Third level fees row looks set to rumble on for a while
The issue of third level fees has always been incendiary in Irish politics. When Minister for Higher Education James Lawless mused on Sunday that the elimination of cost-of-living supports, as ordained by the party leaders and the budget ministers after three years of multi-billion euro one-off giveaways, would mean effective increases to college fees,
he lit a political fuse that continues to fizzle
.
Fine Gael, ever concerned about looking after the people who pay for (almost) everything, went into apoplexy at the prospect of a €1,000 increase in third level fees. It pointed, not unreasonably, to the Programme for Government commitment to reduce fees. Lawless, for his part, noted that it was the leaders of the Government who decided to take away the €1,000 reduction in fees of recent years, and all the other cost-of-living supports.
There are a few things going on here at the same time. The Government is adjusting to the post-election, post-inflation-crisis reality of returning to something like normal budgeting. In truth, the economic conditions should really have meant an end to one-off giveaways last year. But there was an election to be won.
READ MORE
So in a way, this is part of the post-election hangover. It is being experienced differently by both major parties of the Coalition. There are a few reasons this finds its expression in a political row. The most politically dangerous one is that the respective positions are true reflections of how each party sees itself – Fine Gael, the defenders of the squeezed middle who pay for everything and deserve a break; Fianna Fail, more social democratic, prepared to weight benefits towards those who need them most. As evidenced by the reluctance of the party leaders to get involved, this is not an existential row for the coalition. But
it is a real one. And it will run for a while
.
*
Two watery stories in the paper this morning.
Kevin O'Sullivan reports that half a million people
live in areas still with a risk of undrinkable water
, according to the EPA's annual report.
Meanwhile, at the Oireachtas Budgetary Oversight Committee, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council – the Government's budget watchdog – told deputies and senators that Ireland's water infrastructure is
now one of the main constraints on the economy
, limiting the supply of housing and other infrastructure. 'Ireland is a very heavy user of water and that's why we're struggling to keep up,' Ifac chief economist Niall Conroy told the committee. If only it rained more.
*
Slow bicycle race latest: PBP's Paul Murphy says that if there is going to be a united left candidate for the presidency,
then the left will need to unite
. Yup.
*
Farewell then, US televangelist Jimmy Swaggart, who has gone to his, er, eternal reward at the age of 90.
As
our obituary puts it with commendable sobriety
, 'The Louisiana native was best known for being a captivating Pentecostal preacher with a massive following before being caught on camera with a sex worker in New Orleans in 1988, one of a string of major TV preachers brought down in the 1980s and 1990s by sex scandals.' Despite everything, you have to love America.
*
Poor old Keir Starmer. After a backbench revolt, he only survived
after a humiliating climbdown on welfare reforms
. It's not much fun being in government if you've no money. Irish politicians take note.
*
Best reads
Kathy Sheridan on Kneecap:
that's showbusiness, folks
.
Paul Gosling
on the dysfunction of Stormont
. 'If the Irish Government comprises adults,' he writes, 'their equivalents in the North often seem like rowdy teenagers – more focused on arguing and scoring points than on reaching compromise, consensus and the best solutions.'
Miriam Lord is also
wading into the waters of third level fees
.
And Róisín Ingle on the joy of
getting married with your children present
.
*
Playbook
The Taoiseach continues to be Big in Japan, with a series of engagements today.
Back home there's a sharp start at 9am with topical issues. Leaders' Questions at (high) noon; later there's statements on the Middle East and the final stages of the Defamation Bill; weekly votes at 10.15 this evening.
The Seanad sees statements on Sea Fisheries as well as couple of pieces of private members legislation – one on scoliosis treatment and one on domestic violence.
It's a manically busy day at the committees with several meetings of interest on subjects ranging from the controversies at the Arts Council (Minister Patrick O'Donovan is in), the Occupied Territories Bill, waiting lists in hospitals (hello, Bernard Gloster), delays in the planning process and dog control and sheep worrying. The sheep aren't the only ones who are worried.
Full details of the
day in the Oireachtas here
.
