Concerns and hopes aired at public debate over Hobart's proposed Macquarie Point stadium
A 70-person crowd filled ABC Hobart's foyer on Wednesday afternoon, made up of those for, against, and undecided over the planned multi-purpose facility.
Tasmania's AFL team being allowed to play in the national competition hinges on a new roofed stadium being built.
It's a key condition of the government's deal with the AFL.
The panel — made up of Tasmania's Business Minister Eric Abetz, the Tasmania Devils AFL team general manager Kath McCann, prominent architect Mat Hinds, and Independent MLC for Elwick Bec Thomas — fielded wide-ranging questions from the public.
Among them, the possibility of renegotiating the terms of the AFL's deal to either move the stadium's location, or scrap it all together.
"But the deal is there for all to see, that is what we are pursuing."
Mr Hinds, an architect with Taylor and Hinds who gave evidence to the parliament's Public Accounts Committee on the stadium's impacts, said the current site was "far too small" for the size of the development.
"The building itself is drawn to fit, but what we're not seeing is all of the energy of that building and its servicing requirements," Mr Hinds said.
"It's 10 metres higher than the Tasman Bridge.
One point of ongoing contention raised by the audience was the cost to build the stadium — a figure estimated by Tasmanian Planning Commission to be about $1 billion.
Earlier this month, the Tasmanian government confirmed it would no longer seek private investment to help fund the stadium, opting instead to fund the construction through existing funding and extra borrowings.
The government plans to sell off the broader Macquarie Point precinct to pay for the loan, which is expected to be in the hundreds of millions.
While acknowledging the stadium and team came at a "big cost", Ms McCann told the crowd the team and the stadium could not be separated, and the economic benefits would bear out.
"When this comes to town, the indirect benefit of new businesses popping up in this state will be enormous," she said.
"I know it feels like the AFL have starved us, but they are setting this club up for success.
Another sticking point raised by the audience was the approval pathway to make the stadium a reality.
The state government has promised to introduce special legislation to allow the stadium to be built, after saying it no longer had faith in the Project of State Significance (POSS) process, which is currently being undertaken by the Tasmanian Planning Commission.
The special enabling legislation hasn't been released, but it is expected to be voted on in June.
Ms Thomas, one of the independent Legislative Council members whose vote will decide if the legislation passes, said cost was "front of mind" in her pending decision.
"If I'm making a decision with my heart, Tasmania deserves a team," she said.
"However … we have to make decisions with our heads.
Lily Mills, a student at the Tasmania Academy of Leadership and Sport, said it would help keep younger people in the state.
"Without the stadium or without the team, how else could the state offer the same standard of opportunities that the Tasmania Football Club has created and will continue to create," Ms Mills said.
Earlier in the day, politicians and the tourism sector also made their views known.
Peak-bodies representing the tourism, events and hospitality sector — the Tasmanian Hospitality Association (THA), Tourism Industry Council Tasmania (TICT), Business Events Tasmania Board and Destination Southern Tasmania — said the "the once in a generation opportunity was too important to lose".
In a joint statement, they urged Tasmanian policymakers to "back the stadium for its critical economic and social value and to create a vibrant entertainment precinct at Macquarie Point".
All six Tasmanian Greens MPs gathered at York Park in Launceston to announce they had written to AFL boss Andrew Dillon on Wednesday asking for the stadium to be dropped as a condition of the licence.
Greens leader Rosalie Woodruff labelled the stadium "a heartless and unfair" condition and called on Premier Jeremy Rockliff to ask the AFL to renegotiate the terms of the deal.
"The train's left the station, the Tasmanian people and our team are onboard, and we're not going to have a stadium with us," Dr Woodruff said.
Meanwhile, independent MPs Miriam Beswick and Rebekah Pentland called on the state and federal governments, along with the AFL, to "find a better way forward".
"The three key players need to sit down and find a way forward that exposes taxpayers to less risk," Ms Beswick and Ms Pentland said in a joint statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
12 minutes ago
- ABC News
From potential PM to abuse claims: Who is Mark Latham?
