X, India spar over lawyer's 'Tom, Dick, and Harry' remark for government officials
X has long been at loggerheads with Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government over content removal requests.
The remarks were made during a hearing on the U.S. firm's challenge to a government-run website it says is a "censorship portal" that allows officials to issue content removal orders. New Delhi says the website is only to swiftly notify companies of their due diligence obligations.
India is a critical growth market for X owner Musk, who is getting closer to launching his other key ventures Starlink and Tesla in the country.
During the court hearing, X's lawyer, K. G. Raghavan, said it recently received a notice from the railways department to remove a video in which a car was being driven on a railway track. That was news, but the government found it unlawful, he told the court.
"This is the danger, My Lord, that is done now, if every Tom, Dick, and Harry officer is authorised," Raghavan told the high court in the southern state of Karnataka.
The phrase drew immediate condemnation from India's Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, who said "officers are not Tom, Dick, or Harry ... they are statutory functionaries".
"No social media intermediary can expect completely unregulated functioning," Mehta said.
India's IT ministry and X did not respond to Reuters queries.
In 2021, X, formerly called Twitter, was locked in a stand-off with the Indian government over non-compliance with legal orders to block certain tweets. It later complied, but is still locked in a court fight related to the move.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Independent Singapore
4 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
Meta faces backlash over account suspensions amid mounting user frustration
After Meta's admission that it erroneously suspended many Facebook Groups last week, the social media platform is now under intense scrutiny, especially after it attributed the issue to a 'technical error.' A 'technical error' with real-world consequences According to the latest BBC report, for many users of the Meta platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, the problem goes beyond an anomaly in the system. For many, it means interrupted business transactions, severed social connections, and has led to emotional anguish. Despite Meta's assurances that the issue is being addressed, thousands of netizens have testified to being locked out of personal and professional accounts, without warning or clear-cut explanations. Additionally, many say their efforts to appeal against their account suspensions were met with mechanical replies, leaving them feeling helpless and ignored. From lost income to lost memories Among the most vocal detractors is Brittany Watson, a 32-year-old from Ontario, Canada, who initiated a petition when her Facebook account was abruptly deactivated for nine days. 'Facebook isn't just an app for me,' she told BBC News. 'It was years of memories, connections with family, mental health support groups.' See also Sophie the robot whips up oodles of Singapore noodles Brittany says the psychological impact and the draining experience were serious, and her story has reverberated extensively—over 25,000 people have signed her petition. She disputes Meta's description of the problem as isolated to Facebook Groups: 'There is a problem—it's personal accounts, business accounts, Facebook pages, and Groups.' In the meantime, in the UK, journalist John Dale also could not access his Facebook account, and lost control over a local news group with over 5,000 members. His posts were erased, and he can no longer moderate the group of which he is the sole admin. 'It's frozen in time,' he said, adding that his appeal has so far yielded little information from Meta. No human in sight: AI moderation under fire The absence of customer service and the platform's apparent dependence on AI to deal with content moderation and appeals have come under condemnation. Michelle DeMalo, a digital vendor from Niagara Falls, says she suffered a huge financial hit when her Facebook and Instagram accounts were shut off last month. Though her accounts were restored spontaneously the day after the BBC contacted Meta, she is still traumatised by the torment. 'There is no human being you can talk to,' she said. Sam Tall, a 21-year-old from Bournemouth, went through a similar shutdown of both his Facebook and Instagram accounts. His appeal was discarded within two minutes, which led him to think that no human eyes had read her appeal. 'There is absolutely no way that was seen by a person,' he said. 'All the memories, all my friends—gone.' Meta says it employs a blend of mechanical tools and human assessors to implement its community guidelines. But for many, the lack of transparency and real-time support has left them with more questions than answers, and a growing belief that the tech giant is not listening to them. With Reddit forums busy, social media protests swelling, and some users even contemplating a class action suit, Meta may find this problem won't be so easily fixed by attributing it to a 'technical error.'
CNA
5 hours ago
- CNA
India's ONGC signs deal with Japan's Mitsui OSK to build ethane carriers
India's Oil and Natural Gas (ONGC) said on Thursday it has signed an agreement with Japan's second-largest shipping company, Mitsui O.S.K. Lines (MOL), to build and operate two ethane carriers.
CNA
10 hours ago
- CNA
India Hindu pilgrimage begins in contested Kashmir
PAHALGAM: Hindus began a vast month-long pilgrimage in contested Indian Kashmir on Thursday (Jul 3), with many of the faithful starting from near the site where a deadly April attack triggered conflict with Pakistan. Last year, half a million devotees took part in the Amarnath pilgrimage to a sacred ice pillar located in a cave in the forested Himalayan hills above the town of Pahalgam. Pahalgam is the site where gunmen on Apr 22 killed 26 mostly Hindu tourists. New Delhi said the gunmen were backed by Pakistan, claims Islamabad rejected – triggering a series of tit-for-tat diplomatic measures that escalated into a four-day conflict. It was the worst standoff by the nuclear-armed nations since 1999, with more than 70 people killed in missile, drone and artillery fire on both sides, before a May 10 ceasefire. But pilgrim Muneshwar Das Shashtri, who travelled from Uttar Pradesh state, told AFP "there is no fear of any kind". "Our army is standing guard everywhere. No one can raise a finger towards us," he said. India has ramped up security for the event, deploying 45,000 troops with high-tech surveillance tools overseeing the gruelling trek to reach the high-altitude cave, dedicated to the Hindu deity of destruction Shiva. "We have multi-layered and in-depth security arrangements so that we can make the pilgrimage safe and smooth for the devotees," said VK Birdi, police chief for the Muslim-majority territory. "NOT AFRAID" At Pahalgam, soldiers have turned a tented base camp into a fortress encircled by razor wire. Troops in newly deployed armoured cars, or from gun positions behind sandbags, keep a close watch – efforts boosted by facial recognition cameras. "High-quality surveillance cameras have been installed at all major points along the route," said Manoj Sinha, the Indian-appointed top administrator for Jammu and Kashmir. All pilgrims must be registered and travel in guarded vehicle convoys, until they start out to walk. Camouflaged bunkers have been erected in the forests along the route, where dozens of makeshift kitchens provide free food. Electronic radio cards pinpoint their location. Pilgrims can take several days to reach the cave, perched at 3,900m high, around 30km uphill from the last easily motorable track. "Whatever the attack that was carried out here, I am not afraid. I have come to get a glimpse of baba (the ice formation)," said Ujwal Yadav, 29, from India's Uttar Pradesh state, undertaking his first pilgrimage to the shrine. "Such are the security arrangements here that no one can be hurt." Sinha has said that "public confidence is returning", but admits that pilgrim registration had dipped by 10 per cent this year. Once a modest, little-known ritual, attended by only a few thousand mainly local devotees, the pilgrimage has grown since an armed insurgency erupted in 1989. India's government has since heavily promoted the annual event, which runs until Aug 9. Rebels fighting against India's control of Kashmir have said the pilgrimage is not a target, but have warned they would act if it was used to assert Hindu dominance. In 2017, suspected rebels attacked a pilgrim bus, killing 11 people. The gunmen who carried out the Apr 22 killings remain at large, despite the manhunt by security forces in Kashmir where India has half a million soldiers permanently deployed. On Jun 22, India's National Investigation Agency said two men had been arrested from the Pahalgam area who they said had "provided food, shelter and logistical support" to the gunmen.
