TMC MP in SC against Bihar poll rolls revision
2
Kolkata: Trinamool Krishnanagar MP
Mahua Moitra
on Saturday filed a writ petition in the
Supreme Court
against the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, urging the scrapping of the
Election Commission
move.
The EC order violated the Constitution and the Representation of People (RP) Act, 1950, she claimed. Trinamool has been opposing the poll panel move since the order was passed on June 24.
In her petition, Moitra said that she was afraid the SIR would be replicated in Bengal next, ahead of its assembly polls in 2026. Instructions for it "have already been given to the EROs", claimed the MP in her petition. Moitra has urged the SC to stop the EC from "issuing similar orders for SIR in other states."
Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee earlier called the poll panel move "worse than NRC" and alleged that asking for the birth certificates of parents would "target Bengal".
You Can Also Check:
Kolkata AQI
|
Weather in Kolkata
|
Bank Holidays in Kolkata
|
Public Holidays in Kolkata
Moitra, in her petition, a copy of which has been accessed by TOI, argues: "Electoral roll in Bihar has undergone special summary revision between Oct 2024 and Jan 2025, with the existing roll being published on Jan 6, which included updating and deleting names based on deaths, migration and other eligibility factors.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Free P2,000 GCash eGift
UnionBank Credit Card
Apply Now
Undo
Thus, the EC decision to conduct a second revision in such a draconian manner in a poll-bound state is unjustified and unreasonable.
"
Moitra's petition also claims that the EC order mirrored NRC. "The order disproportionately affects economically and socially vulnerable communities and resembles the structure and consequences of the NRC." The move, she says, is absurd because "it requires voters to again prove their eligibility" after having "voted multiple times".
Moitra also questioned the timing of the SIR, saying, "The exercise is being undertaken in close proximity to the Bihar assembly elections scheduled for Nov, thereby risking large-scale exclusion of eligible voters.. The petitioner has reasons to believe that the said exercise would be replicated in Bengal in the coming months." Calling the move "extra-legal," Moitra argued that the "order arbitrarily excludes commonly accepted identity documents such as Aadhaar and ration cards from the list of accepted documents, thereby putting a huge burden on voters who are at a risk of getting disenfranchised.
"
This comes after This line of argument has also found mention in a similar plea that has also been filed by the NGO the Association of Democratic Reforms (ADR) moved the SC on Friday, challenging the poll panel's direction. ADR also sought the setting aside of the order and communication, arguing that it violated the Constitution. The NGO also claimed that the poll panel order could "arbitrarily and without due process" disenfranchise lakhs of voters and disrupt free and fair elections.
Moitra's petition also claims that the EC order mirrored NRC. CM Banerjee has already termed "this NRC-like move threatens the integrity of our electoral process and risks disenfranchising millions." "The order disproportionately affects economically and socially vulnerable communities and resembles the structure and consequences of the NRC." The move, Moitra says, is absurd because "it requires voters to again prove their eligibility" after having "voted multiple times".
This is a first in India where "electors whose names are already there in rolls are being asked to prove their eligibility," the petition says.
Moitra told reporters, "TMC and CM Banerjee have already said SIR posed a great danger to democracy. EC has begun this in Bihar and plans to start this in Bengal and other states. Deletion of names can be done only after a hearing. SIR also asks one to prove their place of birth. For people born between 1987 and 2004, one has to prove the birthplace of one parent, and for people born after that, they need to prove the birthplace for both parents.
.. EC is merely executing BJP's Machiavellian plans."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
34 minutes ago
- Hans India
Congress Allavaru slams NDA over law and order; calls Bihar 'crime capital' of India
Patna: Bihar Congress incharge Krishna Allavaru launched a sharp attack on the NDA government in Bihar on Monday, alleging a collapse of law and order under its rule. He held Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah accountable for the situation in the state. Speaking to media persons at Patna airport, Allavaru said: 'There is a rule of goons in Bihar and it has become the 'crime capital' of India under the BJP. Common people are dying every day, and big businessmen are being killed in front of their homes.' Questioning the purpose of governance if citizens are not safe, he added: 'Why is the government running if no one's life is secure? In Patna, big people and small people are being killed everywhere. "PM Modi and Amit Shah should answer because they are running the Bihar government from the back door using Nitish Kumar as a front.' On Prime Minister Modi's upcoming visit to Bihar, the Congress leader said the PM is welcome but must answer to the people of Bihar. 'What has he given to Bihar in 11 years of the double-engine government? He has made many big statements, but no work has been done." "Murders happen in broad daylight, unemployment is rising, inflation is increasing, education is stagnant, hospitals are neglected, and there is no medicine,' he added. He further said, 'These are the issues of the people. He is the Prime Minister and should answer, and the people of Bihar should demand accountability.' On the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the voter list being conducted in Bihar, Allavaru alleged that the Election Commission is working in favour of the BJP. 'The same thing that happened in Maharashtra, Haryana, and other places is happening in Bihar now. The BJP benefited there, and the election was stolen,' he claimed. He further professed: 'In Bihar, the Election Commission is sitting in the lap of the BJP. So why would the BJP have any problem with this process when it benefits them?' Allavaru's remarks come amid rising political tensions in Bihar following the murder of prominent businessman Gopal Khemka in Patna, which has intensified Opposition attacks on the NDA government over law and order ahead of the upcoming Assembly elections. The Congress, along with other Grand Alliance partners, is raising concerns over governance, voter list revisions, and the safety of citizens under CM Nitish Kumar's leadership.