In diplomatic news, the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade Simon Harris TD will host the Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Qatar HE Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani at Government Buildings today. A 'visual media opportunity only' for the press: the Sheikh is not too keen on questions. You can
read the report on human rights in Qatar by the NGO Human Rights Watch here
. Great lads, the Qataris.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Gaza ceasefire hopes grow as Occupied Territories Bill continues to move through stages
Good morning. Hopes of a ceasefire in Gaza are tentatively growing and the story makes our front page lead this morning, even as health authorities there reported that the death toll had passed 57,000 . Sally Hayden writes from Jerusalem that Hamas was examining new ceasefire offers received from mediators Egypt and Qatar, but repeated that it wants an end to the war and the withdrawal of Israeli troops. Gideon Saar, the Israeli foreign minister, cited 'positive signs' in the talks to end the war in Gaza and free the hostages, the New York Times reported, though prime minister Binyamin Netanyhu repeated that there would be 'no more Hamas . . . We are not going back to that.' READ MORE With US pressure for a ceasefire seemingly increasing, we will likely know more today. Keep an eye on Truth Social. And obv. In few places has Gaza roiled domestic politics as it has in Ireland, with the Government under constant pressure from Opposition and campaigners to take action against Israel. The Government has moved slowly and cautiously on the Occupied Territories Bill – though compared to most other European governments, Dublin has been moving at warp speed. The Foreign Affairs Committee continued its pre-legislative scrutiny of the Government's new Bill last night, with Senator Frances Black among others urging the inclusion of services in the scope of legislation. The committee is expected to conclude this phase next week and then issue a report – it could yet recommend that services are included, posing a significant conundrum for the Government. The possible consequences of the bill continue to worry some in Government. Their worries will be heightened by comments yesterday by an influential US senator . It's 'blatant anti-semitism,' says foreign relations committee chairman Jim Risch. * The row about third level fees rumbles on, with Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald and Social Democrats acting leader Cian O'Callaghan raising the issue again on Leaders' Questions, where Fianna Fáil deputy leader Jack Chambers – also the Minister for Public Expenditure, so not exactly a disinterested observer in all this – was asked out straight four times if he would say whether students would have to pay €3,000 for the next academic year, or €4,000. Four times he declined to say . Earlier, the Minister for Higher Education James Lawless, whose RTE interview on Sunday kicked the whole thing off, sought to defuse the situation – a little anyway – on Kildare FM. He'll be seeking permanent reductions in the student charge during budget negotiations, he said. But could he say for sure that fees would come down? He could not . * Souvenir hunters, maybe? A portrait of Michael D Higgins h as been removed from Belfast City Hall , apparently on the orders of the new (DUP) Mayor of Belfast Tracy Kelly. Previously President Miggledy was up beside King Charles on the wall (which he would love) but Sinn Féin noticed recently that he had been deposed. Nothing is too petty for Belfast city politics. * Mayo for Sam: as talks between the EU and the Trump administration on a trade deal head into their final phase ahead of next week's deadline, meet the European Commission's trade spokesman , Mayoman Olof Gill who spent much of his childhood on Clare Island. 'I am proud that we are holding the line for liberal values,' he says. * Poll position: Paschal Donohoe is well-placed to win another term as head honcho of the Eurogroup , the powerful group of European finance ministers, writes Jack Power. Best reads Economic outlook is 'exceptionally uncertain': inside the Government's trade forum . Finn McRedmond on the necessity for the occasional long lunch . Micheal Martin is in Japan, but Irish pubs (and Irish music) got there first: Denis Staunton reports from a trad session in Tokyo . The population of Ireland has grown by a third in 20 years, according to census reports north and south . Playbook Big Jim O'Callaghan is up for justice questions at the ungodly hour – in parliamentary terms at least – of 8.45 am this morning, followed by agriculture PQs and then the final Leaders' Questions of the week at 12 noon. Government business in the afternoon includes EU rules regarding migrations – safe countries of origin, safe third countries, and a 'recommendation on a coordinated approach to the transition out of temporary protection for displaced persons from Ukraine.' There's something similar in the Seanad. It's a quieter day at the committees today. The Defence Committee will hear from a number of witnesses – including three MEPs – about the proposed abolition of the triple lock. Safe to say the witnesses from the Irish Neutrality League, the Peace and Neutrality Alliance and the Irish Anti-War Movement will not be agitating for jumping into bed with Nato. Elsewhere the Public Accounts Committee will interrogate officials from Children's Health Ireland and the National Treatment Purchase Fund. There could be skin and hair flyin' at that one alright. The Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris is heading for the annual Ireland-Wales Forum in Swansea, where he will meet with the First Minister of Wales, Eluned Morgan. This year's Forum will see the launch of a new Ireland-Wales Shared Statement 2030. Exciting, no?
