The ban on Palestine Action is to scare folk into passivity
Back then, bombings and assassinations killed many. Now, paint has been thrown and railings crashed. It's hardly a parallel.
But Keir Starmer and Yvette Cooper are throwing the book at anyone who dares combine the words Palestine and action in the same sentence or T-shirt. Maybe.
READ MORE: Man-made famine in Gaza 'most severe' since Second World War, expert warns
As Raza Husain KC argued at the PA appeal in London on Monday, there is 'rampant uncertainty' in the aftermath of a ban which carries 'all the hallmarks of an authoritarian and blatant abuse of power'.
Obviously, that's the intention. To scare folk into passivity.
It's a shameful, cowardly strategy that mustn't be normalised or meekly accepted, tempting as it is to conform.
Three people who attended Edinburgh's Palestine Solidarity march on Saturday were arrested days after Sean Clerkin in Glasgow. It's not totally clear what their 'offences' were, but holding a sign; 'Genocide in Palestine, time to take action' was enough to get Sean lifted.
Meanwhile, Kent Police threatened a woman with the Terrorism Act for a sign that read 'Free Gaza' without any reference to PA. How was that an arrestable offence?
Meanwhile, three folk with more profile – Alba leader Kenny MacAskill, former SNP MP Tommy Sheppard and myself – said the same thing last Saturday in Edinburgh. Indeed, I was filmed saying the words 'Palestine needs action', with at least six police in view and 3000-4000 people roaring their approval.
Now, I'm not trying to court arrest. It's a scary prospect. Supporting PA means up to six months in prison. Being a member of the group can mean up to 14 years in jail.
And the real heroes are not here in the UK but trailing Gaza every day, searching for safety and scavenging for food with hope and dignity almost completely stripped away.
It's that tiny shred of hope any person of conscience must feel obliged to nurture.
But not our MPs. In a Commons' vote three weeks ago – where the SNP shamefully abstained on account of PA being bunched with other groups – 385 MPs voted to ban the group. It's important to note this was the first time a non-violent direct action campaign group has ever been proscribed.
Where's the reaction?
READ MORE: Labour are creating uncertainty and acting against democratic freedom
Here in Scotland, why has there not been a peep from Scotland's justice minister about the justice of arresting T-shirt-wearing protesters?
Will the Lord Advocate clarify that talking about action for Palestine will not be considered a terrorist offence in Scotland – whatever politicians south of the Border advise.
Indeed, while we're at it, why doesn't John Swinney make this the subject of a follow-up event on the dangers of the far-right in public life?
Yes, I realise the Terrorism Act is a reserved issue and Holyrood can't change or duck it.
But our law officers and government ministers can produce guidance on what actions constitute support for terrorists. Doing that means activists would be saved stress and jail, police would be saved time – as they tackle the private visit of Donald Trump – and the law would be saved from being an ass.
Scottish Government – you're allowed to have a view. You're allowed to protect your own citizens. And you're allowed to take a side, supporting peaceful campaigners who support the citizens of Gaza and the tradition of policing by consent.
In the absence of a distinctive Scottish stance though, some professionals are taking a side.
Like Blinne Nessa Áine Ní Ghrálaigh KC – the Irish human rights lawyer who led this week's legal challenge against PA's proscription in London. Clearly, from the stubborn retention of her full beautiful Irish name, she's not a gal who toes the line.
In 2017, she secured an acquittal for activists Sam Walton and Dan Woodhouse, arrested for trying to disarm Typhoon jets they believed were bound for Saudi Arabia to bomb Yemen.
Ní Ghrálaigh also represented one of the Colston Four charged with toppling the Colston statue in Bristol in 2020. The jury acquitted the protesters in January 2022, and The Times named Ní Ghrálaigh Lawyer of the Week. It's worth knowing such people exist.
Last year, Ní Ghrálaigh was part of the South African legal team at the International Court of Justice (ICJ), which accused Israel of genocide. The court ordered Israel to observe the Genocide Convention, and enable basic services and humanitarian assistance.
As we all know, that hasn't happened. And the court did shrink from ordering Israel to stop its military campaign.
But the ICJ judgment was the first powerful international intervention against the IDF.
Then Ní Ghrálaigh pointed out that Gaza was the first genocide in history to be broadcast 'in real-time' with 'dehumanising genocidal rhetoric' used by Israeli governmental and military officials, including that 'terrible new' acronym WCNSFs (Wounded Child, No Surviving Family).
