
Queensland's horrific lion attack shows wild animals should not be kept for our amusement
The zoo, which keeps nine lions, has been operating for 20 years and had never experienced an incident such as this.
The victim was a relative of the zoo owner, Steve Robinson, who told the media the lions were not aggressive and the lioness was thought to be 'just playing'.
Although attacks like this are extremely rare, they are obviously of great concern.
The incident should prompt a rethink of our approach to wild animals in captivity, and whether it's morally acceptable – or safe – to keep them there at all.
Why do zoos exist?
Zoos, aquariums and other settings where wild animals are kept captive exist for two main reasons: human entertainment and profit-making.
Surveys show zoo visitors have a preference for large mammals such as elephants, primates and big cats.
Some animals are more tolerant of captivity conditions and exposure to humans than others.
Fish, for example, seem to respond more neutrally to human presence than most other species.
But a recent study found captive animals generally demonstrate abnormal behaviour more often than non-captive ones.
For most wild animals, captivity deprives them of the ability to engage in natural behaviour, which harms their welfare.
For example, free-living dolphins and whales have long-range migration patterns which require vast ocean spaces. They are also highly social and display complex communication behaviour.
Some countries have banned keeping dolphins and whales in captivity for entertainment because it causes the animals to suffer sensory deprivation and stress, among other harms.
Captiv e dolphins were once common in aquariums and marine parks across Australia.
But now only one facility, Sea World in Queensland, still breeds dolphins for entertainment.
And earlier this year, the last elephants at Perth Zoo were moved to a 12-hectare habitat in South Australia to improve their welfare.
Another important welfare question is whether the captive animal has 'agency' – that is, whether it can make choices as it would in the wild.
Can it choose, for example, which other animals it has relationships with? Or whether it has privacy?
Having control over such decisions enhances the quality of life for the captive animal.
It's important to note that some zoos can deliver positive outcomes for animals.
Many play an important conservation role, such as running captive breeding programs for endangered species.
An example is a long-running program across several Australian zoos and other organisations to recover populations of the critically endangered Regent Honeyeater.
The program has released more than 400 zoo-bred birds into the wild.
However, such conservation programs do not necessarily need to involve zoos to succeed.
Weighing up the risks
No matter how domesticated they might seem, some wild animals in captivity will always pose a risk to humans.
Their behaviour can be unpredictable and, as the recent Queensland example shows, even a 'playing' lioness can cause enormous physical harm to people.
Wild animals are called wild for a reason.
To be kept in captivity, most animals require training so they can be safely handled. The Darling Downs Zoo incident shows despite this precaution, things can still go wrong.
But humans will, understandably, always be fascinated by other animals, and want to see them up close.
So, what are the alternatives to zoos?
Open range-zoos, such as the one to which the Perth elephants were moved, can offer a better option for some animals.
Another option is to recreate the zoo experience using technology.
Artificial intelligence, virtual reality and augmented reality can be used to create images of animals that look and seem real.
In Australia, examples include Brisbane's Hologram Zoo and a high-tech puppetry experience touring Australia which replicates a real shark dive.
Overseas, animatronic displays have been created to replace dolphin shows.
Questions about animals kept in captivity require us to consider how much risk to human safety we accept, and the extent to which we prioritise human amusement over animal welfare.
In searching for answers, we can start by asking whether we need zoos at all.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
Majority suffer due to idiocy of the few
Legal instruments In ' Watchdog pleaded for help to curb abuse risks ' (23/7), Noel Towell reports that oversight authorities are so understaffed and underfunded that they could only fully investigate a few of last year's 1500 reports of abuse in childcare centres. But all Australian jurisdictions have a reasonably staffed and funded workplace law enforcement body whose investigators must 'monitor and enforce compliance with″, for example, the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Cth) or Victoria's OHS Act. All such Acts impose a duty on workplace operators to first, identify all risks to the health (including psychological health) and safety of both 'workers' and 'other persons' (including children) at their workplace, then eliminate – or at least minimise and control – those risks. It's a preventive duty. If WHS/OHS inspectors find a serious unaddressed workplace risk, they can issue, on the spot, a compliance-compelling 'improvement notice″. Although duty or notice non-compliance is a heavily penalised criminal offence, the crucial child safety point is that such notices can quickly prevent harm, or further harm, before it happens or continues. Max Costello, North Melbourne Turning the tide Re ' Council's final warning for Frankston mansion owner's sea wall ', 22/7. It was King Canute who was possibly the first significant leader who made a point of reminding his courtiers that no mere mortal has the power to hold back the tide. In more recent times, there's been plenty of coastal hydraulics experts who've explained the dangers and folly of building a hard wall to contain and tame the waves. Other marine engineers have counselled the importance of leaving the primary and secondary dune systems to nature, to accommodate the seasonal fluctuations in tidal and wind dynamics, as well as the dangers of building in sand, including sandstone, well known around the Australian coastline for its vulnerability to erosion Then there's