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
‘The Government needs to stand up for policyholders' – backlash as motor insurance premiums to keep rising
There was a big jump in the number of claims in the first half of last year and increased costs of repairing vehicles, a report from the Central Bank shows. Drivers have seen motor insurance premiums rise for more than a year-and-a-half, with premiums up by more than 8pc in the year to May alone. Now the Alliance for Insurance Reform says the increase in claims would push premiums even higher. This is because the Central Bank said the cost of settling claims was 23pc higher in the first half of last year when compared with the previous six months. 'This is primarily driven by an increasing trend in both the number and cost of damage claims,' the Central Bank's H1 2024 Private Motor and Liability Mid-Year Reports show. When compared with pre-Covid times, the cost of settling injury claims is down 16pc. This was driven by a fall in the number of claims settled. The fact that the cost of settling motor damage claims shot up by 23pc in six months meant there was no justification to increase the official guidelines on award levels further, the Alliance said. T he cost of settling motor claims went up 23pc in just six months The Judicial Council has proposed that personal injury award guidelines should be increased by almost 17pc. Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan is to bring a memo to the Cabinet next Tuesday, paving the way for draft legislation that would give effect to a planned rise in award levels. The Alliance said: 'T he cost of settling motor claims went up 23pc in just six months – now is not the time to increase these costs further.' The Central Bank report also shows that there is no financial benefit for claimants to have their case taken away from the State's Injuries Resolution Board. Injuries claims can be litigated if a settlement from the board is rejected. The Central Bank's report found that the average award paid by the board and one that is litigated both come in at €24,000. Legal fees for cases settled through the Injuries Board average €597. Litigated cases have average legal costs of €24,786. The Alliance said this needs to be specifically addressed in the Government's forthcoming action plan for insurance reform. Alliance board member Tracy Sheridan said: 'The increase in awards will raise premiums further and adversely impact the volume of claims settled at the Injuries Resolution Board. We are already seeing month-on-month premium increases 'The Government has not said a word about the planned increase [in the award guidelines] for the last six months and there has been no opportunity for public debate either. This is wrong.' Ms Sheridan said that if the Government increases award guideline levels by 17pc, there will be no check on costs. 'We are already seeing month-on-month premium increases as the cost of living continues to spiral out of control. 'The Government needs to stand up for policyholders, not make things more difficult for them,' she said. The Central Bank also released a report on business liability insurance, showing claims were down 10pc in the first half of last year compared with the previous half year.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
AG would be obliged to share advice on proposed legislation with public under new Bill
The Attorney General would be required to publicly disclose their legal advice to government on proposed legislation under a Private Members' Bill that will be introduced in the Dáil on Thursday. A Labour Party Bill would require the Attorney General, who is the government's legal adviser, to waive client confidentiality in respect of Bills, such as the occupied territory legislation which is currently undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny. That confidentiality, known as legal professional privilege, would still apply for advice given in the course of litigation, or for other circumstances. The Bill, tabled by party leader Ivana Bacik and finance spokesman Ged Nash, proposes other reforms for the Attorney General's office, including a new duty to the public when the State is involved in litigation with citizens. READ MORE The party said the motivation for the Bill was the controversy that arose in relation to nursing home charges and concerns that the primary consideration of the State when defending claims was to reduce costs, and in so doing, not taking sufficient account of citizens' rights. 'In recent years, there has been concern that the public interest role of the Attorney General may on occasion run counter to his or her obligations when acting as legal adviser to the Government in litigation,' it has stated. 'A Minister may have an interest in settling litigation on confidential terms so as to reduce its financial exposure to other potential litigants. 'This may be a legitimate tactic for a lawyer in private practice to advise on but it fails to acknowledge the specific public interest considerations that arise in public law litigation.' The party has said that a principal purpose of this Bill is to provide a mechanism for both acknowledging and accommodating public interest concerns in State litigation.
