BBC pulls Gaza medics documentary due to impartiality concerns
The BBC said it was "transferring ownership of the film material to Basement Films".BBC News understands the decision to shelve the documentary was taken on Thursday, following public comments by De Pear at the Sheffield Documentary Festival, and another of the film's directors, journalist Ramita Navai, who appeared on Radio 4's Today programme discussing the war in Gaza.A different documentary, Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone, was pulled from iPlayer earlier this year after it emerged its 13-year-old narrator was the son of a Hamas official.
Gaza: Doctors Under Attack - also known as Gaza: Medics Under Fire - is said to examine the experiences of Palestinian medics working during the war in Gaza.The film is directed by Karim Shah, Navai and De Pear, a former editor of Channel 4 News.
In a statement on Friday, the BBC said it had commissioned the documentary over a year ago, but paused the film in April, "having made a decision that we could not broadcast the film while a review into a separate Gaza documentary was ongoing". "With both films coming from independent production companies, and both about Gaza, it was right to wait for any relevant findings – and put them into action – before broadcasting the film."However, we wanted the doctors' voices to be heard. Our aim was to find a way to air some of the material in our news programmes, in line with our impartiality standards, before the review was published."For some weeks, the BBC has been working with Basement Films to find a way to tell the stories of these doctors on our platforms."Yesterday [Thursday], it became apparent that we have reached the end of the road with these discussions. We have come to the conclusion that broadcasting this material risked creating a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC."The corporation added that, contrary to some reports, the documentary had "not undergone the BBC's final pre-broadcast sign-off processes", adding: "Any film broadcast will not be a BBC film."It continued: "We want to thank the doctors and contributors and we are sorry we could not tell their stories. The BBC will continue to cover events in Gaza impartially."
Speaking at the Sheffield Documentary Festival on Thursday, before the decision was announced, De Pear specifically blamed director general Tim Davie for refusing to air the film."All the decisions about our film were not taken by journalists, they were taken by Tim Davie," he claimed while taking part in a panel, as reported by Broadcast."He is just a PR person. Tim Davie is taking editorial decisions which, frankly, he is not capable of making."He added: "The BBC's primary purpose is TV news and current affairs, and if it's failing on that it doesn't matter what drama it makes or sports it covers. It is failing as an institution. And if it's failing on that then it needs new management."Something needs to happen because they are making decisions from a PR defensive point of view rather than a journalistic one. If you make a decision on a journalistic basis you can defend it, but if you make it on a PR basis, you can't."In relation to the war, De Pear claimed staff at the BBC "are being forced to use language they don't recognise, they are not describing something as it clearly is [for fear of impartiality] and it's tragic".Responding to De Pear's comments, a BBC spokesperson said the BBC "totally reject[s] this characterisation of our coverage"."The BBC has continually produced powerful journalism about this conflict. Alongside breaking news and ongoing analysis, we have produced original investigations such as those into allegations of abuse of Palestinian prisoners and Israel's use of bunker buster bombs and in-depth documentaries including the award-winning Life and Death in Gaza, and Gaza 101."
High-profile figures such as actress Susan Sarandon and presenter Gary Lineker have previously accused the corporation of censorship over the delay.An open letter, which was also signed by cultural figures such as Dame Harriet Walter, Miriam Margolyes, Maxine Peake, Juliet Stevenson and Mike Leigh, said: "This is not editorial caution. It's political suppression.""No news organisation should quietly decide behind closed doors whose stories are worth telling," it continued. "This important film should be seen by the public, and its contributors' bravery honoured."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Erin Molan Stellar magazine cover sparks furious backlash over her views about Israel's war in Gaza: 'Never reading this publication again'
A magazine cover featuring Erin Molan has sparked a ferocious backlash over the TV presenter's strong stance supporting Israel in its conflict with Gaza. This weekend's edition of Stellar, which is published in News Corp's Sunday newspapers, is being promoted on Instagram and some readers are furious that Molan appears on the front. The former Sky News Australia host has publicly condemned Hamas since its raids on the Jewish state on October 7, 2023, and in recent months has been reporting from Israel on the Middle East war. While some fans - including model and influencer Bec Judd - were quick to congratulate Molan on taking out the cover position, others could not see past her pro-Israel views. 'No thanks Stella... No one I would support,' wrote one. 