Fujitsu getting away ‘scot-free' from Horizon scandal, says postmaster
Rab Thomson welcomed the first tranche of Sir Wyn Williams' final report, which was released in London on Tuesday.
Mr Thomson spent around 20 years fighting to clear his name after being accused of theft.
The 65-year-old, from Alva in Clackmannanshire, was one of the first to have his conviction overturned and was able to do so in advance of a special law being passed at the Scottish Parliament to exonerate Horizon victims.
Mr Thomson's mother had worked at the Post Office for 30 years and the accusation of theft against him came a few years after he took over the business.
He told the PA news agency: 'I feel quite emotional..
'There's other stories in there worse than mine, don't get me wrong, but it's heartbreaking for it to come to this length – it's going to drag on to March next year.'
He said he had been particularly emotional about the part of the report relating to himself and his mother.
Mr Thomson said he and his mother did not speak for a year after the allegation of theft was made against him.
He said his mother kept herself in her house following the allegation up until her death, saying: 'People were talking behind her back – 'her son stole from the Post Office'.
'But none of the people that accused me of stealing, some of them have not even come forward and apologised.
'So I don't know how they're feeling, maybe guilt I don't know.'
Mr Thomson added: 'If I can get a victory over this, compensation-wise for people out there who haven't had a penny yet and get them as much as we possibly can, then hopefully my mum's up there and she'll be smiling on me.'
He welcomed the report but had one caveat, saying: 'The only problem I see is, I don't know why we're not taking on Fujitsu?
'Why is Sir Wynn not taking on Fujitsu? Because at the end of the day it's them that's brought this crisis to us – at the moment they've got away scot-free.'
In April, Mr Thomson and others launched the Scottish Postmasters for Justice and Redress (SPJR) group.
He has encouraged other Scots affected by the issue to seek redress.
Fujitsu has already acknowledged it has a 'moral obligation' to contribute to compensation for those affected by the scandal, pending the outcome of Sir Wyn Williams' inquiry.
Commenting on the report, SNP MP Chris Law said: 'Westminster is still dragging its heels in delivering fair compensation and it is essential that the Labour government immediately removes every bureaucratic barrier and blockade so that these victims finally get the justice they so badly need.
'The starkness of this report lays bare the tragedies, and even the loss of life, that came about as a direct result of this scandal.
'After decades of failures and cover-ups by successive Westminster governments, Fujitsu and the Post Office, hundreds of people who worked hard for local communities have been made to fight far too long for justice – there must be no more delays from this UK Labour government.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
UK post office scandal may have caused 13 suicides: inquiry
Thirteen people caught up in a faulty accounting software scandal at British Post Office branches may have killed themselves and 59 more contemplated doing so, a public inquiry report published Tuesday said. The Post Office wrongfully prosecuted around 1,000 subpostmasters -- self-employed branch managers -- between 1999 and 2015. Errors in tech giant Fujitsu's Legacy Horizon accounting software incorrectly made it appear that money was missing from their accounts. Many ended up bankrupt after being forced by the Post Office to pay back the missing funds. Some were jailed. Dozens who were later exonerated died without ever seeing their names cleared. Inquiry chair Wyn Williams said that there was a "real possibility" that 13 people killed themselves as a result of their ordeal. Ten people attempted to take their own lives and 59 contemplated it, the report into the scandal found. Many of the prosecutions took place after questions were raised about the software's reliability. Police are investigating possible fraud committed during the scandal. "I am satisfied from the evidence that I have heard that a number of senior, and not-so-senior employees of the Post Office knew or, at the very least should have known, that Legacy Horizon was capable of error," Williams said in the report. "Yet... the Post Office maintained the fiction that its data was always accurate," he added. A "number of senior" people at the Post Office were aware the system was capable of error before it was changed in 2010, he said. - Miscarriage of justice - Welcoming the findings, former branch manager Jo Hamilton said the report showed "the full scale of the horror that they unleashed on us". Williams described the picture of the scandal that had emerged as "profoundly disturbing". "Many thousands of people have suffered serious financial detriment. Many people have inevitably suffered emotional turmoil and significant stress. "Many businesses and homes have been lost. Bankruptcies have occurred, marriage and families have been wrecked," he said. Among those who gave evidence to the inquiry was former Post Office chief executive Paula Vennells who was quizzed about what she knew and when. Vennells broke down in tears when recalling the case of one man who took his own life after being wrongly accused over a £39,000 ($49,537) shortfall at his branch. The long-running saga hit the headlines after the broadcast in January 2024 of a television drama about the managers' ordeal, which generated a wave of sympathy and