He once had a chance at the top job in the nation — now Mark Latham is defending himself against allegations of domestic abuse and being involved in a sex tape in his NSW parliamentary office. The former federal Labor leader-turned-One Nation firebrand is facing mounting political pressure following media reports he took photos of female colleagues speaking in parliament and made disparaging comments about them in private messages. He strongly denies the abuse allegations, which are yet to be tested in a civil court apprehended violence order (AVO) application by his former partner Nathalie Matthews. It marks a dramatic new chapter in the story of a man from the western suburbs of Sydney who was once a protégé of Gough Whitlam, had a shot at becoming prime minister, and has long courted controversy. Mr Latham first entered elected office in 1987 as a councillor on Liverpool Council before being elected mayor in 1991. Mr Latham had received an early boost in his political aspirations with the backing of Gough Whitlam, having worked as a research assistant for the former prime minister and eventually being elected in his former electorate of Werriwa. He was included in Labor's shadow cabinet in 1996 but resigned from the frontbench in 1998 following a dispute with then-leader Kim Beazley. In 2001 he was accused of an altercation in which he allegedly broke a Sydney taxi driver's arm. However, that incident did not affect his political ambitions. In 2003, Mr Latham narrowly won a leadership battle with Mr Beazley 47 votes to 45 votes and he went on to lead Labor to the 2004 election. While riding high in the polls early in his leadership, Mr Latham's approval ratings steadily declined throughout 2004. And it was an aggressive handshake on election eve with then-PM John Howard outside an ABC radio studio that many — including his supporters — blame for his electoral defeat, delivering the Howard government a historic fourth term. Michael Byrne has known Mr Latham for decades — a longtime community campaigner in Liverpool, he helped get Mr Latham elected to local government in the 1980s and attended his wedding, sitting alongside Mr Whitlam and his wife, Margaret. Mr Byrne told the ABC while he would have made a "tremendous" prime minister, the handshake "showed a side of Mark that was there". "He's got the larrikin about him, a tremendous mind on public matters. I think he would have been tremendous (but) he played the game tough." Mr Latham quit politics a few months after his defeat and published his political memoir, The Latham Diaries, in 2005, which savaged his former Labor colleagues and attracted widespread criticism from party figures. In 2006, the Daily Telegraph newspaper accused him of injuring one of its photographers and smashing his camera. Mr Latham responded at the time, alleging stalking and harassment by the newspaper. His time after federal politics also saw him become a regular media commentator, penning newspaper columns and co-hosting programs on Sky News and often critiquing Labor policies and figures. In 2015, he resigned as a regular columnist for the Australian Financial Review after it emerged he had been using a Twitter account to ridicule prominent women in the media, along with Australian of the Year and domestic violence campaigner Rosie Batty. The former Labor leader was then sacked from Sky News in 2017 after suggesting a Sydney high school student was gay on-air because he was involved in a feminist video. That same year, he announced his intention to run again for electoral politics. Mr Latham joined the Liberal Democrats Party, which prompted NSW Labor to place a lifetime ban on him ever rejoining the party. Soon after, he quit the Liberal Democrats and joined Pauline Hanson's One Nation party in a successful bid for a seat in the NSW upper house in 2019. Mr Latham had run on a platform of curbing immigration and overdevelopment — and controversially proposed a law requiring claimants for Aboriginal welfare programs to get a DNA test to prove their eligibility. After being elected to the NSW Legislative Council and serving as the state leader of One Nation, in 2023 he resigned from parliament halfway through his eight-year term and re-nominated in a bid to increase the party's presence in the house. That gamble proved successful, with Mr Latham being returned to parliament, but within days his relationship with Ms Hanson and her right-wing party would crumble. A graphic and homophobic tweet aimed at independent MP Alex Greenwich, was widely condemned by politicians across the spectrum — including Ms Hanson — and he was eventually ousted as NSW leader of her party. Mr Latham then quit One Nation alongside fellow party member Rod Roberts — accusing the party of allegedly "defrauding NSW electoral funds" — and the pair has since sat in parliament as independents. Last year, he was ordered to pay $140,000 in a defamation suit brought against him by Mr Greenwich and separate vilification proceedings relating to his tweet are ongoing in the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). In June this year, Mr Latham used parliamentary privilege to reveal confidential information from a psychologist's report about Mr Greenwich that was prepared for NCAT. That led NSW Premier Chris Minns to deliver a speech in NSW parliament, labelling Mr Latham "one of Australia's biggest bigots". Mr Latham has strenuously denied allegations of a "sustained pattern" of domestic abuse and pressuring his former partner Ms Matthews to engage in "degrading sex acts" in an apprehended violence order (AVO) application filed in a NSW court. News Corporation has published messages he allegedly sent to Ms Matthews that included photos of female MPs while on the floor of parliament and accompanied by disparaging and sexist comments. Mr Latham has not confirmed or denied sending the messages but Liberal MP Susan Carter — who was included in the alleged messages — said he "called and apologised" to her. He has declined an interview with the ABC but responded via text message to a Sydney Morning Herald report alleging he participated in a sex video in his office. "Where's this video they're talking about?" he said. "The paper said they hadn't seen it yet they reported it." Mr Byrne has reached out to Mr Latham since this week's allegations emerged. "I'm concerned for him, because it's awful stuff. He's a solid … red-blooded bloke without the sleaze," he told the ABC. "There's nothing pervy about the bloke."