'So tone deaf,' said another. A third posted: 'Free Palestine ps never reading this publication again.' Several other users threatened to boycott Stellar. Some of the comments are too inflammatory to publish. The Times of Israel ran a profile piece on Molan in May under the headline 'Erin Molan vs. the world: From Australian news anchor to pro-Israel firebrand.' 'Molan has found herself increasingly recognized in Israel, where people on the street often flock to her, eager to thank her for her support,' it reported. The story quoted Molan, who is Catholic, describing her reaction to the October 7 outrages. 'It was never complex to me or grey or fuzzy,' she said. 'It was black and white as to who evil was in this scenario.' Molan has maintained that stance amid Israel's retaliation and the ongoing human crisis in Gaza. Former Sky News Australia colleague Sharri Markson moved quickly last year to quash a conspiracy theory that Molan had been sacked from the network for her pro-Israel views. In December, Markson wished Molan her well in her future pursuits and wrote on X that it was 'categorically untrue' the 41-year-old had been booted off Sky 'because of her Zionism'. in their reporting of the onetime Footy Show presenter's removal by Sky. Daily newspaper Israel Hayom referred to Molan's response to the October 7 massacre in which more than 1,200 Israelis - mostly citizens - were killed and 254 taken hostage. 'Molan has been a vocal supporter of Israel on her Sky News Australia program,' the newspaper stated. 'Strongly condemning both Hamas' actions against Israeli civilians and the pro-Hamas demonstrations that have erupted worldwide, repeatedly using her platform to address the ongoing war.' Israel National News covered the presenter's axing under the headline: 'Sky News Australia fires pro-Israel host Erin Molan.' 'Australian news anchor Erin Molan, who repeatedly defended Israel in the year since the October 7 massacre, has been fired by Sky News Australia,' its story began. Molan posted an impassioned nine-minute video to X in December, repeatedly mentioning the Middle East conflict and thanking everyone who had supported her. 'So that's done now,' she said of her Sky job. 'But I am not. In fact, I'm just getting started. 'So I'm sorry to those who had hoped otherwise. I'm somewhat surprisingly much harder to kill off than you'd think. 'You see the problem is - and it's always been this way with me - I just care too much. 'About you, about the world, about a peaceful existence for every single child.' Molan has called Hamas terrorists 'blood-thirsty killers' and said she would continue 'fighting for every single hostage still captive in Gaza'. Markson's post on X came shortly after Molan's video went live. 'I have to clear up this notion that her departure from Sky is because of her Zionism - this is categorically untrue,' she said. 'No media outlet globally has shown more leadership or clarity on Israel's fight against terrorism and our own battle against antisemitism than us at Sky News Australia and News Corp.' Although network insiders suggested Molan was caught off-guard by the decision to cancel her show, Sky insisted they had ended their partnership with the host on amicable terms. Molan presented her weekly news program, Erin, for the final time on November 29. The decision to cancel Molan's show comes just months after the breakfast radio program she co-hosted alongside comedians Dave Hughes and Ed Kavalee was scrapped by Southern Cross Austereo's struggling 2DayFM station in August. The cancellation of Molan's two key hosting roles is understood to have come at a significant financial cost to the journalist. Sources said she had been pulling in about $200,000 a year for her 2DayFM radio gig and a further $150,000 a year from her job with Sky. Molan joined Sky News Australia in July 2022 after parting ways with Nine after 11 years at the network.
Daily Mail
16 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Lindsay Lohan leaves Kelly Ripa shocked over the real reason she left Hollywood
Lindsay Lohan surprised Kelly Ripa this week when she revealed the true reason she left Hollywood to live in Dubai. The 39-year-old longtime actress cited privacy as the main motive behind her move. 'It's just far away from Hollywood, and I live a very normal life,' the silver screen star confessed while promoting her upcoming movie Freakier Friday on Live with Kelly and Mark on Monday. Lindsay shares two-year-old son Luau with her husband Bader Shammas. She explained, 'There's no worry of, like, I can't go eat at this place 'cause someone's gonna take a picture of my son. And it's just, I feel very safe.' Kelly was stunned to learn how strict Dubai is when it comes to snapping photos in public. 'No, it's not legal,' Lindsay answered when the longtime talk show host asked if there are photographers where she lives. 'You can't even take a picture of someone else if you're at a restaurant. You have to ask the person, which is a big difference from here,' the Parent Trap actress said. 'What? That's incredible!' Kelly gasped in shock before the guest star emphasized, 'Yeah, privacy is key.' Lindsay initially relocated to Dubai in 2014. In November 2021, the Herbie: Fully Loaded actress took to Instagram to announce her engagement to Shammas. She showed off her diamond ring as she posed with her new fiancé, writing in the caption: 'My love. My life. My family. My future.' Lindsay wed her partner in 2022 and revealed the news by referring to him as her 'husband' in an Instagram message that she posted on her 36th birthday. In May the lifelong entertainer told Elle magazine she'd like for her son to have a sibling to play with. 