City of Vincent curbs e-scooter rentals following the death of 51-year-old pedestrian Thanh Phan in Perth
Mr Phan was allegedly struck down from behind by an intoxicated rider in Perth's CBD about 8.40pm on Saturday.
He suffered a brain bleed and was rushed to hospital, but died from his injuries days later.
British tourist Alicia Kemp, 24, now faces charges of dangerous driving occasioning bodily harm and dangerous driving occasioning death after Mr Phan died.
Police allege she was under the influence of alcohol with a 26-year-old passenger on board, before she hit Mr Phan.
The City of Vincent's decision to suspend e-scooter hires while it reviews the service comes a day after its neighbour, the City of Perth, suspended the service in response to the fatality.
Vincent informed its residents e-scooters were no longer be available for hire until further notice and all hireable e-scooters would be removed from the streets within the next 48 hours.
Vincent Mayor Alison Xamon said they were very saddened to hear about Mr Phan's death.
'Like our neighbours at Perth, we have decided to temporarily suspend our trial so we can review the safety of the hireable e-scooters and consider ways to improve this service or if it even needs to continue,' she said.
'We will continue to work closely with our service providers on potential changes to their operations here in Vincent.'
Ms Xamon said public safety was a top priority and they would consider if safety-related measures such as time-of-day restrictions could be implemented on e-scooters.
Australian Medical Association WA president Michael Page told NewsWire at least one person a day was admitted to WA's trauma unit with major injuries caused from e-scooters.
Dr Page said the number of patients with really serious traumatic injuries from e-scooters had been increasing and they were seeing people being admitted with serious head injuries, bone fractures, life altering injuries and sometimes fatal injuries.
'It's really a scourge in terms of injuries in our society and the problem with these council endorsed private hire e-scooters in city centres is people are hopping on without any experience riding e scooters,' he said.
'They're often intoxicated. They might be riding at night. They might not be wearing proper protection and so the chance for something to go wrong is, is very, very high.'
While the AMAWA are not calling for a total ban of e-scooters, Dr Page said hire schemes endorsed by councils to activate city centres and bring vibrancy were a risk
'The question really has to be, does the benefit outweigh the risks when we're seeing deaths and many injuries?' he said.
'They are dangerous you've got plenty of evidence from other cities around the world, other countries around the world, from across WA that these schemes are not very safe.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
4 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Pretend kiss': Teacher denies abusing girl
A music teacher who was photographed kissing an underage teen girl in a cinema photo booth has taken the stand to defend herself at trial, claiming it was a 'pretend kiss' that she did not want or expect. Janelle Colville Fletcher, 40, is contesting the allegations that she groomed and sexually abused a teen girl some years ago and testified this week at the South Australian District Court before Judge Joanne Fuller. The prosecution, led by Chris Allen, allege Ms Fletcher abused the girl in various locations and also that she communicated with her and another teenage girl to make them amenable to sexual activity. Some of the alleged offending happened when the two girls and Ms Fletcher were alone together in a room, the prosecution said, with the teacher allegedly performing a lap dance on a chair. She then allegedly 'dared' the two girls to kiss each other and asked if they would 'date' each other. That same night, Mr Allen said, Ms Fletcher then spent time alone with one of the girls and touched her genital area. The alleged grooming and abuse of the girl then went on for months at various locations, the prosecution said, including the home of Ms Fletcher and in Ms Fletcher's car. This week, the prosecution presented emails and messages between the girl and Ms Fletcher and also various photographs that they allege demonstrate Ms Fletcher was in a sexual relationship with the child. Janelle Fletcher has pleaded not guilty to sexual abuse of a child and communicate to make a child amenable to sexual activity. NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia A photo taken from a photo booth at a cinema shows the pair kissing, but Ms Fletcher, under questioning from defence lawyer Andrew Culshaw, said she was 'pulled in and the photo went off'. 