ABC News
12 minutes ago
- ABC News
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese concludes trip in China's good books
Welcome back to your weekly federal politics update, where Brett Worthington gets you up to speed on the happenings from Parliament House. Going to an aged care home can be a fraught outing for a prime minster. That is of course unless you are visiting a retirement village for pandas, which is where Anthony Albanese found himself at the end of his six-day trip to China. Having dispensed with the Rabbitohs hat he'd worn to the Great Wall of China a day earlier, the PM donned a Hawthorn Football Club shirt as he paid a visit to former Adelaide VIP Fu Ni. The giant panda, one of two Australia rented for more than a decade, chomped on bamboo as the prime minister called her "a great ambassador for China and a great friend of Australia". For a while there, Fu Ni and Wang Wang were some of the only Australian residents that could have got China's top-tier officials on the blower, such was the diplomatic chill that was being cast Down Under. If you needed a reminder of just how much a distant memory those days were for the Chinese government, consider what Albanese again found himself having to sit through this week. Suddenly a bastion of international trade, China's second-most-senior leader, without a drop of irony, told Albanese about the importance of open markets and predictability. He said it was crucial for the two nations to respond together in the face of "growing instability and uncertainty in the global economy." (He was all but screaming: "Looking at you, Donald Trump!") The subtle art of shady diplomacy also saw Albanese find the opportunity to remind China's leaders that their citizens could enjoy the Year of the Snake with some of the world's (he said world's but let's be clear he meant Australia's) finest red meat and wine. Theatrics and symbolism aside, the trip served as a reminder of the extent to which Australia has returned to China's good books, something that has only been reinforced since Trump's return to the presidency. The trip was always going to be closely watched by the United States but what was more surprising was the extent to which it appears American officials sought to influence Albanese's meetings. High-ranking Americans were falling over themselves to comment on reports the US was pressuring Australia and Japan to say what it would do in the event of China invading Taiwan. Almost as soon as Albanese touched down in Shanghai he was being pressed about the reports, forcing him to wade into one of the most sensitive issues a leader could contend with while in China. Albanese's insistence that Australia supported the status quo and that he wouldn't be drawn into hypotheticals was quickly backed by senior Coalition figures Andrew Hastie and James Paterson. Yet new defence spokesman Angus Taylor found himself venturing into terrain no former Liberal leader had previously advanced, in saying Australia should be willing to make a principled stance on Taiwan. It remains unclear if this is new policy or a new case of "well done, Angus". In case you didn't catch it the first time, Treasurer Jim Chalmers was so keen to reinforce it, he made sure to make multiple references to just how "relaxed" he was about the release of a government briefing that cast doubt over Labor's ability to deliver its signature housing pledge. Nothing quite says relaxed like repeatedly saying just how relaxed you are. His department, meanwhile, seemed anything but, desperately seeking to claw back a document released under Freedom of Information (FOI), which broke with long-held traditions in that it actually contained news, just not intentionally. Like most FOIs, the document was redacted up the wazoo (further reinforcing why in the world of FOIs, the expression "free from information" is more apt), except for a series of subheadings in a table of contents that the department forgot to redact. Whoops. The briefing document warned Labor's pledge to build 1.2 million homes over five years to address the housing crisis "will not be met" and that the treasurer would need to find "additional revenue and spending reductions" to meet his objective of a "sustainable" budget. The ABC also revealed that the Housing Minister Clare O'Neil received a series of departmental ideas after the election to reset Labor's housing agenda, including rental assistance for low-income earners, ways to address concerns with the Housing Australia Future Fund and the possibility of scaling back the 1.2 million new homes pledge. Chalmers conceded Labor's plan was "ambitious" but insisted it could be achieved. Few other parties in the parliament see it as a credible proposal, with the Coalition dubbing Labor "delusional" and the Greens calling the plans pie in the sky. To achieve the 1.2 million new homes over five years, Labor will need to average 240,000 new homes a year, something that's only been done twice before. It's led to forecasts that suggest Labor would need a 50 per cent increase on 2024 construction levels, which in part relies on overcoming labour shortages and planning delays, if it's to get close to meeting the mark. Sometimes you get stark reminders of just how low the bar is for blokes in federal politics. Having fronted up for an interview about how the government was responding to the horrific reports emerging from the Victorian child care sector, federal education minister Jason Clare received quite the praise from Sunrise presenter Matt Shirvington. "Keep fighting. I'm not going to, with respect, call you minister today," Shirvington said at the end of the interview. "I'm going to call you Jason. You're a dad. Appreciate you coming on." In fairness, Clare has been working with his Coalition counterpart Jonno Duniam to ensure