US lawyer sanctioned after caught using ChatGPT for court brief
The Utah court of appeals has sanctioned a lawyer after he was discovered to have used ChatGPT for a filing he made in which he referenced a nonexistent court case.
Earlier this week, the Utah court of appeals made the decision to sanction Richard Bednar over claims that he filed a brief which included false citations.
According to court documents reviewed by ABC4, Bednar and Douglas Durbano, another Utah-based lawyer who was serving as the petitioner's counsel, filed a 'timely petition for interlocutory appeal'.
Upon reviewing the brief which was written by a law clerk, the respondent's counsel found several false citations of cases.
'It appears that at least some portions of the Petition may be AI-generated, including citations and even quotations to at least one case that does not appear to exist in any legal database (and could only be found in ChatGPT and references to cases that are wholly unrelated to the referenced subject matter,' the respondent's counsel said in documents reviewed by ABC4.
The outlet reports that the brief referenced a case titled 'Royer v Nelson', which did not exist in any legal database.
Following the discovery of the false citations, Bednar 'acknowledged 'the errors contained in the petition' and apologized', according to a document from the Utah court of appeals, ABC4 reports. It went on to add that during a hearing in April, Bednar and his attorney 'acknowledged that the petition contained fabricated legal authority, which was obtained from ChatGPT, and they accepted responsibility for the contents of the petition'.
According to Bednar and his attorney, an 'unlicensed law clerk' wrote up the brief and Bednar did not 'independently check the accuracy' before he made the filing. ABC4 further reports that Durbano was not involved in the creation of the petition and the law clerk responsible for the filing was a law school graduate who was terminated from the law firm.
The outlet added that Bednar offered to pay any related attorney fees to 'make amends'.
In a statement reported by ABC4, the Utah court of appeals said: 'We agree that the use of AI in the preparation of pleadings is a legal research tool that will continue to evolve with advances in technology. However, we emphasize that every attorney has an ongoing duty to review and ensure the accuracy of their court filings. In the present case, petitioner's counsel fell short of their gatekeeping responsibilities as members of the Utah State Bar when they submitted a petition that contained fake precedent generated by ChatGPT.'
As a result of the false citations, ABC4 reports that Bednar was ordered to pay the respondent's attorney fees for the petition and hearing, refund fees to their client for the time used to prepare the filing and attend the feeling, as well as donate $1,000 to the Utah-based legal non-profit And Justice for All.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
32 minutes ago
- The Independent
Starmer asked to intervene in Trump-Canada dispute
Donald Trump has abruptly ended trade discussions with Canada and threatened new tariffs, citing Canada's planned digital services tax. The US president stated the tax is a direct and blatant attack on US tech companies, leading him to terminate all trade talks immediately. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer is facing calls to intervene in the dispute, particularly ahead of Mr Trump's state visit to the UK in September. Opposition parties, including Liberal Democrats and SNP, have criticised Mr Trump's trade war tactics and questioned the UK government's approach. The escalating tensions have caused market turmoil and highlight concerns about the reliability of the US as a trade partner.
The Independent
42 minutes ago
- The Independent
DOGE loses control of US federal grants website
The US DOGE Service, responsible for Elon Musk 's federal spending cut initiative, has reportedly lost access to a key government website. is a critical platform distributing approximately $500 billion in annual federal awards, making the loss a significant setback for the DOGE initiative. Earlier, DOGE had assumed control of the website, leading to a backlog of grant proposals and risking unspent funds by the fiscal year-end. Federal officials were recently instructed to cease routing grant proposals through DOGE following Musk's split from the Trump administration. The initiative has reportedly fallen significantly short of its $1 trillion savings target, achieving only about $180 billion, although the administration says DOGE's work will continue in a decentralized manner without Musk.
