Indiana hides executions. Firing squads would be more honest
South Carolina executed Sigmon on March 7 and Mahdi on April 11. Three shots to the heart of Sigmon. Two shots … well, two shots missed Mahdi's heart. A third shot missed him altogether. I'll return to that. He died, nevertheless.
Benjamin Ritchie had no such choice. Indiana executed Ritchie starting at 12:01 a.m. Tuesday, declaring him dead at 12:46 a.m. The state used the lethal injection drug pentobarbital, first used in the December killing of Joseph Corcoran, which ended Indiana's 15-year pause in executions. That's the same drug Sigmon and Mahdi passed on in South Carolina, opting instead to take bullets to the chest (or wherever the executioners could put them, given their skills).
If you've been following Indiana's relaunch into state-sponsored killing, you can start to understand why a forced overdose of pentobarbital might not be a first choice for your last experience on earth. For as proud as Indiana is to be executing prisoners again, it doesn't seem so proud of its methodology, which has been kept as hidden as possible.
Indiana killed Ritchie under a veil of secrecy, with no media present. We know pentobarbital is a barbiturate commonly used for animal euthanasia. It has become a lethal injection drug of choice for governments after years of shortages due to pharmaceutical companies opting out of supplying methods of execution.
Executions involving pentobarbital have consistently lacked transparency, especially in Indiana. We don't know exactly how long the pentobarbital took to do its job Tuesday. We don't know if Ritchie suffered.
More from Opinion: Death penalty for Beech Grove cop killer Benjamin Ritchie? Science says no.
You might not care about that. Ritchie landed on death row because he shot Beech Grove police officer William Toney four times and killed him Sept. 29, 2000. He was found guilty of murder in 2002.
As polarizing as the death penalty is, American society finds it most acceptable in cases involving the murder of police officers. Even liberal Marion County Prosecutor Ryan Mears has repeatedly advocated for the death penalty in such cases.
Cards on the table, I oppose the death penalty in all cases. Indiana's approach is especially despicable. Our politicians want tough-guy credit for killing killers, while detaching themselves from the reality of their decisions. They shroud executions in darkness and sanitize the violence through the optics of medicine.
Following Ritchie's execution, six inmates remain on death row in Indiana. All signs suggest the state intends to proceed.
Indiana should go all in on the violence and permit firing squads — a more honest method of execution that also happens to be preferable to at least some inmates. If state Attorney General Todd Rokita is so enthusiastic about killing inmates, he can even pull one of the triggers and put it in a campaign ad.
It's debatable whether firing squads could be considered more humane than veterinarian-inspired death. And, while much of the case against lethal injection is that it can be botched, there is no guarantee that firing squads are more efficient.
Briggs: Jim Banks would let Trump commit any crime you can imagine
In fact, Mahdi's execution in South Carolina was a botch by any standard. Under South Carolina's firing squad protocols, three executioners are supposed to fire one shot each to the heart of the inmate. In Mahdi's case, two shots damaged his liver and other organs and one missed altogether.
"Mr. Mahdi did experience excruciating conscious pain and suffering for about 30 to 60 seconds after he was shot," Dr. Jonathan Arden, a pathologist commissioned by Mahdi's lawyers, Arden wrote in an analysis of South Carolina's autopsy, per NPR.
As awful as that is, at least we know exactly what went wrong and how Mahdi died.
Did anything go wrong in Ritchie's execution? We'd likely never know. Indiana did not allow independent witnesses — and, even if it had, those present did not have enough access or medical knowledge to understand whether the execution went off as planned.
