Should there be harsher penalties for animal abusers? Lawyers weigh in
Source: Straits Times
Article Date: 18 May 2025
Author: Claudia Tan
Given the spike in animal abuse cases, is it time to re-examine the law and implement harsher penalties?
In the space of less than a week, two community cats have died.
One was found on the road near an estate in Yishun on May 9, disembowelled and with its eyes gouged out.
Another was discovered to be severely injured in a carpark in Punggol on May 12. Cat rescuers took the feline to a vet, but it eventually died from its injuries.
The National Parks Board said on May 17 that the cat had likely sustained its injuries due to a vehicular accident.
Nonetheless, the two incidents sparked outrage among members of the public, with some going to the extent of hiring a private investigator to catch the perpetrator.
In 2024, the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) received 961 reports of animal cruelty and welfare concerns involving 2,190 animals – numbers which hit a 12-year-high.
More than half of these were cats, with 1,330 cases.
Given the spike in animal abuse cases, is it time to re-examine the law and implement harsher penalties?
Limitations of the law
Under the Animals and Birds Act, first-time offenders convicted of animal cruelty can be jailed for up to 18 months, fined up to $15,000, or both.
Repeat offenders can be jailed for up to three years, fined up to $30,000, or both.
Despite the large number of reported cases, very few are taken to the courts, said criminal lawyer Josephus Tan, who represented a man who threw a cat over the 13th-floor parapet of his block in Yishun Ring Road in 2016.
On Feb 7, Barrie Lin Pengli was sentenced to 14 months' jail for abusing five cats and killing two of them over a period of one year and eight months. The prosecution, which originally sought a jail term of 24 months, appealed against the sentence on Feb 11.
'There is still a disproportionate number of cats killed compared with perpetrators who are arrested and charged. Optically, it looks very bad because it seems to suggest that (society) does not value the lives of animals,' said Mr Tan.
Head lawyer Gloria James of law firm Gloria James-Civetta & Co told The Straits Times there are several limitations to the current laws when it comes to prosecuting and sentencing offenders.
'A significant challenge is that animals are voiceless and cannot plead their case, which makes it difficult to gauge the extent of their suffering. This can impact the ability to impose a punishment that truly reflects the harm caused.'
Associate Professor Razwana Begum Abdul Rahim, who heads the public safety and security programme at the Singapore University of Social Sciences, said cases of animal abuse often lack direct evidence or credible witnesses.
'CCTV footage is rare, and animal carcasses may be disposed of before analysis can occur,' she said.
'The time lapses between the act of abuse and its reporting can also diminish the strength of cases and make it difficult to arrest and charge suspects.'
Harsher penalties as a strong deterrent
In its 2024 report, the SPCA called for stronger animal protection laws and enforcement, which included stricter penalties as a deterrent.
Mr Tan said that amending the law to introduce tougher penalties is the right way forward.
'The law is dynamic, and it must reflect the cultures and trends of society. If there is a surge in the number of animal abuse cases, then it is something Parliament should look into.'
He suggested that the jail term for first-time offenders be increased to three to five years, and even caning offenders to send a 'strong message' of deterrence.
He likened it to the Ministry of Home Affairs considering caning for some scam offences, given the record amount of scam losses in recent years.
Ms James hopes to see enhanced sentencing for offences committed in aggravating circumstances, as she thinks the current laws are insufficient.
'For example, harsher penalties could be mandated where the act of cruelty is prolonged, involves multiple animals, is committed in the presence of children, or is filmed or shared online.
'These aggravating factors are not currently specified in the Animals and Birds Act. Codifying them would provide greater consistency in sentencing and signal a stronger moral condemnation of particularly egregious conduct,' she said.
Alternatives to punishment
Veteran criminal lawyer Ramesh Tiwary, on the other hand, feels the current laws are adequate.
He said simply meting out harsher punishments is a 'one-dimensional' approach.
'There are many other factors that come into play when somebody commits a crime – he might be frustrated, angry or not thinking straight.'
Rather, more emphasis should be placed on tackling the root of the problem.