Geeky Gadgets
42 minutes ago
- Geeky Gadgets
New Microsoft Outlook Calendar Tips & Tricks 2025
What if your calendar could do more than just remind you of meetings? Imagine a tool that not only keeps your schedule in check but also transforms the way you collaborate, plan, and prioritize. With Microsoft Outlook Calendar's latest updates for 2025, that vision is now a reality. Packed with features designed for the complexities of hybrid work, global teams, and multitasking professionals, Outlook Calendar is no longer just a scheduling app—it's a productivity powerhouse. Whether you're juggling time zones, streamlining recurring meetings, or automating your workflow, these upgrades promise to redefine how you manage your time. The question is: are you ready to unlock its full potential? In this guide, Manizha & Ryan walk you through the most impactful tips and tricks to master Outlook Calendar in 2025. From personalized booking pages that eliminate scheduling headaches to tools like meeting duplication and multi-time zone management, you'll discover strategies to save time, reduce friction, and boost team collaboration. But that's not all—hidden gems like event filtering and Microsoft Loop integration will take your calendar game to the next level, helping you stay organized and connected in ways you didn't think possible. As you explore these features, you might just find yourself rethinking what a calendar can do for your work and life. Outlook Calendar Tips 2025 Streamline Scheduling with Meeting Duplication One of the most time-saving features in Outlook Calendar is the ability to duplicate meetings. This functionality allows you to replicate an existing meeting, including details such as attendees, agenda, and location, with just a few clicks. It is particularly useful for recurring events like weekly project updates or team check-ins where the structure remains consistent. By reducing repetitive data entry, you can allocate more time to strategic tasks and decision-making. This feature ensures efficiency and consistency in your scheduling process. Optimize Hybrid Work with Location Settings Outlook Calendar's location settings are tailored for today's hybrid work culture. You can specify whether you'll be working remotely or in the office on any given day, providing colleagues with visibility into your availability for in-person or virtual meetings. For those concerned about privacy, the option to keep your location private is available. This tool enhances coordination within hybrid teams, making sure meetings are scheduled with greater accuracy and convenience. New Microsoft Outlook Calendar 2025 Features Watch this video on YouTube. Uncover more insights about Microsoft Outlook in previous articles we have written. Enhance Scheduling with Personalized Booking Pages Personalized booking pages simplify the process of scheduling meetings by allowing others to view your availability and book time directly. This feature eliminates the need for back-and-forth emails, making it especially valuable for external stakeholders or clients. You can customize your booking page to align with your preferences and professional branding, making sure a seamless and professional scheduling experience. This functionality is a fantastic option for professionals managing multiple external relationships. Coordinate Effectively with Meeting Polls Meeting polls are an indispensable tool for finding a time that works for all participants. By proposing multiple time slots, you enable attendees to vote for their preferred options or suggest alternatives. This feature minimizes scheduling conflicts and increases participation rates, making it ideal for team collaboration or cross-departmental meetings. It simplifies the often-complex process of coordinating schedules across diverse groups. Navigate Global Teams with Multi-Time Zone Management For teams spread across different regions, managing multiple time zones can be a challenge. Outlook Calendar addresses this by allowing you to display and manage multiple time zones directly within your calendar view. This feature ensures meetings are scheduled at times that accommodate participants from various locations, reducing confusion and missed appointments. It's an essential tool for global collaboration. Boost Efficiency with Separate Calendar Windows Outlook Calendar supports multitasking by allowing you to open your calendar in a separate window. This feature is particularly beneficial for users with dual monitors or those who need to reference their calendar while composing emails or reviewing documents. The ability to seamlessly switch between tasks enhances productivity and ensures you stay organized throughout the day. Collaborate Seamlessly with Microsoft Loop Integration The integration of Microsoft Loop into Outlook Calendar improves collaboration by embedding interactive, real-time updating elements into calendar events or emails. These elements, such as task lists or project updates, ensure all participants have access to the latest information. This feature fosters teamwork and improves project outcomes by keeping everyone aligned and informed. Automate Calendar Management for Greater Focus Automation tools in Outlook Calendar allow you to manage your schedule more effectively. You can set up automatic replies, block time for focused work, or decline new invitations during away periods. Additionally, you can automate the cancellation of meetings when you're unavailable. These features reduce manual effort and ensure your calendar reflects your priorities, helping you stay focused on what matters most. Convert Emails into Calendar Events Instantly Outlook Calendar simplifies the transition from email discussions to scheduled meetings. With a single click, you can convert an email into a calendar event, complete with all relevant details. This feature is particularly useful when email threads evolve into conversations that require dedicated meeting time. It streamlines the scheduling process, saving time and reducing the risk of miscommunication. Tailor Your Calendar with Event Filtering Event filtering allows you to customize your calendar by adding relevant schedules, such as sports events, holidays, or personal appointments. You can also drag emails directly into your calendar to create events without manual entry. These tools help you maintain an organized and personalized calendar, making sure you never miss important events. Improve Team Coordination with Calendar Sharing Outlook Calendar supports public sharing, allowing you to share your calendar with specific individuals or broader groups. This feature is particularly useful for teams or organizations that require transparency in scheduling. By sharing your calendar, you can improve coordination, reduce scheduling conflicts, and foster better collaboration. It's a practical solution for teams aiming to stay aligned and efficient. Maximize Productivity with Outlook Calendar in 2025 Microsoft Outlook Calendar continues to adapt to the evolving needs of professionals, offering features that simplify scheduling, enhance collaboration, and boost productivity. From duplicating meetings to managing multiple time zones, these tools empower you to take control of your schedule and focus on achieving your goals. By incorporating these tips and tricks into your daily workflow, you can make the most of Outlook Calendar and stay ahead in today's fast-paced work environment. Media Credit: Tutorials by Manizha & Ryan Filed Under: Guides Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
