is a proposal for one of these projects of national interest,' the prime minister said in an interview with the Calgary Herald. Article content Article content She's speaking with pipeline proponents about what it would take to get them on board to build such a line, and with oilsands producers about proceeding with their proposed carbon capture project, which has been pegged at $16.5 billion. Article content In recent weeks, Alberta's premier has talked about striking a grand bargain that would see federal approval of the Pathways' carbon capture network along with a major oil pipeline to the B.C. coast.
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
Alberta, Ontario premiers agree to study energy corridors, trade barriers
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and Ontario Premier Doug Ford have agreed to a feasibility study of new pipelines and rail lines between provinces while increasing interprovincial trade of alcohol and vehicles.
