Exclusive: Empire State Building tour guide sues over ‘career-ending PTSD' after getting stuck in elevator 67 floors up
'Maxine Malcolm was entrapped, dangling high up – fearing for her very life and not knowing if the swinging elevator would drop at any time,' reads a civil complaint obtained by The Independent.
'As a result of the incident,' Malcolm, 55, 'found that she could no longer enter an elevator as an unnatural fear would overcome her,' the complaint contends. 'A gripping fear for which she had to seek treatment. As a result of the incident Maxine Malcolm could no longer work in her job and had to leave employment.'
The elevators in the 94-year-old Empire State Building 'often' get stuck, Malcolm says in her complaint. In 2008, five of the building's elevators all got stuck at the same time, forcing passengers to pry open the doors and jump down to the nearest landing. In 2016, members of a high school choir were trapped in an Empire State Building elevator some 40 stories in the air, and had to be rescued by firefighters. Last year, seven people were stranded in a stuck elevator on the tower's 16th floor, finally getting out after 90 minutes when rescue crews led them through a hatch in the car's ceiling.
Reached by phone on Tuesday, Malcolm, a Brooklyn resident, declined to answer any questions about her experience and referred The Independent to her attorney, Manuel Moses, who declined to comment.
Malcolm's complaint, which was filed July 18 in Kings County Supreme Court, says was 'a trusted employee and highly respected in her job, having served millions of tourists' during her 30 years as an Empire State Building tour guide.
Her duties involved 'ferry[ing] passengers on elevators' up to the observation deck, according to the complaint, which claims Malcolm 'observed that these elevators would often get stuck.'
'Maxine Malcolm would observe how on those occasions management at The Empire State Building would make every effort to ameliorate the anxiety and fear this would cause by offering free admission and words of assurance,' the complaint continues. 'Maxine Malcolm noticed that before this incident… occurred there was an elevator that was getting stuck going up to the observation deck and remaining in disrepair.'
According to Malcolm's complaint, cars 5, 6, 8, and 10 'broke down often.'
Around 3 p.m. on September 10, 2023, Malcolm was alone in car 6, heading upstairs for her lunch break, the complaint goes on. When it reached the 67th floor, the elevator suddenly stopped and began swinging back and forth, according to the complaint. Amid the turbulence, Malcolm 'was badly shaken to and fro in this elevator and was knocked to the floor… seriously injur[ing] her shoulder,' the complaint states.
'[I]t should be noted that this was the day before September 11th and in her mind this heightened her fear of possible impending death,' the complaint contends.
Eventually, Malcolm managed to get out, although the complaint does not specify how long she was stuck, and whether the elevator simply started up again or if she had to be rescued.
'Maxine Malcolm remains in psychological treatment related to the elevator incident, as she still suffers from PTSD[,] also known as post-traumatic stress disorder[,] and has a phobia for getting in an elevator by herself that causes severe emotional distress,' the complaint states.
Before Malcolm developed her elevator phobia, she was earning roughly $90,000 annually, with overtime and benefits, according to her complaint. Now, it says, she receives $2,182 per month from workers' comp, or, a little under $550 a week.
Malcolm's lawsuit blames the Otis Elevator Company for her troubles, including personal injury, emotional distress and economic damages. (The Empire State Building and its management are not named as defendants in the suit.)
It claims Otis Elevator breached a 'heightened duty of care as these elevators and more specifically the one involved is specifically used for income-earning purposes and intended to lift very high loads up very far for millions of people annually who have paid a fee to go up to the observation deck.'
'This incident was foreseeable,' Malcolm's complaint alleges. 'There was a history of problems with the elevators in The Empire State Building is that they have a tendency to break down and the employees from the Otis Elevator Company would take those elevators out of rotation, fix them, and sometimes they fix it or put it out for the entire day[,] depending on the issue.'
Yet, Malcolm accuses Otis Elevator of 'allowing' the elevator's condition to deteriorate by failing to – among other things – keep 'all the components of the elevator car, assembly, associated mechanicals and cables, lift electric motors, indicators, [and] sensors… in working order for the safety of the public.'
