Sex-abuse priest's promotion draws attacks on Catholic Church
A French archbishop's decision to promote a priest who was sentenced to jail for raping a teenage boy has drawn new condemnation of the Roman Catholic Church for its record on sex abuse.
Victim support groups and traditionalists have expressed outrage over the case of Dominique Spina, who was found guilty of raping a 16-year-old boy in 2006 and sentenced to five years in prison.
Catholic priest promoted out of 'mercy'
The archbishop of Toulouse, Guy de Kerimel, set off the controversy in June when he named Spina as diocesan chancellor, putting him in charge of archives.
The canonical code lays down that the chancellor must be 'of honest reputation and above all suspicion'.
Kerimel said he had acted out of 'mercy' in making the appointment and that he had 'nothing to reproach' the priest for in an 'administrative function'.
In a statement released on Thursday in the face of mounting protests, Kerimel acknowledged the 'incomprehension' and 'questions' among Catholics but said again that without 'mercy' Spina risked a 'social death'.
'This is in no way about downplaying a crime' and the victim must be 'recognised and helped', he insisted.
ALSO READ: Kokstad to Vatican: Local Bishop gets big job from Pope Leo XIV
Because of the sensitivity of the topic, Catholic leaders have been reluctant to speak publicly, but one bishop told AFP, on condition of anonymity, that the appointment was 'a great shame' for the church.
'A priest convicted of serious sexual acts cannot hold a position of responsibility again. We should be able to say that,' the bishop added.
Anger over priest's appointment
In a joint statement, several groups of victims of sexual abuse in Catholic schools expressed their 'deep indignation' and 'anger' at the appointment.
The Catholic media has also lambasted the appointment.
La Croix, a Catholic daily newspaper, said that 'the principle of mercy cannot be used as a hasty justification'.
The traditionalist website Riposte Catholique called the appointment 'unjustifiable' and said the Vatican should intervene.
'Compassion does not consist of rehabilitating a condemned man to a canonical position,' commented the Christian website Tribune Chretienne, known for its conservative line.
ALSO READ: Pope Leo warns AI could disrupt young minds' grip on reality
France's Catholic Church is already reeling from several sexual scandals in schools it runs and accusations of long-term sexual abuse made against Abbe Pierre, once an icon of the defence of the poor, who died in 2007.
The Church has set up two commissions on acknowledging and compensating for the widespread abuses uncovered by an independent inquiry released in 2021.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
8 hours ago
- eNCA
'Las Vegas in Laos': The riverside city awash with crime
LAOS - Rising from the muddy fields on the Mekong riverbank in Laos, a lotus tops a casino in a sprawling city which analysts decry as a centre for cybercrime. Shabby, mismatched facades –- including an Iberian-style plaza replete with a church tower, turrets and statues -- stand alongside high-rise shells. The Golden Triangle Special Economic Zone (GTSEZ) is the most prominent of more than 90 such areas established across the Mekong region in recent years, often offering people reduced taxes or government regulation. Traffic signs in the GTSEZ are in Chinese script, while everything from cigarettes to jade and fake Christian Dior bags are sold in China's yuan. Analysts say the towers are leased out as centres operating finance and romance scams online, a multibillion-dollar industry that shows no signs of abating despite Beijing-backed crackdowns in the region. The GTSEZ was set up in 2007, when the Laos government granted the Kings Romans Group a 99-year lease on the area. AFP | STR Ostensibly an urban development project to attract tourists with casinos and resorts, away from official oversight, international authorities and analysts say it quickly became a centre for money laundering and trafficking. The city has now evolved, they say, into a cybercrime hub that can draw workers from around the world with better-paying jobs than back home. Laundry hung out to dry on the balconies of one high-rise building, supposed to be a tourist hotel, while the wide and palm-lined boulevards were eerily quiet. It is a "juxtaposition of the grim and the bling", according to Richard Horsey of the International Crisis Group. It gives the "impression of opulence, a sort of Las Vegas in Laos", he said, but it is underpinned by the "grim reality" of a lucrative criminal ecosystem. - 'Horrendous illicit activities' - In the daytime a few gamblers placed their bets at the blackjack tables in the city's centrepiece Kings Romans Casino, where a Rolls-Royce was parked outside. "There are people from many different countries here," said one driver offering golf buggy tours of the city, who requested anonymity for security reasons. "Indians, Filipinos, Russians and (people from) Africa." "The Chinese mostly own the businesses," he added. Cyberfraud compounds have proliferated in special economic zones across Southeast Asia, according to the UN Office on Drugs and Crime. AFP | STR Kings Romans' importance as a "storage, trafficking, deal-making, and laundering hub (is) likely to expand", it said in a report last year, despite crackdowns on illegal activities. The founder of the Kings Romans Group and the GTSEZ is Zhao Wei, a Chinese businessman with close links to the Laos government, which has given him medals for his development projects. He and three associates, along with three of his companies, were sanctioned by the US Treasury in 2018 over what it called "an array of horrendous illicit activities" including human, drug and wildlife trafficking and child prostitution. Britain sanctioned him in 2023, saying he was responsible for trafficking people to the economic zone. "They were forced to work as scammers targeting English-speaking individuals and subject to physical abuse and further cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment or punishment," Britain's Treasury said. The same year and again last August, authorities in China and Laos cracked down on cyberfraud operations in the GTSEZ, raiding offices and arresting hundreds of suspects. - 'Violence doesn't always pay' - With public anger in China mounting, over both scamming itself and alleged kidnappings, Beijing instigated raids this year on centres in Myanmar and Cambodia. AFP | STR The operations primarily targeted Chinese workers, thousands of whom were released and repatriated, along with hundreds of other foreigners. Some say they are trafficking victims or were tricked and forced to scam people online, but some authorities say they are there voluntarily. Scammers have adapted by shifting their locations and targets, specialists say, and Horsey explained that trafficking and abuses have reduced as the business model has developed. "If you're trying to scale and produce a huge business... violence doesn't always pay," he said. "It's better to have motivated workers who aren't scared, who aren't looking over their shoulder, who are actually free to... do their job." Beijing realises it cannot completely stop criminality in the region, so prefers to manage it, he added. Chinese authorities can "pick up the phone" to Zhao and tell him: "Don't do this, limit this, don't target Chinese people", he said. That "is actually more valuable for China than trying to eradicate it everywhere and just lose all influence over it". The United States Institute for Peace estimated in 2024 that Mekong-based criminal syndicates were probably stealing more than $43.8 billion annually. Representatives of both the GTSEZ and Kings Romans did not respond to AFP's repeated requests for comment, while Zhao could not be reached.
