ActionSA slams Eskom's R3.6 billion diesel spending in one month as 'costly cover-up' for failing grid
Image: Timothy Barnard /Independent Newspapers
ActionSA has expressed concern over Eskom's R3.6 billion diesel spend in just 30 days, calling it an 'unaffordable illusion' used to mask South Africa's ongoing electricity crisis.
The party says government claims of ending load shedding are misleading, with diesel-powered emergency generation simply substituting blackouts rather than solving the core issues.
ActionSA Member of Parliament, Alan Beesley, said: 'South Africa hasn't ended load shedding – we've simply replaced it with an unaffordable illusion, paid for by the taxpayer.'
Beesley said that between April 1 and 10, 2025, alone, Eskom burned R1.34 billion in diesel. Yet, Eskom's Energy Availability Factor (EAF), the key metric for generation performance, sits at just 56.11 percent, well below the 70 percent target set by the Minister of Electricity.
This also reflects a decline from the same period last year, when the EAF was 58.96 percent. ActionSA says this proves there are fewer megawatts available now than a year ago, despite significantly higher spending.
'That is not a recovery – it is a cover-up with devastating fiscal consequences,'' Beesley warned.
According to Eskom's 2024 data, diesel-fired generation via Open-Cycle Gas Turbines costs R6,579 per megawatt-hour, compared to R541 for coal and just R113 for nuclear.
ActionSA argues that billions are being wasted to keep the grid afloat when those funds could have been used to restore failing coal infrastructure. If the same amount of electricity had been produced using coal, the cost would have been a fraction, closer to R300 million.
Beesley added: 'Eskom is burning billions, and the people of South Africa are being burned in the process.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
29 minutes ago
- IOL News
Herman Mashaba stands firm on ActionSA's backing of police commissioner amid serious allegations
ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba says the party is not apologetic for supporting KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi. Image: Itumeleng English / Independent Newspapers ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba says the party is not apologetic for standing in support of the KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner, Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi. Mashaba was responding to forensic investigator Paul O'Sullivan, who accused the party of misleading the public for supporting Mkhwanazi without having any knowledge of his hidden history. This was after Mkhwanazi last month alleged that the country's criminal justice system has been infiltrated by criminal syndicates. He made these remarks during a media briefing where he claimed that Police Minister, Senzo Mchunu, has connections to members of a crime syndicate. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading Mkhwanazi also accused some senior police officials of being involved in corruption. O'Sullivan said he was certain that Mkhwanazi has allegedly been involved in serious organised crime for a long time and has somehow managed to stay below the radar. He said ActionSA's support for Mkhwanazi has merely served to embolden his criminal conduct. Mashaba said the party advised him to exercise his constitutional right if he felt the party violated his rights by supporting Mkhwanazi. "ActionSA is unapologetic for our support of General Mkhwanazi's allegations to be investigated. If Paul O'Sullivan has something on General Mkhwanazi, we invite him to provide it to the law enforcement agencies, instead of threatening us," said Mashaba. On Monday, the party's parliamentary leader, Athol Trollip, laid criminal charges against O'Sullivan for threatening him. Trollip said O'Sullivan sent the threatening messages via WhatsApp. He said these messages were not only personal attacks, but also interfered with his work as an elected official in Parliament. He described O'Sullivan's actions as a direct assault on democracy and said such behaviour must face legal consequences to protect public representatives. This was after Trollip posted on his X account that he wants to know how O'Sullivan has inveigled his way into the safety and security system and who appointed him the spokesperson for the SAPS or police commissioner at large, adding that his comments and insinuations were frankly alarming. Responding via WhatsApp last week, O'Sullivan said: "I have been looking at your misinformed attacks on me on social media because someone forwarded them to me. You are clearly an arrogant fool who doesn't have a clue what's going on. Mkhwanazi is one of the biggest criminals that ever wore a police uniform; his crimes, when they are finally exposed, will shock the nation. "Best part is, unlike you, you are in receipt of my taxpayer rand. I don't get a single cent, then he said you attacked me personally on social media as if you're Mkhwanazi's right-hand man, which means that you must be supporting his criminal conduct. Either that, you are far too stupid to know a criminal when you see one," the message read. O'Sullivan added that: "As a result of your patently criminal conduct in aiding and abetting Mkhwanazi, you are now on my radar. When I'm done with Mkhwanazi and Masemola, I am going to take you