As a result, Malcolm's complaint says she experienced severe pain and suffering, emotional distress, and anguish. Malcolm wanted to continue working at the Empire State Building 'into her later years,' but is now unable to, according to the complaint.
She is suing on multiple causes of action, including negligence, elevator phobia and loss of employment, and is seeking monetary damages to be determined in court.
A spokesman for Otis, the world's largest elevator company, told The Independent, 'It would not be appropriate for us to comment on a pending legal matter.'
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Times
21 minutes ago
- New York Times
Tiny Love Stories: ‘My Father Didn't Mind Her Lie'
A Label That Works for Us 'This is my boyfriend,' Cate said when she introduced me to a mother at her son's bouncy castle birthday party in her ex-wife's backyard. The woman's eyebrows rose involuntarily. She knows Cate as a lesbian — if she has a boyfriend, what does that make her now? We didn't even mention me being a trans man. Cate and I glanced at each other and smiled wryly. The truth is, we don't know what to call ourselves either. Straight queers? Gay heterosexuals? Pansexual partners? Luckily, we landed on a term that makes us both happy: fiancés. — Aron Cleary 'Cruel and Kind' Dad was propped up in bed in Louisville, Ky., his handsome face gaunt. This was among his last days, but I didn't know that yet. 'I've been a selfish bastard my whole life,' he said. I was shocked: Dad wasn't one to apologize. I took his hand, buying time. He'd gambled away rent money, cheated on my mother, was critical and grumpy. He'd also read me books, walked me to school and taught me about politics. 'We're all a lot of things, Dad: selfish and generous, cruel and kind. You're human.' He smiled at me. Two days later he died. — Ellen Birkett Morris Want all of The Times? Subscribe.


Washington Post
21 minutes ago
- Washington Post
11 tips for becoming a columnist
So you wanna be a columnist, eh? Young aspiring journalists and wizened elders often ask how I scored this sweet gig. Truth is, I don't entirely know. There's no chance of replicating the particular mix of skill, work and (mostly) serendipity that contributed to my path here. Still, I can offer advice to other lucky pundits who land this perch. Lord knows my own track record is far from perfect, but here are 11 pointers and principles I've aspired to:


Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
Best Online Bachelor Of Social Work Degrees Of 2025
The University of South Florida (USF) performed well across our ranking criteria, but particularly shines when it comes to affordability. The Tampa-based institution boasts the cheapest average in-state tuition and fees on our list. Its average cost for out-of-state learners is also notably lower than average nonresident prices at our other top 10 schools—and even compares favorably with some in-state rates. USF graduates hold the least federal student loan debt on our list, and the school scores in the top three for percentage of tuition covered by institutional aid (among the highest) and percentage of students who take out loans (among the lowest). Although the school charges a distance learning fee of $30 per credit, along with some program-specific additional fees, its costs remain below most of its peers, especially for Florida residents. Pro Tip In-state students at public colleges and universities typically pay lower tuition rates than out-of-state learners or those attending private institutions. However, some state schools allow all online students to pay in-state rates regardless of residency. Earning your bachelor's in social work online can make it easier to balance your studies with outside commitments—and may even save you money. If distance learning seems like a good fit for you, here's how to start narrowing down online B.S.W. programs. Consider Your Future Goals Online B.S.W. programs can help you get the skills, knowledge and credentials you need to start a social work career or apply to a graduate social work program. But not every program is the same, so make sure you find one that can help you achieve your goals. For example, consider whether you plan to go to graduate school to earn a Master of Social Work (M.S.W.). If so, opt for a CSWE-accredited bachelor's program that fulfills M.S.W. prerequisites. Some schools offer combined programs that can help you earn your B.S.W. and M.S.W. in less time. Also, consider whether a prospective program offers fieldwork, which is required for CSWE accreditation. A fieldwork component provides an excellent opportunity to gain hands-on professional experience and make connections that can benefit you after graduation. Understand Your Expenses and Financing Options Tuition rates for the online B.S.W. programs on our list range from $105 to $673 per credit, with total tuition ranging between around $13,000 to $74,000, plus fees, textbooks and living expenses. Our top 10 online Bachelor of Social Work degrees include programs at both public and private colleges. For comparison, the National Center for Education Statistics reports that one year of in-state undergraduate tuition and required fees at a public, four-year college costs $9,750 on average as of 2023, or around $39,000 for a full bachelor's degree. Private universities average $35,248 per year in tuition and required fees, or around $141,000 for a four-year degree. Prospective students can fill out the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) to apply for federal student