The Citizen
9 hours ago
- The Citizen
Journalist critical of Benin president extradited from Ivory Coast
A Beninese journalist living in exile was arrested under circumstances described as a 'trap' by his legal team. Ivory Coast has arrested and extradited to Benin a journalist critical of the small west African country's president, the reporter's lawyers said late on Sunday. Benin was once seen as a thriving multi-party democracy but critics say President Patrice Talon, in power since 2016, has become increasingly repressive. Hugues Comlan Soussoukpe, the publishing director of online newspaper Olofofo, had been living in exile in Togo, where he has held refugee status since 2019, according to his lawyers. Soussoukpe's arrest At the invitation of Ivory Coast's digital transition ministry, he travelled to Abidjan on July 8 for an online innovation forum. On July 11, Benin's press began reporting that he had been arrested in the Ivorian economic capital and extradited. Soussoukpe's lawyer, Charlemagne Dagbedji, confirmed on Sunday that he had been arrested. He demanded that his client's 'fundamental rights be strictly respected' and accused Ivory Coast of inviting the journalist 'for him to then be captured by the Beninese authorities'. ALSO READ: Four Ivory Coast opposition figures barred from October presidential vote Soussoukpe's legal team said in a statement on Sunday evening that he had been imprisoned in Ouidah, south Benin. 'Professional assignment turned into a trap' Condemning the arrest and his extradition, Reporters Without Borders urged Benin to release Soussoukpe immediately. 'What was supposed to be a professional assignment turned into a trap,' added the press freedom watchdog, known by its French acronym RSF. Neither Benin nor Ivory Coast had commented on the journalist's arrest by Monday morning. Online activist jailed Benin has previously been accused of kidnapping online activist Steve Amoussou from neighbouring Togo. Amoussous was detained in August 2024 and in June this year handed a two-year jail sentence for criticising the authorities. NOW READ: Wanted in SA: New extradition request to get Gupta brothers back gains momentum
eNCA
18 hours ago
- eNCA
Excavations begin at child mass grave site in Ireland
DUBLIN - Excavations begin on Monday of an unmarked mass burial site at a former mother and baby home in western Ireland, suspected of containing the remains of hundreds of infants and young children. The planned two-year probe by Irish and foreign experts in Tuam comes more than a decade after an amateur historian first uncovered evidence of a mass grave there. Subsequent 2016-2017 test excavations found significant quantities of baby remains in a subterranean disused septic tank at the location, which now sits within a housing complex. Catholic nuns ran a so-called "mother and baby" institution there between 1925 and 1961, housing women who had become pregnant outside of marriage and been shunned by their families. After giving birth, some children lived in the homes too but many more were given up for adoption under a system that often saw church and state work in tandem. Oppressive and misogynistic, the institutions -- which operated nationwide, some not closing until as recently as 1998 -- represent a dark chapter in the history of once overwhelmingly Catholic and socially conservative Ireland. A six-year enquiry sparked by the initial discoveries in Tuam found 56,000 unmarried women and 57,000 children passed through 18 such homes over a 76-year period. It also concluded that 9,000 children had died in the various state- and Catholic Church-run homes nationwide. Records unearthed show as many as 796 babies and young children died at the Tuam home over the decades that it operated. Its grounds have been left largely untouched after the institution was knocked down in 1972 and housing was built there. Ireland's Office of the Director of Authorised Intervention (ODAIT) will undertake the excavation, alongside experts from Colombia, Spain, Britain, Canada and the United States. It will involve exhumation, analysis, identification if possible, and re-interment of the remains found, its director Daniel MacSweeney told a recent press conference in Tuam.