READ MORE: Doing the right thing for Gaza would gain the SNP more support
Ni Ghralaigh won 'Tatler Woman of the Year Award' in November after her ICJ intervention and dedicated it to the women of Palestine.
'The women of Palestine will build Gaza again from the rubble and destruction as they have before, like women do the world over.
'May the future finally be women-led. May it be led by brilliant, fierce, intelligent, and compassionate women like our mothers and grandmothers before us.'
This week, Ni Ghralaigh's words shocked again as she told the Royal Court of Justice that Merseyside Police have bailed protesters on condition they don't mention Palestine.
'People have been bailed to not mention Palestine?' Justice Chamberlain asked, with Ni Ghralaigh replying: 'It is a condition of bail that they do not mention Palestine.
'The Secretary of State has not distanced herself from any of these actions,' adding that Yvette Cooper had not even described such actions as an 'overreach'.
This is the fearless, clear-eyed interrogation needed to tackle Starmer's outrageous act of political censorship.
Where are the rest?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
STEPHEN DAISLEY: The out-of-touch political dreamers who've now been handed a rude awakening by reality
Ten years and a few months ago, I was dispatched to Paisley to try to interview Mhairi Black. I say 'try to' because everywhere we went someone would interrupt to tell the 20 year-old they were voting for her. It's not easy grilling a candidate on currency options for an independent Scotland when every few minutes a passing stranger suddenly downs their Tesco bags and asks for a selfie. This was the eve of the 2015 general election and the SNP was poised to sweep Labour from its west-central heartlands. Nicola Sturgeon was selling out the Hydro. Black was about to become the youngest MP since the Great Reform Act. I still had hair. It was another Scotland. A decade on, Black says she's done with the SNP and is no longer a member. She pinpoints 'capitulation on LGBT rights, trans rights in particular' as her reason for leaving, though adds: 'I thought the party could be doing better about Palestine as well'. Much as I don't share Black's views on gender or Gaza – or a great deal else, for that matter – I respect them. They're sincerely held. If you're going to hate anyone in politics, don't hate the ones who disagree with you on principle, hate the ones prepared to agree with you on any principle just to get ahead. Unfortunately her principles are far removed from those of the median voter, who remains baffled by the notion that someone can 'identify' into a different sex and even more baffled as to how this became a priority for politicians across the land. Many feel strongly about the deaths in Gaza but for most voters it is nowhere near the top of their concerns, which are dominated by their family, then their social circles, then their neighbourhood, then their country. Idealists who make a virtue of empathising more with those on the other side of the world get very angry about this. They even invented a term for it, 'hierarchy of death', which seems superfluous when we already had a term for it: human nature. For the SNP to have clung onto Black's membership subs, it would have had to return to a subject (trans rights) which has caused it no end of internal division and political misery, and adopt an even more strident stance on Israel's military response to the Palestinians' October 7 invasion and murder, rape and abduction of its citizens. The SNP is a political party, not a moral philosophy seminar. It exists to win elections and, in theory, achieve Scottish independence. What votes would it win by taking Black's advice? What votes is it at risk of losing by not? The former Paisley and Renfrewshire South MP comes close to identifying the problem herself, when she says: 'If anything, I'm probably a bit more Left-wing than I have been. I don't think I have changed all that much. I feel like the party needs to change a lot more.' The SNP does have to change, but not in the direction Black wants. The Nationalists and most other parties have spent the past decade or so breenging off on a tangent about trans rights, systemic racism, Donald Trump and the rest. A correction was long overdue. This agenda lacked popular consent and stoked resentment among both those who opposed it fiercely and those who protested over so much time and effort being frittered away. The Supreme Court judgment in For Women Scotland has helped immeasurably. Party leaders and policy-makers were able to point to the ruling and pass responsibility onto the justices. They weren't backsliding, the court was clarifying the law. For John Swinney, this has been a blessed opportunity to ditch positions he went along with at the time, I've no doubt against his better judgment, but which he knows have gravely damaged his party's standing with the public. A man with more gumption would have stood up and said something when it mattered, but if Swinney isn't much of a leader – and he certainly isn't – nor is he alone in that category. During the initial consultation stage for reforming the Gender Recognition Act, a senior politician in one party admitted to me that they didn't understand the issue, or why it was a priority, but they'd be voting for it because they had been told to. Politics is the trade of dreamers and cynics and while Mhairi Black might be wrong about everything at least she's sincere about it. She isn't the only dreamer to be rudely awakened lately by political reality. Maggie Chapman has found herself dumped as the Greens' lead candidate in North East Scotland, replaced by Guy Ingerson, ex oil-and-gas