financial aid opportunities such as loans, grants, work-study programs and scholarships. Individual schools and departments also offer funding options like scholarships, grants and fellowships. You can seek loans and other forms of aid from private sources as well. Pro Tip Asynchronous programs allow you to engage with course material at any time of day, provided you meet assignment deadlines. If your program is asynchronous, you may communicate with classmates and instructors through formats such as discussion forums and email. An online social work bachelor's degree can qualify you for various social work careers , but distance learning is not necessarily the right choice for everyone. Think about the following factors before you choose whether to earn your B.S.W. in person or online. Which Learning Style Suits You Best? Online learning works best for students with strong time management, self-discipline and organizational skills. Some learners prefer the structure and built-in accountability that comes with attending in-person classes at set times each week. What's Your Schedule? Many students choose online programs if they plan to work full time or have other commitments that would make it difficult to attend traditional in-person courses. Online programs typically provide more flexibility. This is especially true for those with asynchronous classes, which let students watch lectures and complete coursework at their convenience. What Can You Afford? In many cases, an online degree costs the same as or less than similar on-campus programs, but online students avoid expenses associated with commuting to campus and may be exempt from campus-related fees. Plus, if you plan to attend a public university in another state, you might benefit from reduced tuition. Every online bachelor of social work program differs a little, but you can expect many of the same components. In most states, for an online B.S.W. to lead to social work careers, the program must be accredited by the Council on Social Work Education (CSWE). Admission Requirements Every school maintains its own admission standards, but typical requirements may include the following: High school diploma or GED certificate Letters of recommendation Personal essay or statement or statement Criminal background check Minimum GPA ACT or SAT scores Common Courses Each college or university sets its own B.S.W. curriculum, which means that course content and titles may differ among programs. Some common courses include: Human behavior and development. This course examines human development and behavior and the factors that influence them, including environment and mental health. This course examines human development and behavior and the factors that influence them, including environment and mental health. Social work practice. This course explores the practice methods and skills social workers use, such as assessments, interventions and various therapeutic approaches. This course explores the practice methods and skills social workers use, such as assessments, interventions and various therapeutic approaches. Social justice. This course looks at the inequalities various populations face, along with the ways that social workers can make a difference in these areas. This course looks at the inequalities various populations face, along with the ways that social workers can make a difference in these areas. Social welfare policy. This course examines the laws and policies that affect social services and the social work field. Some courses may also look at advocacy and other policy change efforts. This course examines the laws and policies that affect social services and the social work field. Some courses may also look at advocacy and other policy change efforts. Crisis and trauma. This course teaches students how crisis and trauma impact people and explores professional responses, such as therapeutic techniques and intervention strategies. Concentrations Most bachelor's-level social work programs offer generalist tracks only, but you can develop your own informal specialization through electives, research projects and internships. In choosing these components strategically, you can specialize in areas such as: Mental health and substance abuse and substance abuse Healthcare Child and family services Education Community services In-Person Requirements CSWE-accredited B.S.W. programs entail a minimum of 400 hours of supervised field experience. While fieldwork requires in-person attendance, most online programs allow you to complete these hours at a site near you. While licensed clinical social workers typically need a master's degree and licensure, graduates with a bachelor's degree still play a critical support role. Roles and responsibilities for social work degree jobs at the bachelor's level may include: Case management Patient assessments Program planning and development Patient and family education Outreach Support services Social services assistance Advocacy Depending on your state and specialization, you may need licensure to practice. Further education, on-the-job training and supervision may also be required for certain pathways. Types of Social Workers Specializations within the social work field are divided by industry, client population and social service type. The following list details the most common types of social workers . Child and family social worker: These social workers provide services to families and protect the well-being of children. These social workers provide services to families and protect the well-being of children. Medical