the numerous consistent, combined research findings from the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) and more localised data analysis that confirms not only that the high tide is rising due to the cumulative consequences of climate change but, in many regions the tide is rising faster than the worst case scenario envisaged by the IPCC. And yet, one man in his mansion in Frankston, thinks he can hold back the tide? Tell him he's dreaming. Bernadette George, Mildura How to quit Fiona Patten's article was concise, well-written (″ Australia has become the global village idiot on quitting smoking ″, 24/7). I agree with all her points. As a former smoker, I changed to vaping 13 years ago and four years ago decided to stop that also. Vaping, in my opinion, is the only way to get off cigarettes completely and should be easily available. Ingrid Pezzoni, Toorak Learn to like politics Even as a schoolgirl, I was keenly interested in politics and could not understand why most of my fellow students didn't care at all. As an adult, I find nothing has changed. Most people I know vote because they have to, some even barely know who the current political chiefs are. Age has nothing to do with political responsibility, but maybe more effort could be made within the school curriculum to encourage political awareness and the importance of participation in political debate. Hopefully, that would also result in better candidates. Valerie Johnson, Eaglemont One vote each What a great idea. Give extra votes to those who ″contribute more to the successful running of our society″ (Letters, 24/7). Success, by implication, is the gaining of wealth. The wealthy already have superannuation tax concessions, family trust tax concessions, capital gains tax concessions, negative gearing and expensive tax minimisation accountants. Let's give them more votes so they can vote themselves even more tax avoidance schemes. Those who cannot afford tertiary education or a house, or who cannot hold a full-time job because they have disabilities or are single parents, would only have one vote, at least until the multiple-voting rich removed that privilege. Australia is supposed to be a democracy, not a plutocracy. That is why we have ″one vote one person″. Helen Moss, Croydon Push for ceasefire For the past 60 years or so, there has been little anti-Jewish activity in Australia but it has increased significantly lately. I have been surprised by some people asking why this sudden increase has occurred. There is much violence in the Middle East but the main thing that has changed is the starvation and killing of defenceless people in Gaza day after day. This is a very disheartening, distressing saga. Some Australian residents will protest peacefully, others may act violently towards entities associated with Israel. Some people think the best way to stop attacks is to censor Australians but this is not resolving the root cause. Further, citizens should not be prohibited from rational discussions on national and international issues. Our current laws can handle racial hate speech and violence. Meanwhile, the Australian government should apply pressure on Israel to agree to a permanent ceasefire. Graham Kelley, Mount Waverley Words not enough The government is being disingenuous in saying that all our exports to Israel are non-lethal. We supply parts that are vital to the IDF's military strikes. Even worse, last year the Israeli weapons and surveillance company, Elbit systems, was awarded a $917 million contract with Australia. Seventy-eight Labor branches are now calling for the government to impose sanctions on Israel, yet nothing happens (″ Immense frustration': Labor base demands sanctions against Israel ″, 24/7). Words are not enough, the Labor Party needs to hear the calls of its members and of Australians and impose sanctions on Israel without further delay. The cruelty being perpetrated in Gaza must end. Lorel Thomas, Blackburn South A tasty read While agreeing with your correspondent about the sad decline in readership among men (″ Young men have stopped reading books – and these are the reasons ″, 22/7), I flinched wearily at yet another drive by slap at fantasy and other genre fiction. An equally jaundiced reader of fantasy could view the genre of literary fiction as pretentious navel gazing. And as for the claim that a scarcity of literary fiction ″diminishes our ability to understand each other and address issues at the core of our society″, it neglects the possibility that the best of fantasy and genre fiction does it in a profound and sublime way that literary fiction simply cannot. Fantasy and other genres can take us out of the mundanity of the here and now into wider, more expansive considerations of the human condition. Such works as Piranesi' by Susanna Clarke or Kazuo Ishiguro's writing certainly help develop empathy and a desire to make sense of the world in a movingly insightful way, and are tasty as well as being full of nourishment. Michael Pryor, Alphington AND ANOTHER THING Scott Morrison Who asked Scott Morrison to speak to US Congress? He was an abject failure as a politician, displaying appalling judgment. Haven't they got that message? Or has he been asked because he'll say what they want to hear? David Ashton, Katoomba, NSW Now we know why the Trump regime seems so out of touch with public opinion in Australia. To get a view on what we think, they consulted Morrison, who has been in the wilderness for a full term of parliament. Tony Haydon, Springvale When is Morrison going realise that he is irrelevant? Corrado Tavella, Rosslyn Park, SA Trump world Another $800 million to the US for AUKUS? Talk about money for jam. Donald Trump must be laughing all the way to the bank. Jane Ross, San Remo I hope imported US beef is well labelled as such so I can tell if it's from you Donald! Steve Melzer, Hughesdale


Perth Now
5 hours ago
- Perth Now
Stirling launches state's first regular Auslan Storytime
