Italy cracks down on sweatshops feeding Loro Piana, Armani, Dior
The crackdown, led by Milan's corporate court and the labor-crimes unit of the Carabinieri military police, has snared contractors linked to five well-known fashion labels including Valentino, Armani and Dior.
Loro Piana, owned by French luxury powerhouse LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE, became the latest on Monday, and was placed under court supervision for up to a year.
'There is already a reputational issue in the fashion industry, which started with prices spiraling unreasonably,' said Stefania Saviolo, a lecturer on fashion and luxury management at Milan's Bocconi University. 'These investigations not only damage the brands involved, they affect all of Made in Italy as a system.'
Loro Piana, part of LVMH since 2013, denied wrongdoing and said it will cooperate with authorities. The company said it terminated relations with the supplier within 24 hours of being informed of the contractors' existence.
The fragmented, mostly family-run structure of high-quality Italian manufacturing 'can pose challenges in transparency and oversight,' said Toni Belloni, president of LVMH Italy. The group has strengthened controls and revised its internal charter, he said in a statement to Bloomberg News. 'However, areas of fragility remain, so we must work to improve our practices.'
The fashion industry is one of Italy's biggest, accounting for about €96 billion worth of Made in Italy products in 2024, according to industry group Camera Nazionale della Moda. The vast majority are destined for overseas markets.
Yet the tailor's case shines a light on the treatment of workers who make garments that can cost thousands. He worked from 9 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily through late 2024, when his 'caporale,' or boss — also a Chinese transplant — stopped paying him for unknown reasons, according to the court documents.
After repeated demands for his wages, a confrontation ensued. The employer punched the tailor and beat him repeatedly with an aluminum tube, the documents said, leading to a criminal complaint.
Past enforcement efforts have failed to stamp out labor abuses.
'These cases have been increasing in the last few years, with more big groups taking control of smaller Italian companies and starting outsourcing part of the production,' said Roberta Griffini, secretary for the Filctem CGIL Milano union.
Responsibility is sometimes hard to determine because subcontractors work for more than one fashion group, Griffini added.
The UK has also cracked down on illegal sweatshops, particularly small factories operating in cities such as Leicester. A 2021 UK report found companies in numerous industries couldn't guarantee their supply chains were free from forced labor.
For fashion producers in Italy, the supply chain should be short and closely monitored, said Saviolo of Bocconi University. Younger consumers in particular are paying more attention to brand credibility.
Milan is the locus of the sprawling fashion industry in Italy, housing about one-fourth of the nation's 600,000 fashion workers across some 60,000 companies, according to Camera Nazionale della Moda.
The Lombardy region's dense ecosystem of design studios, tanneries and sample makers gives brands unrivaled speed but also shelters what prosecutors called 'a generalised manufacturing method' in which legitimate subcontractors parcel out work to micro-factories operating from converted garages and semi-legal industrial parks.
Chinese-owned firms make up a significant part of this complex. About 20% of Lombardy's 10,000-plus textile workshops and factories are Chinese-owned, according to Milan's Chamber of Commerce. The area has drawn a large number of Chinese immigrants, driven by small-business opportunities, globalization of the fashion industry and growing family ties.
The judicial clampdown in Italy is unfolding against a jittery global backdrop, with demand falling and a US-led tariff war threatening to magnify export costs.
The personal luxury-goods industry, worth €364 billion, lost 50 million customers in 2023 and 2024, Bain estimated last year. The sector will shrink between 2% and 5% this year, according to the consulting firm's June follow-up.
Italy's fashion industry was already grappling with falling sales, inflation and international tensions. Brands squeezed by softer demand and volatile costs have doubled down on 'near-shoring' quick orders to Lombardy's workshop belt to protect margins.
That very strategy, say prosecutors, is fueling the race to the bottom that the courts are now trying to halt.
Investigators traced Loro Piana's knitwear to intermediaries which subcontracted to factories where illegal migrants worked 90 hours a week and slept next to their sewing machines. The judges said the firm 'negligently benefited' from illegal cost-cutting.
The judicial administrator appointed Monday is tasked with monitoring Loro Piana management's progress toward addressing its supply chain.
The issues have been similar at other luxury brands, including Giorgio Armani Operations, Dior Manufactures, Valentino Bags Lab and Alviero Martini: opaque layers of small subcontractors, paper safety records and a workforce of mostly undocumented Chinese migrants.
Armani, Dior and Alviero Martini were released of court oversight after implementing measures such as real-time supplier audits. The unit of Valentino, which is owned by Kering SA and Qatar's Mayhoola, is still subject to court monitoring.
The Italian Competition Authority has also been involved. In May it closed an unfair-practices probe into Dior, securing €2 million in funds for anti-exploitation initiatives and requiring the company to improve supplier vetting.
Dior noted then that no infringement was established, and said it is dedicated to high standards of ethics and excellence.
