'Not Something to Celebrate': As it Turns 80 and Faces Dwindling Global Clout, Can the UN Survive?
Founded in 1945 to prevent another world war, the UN's initial goal has been partly realized. However, conflicts persist globally, increasing the humanitarian needs while donor nations reduce aid. The grim mood at UN headquarters reflects anxiety about the upcoming US review of multilateral institutions, ordered by President Trump, and the resulting job cuts. Despite global changes and expansion of the UN system, its effectiveness is questioned, especially given current geopolitical challenges and US funding cuts.
While credited with preventing World War III, the UN faces criticism for its current state. Bolton, a former US ambassador to the UN, considers it in its worst shape since its founding. Gowan, of the International Crisis Group, believes the UN will shrink in the next few years due to various factors. Bremmer, of the Eurasia Group, maintains that the UN remains relevant, despite lacking resources and military capabilities, due to its unique legitimacy in representing the global population. He added, 'The important thing is that as long as the great powers decide not to leave the United Nations, every day that they stay is a vote of confidence in the UN.'
Guterres' 'Pact for the Future' seeks to address 21st-century challenges. Potential reforms include merging aid and development agencies. Gowan notes that the UN's New York location facilitates a lot of diplomatic business unrelated to the UN itself, and even intelligence gathering. The Trump administration's undermining of the UN is expected to elevate China's importance within the organization. Bremmer notes that China is poised to become more influential in agencies like the WHO and UNRWA as the US withdraws or reduces funding.
Security Council expansion is a key area for change. There is broad agreement that Africa and Latin America should have permanent seats. Despite the UN's current challenges, its structure, including the veto power of major powers, is believed to ensure its survival.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Arabiya
14 minutes ago
- Al Arabiya
US President Trump stakes reputation as dealmaker with tariff policy
Donald Trump is staking his reputation as a tough negotiator and slick dealmaker -- that has served him well throughout his life -- with his ultra-muscular, protectionist tariffs policy. On Friday, the White House released a picture of the US president seen with a smartphone pressed to his ear, with the caption: 'Making calls. Making deals. MAKING AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!' Every trade deal announced by the president, who is convinced that tariffs are both a tool and manifestation of America's economic might, is celebrated by his supporters as a show of his negotiating prowess. This week's flurry of rate changes was no different. On Thursday, with the stroke of a black marker, the former real estate developer slapped fresh tariffs on dozens of US trade partners. They will kick in on August 7 instead of August 1, which had previously been touted as a hard deadline. The Republican leader's backtracking, frequently setting trade deadlines only to rescind or extend them -- he most recently granted Mexico a 90-day extension -- has given rise to the mocking acronym 'TACO' ('Trump always chickens out'). The jokes implying Trump is all talk and no action on trade have previously struck a nerve for the president. 'Not chicken' But analysts believe there will be no going back this time. Trump has 'not chickened out,' according to Josh Lipsky, an international economics expert at the Atlantic Council think tank. Lipsky told AFP the president is 'following through, if not exceeding' what he vowed during his campaign in respect to tariffs. Matthew Aks, a public policy analyst at Evercore ISI, said he did not anticipate a 'massive shift' on the latest order, aside from some economies like Taiwan or India striking deals during the seven-day buffer. Following crunch negotiations leading up to the tariffs announcement, Trump struck a series of compromises, notably with the European Union, Japan, and South Korea, setting varying tax rates and touting high investments in the United States. The details of these agreements remain vague and leave the door open to key questions: Are exemptions possible? What will become of key sectors like automobiles, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors? And what of China? The US president and leaders of other countries 'have reasons to avoid going into detailed agreements' explained Aks, allowing all sides to present the deals in the most positive, or least negative, way possible to their public. The ability to conclude deals -- often with or without crucial detail -- is, for the 79-year-old Republican, an integral part of his political signature. 'Art form' In his book 'The Art of the Deal,' the billionaire wrote: 'Deals are my art form. Other people paint beautifully on canvas or write wonderful poetry. I like making deals, preferably big deals. That's how I get my kicks.' Trump explained in his book that he always 'protects' himself 'by being flexible.' 'I never get too attached to one deal or one approach.' But despite comments about his trade policy reversals, Trump has hardly budged from his trade strategy, and that could prove politically painful. In a survey conducted by Quinnipiac University published in mid-July, only 40 percent of respondents said they supported the president's trade policy, while 56 percent criticized it. The latest employment figures bear the marks of Trump's protectionist offensive, according to experts. Job creation in May and June was revised sharply downward, falling to levels not seen since the COVID-19 pandemic.
Al Arabiya
44 minutes ago
- Al Arabiya
Guatemalan officials plan to visit ‘Alligator Alcatraz' detainees
The Guatemalan government on Friday said it has arranged for its officials to visit a notorious US migrant detention center to check on 14 detainees from Guatemala housed there. The facility, dubbed 'Alligator Alcatraz' due to its location in the swamps of the Everglades in southern Florida, has come under fire by both environmentalists and critics of US President Donald Trump's crackdown on migration, who consider the facility to be inhumane. Guatemala's Ministry of Foreign Affairs said in a statement it had requested permission from US officials to visit the detained Guatemalans 'to identify, interview and learn about their situations and conditions.' The statement said Guatemalan officials are set to visit on August 7. 'Until this moment, we have confirmed the nationalities of 14 Guatemalans held there – all men of legal age,' the statement added. Trump visited the facility in July, boasting about the harsh conditions and joking that the reptilian predators will serve as guards. 'A lot of bodyguards and a lot of cops in the form of alligators – you don't have to pay them so much,' Trump said. Earlier this week, Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum said 30 Mexican nationals were being held at 'Alligator Alcatraz' as well. The current facility consists of bunk beds inside cages made of metal fencing, and can house 1,000 people currently. New York-based NGO Human Rights Watch (HRW) issued a report last month detailing abuse and degrading treatment suffered by migrants housed at multiple detention centers in Florida.
Al Arabiya
an hour ago
- Al Arabiya
Ukrainian drone strikes kill three in Russia
Ukrainian drone strikes killed three people and wounded two others overnight in western Russia, regional governors said on Saturday. One woman was killed and two others were wounded in an attack on an enterprise in the Penza region, Governor Oleg Melnichenko said on Telegram. An elderly man died after falling drone debris sparked a house fire in the Samara region, according to Governor Vyacheslav Fedorishchev. In the Rostov region, a guard at an industrial facility was killed following a drone attack and fire, acting Governor Yuri Sliusar said. 'The military repelled a massive air attack during the night,' Sliusar wrote on Telegram, saying drones were destroyed over seven districts. Russia's defense ministry said its air defense systems had shot down 112 Ukrainian drones over Russian territory between Friday night and Saturday morning, including 34 over the Rostov region. In Ukraine's central-eastern Dnipropetrovsk region, overnight Russian drone attacks wounded three people and damaged buildings, homes, and vehicles, regional Governor Sergiy Lysak said. Russian forces have claimed gains in Dnipropetrovsk, recently announcing the capture of two villages — part of what AFP analysis of US-based Institute for the Study of War (ISW) data calls Moscow's accelerated push in July. Kyiv denies any Russian presence in the region. Russian President Vladimir Putin, who has repeatedly rejected calls for a ceasefire in the more than three-year conflict, said on Friday he still seeks peace but that Moscow's demands remain 'unchanged.' These include Ukraine ceding territory and abandoning ambitions to join NATO. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said only Putin could end the war and reiterated his willingness to meet, writing on X: 'The United States has proposed this. Ukraine has supported it. What is needed is Russia's readiness.'