worker turned Net Zero enthusiast. According to a pet theory of mine, that makes it unlikely that Chapman will be re-elected next May. The theory: a person's likelihood to vote for the Scottish Greens correlates with their proximity to a Pret A Manger. Edinburgh and Glasgow, home to 11 and six branches of the posh sandwich chain respectively, just so happen to be the Greens' best and second-best performing areas on the regional lists. Aberdeen, with just two, lags far behind in Green support. Whether or not my theory holds water (or overpriced coffee), Chapman's Holyrood career appears to be over after years of headline-grabbing pronouncements. Her principles also deserve respect. Not because they're sincerely held but because we should remain open to ideas from other planets. When the landmark ruling was handed down in For Women Scotland, Chapman attended a rally to denounce the 'bigotry, prejudice and hatred coming from the Supreme Court'. She once told an interviewer that allowing eight year olds to change their legal sex was something that 'in principle we should be exploring'. Following the October 7 attack on Israel, she shared a tweet saying the murderous rampage was not terrorism but 'decolonisation'. Yes, her views are deranged, but the more pertinent question is how these came to be the views of someone elected to make sure Scots can see a doctor, find a good school for their children, and not get mugged at knifepoint. The answer is that ideologues like Chapman are not interested in all that boring, quotidian stuff that fixates middle-class taxpayers. Simply ghastly people, those bourgeois types, with their petrol-guzzling cars, their authoritarian demands for more police on the streets, and their grasping fixation with ambition and acquisition. Don't they know there are more important issues in the world? There are far too many in Holyrood or keen to get there who think like this. For them, life is just one long university debating society match, in which enlightened elites like them exchange barbs and bon mots over affairs of state. The little people might fret about bills and savings and leaving an inheritance for their children, but they are above such vulgar materialism. They are here to change the world, you know. In my observation, those most keen to change the world tend to have the least experience of it. They make terrible politicians because they quickly find out the world doesn't work the way they want and they resent the voters for that. If the voters set the agenda in politics, Mhairi Black and Maggie Chapman wouldn't be the only ones in our insular, self-righteous governing class that would be stampeding for the exit. Democracy is still the most radical idea of all. Maybe one day we'll give it a try.
Western Telegraph
31 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Three arrested as demo takes place outside hotel used to house migrants
Sunday saw the latest in a series of demonstrations outside The Bell Hotel in Epping, Essex, after an asylum seeker was charged with allegedly attempting to kiss a 14-year-old girl. Protesters waved union flags, while Stand Up To Racism counter-protesters marched to the hotel with signs reading: 'Stop scapegoating refugees and migrants'. People take part in a Stand Up to Racism protest (Jordan Pettitt/PA) A 52-year-old man from Loughton was arrested on suspicion of a public order offence. It is understood the arrest was in connection with abuse being shouted towards counter-protesters. A 53-year-old woman, also from Loughton, was arrested on suspicion of a racially aggravated public order offence connected with a previous protest, and it is understood she was part of the protest against the use of the hotel. A 27-year-old woman from Deptford was arrested on suspicion of criminal damage and a public order offence, and it is understood she was part of the counter-protest. People take part in a Stand Up to Racism protest in Epping (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Essex Police Chief Superintendent Simon Anslow said: 'I want to thank those who attended for the peaceful nature of both protests. 'Our role is to ensure that you can express your democratic right to protest safely and lawfully and we had a proportionate and robust plan in place to ensure that could happen. 'I am pleased that today has passed off without incident and I am grateful to our colleagues from other forces for their support.' Weyman Bennett, co-convener of Stand Up To Racism, told the PA news agency that volunteer security personnel accompanied them. He added: 'We're happy to demonstrate but we're not happy to be attacked by thugs, racists and hooligans.' It is believed that the hotel houses a number of asylum seekers (Jordan Pettitt/PA) One man was seen being taken away from the station area by two officers, though it was not clear if he was part of any group. Members of Stand Up To Racism were seen trying to stop people from filming the protesters, as locals watched the march from their driveways. One local man was seen chanting in support of Tommy Robinson, whose real name is Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, as the march went past. He began shouting 'there's only one Tommy Robinson' when a protester approached him. One Stand Up To Racism protester chanted 'fascist scum' at him before police stepped in to ensure they would not come together. Essex Police said it had established protest restrictions due to repeated serious disruption, violence, and harm to the community during previous demonstrations. The force said that there was a ban on anyone wearing face coverings and that there were designated sites opposite the hotel for protesters. Protesters and counter-protesters were