new laws can be rushed through the parliament to allow the government (the keeper of the purse strings) to cut off funding to centres that fail to keep children safe. Both men have been candid in recent days on how both sides of politics have to carry the can for why there are inconsistencies in reporting of incidents, the lack of a national database to track employees in the sector and why there still isn't nationally consistent working with children checks despite a royal commission calling for it more than a decade ago. None of these are issues Jason Clare, the father, can tackle. But not only are they issues Jason Clare, federal minister, can address, but they're issues that, as a minister of the crown, he bares a responsibility to tackle. Next's week first meeting of the 48th parliament will bring with it the first day of school energy for the new MPs and senators elected in May. First speeches are being written, shirts are being pressed and politicians are likely looking in the mirror to practice not looking like dears in the headlights. The new MPs and senators have spent recent weeks attending new MP school, which one candidly said felt like trying to drink water from a fire hydrant. One MP who will be among those being sworn in will be independent Nicolette Boele from the once safe Liberal seat of Bradfield. Having already been allocated an office, she will take her seat alongside 149 other MPs. But unlike her colleagues, she will face months of lingering doubts about how long she'll get to keep the seat, with her Liberal opponent Gisele Kapterian taking the matter to court. The last time the Court of Disputed Returns considered a House of Representatives challenge, the case was much like this one. The initial victor (in this case Kapterian) went on to lose the seat in the full recount. The 2007 matter not only upheld the recount result, it saw a slight increase in the victor's margin. Should the court hear the matter, it will rest on around 800 so-called "line-ball ballots" which a judge will likely reassess to ensure they were correctly adjudicated during the recount but it could be months before there is an outcome (in 2007 it took eight months). Kapterian's electoral plight sums up the state the party finds itself in, something that will be stark when the opposition takes its seats next week. If Labor's 50 female MPs opted to sit in their own party in the House of Representatives, they'd have seven more MPs than the entirely of the 43-member Coalition opposition, of which just nine are women.
News.com.au
14 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Anthony Albanese accused Coalition of 'constant negativity' snaps back at 'indulgent' China trip attack
Anthony Albanese has hit back against the Coalition's criticism of his 'indulgent' trip to China, accusing them of 'constant negativity' and a failure to acknowledge the importance of Australia's 'most important trading partner'. Liberal frontbencher James Paterson earlier said the Prime Minister's six-day trip was 'starting to look a little bit indulgent,' which he described as 'a Gough Whitlam history tour on the Great Wall of China' and questioned whether 'a visit to Chengdu to pose with some pandas, and whether a hit of tennis is strictly necessary'. 'I hope it's not for the Prime Minister's personal enjoyment,' Senator Paterson told Sky News on Thursday. 'I mean, the appropriate time to do a nostalgic history tour of Labor Party mythology is after you retire, in your own time, at your own expense, not on the taxpayer dime.' Sussan Ley also said she was 'disappointed' Mr Albanese 'didn't get the assurances that he should' about circumnavigation of Chinese navy warships in Australia, or the live firing exercises which were done without advanced notice. Asked for his response to the comment during a press conference in the city of Chengdu, Mr Albanese rejected the claims. 'I think the opposition have got some issues they need to sort out within themselves, including over the relationship with China,' he told reporters. He said China was Australia's 'most important trading partner', with one in four Australian jobs dependent on the relationship, and reiterated the importance of a stable relationship. 'They've just had an election result because in part, they themselves have characterised it as their constant negativity' and said the trip had been 'very successful'. 'They need to stop looking for reasons to say they're against and decide what they're for.' Mr Albanese also described Chinese President Xi Jinping as 'warm and engaging' and said China was a 'confident,' 'creative' and 'dynamic' country. Mr Albanese said he wanted to see Australia and China establish a 'stronger relationship' with 'more agreement and less disagreement' over the next three years, while acknowledging the two countries had different political systems, cultures and values. 'We have different values. So we understand that,' he said. 'What I'd like to see is to be able to talk about those issues regularly, get as much agreement as possible, but understanding of where our nations are coming from, out of understanding, can come greater co-operation.' Speaking after the press conference, Coalition education spokesman Jonno Duniam said while it was important to show 'deference to your host,' he questioned the value of the trip. 'We have our prime minister there on a multi-day trip, a range of high-level meetings with very little in the way of outcomes that can be perceived back here home in Australia,' he told Sky News. 'At the same time, we've got drills occurring in Taipei for potential and perhaps eventual invasion by Chinese forces of Taiwan's territory there. 'There's a lot of water to go under the bridge, but I'm failing to see the benefits of what you've don, or what will come from this visit.'