'In the second photo from the bottom … we can see you and (the girl) appear to be kissing … can you explain to Her Honour what happened,' Mr Culshaw asked. 'It was meant to be a pretend kiss like we had done previously where our lips don't actually touch, and in that particular photo we got close and she did sort of pull me in and the photo went off, yeah,' Ms Fletcher said. 'When you say 'she pulled you in and the photo went off', what happened?' Mr Culshaw pressed. 'Just like around my neck sort of thing, just like, just so we would touch, yeah. 'Did you voluntarily engage in a kiss with her?' Mr Culshaw pressed 'No, I did not,' Ms Fletcher said. Other photos, exhibited in court, show the girl at Ms Fletcher's house. 'You appear to be leaning against her (the girl),' Mr Allen said. 'Yes,' Ms Fletcher replied. Defence lawyer Craig Caldicott (right) is representing Ms Fletcher. NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia 'Is that a selfie taken by you?' Mr Allen asked. 'It does appear that way, yes,' Ms Fletcher said. 'Does it appear that it is taken in your house?' Mr Allen continued. 'Yes,' Ms Fletcher said. In a series of emails read out in court, Ms Fletcher appears to express strong feelings for the girl. In one, Ms Fletcher wrote: 'My feelings for you are not lust but love.' 'In your mind, what is the difference between the two?' Mr Culshaw asked. 'Lust is like with you are attracted to someone. You have the hots for them, so I guess similar,' Ms Fletcher replied. 'Love is not necessarily sexual or romantic, it is love.' In other emails, Ms Fletcher told the girl: 'I am being selfish wanting you to myself when I need to let you live your life with someone your own age', and also 'right now, we can't be open. Right now we will have to continue as we are in secret ...' But Ms Fletcher argued these messages were written to keep the girl happy and also to guide her away. 'Really, all the emails, the intention behind it was to try and make (the girl) feel that she is not abandoned, she is loved, she is wanted and that in another time or place, maybe she could entertain that she could be with me, but my sole intent of all of these was to slowly get her to think it was her idea to not be with me but to be with … someone her own age and I wanted her to think it was her idea,' Ms Fletcher said. She told the court the girl had expressed romantic feelings for her and that she was struggling with her sexual identity. Ms Fletcher said the girl started exhibiting 'concerning behaviour' and she sought to point her in the direction of a more age-appropriate relationship. In one email, she told the girl she was 'completely in love' with her, but she told the court that was a lie. 'I did think she was a beautiful person,' Ms Fletcher said. 'It wasn't true that I was in love with her.' 'Why did you write it there,' Mr Culshaw asked. 'Because that's what I knew she wanted to hear,' Ms Fletcher said. The trial is being held at the South Australian District Court in Adelaide. NewsWire / Naomi Jellicoe Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Allen, in his opening cross-examination of Ms Fletcher, reiterated the prosecution's allegations of extended sexual abuse at various locations and Ms Fletcher flatly denied each allegation. When Mr Allen said Ms Fletcher was grinding on a chair inside a room with the girl and another girl present, Ms Fletcher appeared to giggle. 'Do you think that's funny?' Mr Allen said. 'Sorry, I don't mean to be rude. No, that's not,' Ms Fletcher replied. Ms Fletcher holds a PhD in music education. She told the court that she was heterosexual and believed in the Catholic faith. She was still legally married to a man, though the pair had separated, she told the court. Closing arguments in the judge-alone trial are expected on Monday.