'I think enhancing or increasing sentences is not going to prevent the offence. It is more necessary to find out why people are doing these things. If we can find out why people are being cruel to animals, then perhaps we can work at removing the reasons and solving the problem.'
Mr Tiwary believes in educating offenders, which can be done by taking them to a shelter to take care of animals, for example.
'This way, you teach the (offender) that animals deserve love and affection, rather than just sending them to prison.'
Beyond fines and jail terms, Prof Razwana suggested a longer disqualification period from animal ownership, up from the current 12 months.
Ms James echoed similar sentiments: '(12 months is) manifestly inadequate in cases involving severe or repeated cruelty. The revised Act should empower courts to impose longer-term or even permanent disqualification orders in appropriate cases.
'This would better reflect the gravity of the harm caused and provide greater protection for animals in the long term.'
Ms James recommended post-sentence behavioural reviews for convicted offenders, which assess whether offenders have internalised the consequences of their actions, and if they remain a risk to animals.
Prof Razwana said public education efforts should also be ramped up to inform the public about their duty of care towards pets and animals. She added: 'Tackling animal cruelty requires a multi-faceted approach: stricter laws, better enforcement, deeper psychological intervention and systemic education.'
Acknowledging that the Government's move to review the Animals and Birds Act is a 'step in the right direction', Prof Razwana said its success will depend on how well it integrates legal reforms with public education and offender rehabilitation.
'It is also critical to work with affected stakeholders, the communities and individuals in addressing the root cause and the aftermath of such cruel incidences,' she said.
Claudia Tan is a journalist at The Straits Times covering the crime and court beat.
Source: The Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Singapore Law Watch
2 days ago
- Singapore Law Watch
Fine for company director who played role in collecting $112k in kickbacks from migrant workers
Fine for company director who played role in collecting $112k in kickbacks from migrant workers Source: Straits Times Article Date: 25 Jul 2025 Author: Samuel Devaraj A company director has been fined after he admitted to playing a role in collecting $112,400 in kickbacks from migrant workers as a condition for renewing their work passes in December 2020. A company director has been fined after he admitted to playing a role in collecting $112,400 in kickbacks from migrant workers as a condition for renewing their work passes in December 2020. On July 24, Loo Kim Huat was fined $90,000 and also ordered to pay a penalty of $42,000, after he pleaded guilty to six charges under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act. Another 12 similar charges were taken into consideration during sentencing. According to a press release from the Ministry of Manpower (MOM), Loo, 68, was the director and group head of conservancy at WIS Holdings, which manages Weishen Industrial Services, a company providing estate cleaning and maintenance services for town councils. He had conspired with four others in the collection of kickbacks from 18 employees of Weishen as a condition for renewing their work passes. The illicit payments ranged from $900 to $7,000 for each worker. His four co-conspirators were Lim Choong Seng, a former site manager at Weishen; conservancy workers Kabir Mohammad Humayun and Robel; and Kamaruzzaman, an employment agent based in Bangladesh. According to court documents, the 18 foreign employees were primarily conservancy workers deployed to perform estate cleaning and maintenance services for town councils. The scheme which had been ongoing for four to five years before December 2020 originated from Kamaruzzaman, who was responsible for bringing in Bangladeshi nationals to work in Singapore at Weishen. Kamaruzzaman instructed Lim, Kabir, Robel and Kamaruzzaman's relatives in Singapore to collect the employment kickbacks from foreign employees whose work permits were applied for under Weishen. After the employment kickback monies were collected by Kabir and Robel, they would be handed to Lim, and then to Loo. Loo, who was Lim's direct superior, would pay Lim $300 for every kickback collected from each foreign employee. Loo and Lim would decide which foreign workers' work passes to renew, providing positive feedback to Weishen's human resources department for only the foreign employees who had paid the kickbacks. After receiving information on possible contravention of the laws under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act, MOM employment inspectors carried out investigations into Weishen on Dec 8, 2020. MOM said Lim was convicted in August 2024 and fined $84,000 while Kabir's case is still pending before the court. According to court documents, Robel remains at large. An MOM