outrage. Fujitsu's European director Paul Patterson told a parliamentary committee later that the firm, which assisted the Post Office in prosecutions using flawed data from the software, was "truly sorry" for "this appalling miscarriage of justice". Many of those involved are still battling for compensation. The government's Department for Business and Trade (DBT) said last month that 7,569 claims out of the 11,208 received had now been paid, leaving 3,709 still to be settled. Alan Bates, a former branch manager who led the fight for justice, has said the compensation process has "turned into quasi-kangaroo courts". Bates, who was awarded a knighthood by King Charles III for his campaign to highlight the scandal, told the Sunday Times newspaper in May the DBT "sits in judgement of the claims and alters the goal posts as and when it chooses". Post Office Minister Gareth Thomas said last month the government had made it a priority to speed up the delivery of compensation since taking office in July 2024. har/jj/fg
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
'Post Office IT scandal destroyed my health'
A woman thought to be the oldest victim of the Post Office's Horizon IT scandal said the ordeal "destroyed" her health. Betty Brown, 92, from County Durham, ran the Annfield Plain branch with her late husband Oswall in the 1990s and early 2000s and they spent more than £50,000 of their savings to cover shortfalls that did not exist. Ms Brown was speaking on the day the first volume of the report from the official inquiry into the scandal was published - revealing the scale of the suffering caused to hundreds of sub-postmasters wrongly prosecuted over money said to be missing from their accounts. The Post Office apologised "unreservedly" and said it would carefully consider the report. Overseen by Sir Wyn Williams, it found the situation had a "disastrous" impact on those accused with at least 59 people having contemplated suicide at various points. Ten attempted to take their own lives and more than 13 people may have killed themselves due to the scandal. Recalling her own situation, Ms Brown said: "We had a nice office, nice atmosphere, nice customers and everything was fine, no problem. "And then we were told about this wonderful advancement in technology and we would get a system put in called Horizon that would half the workload. "Then the very first night, the balance was £500 short, but they thought something had been missed in the accounts or whatever and that was just let go. "Then it began eventually that there were so many mistakes in the system that it was concerning, and these losses were coming out in amounts of £1,500, £1,600 every week, and we were having to put this money in and make it good because that's what you sign up for." Post Office scandal had 'disastrous' impact on victims Five things we now know about the Post Office scandal Exhausted, angry, heartbroken: Postmasters react as horror of scandal laid bare Ms Brown said the ordeal caused her to lose her voice while the anxiety disrupted her husband's cancer treatment. He died a year after they sold the post office, which Ms Brown said they felt forced to do. "The stress was unbelievable," she said. "You would go to bed at night and you couldn't sleep." Ms Brown and her husband moved away to Consett after the ordeal, saying there had been a "stigma" and that it forced them to keep "a low profile". When people asked the couple what they had previously done for work, they would evade giving an answer, she said. Ms Brown was one of the original 555 victims who took part in the landmark group legal action led by Alan Bates against the Post Office. She is campaigning for full compensation after originally being offered less than a third of what she had claimed for. Earlier this year she said she received a new offer of 60%, which she also rejected. Praising the report, she said Sir Wyn had "done a wonderful job". She added: "He has felt the pain, he's felt the anxiety, he's felt the agony, he's felt everything that sub-postmasters felt and he has been able to bring that with all his skill into a meaningful book. "I hope that the Post Office will take this on board." Chris Head, who became the youngest sub-postmaster when he took over the branch in West Boldon, South Tyneside, at the age of 18 was falsely accused of stealing more than £80,000 in 2006 before the criminal case against him was dropped. He said he was concerned about how the government would respond to the report. "It's a great day for everybody being here listening to it and obviously being vindicated. "The problem is, will it be acted upon? And that is a huge concern because it'll take the government many months to respond to these recommendations." Mr Head believes the Post Office "hasn't addressed the wrongs of the past" and warned there was "no trust". He added: "I think you can't get closure until people are held accountable for their actions. But at the same time that is so slow. "So what we need to do in the meantime is get this redress paid out to people, get it as full and fair as what has been promised, and allow people the opportunity to try and rebuild their lives while that accountability process takes place." A Post Office spokesperson said: "The inquiry has brought to life the devastating stories of those impacted by the Horizon Scandal. "Their experiences represent a shameful period in our history. "Today, we apologise unreservedly for the suffering which Post Office caused to postmasters and their loved ones. "We will carefully consider the report and its recommendations." Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram Post Office scandal had 'disastrous' impact on victims Five things we now know about the Post Office scandal Oldest Post Office scandal victim rejects higher payout as 'still not good enough' Post Office