Perth Now
6 hours ago
- Perth Now
Uncertain future for sex abuse MP
Former NSW minister and Kiama MP Gareth Ward faces an uncertain future in parliament after being found guilty of sexually abusing two young men. The former Liberal MP was found guilty of three counts of assault with act of indecency against an 18-year-old man at Meroo Meadow in 2013 by a jury on Friday. The jury also found Ward guilty of a fourth offence of intercourse without consent against a 24-year-old man in Potts Point in 2015. Ward, who was first elected to the seat of Kiama in 2011, now faces an uncertain future in parliament. Under a memorandum provided to the Premier and cabinet in 2022, an MP only faces expulsion if they are found by the House to be 'guilty of conduct unworthy of a member of parliament'. 'The expulsion of a member from the Legislative Assembly does not preclude the expelled member from recontesting his or her former seat at the resultant by-election,' the report by then Deputy Secretary of General Counsel Kate Boyd stated. Former NSW minister and Kiama MP Gareth Ward has been found guilty of sexually abusing two young men. NewsWire / John Appleyard Credit: News Corp Australia 'A person who has been convicted for an offence and is serving a sentence of imprisonment for 12 months or more is not so entitled' under the Electoral Act 2017. An MP who is convicted of an 'infamous crime', or an offence punishable by imprisonment for life or for a term of five years or more, would vacate their seat under the Constitution Act 1902, according to the report. Under the Act, an MP may also delay their expulsion if an appeal has been lodged. 'This provision does not affect the power of the House to expel a Member: Constitution Act 1902 s. 13A (3),' the report said. The report was prepared in relation to Ward's matters and was to provide the then Acting Premier 'on certain legal risks associated with the expulsion, or alternatively, the suspension of a member of the Legislative Assembly, in circumstances where the member has been charged with a serious criminal offence and is awaiting trial'. Since his arrest three years ago, Ward denied the allegations and pleaded not guilty to all counts. Ward has held the seat of Kiama on the NSW south coast since 2011. NewsWire / John Appleyard Credit: News Corp Australia In Western Australia, former MP James Hayward was automatically removed from parliament after he was convicted of sexually abusing a young girl the year he sought election to the state's upper house. Ward first entered politics on the Shoalhaven City Council in 2004. He was appointed Families Minister following the 2019 state election, when still with the Liberal Party. In 2023, he contested the seat of Kiama as an independent and had been suspended in March 2022 until the end of that term in March 2023 after he was charged by police.
Perth Now
8 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Bizarre' twist in ‘terrifying' plane incident
A man who tried to open the doors of a plane mid-flight and assaulted a crew member who tried to stop him has had his charges dropped after a court found he was suffering 'adverse and unusual' effects of a drug he'd only just been prescribed. Shadi Taiseer Alsaaydeh, a 47-year-old Jordanian national, tried to open the doors of a plane in the middle of a flight coming into Sydney from Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. He was moved to another seat where he again tried to open one of the doors, assaulting an airline crew member as staff and passengers restrained him. Mr Alsaaydeh pleaded guilty to charges of endangering the safety of aircraft and assaulting, threatening and intimidating the airline crew. The offences can carry a maximum of 10 years imprisonment; however, magistrate Jennifer Atkinson dropped the charges on Friday morning. A man who tried to open the doors of a plane mid-flight and assaulted a crew member who tried to stop him has had his charges completely dropped. NewsWire / James Gourley Credit: News Corp Australia Having spent months in custody, Mr Alsaaydeh dialled into court through an audiovisual link, often sitting with his head down and wiping away tears. The court was told how Mr Alsaaydeh had only recently been prescribed the sleeping medication Stilnox by a doctor before his flight to Australia, and it was likely side effects of the drug caused him to embark on the 'terrifying' ordeal. 'This is different to a situation where you might have been on prescription medication for a long period … what happened on that flight likely was you suffering from one of the adverse and unusual side effects of that medication,' Ms Atkinson told the court. She said she had seen previous reports of 'really bizarre behaviour' as a result of the medication, with a pharmacologist's report revealing Mr Alsaaydeh's actions as described by airline staff were consistent with the unusual side effects. 'The bizarre behaviour described by airline staff is entirely consistent with what is known as parasomnia or complex sleep behaviour associated with amnesia and hallucinations in which an individual engages in potentially dangerous actions, effectively in a sleep state, without any awareness or memory of any activity after recovering from the effects of the drug,' Ms Atkinson quoted from the report. She said Mr Alsaaydeh had previously travelled overseas to represent the Jordanian government, he was 'well regarded' in Jordan and had no criminal record. 'But on the 5th of April you got on a flight from Kuala Lumpur to Sydney and you took Stilnox and other medication and what happened after that was incidents on the plane where you tried to open the door and where you assaulted cabin staff,' she said. Mr Alsaaydeh nodded as Ms Atkinson said how it would have been a 'terrifying time' for others on-board the plane. Ms Atkinson ultimately dropped the charges, with Mr Alsaaydeh set to leave Australia. 'It is inexpedient to inflict any punishment and without proceeding to a conviction I dismiss the charge,' she said. Mr Alsaaydeh immediately stood and clasped his hands together upon her decision. More to come