'I feel like we live in a different world now, where women make it such a point, especially in motherhood, to make time for ourselves. 'We make it important. But also, once you have one kid, you're like, "Oh, my kid needs a kid to play with,"' she shared. She also noted, 'I don't know if it's selfish — but I'm like, I need more than one kid to take care of me when I'm older.' This comes after the Lohans came out in full force in support of Freakier Friday. Lindsay was supported by practically her entire family at a special screening of the new film on Monday. Joined by her husband Bader, mom Dina Lohan, 62, and siblings Ali, 31, Michael Jr., 37, and Dakota, 29, Lindsay couldn't have looked happier to have her family by her side on her big night. The Parent Trap actress looked mesmerizing in a fitted white dress with flared tulle skirt and strappy heels. Lindsay, who has been praised for her gorgeous complexion as of late, coated her blemish-free visage with shimmering blush, a nude coat of lip gloss, and a dramatic dusting of eye shadow. Her long blonde hair cascade down in mermaid inspired waves while a delicate necklace injected another punch of glam. Lindsay's mother Dina also looked incredible in a lilac floral print dress with her hair styled in loose waves and a side swept bang. As for sister Ali, she wowed in a silky blue dress and messy bun. Brother Dakota opted for an edgy energy with a black tank top, chain necklace, and grey slacks. Michael Jr. looked dapper in a grey suit, posing beside his wife Nina.
The Herald Scotland
17 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
John Swinney issues 'freedom of speech' warning at Festival
Mr Swinney was speaking at the Edinburgh International Festival's headquarters days after Jewish performers claimed their Fringe shows had been cancelled by venues who cited safety concerns raised by staff. Read more: The First Minister, who praised the 'glorious diversity' of Scotland in his speech at The Hub venue, stressed the importance of performers having the ability to 'challenge us, to ask us tough questions, and to force us to look at things from different perspectives.' He added: 'Culture that helps us to understand ourselves, to understand each other and to understand the world around about us.' Mr Swinney, who said he wanted to ensure Scotland was a country of 'robust debate and inquiry,' later launched a new defence of Edinburgh-based investment firm Baillie Gifford, one of the key corporate backers of both the EIF and the Fringe. Pro-Palestine campaigners have called for the both events to sever their links with the firm, which is said to have more than £60m worth of investments in a defence giant which has worked with state-owned arms companies in Israel. In his speech, Mr Swinney admitted global conflict was 'redrawing the world order', and said years of economic stagnation and austerity in the UK had left people disillusioned and alienated, and expression concern at how new technology had left people 'much more exposed to disinformation and harmful material.' He added: 'I want to ensure that Scotland's culture sector continues to bring people together for many generations to come. 'I know that, just like the government, this sector has faced significant and prolonged financial pressures. 'You've been squeezed by rising costs, by new restrictions on the freedom of movement in Europe, by job losses during the pandemic and too many other challenges to mention. I know also that freedom of expression is under greater and greater attack, both at home and around the world. 'I want to ensure that Scotland – the birthplace of the enlightenment – remains a country of robust debate and inquiry. 'I firmly believe that art and culture must be able to challenge us, to ask us tough questions, and to force us to look at things from different perspectives. 'And yes, it must at times be allowed to shock and to offend us. It can also heal us. So let me be absolutely clear – as First Minister I will always protect freedom of speech in our country. 'It is not the First Minister's job to tell you what to create – nor would I ever seek to do so.' Mr Swinney was later asked about controversy over the cancellation of Fringe shows by Jewish performers Rachel Creeger and Philip Simon, and the renewed calls for Baillie Gifford to be dropped by festivals. He said: "What I make a pitch for is an atmosphere of tolerance and respect for other people's opinions. If we all have respect for each other's opinions then we will be able to enable everyone to express their opinions. "I believe in freedom of speech and that we should be tolerant of others. "I feel our society is healthier where we have an expression of views respectively and courteously, so all of us are able to do so on all subjects, but particularly on the issues of the greatest sensitivity. "I want there to be freedom of expression and I want people to be able to air their views. "Some of the ability to do that and the creation of opportunities to do so comes through the sponsorship that is offered by organisations like Baillie Gifford. "My view hasn't changed from what I said before. I think Baillie Gifford has an important contribution to make as one organisation to the offer of philanthropic support for the arts."