kept separated (Jordan Pettitt/PA) A dispersal order was in effect from 12pm on Sunday until 8am on Monday, covering Epping town centre and nearby transport hubs. Both sets of protesters were kept separated by fences. Those protesting outside The Bell Hotel in Epping chose to ignore counter-demonstrators and began singing. They sang Sweet Caroline and Come On Eileen while demonstrators from Stand Up To Racism chanted: 'Nazi scum off our streets'. Essex Police said that residents have reported feeling 'trapped', fearful of leaving their homes and anxious about protest activity previously. A number of demonstrations have taken place outside the hotel (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Hotel residents and staff have been advised to remain indoors after 5pm as some have experienced verbal and physical harassment, including a resident chased and injured while returning to the hotel, the force added. Essex Police said there was an 'escalation of violence' during protests on July 13, 17, 20 and 24, involving hundreds of people. The force added that officers were assaulted, missiles were thrown, vehicles were vandalised and the hotel sustained broken windows and graffiti. The Epping protest was sparked by the charging of asylum seeker Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu, 38, with sexual assault after he allegedly attempted to kiss a 14-year-old girl. He denied the charge at Chelmsford Magistrates' Court and will stand trial in August.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Three arrested as demo takes place outside hotel used to house migrants
Protesters waved union flags, while Stand Up To Racism counter-protesters marched to the hotel with signs reading: 'Stop scapegoating refugees and migrants'. People take part in a Stand Up to Racism protest (Jordan Pettitt/PA) A 52-year-old man from Loughton was arrested on suspicion of a public order offence. It is understood the arrest was in connection with abuse being shouted towards counter-protesters. A 53-year-old woman, also from Loughton, was arrested on suspicion of a racially aggravated public order offence connected with a previous protest, and it is understood she was part of the protest against the use of the hotel. A 27-year-old woman from Deptford was arrested on suspicion of criminal damage and a public order offence, and it is understood she was part of the counter-protest. People take part in a Stand Up to Racism protest in Epping (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Essex Police Chief Superintendent Simon Anslow said: 'I want to thank those who attended for the peaceful nature of both protests. 'Our role is to ensure that you can express your democratic right to protest safely and lawfully and we had a proportionate and robust plan in place to ensure that could happen. 'I am pleased that today has passed off without incident and I am grateful to our colleagues from other forces for their support.' Weyman Bennett, co-convener of Stand Up To Racism, told the PA news agency that volunteer security personnel accompanied them. He added: 'We're happy to demonstrate but we're not happy to be attacked by thugs, racists and hooligans.' It is believed that the hotel houses a number of asylum seekers (Jordan Pettitt/PA) One man was seen being taken away from the station area by two officers, though it was not clear if he was part of any group. Members of Stand Up To Racism were seen trying to stop people from filming the protesters, as locals watched the march from their driveways. One local man was seen chanting in support of Tommy Robinson, whose real name is Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, as the march went past. He began shouting 'there's only one Tommy Robinson' when a protester approached him. One Stand Up To Racism protester chanted 'fascist scum' at him before police stepped in to ensure they would not come together. Essex Police said it had established protest restrictions due to repeated serious disruption, violence, and harm to the community during previous demonstrations. The force said that there was a ban on anyone wearing face coverings and that there were designated sites opposite the hotel for protesters. Protesters and counter-protesters were kept separated (Jordan Pettitt/PA) A dispersal order was in effect from 12pm on Sunday until 8am on Monday, covering Epping town centre and nearby transport hubs. Both sets of protesters were kept separated by fences. Those protesting outside The Bell Hotel in Epping chose to ignore counter-demonstrators and began singing. They sang Sweet Caroline and Come On Eileen while demonstrators from Stand Up To Racism chanted: 'Nazi scum off our streets'. Essex Police said that residents have reported feeling 'trapped', fearful of leaving their homes and anxious about protest activity previously. A number of demonstrations have taken place outside the hotel (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Hotel residents and staff have been advised to remain indoors after 5pm as some have experienced verbal and physical harassment, including a resident chased and injured while returning to the hotel, the force added. Essex Police said there was an 'escalation of violence' during protests on July 13, 17, 20 and 24, involving hundreds of people. The force added that officers were assaulted, missiles were thrown, vehicles were vandalised and the hotel sustained broken windows and graffiti. The Epping protest was sparked by the charging of asylum seeker Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu, 38, with sexual assault after he allegedly attempted to kiss a 14-year-old girl. He denied the charge at Chelmsford Magistrates' Court and will stand trial in August.
