Man who sold ‘extraordinarily rare' Seamus Heaney books has stolen property charge dismissed
Seamus Heaney
first editions worth €2,000 at a bric-a-brac stall has walked free from court.
Alan Ladak (70), of Fahy Gardens, Loughrea, Co
Galway
, admitted he was reckless in buying the books for about €40 each, with a view to selling them for a profit.
He pleaded not guilty at
Dublin District Court
to possessing stolen property last year, namely two books by the late Nobel Prize-winning poet – The Tollund Man, worth €1,250, and Shivers, valued at €750. The books previously disappeared from Kenny's Books in Galway.
They were located after Mr Ladak later went to sell them to the Temple Bar Bookshop in Dublin between May 1st and June 30th, 2024 and on October 6th, 2024.
READ MORE
Granting a dismissal, Judge Adrian Harris accepted legal submissions from defence counsel Aoife Mutch, which focused on the lack of evidence presented in court, as the two books, after being returned, were re-sold before the trial.
He was also found not guilty of unlawful possession of a knife on the date of his arrest.
Garda Alan Cawley questioned Mr Ladak, originally from England, who brought Shivers to the Temple Bar Bookshop on October 6th and returned four days later to complete the sale.
Mr Ladak's statement recorded that he was offered €200 for Shivers
on October 6th. He recalled selling
The Tollund Man
for €250 between May and June of last year.
He maintained he bought each book for about €40 from an anonymous bric-a-brac stall in Galway city centre.
Mr Ladak denied knowing they were stolen, but he agreed he had been reckless and was not diligent in establishing where the books came from.
'I thought they were cheap at the time, and I hoped to make money,' he said during interview, adding that he hoped to receive €200 for each.
Asked why he came to Dublin to sell them, he told the garda he had free travel, it was a day out and there were more shops there.
Tomás Kenny, of Kenny's Bookshop, recalled being contacted by Temple Bar Books about the edition of Shivers Mr Ladak brought in. He said only 125 copies were printed.
He described that edition as 'extraordinarily rare', having been signed to poet Gerard Fanning.
He said publisher Peter Fallon had autographed the other book and they had previously gone missing from his bookstore.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
GAA pay tribute to Fermanagh shooting victims at All-Ireland football final
The GAA have paid tribute to the victims of a fatal shooting in Maguiresbridge with a minute's applause at Croke Park ahead of Sunday's All-Ireland SFC final. Vanessa Whyte, who was 45, and her children, Sara (13) and James (14) died after they were shot at their home in the Co Fermanagh village on Wednesday. A male who also suffered gunshot wounds remains in a serious condition in hospital. Vanessa Whyte and her children were active members of two local GAA teams. In separate statements on Wednesday night, both St Mary's Maguiresbridge Gaelic Football Club and Lisbellaw St Patrick's Hurling Club offered "heartfelt condolences to the families and friends of those impacted by the tragic incident. Vanessa Whyte and her children, Sarah and James "We are working with the GAA at county, provincial and national level, to implement the Association's critical incident protocols. We will work closely with all appropriate services to ensure that those who require support at this difficult time can access it. "The deceased were all active and beloved members of our club. We will not be making any further comment at this difficult time." A murder investigation has been launched, and police are probing a triple murder and attempted suicide line of inquiry. Ahead of today's All-Ireland SFC final at Croke Park between Donegal and Kerry, a minute's applause was warmly received with a picture of the mother and children displayed on the big screen at Croke Park. Ulster champions Donegal, managed by Jim McGuinness, are hoping to win their third All-Ireland title today as they take on Jack O'Connor's Kerry, who are bidding to win the Sam Maguire Cup for the 39th time.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘We are coming here with hearts broken': Prayer service to be held for Fermanagh shooting victims
