Penang does not sell land to meet state expenditure
Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow said that therefore, the term 'land sale' is not used in the context of state government land administration and emphasised that it is not merely for generating revenue, but also to drive development, create job opportunities, and add economic value to the local area.
'For land disposal matters, the state government will consider current land valuation based on the Valuation and Property Services Department (JPPH). If the land involves strategic projects, including housing construction, the state will use the Request for Proposal (RFP) approach to dispose of the land.
'This allows the state government to obtain a higher premium income than the current land valuation,' he said during his winding-up speech on the opening address by the Penang Yang di-Pertua Negeri, Tun Ramli Ngah Talib, at today's state legislative assembly.
He said that land disposal methods do not reduce state holdings or solely aim to increase state revenue, as a limited resource like land is used for development and to enhance socioeconomic conditions of affected areas.
If the approach adopted is not to develop the land, Chow explained that it would become a burden on the state as it would then incur costs of maintenance. Additionally, the people would not be able to enjoy the benefits of developing the site, such as the construction of roads, playgrounds and other facilities.
He also stated that Penang should not be ashamed of developing land for the state's progress and the welfare of the people.
'We (Penang) don't have gold mines, we don't have timber -- why should we be ashamed if land is our (only) asset? There are no other sources of revenue, so why be evasive about relying on land development to generate income?
'This (land sale) is to drive socioeconomic development in our state. Over the past 50 years, this has been Penang's generic formula,' he said.
Meanwhile, Chow mentioned that the State Finance Department has conducted a review of state revenue from two perspectives: first, by increasing the collection of existing state revenue, including tax arrears, through data cleansing methods and reviewing irrelevant rates.
The second perspective, he said, is through identifying new sources and methods for generating state revenue, including reviewing land tax rates, reclassifying rural areas into urban and strengthening state statutory bodies to enable the implementation of new revenue collection.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Resistance to Buntong market redevelopment
PLANS to demolish and redevelop the 70-year-old Buntong wet market in Ipoh, Perak, have sparked opposition from some traders there. A longstanding hub for fresh produce, spices, clothing and other essentials, Buntong market has been a mainstay in the community for decades. However, it faces issues such as outdated infrastructure and drainage problems, which have prompted the government to push for extensive renovations similar to those underway at Pasir Pinji market. Trader concerns Buntong assemblyman Thulsi Manogaran said the plan is to build a one-storey facility with modern facilities while maintaining the heritage value of the Buntong market. Traders will be relocated to a temporary market to be built at an open area at Jalan Kantan, between First Garden and Buntong. The Buntong wet market has about 190 active traders, who will be moved to a temporary site which will be built along Jalan Kantan. Despite the proposed benefits, many traders argue the redevelopment is unnecessary and a waste of resources. Noodle and drink seller Chow Yeoi Sing, who has operated at the market for nearly 50 years, is among those against the plan. 'This market is like a second home to me. There's no need to build a new market. 'A few repairs and upgrades are all that's needed. 'Repainting, upgrading the drainage and resurfacing the floor would suffice,' Chow insisted. He claimed that 50% of traders opposed the move, primarily due to concerns about business disruption during relocation to the temporary site. 'We've been briefed, but there's no clarity on how long it will take or what the conditions will be. 'We don't agree with the redevelopment as it stands,' he added. Jalan Kanthan in Kampung Baru Buntong. Chow also highlighted that the market underwent an upgrade a few years ago, which included roof repairs and fan installations. Market facelift Housing and Local Government Minister Nga Kor Ming had earlier this year said that the Buntong market would be given a facelift. This is part of the ministry's efforts to rejuvenate markets nationwide that are 50 years and older, modernising them and turning them into tourist attractions. Currently, the 66-year-old Pasir Pinji wet market in Ipoh is undergoing a RM14mil redevelopment, which was announced by Nga in January 2023. Once completed, the new Pasir Pinji market, scheduled to be reopened in 2027, will be able to accommodate 214 traders and boast environment-friendly features. The Pasir Pinji traders are currently operating from a temporary site about 1km away. Apart from the Pasir Pinji market, Ipoh Central Market in the city centre is also set to undergo a major upgrade, costing about RM15mil. Buntong market also attracts locals for its inexpensive hawker food. Work is expected to start some time this year. Unwilling to move Despite the expected benefits of a new building with better facilities, some traders at Buntong market expressed fears that they will lose customers during the relocation. They claim the temporary site is inconvenient and unsafe. 'The temporary location at Jalan Kantan is not suitable. 'It is too far and looks eerie, especially as we open our stalls before sunrise,' said Lim Kan Yoke, who sells brooms and household equipment. 'The place looks secluded and we fear that our regular customers may not want to go there, causing us to lose business,' added Lim, who has been operating at the market for about 40 years. Wong Yoke, who sells clothing at the Buntong market, is also concerned about moving. 'How are we going to move our wares and equipment?' asked Wong, who has been operating at the market for more than 40 years. Traders at Buntong market say only minor repairs, such as resurfacing of damaged floors, are needed. 'Most of the traders here are elderly. Some may not even live long enough to move back (to the new market),' she pointed out. Lim urged the government not to waste funds redeveloping the market. 'I think the money can be spent on other things, like improving the roads or drainage system (in Buntong), and carrying out pest control. 'If the market is really in a dilapidated condition, then we would have no qualms about redeveloping it, but for us, it is still in good shape,' she said. The disgruntled traders approached Perak Gerakan public service and complaints bureau deputy chief V. Subramaniam for help in stopping the redevelopment project. 'I advised the traders to approach their assemblyman,' Subramaniam said, adding that he was willing to facilitate the dialogue. 'I think the traders will have a meeting among themselves before making any further decisions, so we will wait and see. 'I do hope that the traders' grouses will be heard,' he added. When contacted, Thulsi defended the redevelopment, citing numerous systemic issues such as traffic congestion, pest infestations and outdated drainage systems that cannot be resolved with minor upgrades. 'Rebuilding is the only viable solution. The market's current condition is not safe or conducive, especially for the elderly community,' she said. She said Buntong had one of the many active markets in the city. 'There is still a vibrant economy there. I think in order to uplift the people, there needs to be a modern market, which will be better, safer and cleaner,' she added. Redevelopment model Thulsi also assured that the redevelopment would maintain the market's heritage while providing modern facilities. As for the temporary market, it is about 1km from the current location, she said. 'It's the nearest available state-owned land. Once the temporary market is set up, we can proceed with redevelopment bids,' she said. As for the redevelopment project, Thulsi said it would follow the Pasir Pinji market model. 'The current Buntong market has about 190 active traders, so the plan is to have about 200 lots at the new premises. 'The design has yet to be finalised and I believe a competition to determine it will be held,' she said. 'As for the cost, it should be about RM14mil,' she added. She also said that a temporary market would need to be built first. 'The plan is to build the temporary market this year, with the redevelopment project starting next year,' she added. Despite ongoing objections, Thulsi noted that some traders were supportive of the project as they recognised its potential benefits. 'I'm continuously engaging with traders, encouraging them to form an association to voice out their concerns,' she added. To assuage fears, Thulsi arranged visits for Buntong traders to the temporary Pasir Pinji market. 'The aim is to highlight the positive aspects of redevelopment,' she said, adding that the traders seemed receptive.
