Australia mushroom trial verdicts live: Erin Patterson expressionless in court as jury finds her guilty of murders and attempted murder

The Guardian

4 hours ago

Update:
Date: 2025-07-07T05:45:45.000Z
Title: Erin Patterson
Content: Australian woman found guilty in trial over beef wellington lunch that contained death cap mushrooms – follow updates
Who are and the other key figures in Australia's mushroom lunch trial?
Five key moments in the murder trial of Australia's mushroom lunch cook
Cait Kelly
Mon 7 Jul 2025 07.45 CEST
First published on Mon 7 Jul 2025 05.42 CEST
From
6.21am CEST
06:21
The jury has found caused the death of her lunch guests.
On the three charges of murder she has been found guilty. On the charge of attempted murder she has also been found guilty.
Updated
at 6.24am CEST
7.43am CEST
07:43
Benita Kolovos
Judge thanks 'excellent' jurors for their work
After the verdicts were delivered, Beale thanked the jurors for their work over more than 10 weeks.
He described them as 'excellent' and praised them for remaining in high spirits – even after the trial ended up going weeks longer than expected.
Beale said they would be exempt from appearing on another jury for 15 years.
There were initially 15 people empanelled as potential jurors – three additional people than the usual 12, in case someone fell sick or was discharged.
One juror was removed in May after the courts heard information they had discussed the case with family and friends.
Two others were balloted off after the judge gave his final directions to the jury.
In the end, seven men and five women were left to determine the verdict.
Updated
at 7.45am CEST
7.33am CEST
07:33
Five key moments from murder trial
Adeshola Ore was one of our key reporters covering this case, blogging live for several weeks, including from Morwell. Now, she writes about five key moments she saw during the trial. You can read it here:
Updated
at 7.40am CEST
7.23am CEST
07:23
Victoria police has released a statement relation to the guilty verdict. It reads:
Victoria Police acknowledges the decision of the jury today.
Our thoughts are with the respective families at this time and we acknowledge how difficult these past two years have been for them. We will continue to support them in every way possible following this decision.
We would also like to acknowledge the work of homicide squad detectives over the course of this complex investigation, as well as the significant support received from a number of other areas across Victoria Police.
The Patterson and Wilkinson families would not be supplying a statement via Victoria police and have asked for privacy, the police said.
Updated
at 7.28am CEST
7.08am CEST
07:08
's barrister, Colin Mandy SC, left the court without making comment.
Det Leading Sen Const Stephen Eppingstall, the informant or officer in charge of the investigation, also left now without commenting.
Police have also left but have said they will return to make a brief statement to media in about an hour.
Updated
at 7.21am CEST
7.04am CEST
07:04
Benita Kolovos
As we wait for the prosecutor, Nanette Rogers SC, and Patterson's barrister, Colin Mandy SC, to leave the court, I'm reflecting on the moment we heard the verdict.
Justice Christopher Beale had asked everyone in the court to remain quiet throughout the short hearing but he didn't really have to – you could hear a pin drop in courtroom four.
Media, members of the public and a sole friend of Patterson's all sat in silence as the charges were individually read. After each, the jury's foreperson said guilty.
Patterson, who was seated at the back of the court, stared at the jury. The public gallery all turned her heads to see how she would respond. She was expressionless.
After weeks of evidence, dozens of witnesses, days of deliberations, it was all over within a few minutes.
Updated
at 7.20am CEST
6.56am CEST
06:56
We are waiting to see if 's legal team addresses the large media presence outside. Earlier, a spokesperson for the Patterson family left court without giving a statement.
Updated
at 7.07am CEST
6.47am CEST
06:47
Sentencing hearing to come
We don't yet have a sentencing date, but that will be the next step in the process.
There will be a sentencing hearing, with submissions and arguments from the prosecution and defence about what they think the sentence should be.
Updated
at 6.49am CEST
6.46am CEST
06:46
Patterson's friend says she is 'saddened' by verdict
One of Patterson's friends was surrounded by media as she left the court.
She did not say much as reporters chased her to her car, but did tell them she was 'saddened' by the verdict:
I'm saddened. It is what it is.
She said Patterson had told her she would 'see her soon' before she left the court.
I'm her friend. I will visit her.
Updated
at 6.50am CEST
6.40am CEST
06:40
Benita Kolovos
Patterson speaks to lawyers privately as hearing concludes
No members of the Patterson or Wilkinson families attended court for the verdict.
The gallery has been asked to leave the court so Patterson can speak to her lawyers privately, which concludes today's hearing.
I've headed outside to a huge press pack of journalists from across Australia and the world.
A friend of Patterson's has left the court in tears. She says she is upset by the verdict.
Updated
at 6.43am CEST
6.38am CEST
06:38
After a trial lasting more than two months, has been found guilty on four charges.
For a full recap of the verdict, you can read this piece from my colleagues Nino Bucci and Adeshola Ore:
Follow along as our coverage continues.
Updated
at 6.39am CEST
6.25am CEST
06:25
The jury has now been discharged.
Our reporter Benita Kolovos is in the court and says was stoic as the charges were read. There were no tears.
Updated
at 6.41am CEST
6.24am CEST
06:24
Benita Kolovos
As the verdict was read out, Patterson did not drop her gaze from the jury. She looked ahead calmly.
Updated
at 6.24am CEST
6.21am CEST
06:21
The jury has found caused the death of her lunch guests.
On the three charges of murder she has been found guilty. On the charge of attempted murder she has also been found guilty.
Updated
at 6.24am CEST
6.17am CEST
06:17
Benita Kolovos
Patterson has arrived in court for the verdict.
She's currently speaking to her lawyers, led by Colin Mandy SC, before court begins any minute.
Patterson is wearing a black blouse with a paisley print and has worn her hair out and straight. She appears calm.
Patterson, flanked by two security guards, now has her eyes closed and is taking deep breaths as we await the arrival of Justice Christopher Beale.
Updated
at 6.28am CEST
6.04am CEST
06:04
Benita Kolovos
Lunchtime rush at Morwell court
I'm at Latrobe Valley law courts in Morwell, where the jury are have indicated they've reached their verdict after seven days of deliberations in the triple murder trial of .
The court was on a lunch break when the jury made their decision. Many of the dozens of journalists who have been camped in Morwell for the entire 11-week trial were out for lunch, sparking a literal dash through the city to get back to court.
Now, we're all waiting outside court room 4 to get one of the limited seats inside to watch the verdict.
Members of the public are also queueing up, with some having left their handbags out the front of the court to save their place in the line.
I'll continue to provide updates throughout the afternoon.
Updated
at 6.17am CEST
6.04am CEST
06:04
The court is expected to reconvene at 2.15 and we will bring you updates as we have them.
, 50, faces three charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder relating to a beef wellington lunch she served at her house in Leongatha, in regional Victoria, on 29 July 2023.
She is accused of murdering her in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, and her estranged husband's aunt, Heather Wilkinson. The attempted murder charge relates to Heather's husband, Ian.
Patterson has pleaded not guilty to the charges.
The prosecution alleges Patterson deliberately poisoned her lunch guests with 'murderous intent', but her lawyers say the poisoning was a tragic accident.
5.42am CEST
05:42
Welcome to our live blog of 's triple murder trial.
The jury has indicated it has reached verdicts in the case of the mushroom lunch cook.
The court is expected to reconvene shortly. We'll bring you live updates.
Patterson, 50, faces three charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder relating to a beef wellington lunch she served at her house in Leongatha, in regional Victoria, on 29 July 2023. She has pleaded not guilty to the charges.