In a WA-first, the City of Stirling has launched an Auslan Storytime program to bring early literacy to deaf and hard-of-hearing families regularly. Run in partnership with Deaf Connect, the free storytime sessions involve book reading led by a deaf storyteller in Auslan, supported by an interpreter. Designed for children up to five, the sessions blend signing, reading, singing, talking and play to support early language development in an inclusive setting. Auslan Storytime has gained popularity in the eastern states, but the City of Stirling said this is the first time it's been offered regularly in the state. The program began fortnightly sessions starting at 10:30 am on Thursday, July 24, at Stirling Libraries – Osborne, and will continue throughout the 2025 school year. This comes after an official launch was held on Saturday, June 28, attracting a strong turnout of 37 families. Stirling Deputy Mayor Suzanne Migdale said the launch's success showed strong demand for inclusive and accessible activities. Credit: City of Stirling Stirling Deputy Mayor Suzanne Migdale said the success of the June launch demonstrated strong community demand for more inclusive and accessible activities across the City. 'The energy and enthusiasm for Auslan Storytime at the launch event demonstrates the need for programs supporting early literacy for deaf and hard-of-hearing families,' Deputy Mayor Migdale said. 'The City of Stirling is proud to support Deaf Connect in the delivery of this program to make our libraries a more inclusive place for all families.' Currently, around 3.6 million Australians experience some degree of hearing loss. With an aging population, this figure is projected to more than double to about 7.8 million by 2060, according to the Department of Health. At birth, roughly one in every 1,000 Australian babies is diagnosed with hearing loss, a number that rises to two in every 1,000 by the time children enter school. Auslan, short for Australian Sign Language, is the primary language used by deaf and hard-of-hearing Australians, helping to break down communication barriers. Roughly one in every 1,000 Australian babies is diagnosed with hearing loss at birth. Credit: BRIAN MITCHELL / Getty Images Although focused on improving early literacy and library engagement for deaf and hard-of-hearing families, the City believes the storytime program benefits the wider community by promoting greater inclusion and deaf culture awareness. It is also said to benefit hearing families by teaching basic Auslan signs that can aid pre-verbal communication and strengthen parent-child bonding. The City's Auslan Storytime program is supported by funding from the State Government through the State Library of WA's Better Beginnings program. The free sessions can be booked online at

Sydney Morning Herald
a day ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘We haven't looked back': How these eight schools are turning around results
Two Central Coast schools – The Entrance Public and Budgewoi Public – were highlighted in a new report by The Grattan Institute, The Maths Guarantee, on how to boost maths performance in primary schools. Stitt credits teaching consistency and 'door-to-floor' class routines for the dramatic turnaround in behaviour. The school recorded 80 suspensions in 2020, last year that fell to 20. Just three suspensions have been issued in the first two terms of this year, he says. He recalls starting at the school in 2019, when 'classrooms would be trashed, we had violence. I was constantly at rooms getting turned over. We would have to evacuate the classrooms,' he says. Teachers became afraid to teach, he says. 'We had to draw a line.' 'Open plan learning didn't really work here. That free-range approach, the students didn't cope well. Kids were disengaged, we had kids facing all different ways. It can add to cognitive load too, so we did away with that and kids can focus on learning.' The change in teaching approach meant lessons became fast-paced and students were engaged. Teachers check for students' understanding as the lesson progresses, data is monitored carefully. Vocabulary classes were introduced to help students learn up to 400 'tier two' words a year. This year, for the first time, the school's year 3 reading, spelling and numeracy NAPLAN results are above the Australian average. The school is in the top 10 per cent of public schools for value-add data, the contribution a school makes to student learning. Five years ago, about 60 per cent of year 1 students at the school needed extra support with phonics, or identifying letter-sound combinations. Last year, it was 16 per cent. The eight Central Coast schools are also part of a grassroots group known as the Effective and Systematic Teaching Network (EAST) which writes lessons plans schools can use with the kindergarten to year 6 maths curriculum. Sam Higgins, a year 4 teacher at The Entrance who helped write the EAST maths resources, says providing lesson plans is especially useful for new teachers. 'When I started teaching I felt like I was really struggling. You're just left to your own devices, which can lead to a lead to a haphazard approach to teaching. Having shared resources gives you something to lean on,' Higgins said. But Stitt said while there is a high level of structure to the school day, 'there is a lot of room for individualism, warmth, and for the teachers to put their twist on things.' Jesmond Zammit, principal at Gorokan Public, said having a network of schools to share knowledge has helped improve student outcomes. 'We were all doing our own things within each individual school. Now we have a collective where the primary pedagogy is explicit teaching, and we have a laser focus on it,' Zammit said. 'We work together, we visit each other's schools.' At The Entrance and Gorokan Public, about 60 per cent of students come from the lowest socio-educational quartile. 'Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students make up 25 per cent of our 610 students. This year their year 5 NAPLAN reading results were off the charts, and well above statistically similar schools,' he said. 'It's been a real game changer for our students in terms of life opportunities. And if they go to another school in this area, then the learning is consistent.' Stitt said one of the major changes is that parents have confidence in the school. 'We get about 60 or 65 per cent at parent teacher interviews. Our aim over the next year is to increase that, really get more parent engagement because we know what a difference that can make.'