A prayer service will be held in Co Clare for a mother and two children killed in a shooting incident in Co Fermanagh . Vanessa Whyte (45), a vet from Co Clare, her son James (14) and daughter Sara (13), were killed in a suspected triple murder and attempted suicide at a house in Maguiresbridge on Wednesday morning. Ms Whyte was originally from Barefield, a village near Ennis in Co Clare. A murder investigation has been launched, while an adult male remains in a serious condition in hospital. READ MORE A prayer service will take place at the Church of Immaculate Conception in Barefield on Sunday evening. A notice on the parish website describes it as a service to remember Vanessa, Sara and James. Barefield parish priest, Fr Tom Fitzpatrick, said the community wanted to gather together to remember the family. The prayer service has been organised to take place on Sunday evening to allow for Ms Whyte's brother, Ivor, to travel home from Australia . 'The prayer service was organised by the community, myself and the pastoral council. We planned it days ago,' Fr Fitzpatrick said. 'The purpose of the service is to gather as a community and be with the family and let them know we are thinking of them and we are here in shock and in pain. 'When something happens in a rural community, even to one person, it affects everybody. We are coming here with hearts broken. A lot of the community knew Vanessa and she was so well loved.' It is understood that the funeral of the mother and her two children will take place in Barefield later this week. On Saturday, detectives from the major investigation team, who are carrying out the murder investigation, said they are continuing with their inquiries and appealed for information involving the movements of a vehicle. Detective Chief Inspector Neil McGuinness said: 'Our investigation is ongoing and we are working tirelessly to determine the exact circumstances of this tragedy. 'I would continue to appeal generally for anyone with information to come forward, and more specifically, I would ask anyone who saw a silver Mercedes saloon car being driven in the Clones Road area of Newtownbutler, or between Maguiresbridge and Newtownbutler, on the evening of Tuesday July 22nd, to call detectives on 101, quoting reference 276 23/07/25. 'Anyone who was travelling in the area and who may have captured dashcam footage which could assist, please get in touch.' The man who remains in a serious condition in hospital was a member of the same household, the PSNI said. On Friday, hundreds of people attended a community vigil for the family in Maguiresbridge. – PA
Sunday World
9 hours ago
- Sunday World
Dad of boy hurt by Clare hurling star shows pictures of wounds sustained in incident
Family of youngster injured by the former All-Stae believe a 'dangerous precedent' set by not-guilty verdict Photographs show the extent of the boy's injuries following the dispute at the disused hotel Photographs show the extent of the boy's injuries following the dispute at the disused hotel Niall Gilligan faced charges after causing injuries to a 12-year-old boy at a disused hotel he owns The family of a 12-year-old boy who was hit with a stick and kicked by All-Ireland winning hurler Niall Gilligan have released shocking images of the youngster's injuries – days after the former All Star was acquitted of assault. The boy's father yesterday told the Sunday World his son (now 14) had told him 'I want people to see my injuries' because he feels he has been unfairly vilified as a result of the outcome of the case. The images, which were shown in court, show how the boy suffered bruising to his right shoulder, a fractured bone in his left hand, a 2cm wound to his right forearm and a 2cm wound to his left shin – as a result of the blows and kicks he sustained. The incident occurred after Gilligan found him trespassing at a property he owned. The boy's father said yesterday he believes the jury's decision to find Gilligan not guilty, after being shown these images during the trial, sets a dangerous precedent in what can now be considered 'proportionate force' in cases where self-defence is used. Niall Gilligan faced charges after causing injuries to a 12-year-old boy at a disused hotel he owns 'We feel the verdict was the wrong one,' the boy's father said. 'This was very much a legal decision where a deep understanding of the law was required and I don't know if that should be left up to 12 random people. 'This man was accused, he admitted being there and he admitted applying the force that caused these injuries and yet he walked free. 'And, ultimately, I think that sets a dangerous precedent for what self-defence can be, especially when it involves a minor. 'This wasn't his home house; it was a premises that had been derelict for about a decade. 'For me, that's what stung here, that 12 people made a legal decision after seeing these pictures of my son's injuries, that this was a justified use of force. Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 27th 'Just because stitches can be removed in a week, doesn't mean these weren't serious injuries. 