The Sun
12 hours ago
- The Sun
Penang open to renegotiating Karpal Singh Drive reclamation project
BATU KAWAN: The Penang government has expressed willingness to renegotiate the proposed land reclamation project off Karpal Singh Drive following concerns raised by the NGO ProtectKarpal. Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow stated that the state remains committed to adhering to the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process before making any final decisions. Chow clarified that the public engagement session concluded on June 30, and the developer must address all concerns before proceeding. The project developer has until February next year to secure EIA approval. 'If approval is not granted, the project may not proceed. If approved, we are open to reviewing implementation methods to minimise environmental impact,' he said after officiating a new public market and hawker centre in Bandar Cassia. The ProtectKarpal group, consisting mainly of Karpal Singh Drive residents, raised objections regarding construction methods and environmental risks. They also urged the gazetting of the nearby Middle Bank as a marine sanctuary due to its ecological significance. Chow acknowledged these concerns, stating the state government is open to discussions despite an existing agreement between the Penang Development Corporation (PDC) and the developer. 'Adjusting the project scale may require compromises, particularly in land allocation, but balancing development and sustainability is crucial,' he added. The RM1 billion Jelutong landfill redevelopment, initiated in 2020, remains under scrutiny as environmental assessments continue. Meanwhile, the RM46 million Bandar Cassia public market and hawker centre project is set for completion by June 2027. - Bernama
The Star
18 hours ago
- The Star
Penang open to adjusting land reclamation project near Karpal Singh Drive
GEORGE TOWN: Penang may consider scaling down its portion of a proposed land reclamation project off Karpal Singh Drive if necessary, Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow says. Chow said the RM1bil project is still subject to approval from the Environment Department (DOE) through the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process. "We have a deadline to submit the EIA report by February 2026. "Until then, we can resubmit the report. "In the event we do not get it, we can still appeal and submit improvements," he told reporters after an event in Batu Kawan on Wednesday (July 3). Chow was responding to questions regarding a recent meeting with the environmental advocacy group Protect Karpal Singh Drive Action Committee. Chow said the state government would consider their concerns and remained open to discussions. "Matters can still be considered and negotiated. "If the project secures EIA approval, emphasis will be placed on the method of construction to address their concerns," he said. Chow added that Penang local government, town and country planning committee chairman H'ng Mooi Lye has since held discussions with PLB Engineering and the Penang Development Corporation (PDC) to better understand the details of the proposal. "For now, we are still waiting for the EIA decision. "There may be a need to revisit and renegotiate certain aspects of the project, especially since some land and components are allocated to the state. "Some of these involve profit-sharing arrangements, and we might have to give up part of our portion,' he added, noting that only the initial contract has been signed at this stage. In 2020, PDC signed a deal with PLB Engineering to rehabilitate and develop the Jelutong landfill, including reclaiming land off Karpal Singh Drive. The proposed project involving almost 65ha of land would involve 38.3ha of land reclamation off Karpal Singh Drive and the rehabilitation of the adjacent 36.4ha Jelutong landfill that has been operating since the 1990s. Post-rehabilitation, the area will transition into a mixed-development zone, with 20–30% of the reclaimed land allocated to the state. The RM1bil project, a collaboration between PDC and PLB Engineering Bhd, is awaiting Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) approval from DoE. The project would strictly avoid encroaching on the ecologically sensitive Middle Bank marine sanctuary, Chow assured. Activists have since called for rigorous oversight to ensure compliance with conservation commitments, given the sanctuary's irreplaceable role in Penang's marine heritage. Spanning approximately 10sqkm (3,861 acres or 1,562.49ha) in the South Channel between Penang Island and the mainland, the Middle Bank sanctuary is a linchpin of marine biodiversity in the Straits of Malacca. It hosts the region's only extensive seagrass bed, a critical ecosystem that supports over 429 documented species of flora and fauna. Among these are seven species of seagrass, which form underwater meadows vital for carbon sequestration, coastal protection, and nurturing juvenile marine life.