Indiana politicians want credit for killing bad guys. Inmates facing death want the quickest, most painless method of execution possible. Firing squads, as savage as they are, could better serve these cursed interests.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
4 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Kilmar Abrego Garcia says he was beaten and subjected to psychological torture in El Salvador jail
Advertisement The Trump administration has asked a federal judge in Maryland to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that it is now moot because the government returned him to the United States as ordered by the court. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up A U.S. immigration judge in 2019 had barred Abrego Garcia from being deported back to his native El Salvador because he likely faced persecution there by local gangs who had terrorized him and his family. The Trump administration deported him there despite the judge's 2019 order and later described it as an 'administrative error.' Trump and other officials have since doubled down on claims Abrego Garcia was in the MS-13 gang. On March 15, Abrego Garcia was deported to El Salvador and sent to the country's mega-prison known as the Terrorism Confinement Center, or CECOT. Advertisement In the new court documents, Abrego Garcia said detainees at CECOT 'were confined to metal bunks with no mattresses in an overcrowded cell with no windows, bright lights that remained on 24 hours a day, and minimal access to sanitation.' He said prison officials told him repeatedly that they would transfer him to cells with people who were gang members who would 'tear' him apart. Abrego Garcia said he saw others in nearby cells violently harm each other and heard screams from people throughout the night. His condition deteriorated and he lost more than 30 pounds in his first two weeks there, he said. Sen. Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat, visited Abrego Garcia in El Salvador in April. The senator said Abrego Garcia reported he'd been moved from the mega-prison to a detention center with better conditions. The Trump administration continued to face mounting pressure and a Supreme Court order to return him to the United States. When the U.S. government brought back Abrego Garcia last month, it was to face federal human smuggling charges in Tennessee. Attorney General Pam Bondi said at the time of Abrego Garcia's return that this 'is what American justice looks like.' But Abrego Garcia's attorneys called the charges 'preposterous' and an attempt to justify his mistaken expulsion. A federal judge in Tennessee has ruled that Abrego Garcia is eligible for release -- under certain conditions -- as he awaits trial on the criminal charges in Tennessee. But she has kept him in jail for now at the request of his own attorneys over fears that he would be deported again upon release. Justice Department spokesman Chad Gilmartin told The Associated Press last month that the department intends to try Abrego Garcia on the smuggling charges before it moves to deport him again. Advertisement Separately, Justice Department attorney Jonathan Guynn told a federal judge in Maryland last month that the U.S. government plans to deport Abrego Garcia to a 'third country' that isn't El Salvador. Guynn said there was no timeline for the deportation plans. But Abrego Garcia's attorneys cited Guynn's comments as a reason to fear he would be deported 'immediately.'
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Rep. Jayapal defends comment calling ICE ‘a terrorist force,' says White House ‘owes an apology' to Americans
Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., defended a recent social media post calling ICE a 'terrorist force' Wednesday. During an interview with Brianna Keilar on 'CNN News Central,' the host spoke to Jayapal about her Tuesday Instagram post where she wrote that 'ICE is acting like a terrorist force. People across the country of all legal statuses — including U.S. citizens — are being kidnapped and disappeared off the street by masked men. No oversight, no accountability. Completely lawless.' Advertisement Keilar asked Jayapal to respond to a statement from White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson, which was obtained by Fox News Digital. In the statement, Jackson said, 'Jayapal's disgusting comments warrant an immediate apology. Heroic ICE officers are simply doing their jobs and enforcing federal immigration law, with the utmost professionalism.' 'Dangerous smears by deranged leftists like Jayapal radicalize their supporters to violently attack and obstruct federal law enforcement. Because of comments like Jayapal's, assaults against ICE agents have increased by 500% this year. And that number will go even higher if Jayapal doesn't stop with her smears,' Jackson added. 3 Rep. Pramila Jayapal defended her recent Instagram post calling ICE a 'terrorist force' while being interviewed by Brianna Keller on 'CNN News Central.' CNN Advertisement Jayapal responded, 'What is deranged and cruel and outrageous is that, literally, we are seeing ICE agents, I assume they're ICE agents. They say they are. They don't have any identification. They're wearing masks. They're in plain clothes. They are coming and kidnapping and disappearing people on the streets of the United States.' 'I never in a million years thought that that is something that I would see here in America,' she added. 3 White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson said Jayapal's comments were disgusting and should apologize for her remarks. Instagram/@repjayapal 'And so I think it is the administration that has to apologize to U.S. citizens that have been rounded up to legal, permanent residents, to people with legal statuses across the country who are getting swept up, people who have been here for 20 years and committed no crimes, getting swept up by masked men who are kidnaping them and deporting them.' Advertisement Jayapal called ICE's immigration enforcement 'outrageous,' 'unconstitutional,' and 'illegal.' 'It is absolutely terrorizing people, including small businesses, farmers,' Jayapal said. 'The round table I had in Spokane was with people from the Growers League, farmers who are terrified, restaurant owners who can't have, you know, who are seeing their sales go down because nobody wants to come out and eat. Literally. People are so afraid, Brianna. It's never something I thought I would see in the United States of America. The White House owes an apology to the American people for what they are doing.' 3 Jackson stated, 'Heroic ICE officers are simply doing their jobs and enforcing federal immigration law, with the utmost professionalism.' AFP via Getty Images Advertisement Border czar Tom Homan brought up attacks on ICE agents on Monday during an appearance on 'The Will Cain Show' where he also criticized a new app called ICEBlock that is reportedly being used to track ICE agents. 'Assault against ICE is up over 500%,' Homan said. 'Now you've got an app that's going to tell where ICE operations are going to. It's only a matter of time before ICE agents are ambushed by some nut, like what happened in L.A., throwing them out a cocktail, throwing bricks at these officers. This is just disgusting at every level.'