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
'No clarity yet': Tejashwi Yadav slams Election Commission over Bihar SIR drive; once again claims that names will be 'removed' from list
RJD leader Tejashwi Yadav NEW DELHI: Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) leader Tejashwi Yadav on Monday alleged that his party-led opposition Mahagathbandhan (Grand Alliance) is yet to get clarity from the Election Commission of India (ECI) regarding the poll panel's contentious electoral roll revision exercise in poll-bound Bihar. His remarks came on a day when the Supreme Court agreed to hear petitions challenging ECI's Special Intensive Revision (SIR), with the hearing set to be held on Thursday. "On July 5, we met ECI officials and posed our questions. The worry is that we have no clarity from them so far," Yadav said at a joint press conference of the Mahagathbandhan allies. The Bihar EC, on the other hand, has no authority to provide an answer as it works "only as a post office," he added. Further, the former deputy chief minister and current leader of opposition reiterated his charge that people would lose their voting rights if they do not have the 11 documents which EC has sought in the state. "People of don't have the 11 documents which ECI has asked for; rather, they have an Aadhar card, MGNREGA card, and ration card. This is the only document which the poor people of Bihar have. It is clear that the people who do not have these 11 documents, their names will be removed," Yadav said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like One of the Most Successful Investors of All Time, Warren Buffett, Recommends: 5 Books for Turning... Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Click Here Undo Since the announcement of SIR of electoral rolls, the opposition parties have raised their concerns. The Supreme Court petitions against thedrive were filed by RJD MP Manoj Jha, the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR), activist Yogendra Yadav, Trinamool MP Mahua Moitra, and former Bihar MLA Mujahid Alam. The petitioners sought a direction to quash ECI's June 24 directive, which requires large sections of voters in Bihar to submit proof of citizenship to remain on the electoral rolls. They also raised concerns over the exclusion of widely held documents like Aadhaar and ration cards, stating that this would "disproportionately affect" the poor and marginalised voters, especially in rural Bihar.
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘India's minorities are hostages': Owaisi slams Rijiju over ‘benefits' claim; says Muslims are called ‘jihadi', ‘Rohingya', and ‘Pakistani'
NEW DELHI: AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi on Monday lashed out at Union Minister Kiren Rijiju after the BJP leader claimed that minorities in India enjoy more benefits and protections than the majority. In a long post on X, Owaisi said Rijiju was not showing the true picture of what Indian Muslims go through and reminded him to follow his duties as a minister under the Constitution. Rijiju on X had stated that 'India is the only country where the minorities get more benefits and protections than the majority community!' This remark triggered a strong response from Owaisi. Owaisi claimed that Rijiju was speaking like a ruler instead of someone holding a constitutional post. "You are a Minister of the Indian Republic, not a monarch. Kiren Rijiju, you hold a constitutional post, not a throne. Minority rights are fundamental rights, not charity," he said. He questioned Rijiju's idea of 'benefits' by pointing to the abuse and violence Muslims face. "Is it a 'benefit' to be called Pakistani, Bangladeshi, jihadi, or Rohingya every single day? Is it 'protection' to be lynched? Is it protection that Indian citizens were kidnapped and pushed into Bangladesh?" Owaisi questioned. The Hyderabad MP also raised concerns over the bulldozing of Muslim properties. "Is it a privilege to watch our homes, masjids, and mazaars being bulldozed illegally? To be made socially, politically, and economically invisible?" he wrote. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo He further alleged that hate speeches were being made by top leaders. "Is it an 'honour' to be the target of hate speeches from no less than the Prime Minister of India?" he said. Owaisi claimed that Muslims in India were no longer treated equally as citizens. "India's minorities are not even second-class citizens anymore. We are hostages," he said. Owaisi alleged that Rijiju should answer why there is no religious parity in board memberships. "If you want to talk about 'favours', answer this: can Muslims be members of Hindu Endowment Boards? No. But your Waqf Amendment Act forces non-Muslims onto Waqf Boards — and allows them to form a majority," Owaisi said. The AIMIM leader accused the government of slashing key scholarships for Muslim students. He cited government data and said that Muslims are being left behind. "You discontinued the Maulana Azad National Fellowship. You defunded the pre-matric scholarship. You limited the post-matric and merit-cum-means scholarships. All because they benefited Muslim students," he wrote. "Muslims are now the only group whose numbers have fallen in higher education. Their presence in the informal economy has gone up. They have been among the worst-hit by your economic policies. This is your own govt's data," Owaisi said. Furthermore, Owaisi said Muslim families are seeing a decline in progress across generations. "Indian Muslims are the only group whose children are now worse off than their parents or grandparents. Intergenerational mobility has reversed. Muslim-concentrated areas are the ones most starved of public infrastructure and basic services," he stated. He ended by saying that minorities in India are only asking for the justice promised by the Constitution. "We are not asking to be compared with other minorities of other countries. We are not asking for more than what the majority community gets. We are demanding what the Constitution promises: social, economic, and political justice."