'The broken bone in his hand healed in a month, but it doesn't mean it's not a broken bone. 'And we're not talking about the psychological damage — we're talking about the physical injuries. 'It leaves a bitter taste in our mouth.' Mr Gilligan, a former Clare hurler, stood trial before Ennis Circuit Court charged with assault causing harm to the boy at the Jamaica Inn Hostel in Sixmilebridge, which he owned, on October 5, 2023. The ex-sportsman, who is a farmer and auctioneer, was also charged with producing a wooden stick capable of inflicting serious injury during the course of a dispute. Both charges were denied by the 48-year-old, who claimed he had acted in self-defence. It was the prosecution's case that two boys had exited the building and were outside when Mr Gilligan encountered them while checking on the property that night. In his evidence, the boy claimed Mr Gilligan hit him 'full force' with the stick and that there were repeated blows. The boy said he tried to defend himself by putting up his hand and that his wrist ended up as 'big as a sliotar'. He said he could not feel anything because he was 'just terrified'. 'He was so tall and I was so small. It just scared me,' he said. Photographs show the extent of the boy's injuries following the dispute at the disused hotel . . . The boy admitted during cross-examination that it had been his third time going into the Jamaica Inn Hostel, and that he had stolen keys to the property and let off fire extinguishers there with a friend. A majority verdict acquitting Mr Gilligan was returned after five hours of deliberations. Speaking yesterday, the boy's father said the impact this incident has had on his son and his family are immeasurable. 'We can only protect him to the best of our ability,' he said. 'We sent him for counselling and we'll probably have to send him for counselling again. 'He's going to run into this guy again at some stage and I don't know how he will react. 'He's a 14-year-old boy now and he's seen the comments, he's reading what being said in the articles, and he's seen the smears against him. 'The building had been abandoned and was a popular place for teenagers to go and yet every bit of damage that was ever done there is being blamed on him. 'My son and his friend admitted what they did, they entered the premises a few times and messed with fire extinguishers and hid keys they found so they could get back in. 'But their fear now is this will follow them for the rest of their lives. 'So for us, and for my son, the pictures show the extent of what happened here. 'And we've promised him we'll get his word out there. 'At the start he didn't want the photos out there but after reading the comments he came to me and said: 'I want people to see the injuries … these people need to see the injuries.' 'That's a 14-year-old boy saying that. 'He's willing to do this to clear his name. He's the victim here and yet feels he's being made out to be some kind of a criminal.' Contacted by the Sunday World yesterday, Mr Gilligan said he was busy and not in a position to discuss the case but might do so at a later stage. The court heard how in a prepared statement to gardaí, Mr Gilligan said he came into contact with the boy in a corridor inside the building, not outside, and that he acted in a reasonable manner to protect his property from destruction by fire and further damage. He claimed the boy and others had broken into the building and caused extensive damage, including lighting a fire, releasing fire extinguishers, breaking windows and writing graffiti. 'I acted in a reasonable manner to protect myself from injury and assault from a person or persons unknown to me'. The statement went on to say Mr Gilligan heard footsteps behind him and did not know 'who or what' was coming at him. He said he felt he was going to be attacked and, to protect himself, 'drew out with the stick on two occasions and then kicked out twice'. Mr Gilligan's counsel argued the former hurling star did not know he was dealing with a child and was in the dark and believed he was under siege. He was 'at the end of his tether' due to the vandalism of a vacant property he was trying to sell. The force used was reasonable in the circumstances as Mr Gilligan believed them to be, it was argued. Judge Francis Comerford told jurors they had to decide if the incident was an assault or not an assault due to lawful excuse. They were told lawful use of force could not be considered as a defence if the first encounter with the boy was outside the building rather than in the corridor. The judge said that if it was in the corridor, jurors would then have to consider whether the force used was reasonable and necessary in the circumstances as Mr Gilligan saw them.