prosecutor told the court on July 24 that Kamaruzzaman, who operated from Bangladesh, remained outside of Singapore's jurisdiction the last time the ministry checked. Loo has paid a total of $83,050 as restitution to the affected migrant workers. Nine of the workers have returned home; the other nine are working in Singapore, with three employed at Weishen, MOM said. Those who are found to have collected kickbacks can be jailed for up to two years, fined up to $30,000, or both. Migrant workers who suspect that they are being asked to give kickbacks can seek help by calling MOM at 6438-5122, or the Migrant Workers' Centre at 6536-2692. MOM said members of the public who are aware of suspicious employment activities, or know of people or employers who contravene the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act, should report the matter to the ministry on its website. All information will be kept strictly confidential, it said. An anonymous complaint led to 24 weeks' jail for a former operations manager of a conservancy company, who oversaw estate cleaners in Nee Soon East and Pasir Ris-Punggol. Derrick Ho had collected $396,440 from 57 Bangladeshi workers from 2014 to 2020 for the renewal of their work permits, in one of the largest cases of kickbacks that MOM has investigated to date. He was sentenced in November 2024. Source: The Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction. Print
Singapore Law Watch
2 days ago
- Singapore Law Watch
New efforts introduced to support ex-offenders' rehabilitation, lower recidivism rate
New efforts introduced to support ex-offenders' rehabilitation, lower recidivism rate Source: Straits Times Article Date: 25 Jul 2025 Author: Syarafana Shafeeq The new framework for the Community Action for the Rehabilitation of Ex-Offenders (Care) Network will guide the sector towards reducing recidivism among ex-offenders. To better support ex-offenders to ease back into society, the workers who help them will be moved across organisations to share expertise, said Law Minister Edwin Tong on July 24. The aftercare support sector will widen its network of partners, too. These steps, along with assessing needs and reducing programme overlap, are part of new efforts to improve care for ex-offenders in the next five years. The new framework for the Community Action for the Rehabilitation of Ex-Offenders (Care) Network will guide the sector towards reducing recidivism among ex-offenders. Singapore's two-year recidivism rate has fallen from 40.1 per cent in 2000 to 21.3 per cent for the 2022 cohort, which is among the lowest globally. Recidivism refers to the tendency of an ex-inmate to reoffend. The five-year rate for the 2019 cohort was 36.6 per cent, marking the third straight year it has stayed below 40 per cent. This is partly due to the collective work of the Care Network, which comprises agencies that support this work, said Mr Tong. He was speaking at the Care Network Summit and Correctional Practice and Research Symposium on July 24 at Parkroyal Collection Marina Bay. The network was set up in 2000 to encourage partners who provide aftercare and other services for inmates, ex-offenders and their families to work together. Previously, agencies worked in isolation and were largely uncoordinated, said Mr Tong, who is also Second Minister for Home Affairs. Today, the network has 10 core members and more than 170 community partners. These include Yellow Ribbon Singapore, Singapore After-Care Association and Life Community Services Society. Mr Tong said that Singapore is often seen as a country with tough laws and a strict system, but it is equally invested and puts a lot of weight on aftercare, integration and rehabilitation of ex-offenders. The Care Network, which marks its 25th anniversary in 2025, wants to put in place more cross-sector mentorship programmes, allowing officers from the Singapore Prison Service and staff from community partners to be seconded to different organisations to share knowledge and best practices. A steering committee will also look into the best ways to optimise resources and assess whether some initiatives should make changes to better meet beneficiaries' needs. New partnerships will also be fostered to expand support and opportunities. For instance, in 2024, the Industrial and Services Co-operative Society Limited teamed up with the Institute of Singapore Chartered Accountants to offer financial literacy workshops for ex-offenders and their families. In his speech, Mr Tong said that the network has strengthened volunteer training, with 40 courses now available in areas like family work, managing addiction, and restorative practice. The network now has more than 4,000 volunteers. Throughcare support for inmates, which refers to the support provided to individuals both during and after their time in custody, has also improved over the years. In 2019, SPS introduced the Throughcare Volunteer Framework, which allows volunteers who have been supporting inmates to continue to do so after they have been released. The initiative now has more than 1,900 volunteers supporting ex-offenders. SPS launched the Desistor Network in 2023 to give ex-offenders a platform to give back and help others turn away from a life of crime and drugs. Currently, more than 100 desistors volunteer their time to support and share their experiences with inmates and other ex-offenders. One of them is 38-year-old Nur Azlina Zulkifli, who began using drugs at 12 and continued doing so for over a decade. In 2012, at the age of 25, she was caught by the authorities and sent to the Drug Rehabilitation Centre. She relapsed in 2019 and was detained again. 