on." O'Sullivan said he would take the ActionSA on as well and expose the party for being involved with a "criminal like Trollip". Responding to the messages, Trollip said: "If you think these are public attacks, you must have a very thin skin, especially for one who seeks the public limelight. As for supporting Mkhwanazi, let alone aiding and abetting him, you clearly haven't read the meaning of what I said in my posts that you are complaining about. "But one thing is for sure is that you've now threatened me and called me a criminal, which is clearly your modus operandi." Speaking to the media, Trollip said he was simply doing his job as a public representative and member of Parliament, adding that he was calling for the allegations, both O'Sullivan's and Mkhwanazi's, to be investigated. He said O'Sullivan also threatened Mashaba, saying he would tell everyone he knows not to support ActionSA. O' Sullivan, who claimed that he donated and prompted others to make donations when the party was established in 2020, wrote an email informing Mashaba and the party's national chairperson, Michael Beaumont, that he dissociated himself from ActionSA. He added that he would warn the public not to vote for the party or make donations because it cannot be trusted. However, Mashaba said this is something that should not worry ActionSA and its members. "We are not going to lose any sleep as a result. We advised him to exercise his constitutional rights if ever he feels ActionSA violates his rights by supporting Mkhwanazi," he said. In his affidavit, O'Sullivan said his comments were about exposing wrongdoing in the police service, not personal vendettas.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
ActionSA introduces performance tracker and discusses Mettler's future
Tshwane Mayor Nasiphi Moya has reiterated that the multiparty coalition in the city remains stable, despite potential threats from the ANC to remove City Manager Johann Mettler, a move opposed by ActionSA. Image: Oupa Mokoena / Independent Newspapers ActionSA has taken a decision to desist from speaking out about potential threats to remove City of Tshwane municipal manager Johann Mettler, who has faced recent criticism from the ANC over the legitimacy of his 2022 appointment. Party national chairperson Michael Beaumont made this assertion during a media briefing in Pretoria on Tuesday, where the party launched the Tshwane mayor's performance tracker that shows how the city is performing under the leadership of ActionSA Mayor Nasiphi Moya. The controversy surrounding Mettler's appointment has been ongoing, with the ANC announcing plans to request a special council meeting to debate the validity of his appointment. The party has raised concerns about alleged irregularities in the selection panel's composition and questioned whether Mettler met the required minimum competency levels. Mettler's appointment has been surrounded by controversy following a letter from Gauteng MEC for Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Jacob Mamabolo, to Moya, inquiring about the integrity of the appointment process for a senior manager. Asked to clarify ActionSA's stance, Beaumont said the party will not engage further on the issue of threats to remove Mettler from his position. 'We ventilated our opinion on the issue. It is a matter of public record and particularly in light of our view that we should not invite unnecessary instability in the city that is starting to move forward for the first time in a long time. In our view this is a governance issue and we would like to draw a very big wall between governance and the party political issues,' he said. He had previously stated that ActionSA does not support Mettler's removal, citing that stability in senior city management is crucial to the formula that has begun to yield success. On a lighter vein, Beaumont responded to speculation about a potential motion of no confidence against Moya, saying that it is a trend in South Africa for people to start plotting a mayor's removal from day one. He taunted those planning the motion, saying: 'If you think the reaction to General (Nhlanhla) Mkhwanazi was big, I would like to consider carefully how the residents would respond to anyone who tries to remove this mayor. I wish that political party good luck with their idea.' Meanwhile, ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba said threats to remove Mettler will be handled by Moya in a proper and professional manner at the appropriate time. Beaumont explained that the Tshwane mayor's performance tracker is updated in real-time with data from the city, allowing residents to monitor the city's progress on the party's website. The ActionSA-initiated government tracker monitors key areas such as financial stability, infrastructure, economic revitalisation, safety and cleanliness, governance, and customer care. Moya said the tracker is going to take the city far and reiterated that the coalition is stable. 'There is a lot that we have been doing as the coalition partners. In case and when we have disagreements, which we have had, we have to find ways to resolve those,' she said. [email protected]
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Eskom proceeds with court challenge to five trading licences
