Just 21 companies prosecuted in 15 years for not paying minimum wage
Experts said the small numbers 'emboldened' rogue employers who paid workers far less than they were due as ministers were warned to get a grip of the problem, amid claims it was hampering economic growth and increasing the burgeoning welfare bill.
Between 2008 and 2023, only 21 employers were successfully prosecuted for underpaying the minimum wage, with an additional case accepting a caution, according to official figures from the Department for Business and Trade.
Ministers say criminal prosecution is reserved for the most serious cases, which involve deliberate underpayment or reckless pay practices.
These are usually where there is a wider public interest, or where employers are persistently non-compliant or refuse to cooperate with HMRC, they say.
Last year 524 businesses were 'named and shamed' for failing to pay the minimum wage, leaving more than 172,000 workers out of pocket, and ordered to repay workers nearly £16 million, plus an additional financial penalty.
But Labour peer Lord Sikka, emeritus professor of accounting at the University of Essex, described those punishments as 'puny' and called for more companies to be prosecuted.
The figures on prosecutions were revealed by minister Baroness Jones of Whitchurch in response to a question from Lord Sikka.
He told The Independent: 'Our enforcement is incredibly weak.
'I think this is part of the British disease where the law is not really enforced, because they do not employ enough enforcers. It really then emboldens rogue employers because they can then game the system. And every year hundreds of thousands of workers are denied the minimum wage.
He called for more prosecutions and said the penalty for not paying the minimum wage 'should at least equal the remuneration of the company board. The larger the company the bigger the penalty'.
He added that a failure to pay the minimum wage, brought in the Labour prime minister Tony Blair has an impact 'at many levels of the economy. It could boost growth and reduce the welfare budget - if people are earning more they have to claim less welfare.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Auto Car
24 minutes ago
- Auto Car
BYD is bringing its Land Rover Defender rival to the UK
BYD is going after the Land Rover Defender in the UK with the new B5 – a premium range-extender 4x4 with competitive off-road stats and supercar levels of power. Launched in China last year as the Bao 5, the Defender 110 rival is one of three models from BYD's new SUV sub-brand Fangchengbao but it is likely to be badged Denza in the UK and positioned as a sibling to that premium brand's Z9 GT shooting brake - also headed to the UK. Denza was founded in 2010 as a joint venture between BYD and Mercedes-Benz but is wholly owned by the Chinese firm. Both cars will make their debut at the Goodwood Festival of Speed next week, ahead of sales beginning in 2026. The move to import the B5 confirms Autocar's previous report that BYD would launch its Fangchengbao cars here in a bid to diversify its powertrain offering and tap into new market segments. The company's president, Stella Li, told Autocar at last year's Festival of Speed that she predicted the SUVs "will be very popular in the UK". 'In the UK, the roads are narrow but we love these big SUV off-road cars, so Fangchengbao will be here,' she said, referencing the popularity of large premium SUVs in this market, a sector in which BYD has until now been absent. The company has not confirmed any specification details for the B5, but it is expected to be largely unchanged from the car in China, which uses a 'DMO Super-Hybrid Off-Road' ladder-frame platform and takes its power from a range-extender system that pairs a 1.5-litre turbo engine with an electric motor on each axle. The system pumps out up to 677bhp and 561lb ft - more than any Defender, including the new V8 Octa. Meanwhile, a sizeable 31.8kWh battery (which serves as a structural element) supplies enough power for a claimed EV range of up to 78 miles on China's CLTC cycle - though that's likely to be nearer 50 miles in practice. The B5 forms part of BYD's push to dramatically increase its hybrid car offering in the face of wavering EV uptake in Europe. The core BYD line-up is set to be boosted next year with the arrival of the Seal 06, a plug-in hybrid saloon/estate in the mould of the BMW 3 Series. The Denza Z9 GT will also be available as a PHEV with a "colossal" combined range, or with pure-electric power. Also starring on BYD's stand at Goodwood will be Denza's new D9 MPV, a "business-class" people carrier in the mould of the Lexus LM.
BBC News
27 minutes ago
- BBC News
Family-owned Roberts bakery firm planning to cut up to 250 jobs
Up to 250 job cuts are planned at a family-owned Cheshire bakery firm that was hit by a factory fire two years Bakery said it faced "significant" economic challenges including the fact that "bread volumes have not rebounded as anticipated" since the June 2023 a statement, Roberts said "two-thirds of the bread production capacity was lost for over a year" and "getting back on our feet after the fire has been incredibly tough".A formal consultation period of at least 45 days will begin soon for the company's workforce in Northwich. 'Hardest decision' Roberts employees in Ilkeston, Derbyshire and Winsford are expected to be Northwich-based firm, which employs about 700 people, recently reported a pre-tax profit of £20m, up from a loss of £7m in 225 and 250 roles are expected to be turnover has fallen sharply, from £96m in 2023 to £ Roberts family has owned the business since its inception in a statement, the company said "severe challenges" including the "global impact of Covid-19, the economic pressures from Russia's war in Ukraine, and the ongoing cost-of-living crisis" had increased Roberts' energy bills and raw materials also said these factors had impacted their customers' budgets."It is with heavy hearts that we have to reduce the size of our workforce," the company said."This is without doubt the hardest decision our family has ever faced in the bakery's long history." 'Local institution' Andrew Cooper, Labour MP for Mid Cheshire, described it as "devastating news", particularly after the "workforce has shown incredible resilience, especially in the wake of the 2023 fire".He said: "Roberts Bakery has been part of the fabric of our community for over 130 years. It's more than just a business, it's a local institution that generations have worked for, and taken pride in."Cooper added that he visited the bakery in December to discuss the company's said: "I know this decision will not have been taken lightly. My thoughts are with every employee and their family at this very difficult time." Read more stories from Cheshire on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC North West on X. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
BBC News
27 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Distress' at Stroud Pride amid transphobic graffiti
Police are hunting for two people after transphobic graffiti was sprayed around a park hours before a Pride event Police has released CCTV images of a man and a woman who were seen entering Bank Gardens in Stroud with cannisters at 3:30 BST on 20 slogans appearing to target transgender people were sprayed at the gardens, with stickers of a similar theme placed around the Simon Ellson said: "Not only did this incident cause significant distress for many LGBT+ people in the community, it was also an act of mindless criminal damage." PC Steph Lawrence added: "Hate crimes will not be tolerated and we will do all we can to ensure that people within our county feel safe in their day-to-day lives."CCTV footage showed a man and a woman entering the gardens hours before Stroud Pride's celebrations began. Related graffiti was also found by a shop on Kendrick male suspect is described as white and was wearing a black jacket with the hood up, light grey baggy trousers and black woman is also said to be white with long brown hair. She was wearing a light-coloured dress and a navy jacket and was carrying a black from Stroud Town Council and the Stroud Pride worked swiftly to remove the graffiti, Insp Ellson with relevant information should call police.