'I think the reason I relapsed was because I did not have a support system when I was first released. My parents are conservative and strict, and I did not talk to anyone else about it because I felt ashamed,' she said. After her second incarceration, she realised she needed more support to help her work through the emotional struggles of kicking an addiction. She joined a community programme by the Singapore Anti-Narcotics Association (Sana), and continued to volunteer there after completing it, to help other ex-offenders. Ms Azlina, who works as a senior project manager now, started her own peer support group for ex-offenders, named Ultimate Friends SG, in 2024. She visits halfway houses and liaises with other organisations to look for ex-offenders who may be interested in joining the group. There were 60 people in the group as at July, up from 10 when it was started. 'I think having support like this can really affect whether someone chooses to reoffend,' she said. Source: The Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction. Print
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
Rare sambar deer put down after getting badly injured in Mandai Road accident
Find out what's new on ST website and app. The sambar deer is considered to be at high risk of extinction in the wild. SINGAPORE - A rare sambar deer was put to sleep after it got severely injured in a road accident in Mandai Road. A National Parks Board (NParks) spokesman, responding to Straits Times queries, said the board was alerted to an accident involving a car and a sambar deer at about 5.15pm on July 24. NParks immediately asked Mandai Wildlife Group for veterinary assistance because its offices are located in Mandai Lake Road, near the accident spot. NParks group director of wildlife management How Choon Beng said: 'As the deer's injuries were assessed to be severe, it was jointly agreed by NParks and Mandai to humanely euthanise it on site on welfare grounds.' The driver of the car and a passenger were unharmed, he added. In a video circulating on social media platform TikTok, the injured sambar deer can be seen on the road, and nearby is a car with its front bumper damaged, likely from the impact of the accident. Mr How said motorists should drive within the speed limit, and be alert to animals crossing when driving on roads flanked by forested areas, especially where there are signs to indicate animal crossings. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore SMRT to pay lower fine of $2.4m for EWL disruption; must invest at least $600k to boost reliability Singapore MRT service changes needed to modify 3 East-West Line stations on Changi Airport stretch: LTA Asia Live: Thailand-Cambodia border clashes continue for second day Singapore Etomidate found in blood of 2 people involved in fatal Punggol Road accident in May: HSA Singapore Vape disposal bins at 23 CCs for users to surrender e-vaporisers, without facing penalties Singapore Tipsy Collective sues former directors, HR head; alleges $14m lost from misconduct, poor decisions Sport Training sessions at World Aquatics Masters Championships cancelled due to Sentosa's water quality issues Singapore Kopi, care and conversation: How this 20-year-old helps improve the well-being of the elderly People should not handle injured wild animals on their own, he added. For wildlife in need of urgent rescue, people can contact the NParks 24-hour Animal Response Centre on 1800-476-1600, he said. NParks added that it receives an average of three reports a year involving vehicular-related incidents with sambar deer, including cases of non-fatal accidents in which the deer escapes into the forest. The number does not take into account unreported accidents, it said. In December 2024, a sambar deer died after an accident involving a lorry and a motorcycle in Mandai Road. And in July 2024, another sambar deer died in an accident involving a taxi. An NParks study carried out in 2021 estimated that there were about 15 wild sambar deer in Singapore. Another study in 2023 found that sambar deer were making a comeback after several animals escaped from public and private local zoos in the 1970s. According to the International Union for Conservation of Nature website, sambar deer are believed to be at high risk of extinction in the wild. The deer's natural habitat includes forested areas and grasslands, but a tendency to roam and wander, especially during mating season, often brings it to the roads and in contact with motor vehicles.