Armani Group, still under investigation by the competition authority over alleged unfair commercial practices, said the allegations have no merit and its companies are cooperating with authorities.
In Milan, coordination has tightened with an accord in May between the Milan Prefecture, the fashion chamber, trade unions and leading brands. The pact sets up a shared database of vetted suppliers and commits signatories to regular certifications.
The outcome of the Loro Piana case for now rests with updates to the bench on its progress.
As for the tailor, the Milan prosecutor is now trying to get him hired legally, according to a person familiar with the matter, who asked not to be named discussing a personal matter. This would require the employer to make pension contributions, pay taxes and provide standard benefits.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local France
an hour ago
- Local France
French prosecutors demand Fiat face trial in diesel scandal
A source close to the case, who asked not to be named, told AFP on Wednesday that the Paris prosecutors' office made the demand on June 30th, accusing Fiat of aggravated fraud. It would be the fourth trial demanded in France against major car makers after cases against Volkswagen and the French companies Peugeot-Citroen and Renault. The source said the Italian company is accused of selling Fiat, Alfa Romeo and Jeep vehicles fitted with diesel engines that 'frequently exceeded the regulatory threshold for nitrogen oxide emissions', highly dangerous to humans, between 2014 and 2017. The scandal has caused waves in the global car industry since September 2015, when Volkswagen admitted tampering with millions of diesel vehicles to dupe pollution tests. Advertisement A German court in May convicted and handed prison sentences, some suspended, to four former Volkswagen managers over their part in the scandal. Filing their case against Volkswagen in February, French prosecutors said nearly one million French customers had to pay for servicing and repairs after the emissions breach was revealed.
Euronews
4 hours ago
- Euronews
Retaliatory tariffs: Which EU countries could be impacted the most?
The EU is gearing up for retaliation in case trade negotiations with Washington fail by 1 August. Should there be no agreement, the US will start charging 30% tariffs on almost all goods imported from the bloc. After having been caught off guard by a letter threatening the 30% duty on EU goods last weekend, the European Commission has quickly tabled a plan to put countertariffs on US exports worth €72 billion, inevitably hitting the European Union's own economy. This is a follow-up on the European Commission's previously proposed list of US products, worth €95bn, that could be hit with EU countertariffs. The potential EU retaliatory tariffs target imports of industrial goods from the US, including aircraft and aircraft parts, machinery, automotives, chemicals and plastics, and medical devices and equipment. These types of imports are worth €65.7bn out of the €72bn total. It also lists agricultural products, including bourbon, but there are minor though surprising items, such as amusement park rides, toothbrushes, hairbrushes and natural rubber latex. If imposed, the tariffs mean that European consumers or businesses would buy these products at a higher price, pushing up inflation. However, according to Sylvain Broyer, chief European economist, S&P Global Ratings, the inflationary effect of countermeasures could be minimal. He told Euronews Business that 'EU tariffs on US goods would have only a modest impact on European inflation — likely just a couple of tenths of a percentage point — and are unlikely to significantly affect overall economic activity.' The bigger risk may come from supply chain disruptions. Where Europe could really feel the pinch is in services: 'the EU is highly reliant on US services, particularly in sectors like technology, payments and consulting,' Broyer said. Which EU countries are hit the most by these countermeasures? Certain industries, propping up various countries' economies, could face serious supply chain disruptions if the EU and the US go into a trade war. Aviation is one of them, as aeroplanes and aircraft parts are some of the products set to be the most dramatically impacted by EU countermeasures. Potential EU import restrictions on these goods, worth nearly €11bn, according to a document from the European Commission. Within the member states, the country with the biggest US aircraft imports in 2024 was Ireland, followed by France, the Netherlands and Germany. Aviation between the US and EU is a highly interconnected sector. French multinational aerospace and defence company Thales supplies US-based Boeing and European competitor Airbus with flight management systems and cockpit displays. In exchange, US aerospace giant Honeywell provides flight management systems for Airbus. Apart from threatening serious breakdowns in the supply chain, the EU's potential retaliatory tariffs on US-made aircraft is a direct blow to Boeing. The firm sourced 13% or more than $8.7bn (€7.5bn) of its revenues from Europe in 2024. Any such step from the EU may risk higher US tariffs on European aircraft. For the European firm Airbus, its North America revenue was double that of Boeing's last year, at more than $16bn (€13.8bn). Ireland left vulnerable Potential EU countermeasures on aircraft imports, coupled with retaliation from the US administration, could risk Ireland's position as a world-leading hub in aviation. Ireland is home to more than 50 aircraft leasing companies managing 10,000 aircraft. According to a recent report by aviation investment group Irelandia, this is equivalent to 37% of the global commercial fleet and makes the country a central player in the world's air transport infrastructure. Ireland is already facing a serious hit to its economy due to potentially high US tariffs on its exports to the US after the 1 August deadline. The country is deemed to be one of the most affected economies in the EU, besides Germany. Brussels-based think tank Bruegel has estimated that Ireland's cumulative real GDP loss, due to the total impact of US tariffs, could be 3% by 2028. That's if, as President Trump has promised, pharmaceutical goods face heavy duties. 