7 hours ago
Military honors bestowed on Illinois veteran identified nearly a decade after death
CHICAGO -- Standing near the gravestone for the relative he never met, Mark Bailey accepted the crisply folded American flag from the Army officer, hugged it to his chest and closed his eyes. Though the person he called his aunt — born Reba Caroline Bailey — had been estranged, missing for decades and died in 2015 as an unidentified ward of the state, he felt connection and a sense of closure. 'I want to let Reba know we're part of the circle and part of the family,' he said. Mark Bailey was among dozens of attendees at an unusual funeral service with military honors this week for an Illinois veteran with memory problems so severe that they died an unnamed person. The ceremony became possible because of an extraordinary cold case investigation that identified the 75-year-old postmortem. Investigators unearthed the mystery of how the Women's Army Corps veteran ended up homeless in Chicago with few recollections of their own life, aside from identifying as a man named Seven. 'I never knew I had this family member,' said Mark Bailey's 19-year-old son Cole, who also drove from central Illinois for the service. 'It's nice to know I have somebody that's been found and isn't lost anymore.' Since the investigation's conclusion, the numbered cement cylinder that marked the unidentified grave has been replaced with a rectangular plague with a cross that reads: 'Reba Caroline Bailey, PFC US Army.' The case of Seven Doe, the name appearing in some official records, came to Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart's office in 2023. The unidentified body belonged to a person who died of natural causes in an assisted living facility. They were a ward of the state, unable to remember a legal name or family. The cause of death was heart disease with diabetes and dementia as contributing factors and the body was buried in a section for unclaimed people at Mount Olivet Catholic Cemetery on Chicago's Far South Side. The medical examiner marked it as the 4,985th case of the year and put the number on the headstone. In 2023, investigators ran fingerprints taken postmortem and found a 1961 Army record for the veteran, formerly of Danville, about 140 miles (225.31 kilometers) south of Chicago. The search for close living relatives came up short; five siblings and an ex-husband had all died. The family members they did locate had only heard stories of a relative who had disappeared. After making the identification, detectives ordered a new headstone with the same name on military records. It was quietly installed last year. Commander Jason Moran, who oversees the sheriff's missing persons unit, said it was rewarding to make sure the identified veteran got the benefit of a funeral with military honors. 'It's just a privilege to be able to help families and really close the story,' said Moran, whose work on other high-profile cold cases has gained notoriety. Several generations of the Bailey family have told stories about what happened to their missing relative since leaving the military to get married. They've wondered about the possibility of children or their relative's gender identity. Some believe that there was a family dispute but the stories about its origins vary from the decision to join the military to sexual orientation. Family members tried to find their missing relative over the years, including Amanda Ingram, who would have been a great-niece. She maintains a meticulous family tree with Census records and photos. 'It's amazing how somebody can just disappear like that and not know what happened,' Ingram said this week. 'I'm pretty sure we're never going to know the details.' On a winter day in the late 1970s, a person wearing a military-style jacket and aviator cap was curled up on the porch of St. Francis Catholic Worker House in Chicago. Residents who stayed there at the time told the Associated Press that the person asked to be called Seven, spoke in the third person and identified as a man. Seven quickly became the house cook. The meals drew crowds to the neighborhood where several homeless advocacy groups operated, according to former residents' accounts. Investigators have tried to explain the memory loss and floated theories about brain damage related to a 1950 car accident that killed Bailey's mother or to military service. That included stints at Fort Ord in California, a polluted former Army base, and Fort McClellan in Alabama, formerly used for chemical weapons training, and where the federal government has acknowledged potential exposure to toxins. Neither family, investigators nor residents of the worker house figured out the meaning behind the name Seven. Ingram, who lives in Alabama, couldn't make the ceremony this week. But she asked volunteers from an Illinois chapter of Daughters of the American Revolution to attend on her behalf. 'Everybody who comes to visit that cemetery will pass by it and know who she was,' said Ingram, whose detailed family trees include records using Bailey's birth name. Mark Bailey said he and his son wanted to bring something to the service that would honor both parts of their long-lost relative's life. They had heard their relative had an affinity for the Cubs and looked for a jersey with the number '7' on it, but settled on a blue team cap. They set it on the headstone. The service held Tuesday included prayers, a 21-gun salute and a bugler playing taps — a chilling, 24-note salute that is traditionally played at funerals of U.S. military veterans. Attendees included Cook County sheriff's investigators and Archdiocese of Chicago staff. 'I just wish the rest of them could be identified as well,' Mark Bailey told those attending while pointing to the rows of unidentified graves. Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart said the ceremony left him nearly speechless, saying the Illinois veteran deserved military honors and a flag from the U.S. president 'instead of being forgotten and left as an anonymous number somewhere.' Relatives said they planned to eventually display the flag at the American Legion in Potomac, near where the Bailey family has roots. Mark Bailey said the acknowledgement of military service was particularly meaningful with so many veterans in the extended family. He hoped the memory would stay with his son Cole, who plans to enlist. 'For him, it'll be something he'll have forever,' he said.