social worker: These social workers deliver support and resources to clients and their families in medical settings. Medical social workers may work with patients navigating illnesses or chronic conditions. These social workers deliver support and resources to clients and their families in medical settings. may work with patients navigating illnesses or chronic conditions. Mental health or substance use social worker: Social workers in these specializations help clients and their families manage various mental health conditions or addiction. They may provide counseling and intervention services or help clients find services and resources. Social workers in these specializations help clients and their families manage various mental health conditions or addiction. They may provide counseling and intervention services or help clients find services and resources. School social worker: A specialization in school social work focuses on issues in the school system, such as children's academic development, program development or counseling for students and teachers. A specialization in focuses on issues in the school system, such as children's academic development, program development or counseling for students and teachers. Gerontological social worker: In this specialization, social workers support older adults as they navigate aging, health issues and residential care facilities. These professionals, also called geriatric social workers , also advocate and develop programs for aging adults. In this specialization, social workers support older adults as they navigate aging, health issues and residential care facilities. These professionals, also called , also advocate and develop programs for aging adults. Forensic social worker: Forensic social workers apply their expertise to legal matters, such as child custody and domestic violence cases. They may support clients in the legal system or provide assessments and consultations for the courts. Like many other fields, social work salaries vary by education, experience and location. Social work also has several types of licensure and field specializations that can impact your earning potential. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Read more B.S.W. degree requirements vary by program. However, a typical curriculum includes classes on topics such as social work practice, human behavior in the social environment and statistics for social workers, along with a fieldwork practicum. In general, if you choose a CSWE-accredited program, a B.A. in social work and a B.S.W. are equivalent degrees that cover the same topics. Some schools use the title B.S.W., while others use B.A. in social work. The highest social work license is the licensed clinical social worker (LCSW) credential, which may be called the licensed independent clinical social worker (LICSW), depending on the state where you practice. This credential allows you to offer clinical services such as individual psychotherapy and requires an M.S.W. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that social workers as a whole earned a median annual salary of $61,330 as of 2024. Salaries vary by education level, years of experience, specialization and location. If you plan to pursue a career as a social worker, an online degree in the field is worth it. This degree is a typical requirement for entry-level social work careers and can prepare you for graduate study in social work. The cost of an online bachelor's degree in social work usually aligns with other programs at the same school. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, in-state students at public colleges and universities paid an average of $9,750 in tuition and required fees during the 2022–2023 school year, while those attending private institutions paid $35,248 on average. Whether you earn your degree on campus or online, Bachelor of Social Work programs typically require about four years of full-time study. Part-time degree seekers may take longer, while students with transfer credits can often finish faster. A bachelor's degree is enough to qualify you for entry-level social work roles. Some states license social workers at the bachelor's level, while others only require licensure for master's-level social workers. If you plan to earn a social work license, look for programs with accreditation from the Council on Social Work Education. Any college degree demands dedication and hard work, but a bachelor's degree in social work typically doesn't require advanced mathematics or technical skills that many students may find hard to master. Nonetheless, social work can be hard on an emotional level, and balancing field placements with academic work may be logistically challenging. Those who advance to master's-level social work programs may encounter heavier research, theory and statistics components than bachelor's students. Yes—to hold accreditation, an online social work degree program must include in-person fieldwork. Earning a Bachelor of Social Work online allows you to complete classroom requirements remotely, while field experience can often take place in your home area. A bachelor's in social work prepares you for entry-level social work roles in areas such as residential treatment and mental health. To become a licensed clinical social worker, you'll need a Master of Social Work. Yes—as long as it is accredited, an online social work degree entails the same academic rigor as an on-campus program and is an equally valid credential. Both on-campus and online social work students complete the same courses and fieldwork.