'In Ireland's case, the aircraft imports amount to over 1% of GDP, in the Netherlands, the large machinery and medicinal equipment imports are equivalent to 6% of GDP,' Rory Fennessy, senior economist at Oxford Economics, told Euronews Business. Belgium's overall imports from the US are equivalent to 5% of GDP. Machinery is the second most concerned product group on the Commission's list, imports worth €9.43bn would be hit by countertariffs. That would come as a shock to supply chains in Germany, the Netherlands, France and Ireland. 'Even if countries have a limited direct import exposure to the United States, there can be significant spillovers to other countries simply down to the close supply chain integration and the impact on adjacent support industries due to tariffs,' said Fennessy. One of the key examples is the close relationship between Germany and the Central and Eastern European countries, including Hungary, Poland and Slovakia, especially with regards to the automotive sector. Countries in Central and Eastern Europe have been attracting a lot of foreign investment, much of which came from Germany. This plays an important role in driving the region's development. And vehicles are the third-largest product group exposed to potential retaliatory tariffs. The country with the highest imports of vehicles or parts from the US is Germany, worth nearly €7.5bn in 2024, followed by Belgium (€1.8bn). These countries would feel the most pressure from higher prices in this sector. 'But of course, the exact spillover varies and some countries are more directly exposed in certain sectors, so would likely feel a quicker price impact in such cases,' Fennessy added. If prices go up, even temporarily, while companies try to find new sources to contribute to their supply chains, that would be another blow to Germany's ailing automotive sector and could lead to more cost-cutting measures from the major brands, including Volkswagen and Mercedes. These firms have production plants in Hungary and elsewhere in central and eastern Europe. What other products are concerned? The European Commission's product hit list includes chemicals and plastics, as well as medical devices, with each category amounting to more than €7.5bn worth of imports from the US to the EU in 2024. The most affected countries are Belgium, the Netherlands and Germany. As for chemicals, the EU nation that buys the most from the US is Belgium, with €13.7bn worth of imports in 2024. That's followed by the Netherlands with €12.5bn and Germany with €12.3bn. When it comes to plastics, Belgium tops the list with more than €3bn of US imports, followed by Germany (€2bn) and the Netherlands with €1.5bn. Imports of US medical devices in the EU was the highest in the Netherlands, where these products were worth €4.63bn. That's followed by Germany, with €2.65bn in imports, and Belgium with more than €1bn. The EU is also considering putting retaliatory tariffs on €6.4bn worth of agricultural products, including bourbon whiskey. The country that imports the most bourbon from the US is the Netherlands, buying goods worth more than €60 million a year. This, on its own, may not hurt the economy. But if the European spirits and drinks sector is exposed to Washington's countermeasures, French wine and Irish whiskey would also be targeted. If there is no agreement between the US and the EU before Trump's deadline, the European agricultural sector, among many others, will face a 30% tariff on its exports to the US, a consequence labelled catastrophic by French lobbying groups. Brussels says it is still seeking a deal to avoid a tit-for-tat escalation in the trade war but is poised to retaliate if needed.
LeMonde
5 hours ago
- LeMonde
In Arles, Fragonard's Museum of Fashion and Costume gracefully unveils treasures
At 10 am on June 5, at 16 Rue de la Calade, in the southern French city of Arles, the truck finally arrived. It had left Grasse at dawn, but in this narrow and busy street in the historic center, delivering the precious cargo proved challenging. It was an important day. About 30 mannequins were set to join the future Fragonard Museum of Fashion and Costume. At first, they would be stored in the reserves on the third floor, alongside the library, restoration workshop and offices. Their accessories followed, packed in large cardboard boxes, with a single outfit sometimes requiring up to 20 boxes. Pushed on carts, these enigmatic, white-shrouded figures drew questions from an amused passerby: "What is this? Ghosts?" With just a month to go before the opening, several tradespeople were putting the finishing touches on the site. The teams were more excited than ever. Orchestrating the operations, museum and textile collections director Clément Trouche showed no sign of stress, greeting everyone with a kind word. An iconic perfumer from Grasse since 1926, Fragonard is now run by the fourth generation of a family of enthusiasts and collectors. In France, the company operates not only three production sites, 25 boutiques and a guesthouse (in Arles), but also several museums in Grasse and Paris, including one dedicated to the painter and glove maker Jean-Honoré Fragonard, as well as the Museum of Provençal Costume and Jewelry, both located in Grasse. The latter, inaugurated in 1997, was created to house the important collection built by Hélène Costa (who died in 2007), whose three daughters – Agnès, Françoise and Anne – now run the family business. Lovingly collected