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Government ‘sympathetic' to Post Office inquiry's 19 recommendations
A minister has said he is 'sympathetic' to Sir Wyn Williams's 19 recommendations made in the first volume of the Post Office inquiry's final report. The Government will respond 'properly' to Sir Wyn's recommendations by the inquiry's October 10 deadline, Gareth Thomas pledged at the despatch box. 'I cannot assuage the anger of the victims, nor will the anger I feel on their behalf ever be assuaged,' business minister Mr Thomas told the Commons. 'But we are determined to do more on redress and beyond, and to do it quickly, to give more of the victims of this appalling scandal, at least, a measure of the peace they so rightly deserve.' Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry chairman Sir Wyn published the first volume of his final report on Tuesday. He found a 'number of senior people' at the Post Office were aware the Legacy Horizon system was capable of error up until it was changed in 2010, with several employees also aware the updated system, Horizon Online, also had bugs and defects. Among his 19 recommendations in the report was that the Government and Post Office should make a public announcement about what they mean by 'full and fair redress'. Mr Thomas told MPs: 'Blameless people were impoverished, bankrupted, stressed beyond belief, lost their jobs, their marriages, their reputations, their mental health, in some cases lost their lives.' He added: 'To be clear, I am very sympathetic to Sir Wyn's 19 recommendations today. 'Clearly, a number of them require careful consideration.' Mr Thomas said the Government already accepts a recommendation that the 'best offer principle' should apply where claimants can receive money through the High Court Group Litigation Order (GLO) scheme. Claimants 'should be able to bank the best offer they get', Mr Thomas said, including if they disagree with their award and lodge an appeal with an independent panel. 'We will provide redress for family members of postmasters who suffered because of the scandal,' the minister continued. He said: 'Sir Wyn rightly recognises that designing a suitable compensation scheme for family members raises some very difficult issues. 'Nonetheless, we want to look after those family members who suffered most, meeting Sir Wyn's recommendation that we should give, and I quote, 'redress to close family members of the most adversely affected by Horizon'.' Mr Thomas later said: 'Sir Wyn argues that there should be a standing public body to deliver redress in any further scandal. I have a considerable amount of sympathy with that argument, but clearly we shall need to analyse the options fully before we commit to it. 'We will reflect on how to address those twin challenges, and will bring our conclusions back to the House.' Ian Byrne pressed the Government on Labour's manifesto pledge to bring forward a Hillsborough law, named after the 1989 stadium crush in Sheffield, which would place a legal duty of candour on public servants and authorities and provide legal aid for victims of disasters or state-related deaths. The Labour MP for Liverpool West Derby said: 'The publication of the report confirms the scale – the heartbreaking scale – of the human impact of this shocking miscarriage of justice.' He warned that the Post Office scandal 'follows a familiar pattern, where institutions deceive and distort because they put their reputations before truth and justice'. Mr Byrne, who has proposed his own Hillsborough law, having tabled the Public Authority (Accountability) Bill, asked: 'Does the minister agree that this report again shows why the Government must honour its pledge and promise to enact the Hillsborough law in full, and end this culture of cover-ups which does so much damage to the innocent victims' families and this country's reputation?' Mr Thomas replied: 'We need to see in full who was responsible for this disaster and why. 'Sir Wyn Williams's work in this regard is critical. We are awaiting his final report which will look at what happened and why it happened, and who was responsible, and that transparency will be hugely important in terms of helping the Post Office to learn the lessons from this appalling scandal, but for also the country as a whole to learn the lessons from the scandal. 'And if there are measures that we need to bring forward to make sure the Post Office is never in a position like this again, then we will certainly look to bring those forwards.' Conservative former minister Sir Andrew Mitchell said 'many' of his colleagues had raised Horizon redress 'for years' and added: 'It took the ITV drama of January 1 2024 (Mr Bates vs The Post Office) for the earth to move, which rather begs the question, what is the point of Parliament and its elected representatives?' He also asked: 'Isn't it about time that the institutions of the state got out the handcuffs and held the tax-funded villains who perpetrated this monstrous injustice to full and total account?' Mr Thomas said: 'Sir Wyn's further report will lay bare who is responsible, that and the work of the police. 'Their work is ongoing. There are 100 police officers working on this case. They are in touch with subpostmaster representatives and they have identified a series of people who are of interest to their inquiry.'