Fears 'cherry-picking' of its best customers. Eskom has made good on its earlier threat to challenge in court energy regulator Nersa's granting of licences for electricity trading. It wants trading rules to be finalised first and even suggests that traders contribute to the payment of municipalities' R100 billion arrear debt for bulk purchases. Following Nersa's publication of the reasons for its decisions, Eskom has launched an application in the Gauteng Division of the High Court to have the granting of five trading and one import/export licence reviewed and set aside. The respondents are Nersa and the five licensees: Green Electron Market, CBI Electric Apollo, GreenCo Power Services, Discovery Green and Noa Group Trading. This comes more than decade after the first electricity trading licence was granted to PowerX. Nersa has so far granted around ten such licences. According to the agenda, the regulator will consider two more trading licences and two import/export licences at its 30 July meeting, as well as an application by a municipality for separate distribution and trading licences. If granted, Eskom may join the new licensees to the action. Traders, also referred to as aggregators, are essentially middle-men between independent power producers and end-users. They enter into agreements with multiple generators and sell to multiple customers with diverse energy requirements, at a margin to compensate them for taking some of the risk. This enables especially smaller businesses to access renewable energy despite being unable to take the full production of a specific independent power producer or enter into a 20-year off-take agreement. ALSO READ: Electricity trading? Not so fast, says Eskom Eskom's argument In an affidavit in support of the application, Eskom senior manager for legal matters Mohlago Masekela says the licensing decisions 'form the beginning of a fundamental change of policy by Nersa that has not been the subject of public consultation and the implications of which appear not to have been explored by Nersa.' According to Masekela it will 'upend the entire landscape of electricity provision in this country, without taking meaningful steps to understand the consequences before doing so. 'Under the guise of promoting competition and labouring under material misapprehensions about the law and the facts, Nersa has allowed a free-for-all in which traders are allowed to poach the best of Eskom's customers without carrying any of the redistributive obligations that the tariffs paid by those customers to Eskom enable Eskom to discharge.' Eskom contends that its distribution licences and those of municipalities, grant them the exclusive right to distribute and trade in electricity in the licensed distribution areas. It relies on Nersa's distribution rules that prohibit two or more distributors to operate in the same area. According to the utility, no rules have ever been made to deal with electricity trading as a separate licensed activity. Although Nersa has acknowledged the need for such rules and has embarked on a process to finalise it, it proceeded to approve trading licences in the meantime. This, Eskom states, is irrational. Eskom submits it is not possible to lawfully issue individual trading licences on an ad hoc basis, without considering the impact on the businesses of Eskom and municipalities of traders cherry-picking its best clients and setting conditions to balance the rights of such traders with those of Eskom and the municipalities. ALSO READ: Nersa approves cross-border electricity trading Eskom argued that instead of promoting competition, the granting of the trading licences will lead to unfair competition, because traders will have the flexibility to offer large power users, that are consistent payers, discount tariffs, while Eskom is bound to regulated prices. The utility states that 'simply opening up a free-for-all for traders in areas of supply previously provided by either Eskom or a municipality, has the potential of causing profound risk to the viability of the system'. 'Eskom continues to hold the various obligations arising from the obligations in its distribution licences, but can now have its most reliable and lucrative customers taken from it by traders given permission to trade in the same area of supply.' It continues: 'Ultimately, since it is funded by both the taxpayer (in the form of government assistance given in the recent past) and the electricity consumer, it is taxpayers and smaller electricity consumers who are not attractive to traders, who will pay the price for this.' Some of the issues Eskom believes should be addressed in the trading rules include which customers will be allowed to chose who they buy electricity from, thereby demarcating the trading market. If customers are for example allowed to buy from a trader, but top-up continuously or on an ad hoc basis from Eskom's supply, the rules could provide for Eskom to set differentiated tariffs in such cases 'that reflect the true cost of providing these specific services.' ALSO READ: Presidency 'very concerned' about licence for Eskom transmission unit Eskom further suggests that the matter of the R100 billion-odd arrear municipal debt must be dealt with in the trading rules by restricting traders from operating in defaulting areas or establishing a financial clearing house that prioritises the payment of Eskom arrears before disbursing revenue to traders. It suggests that the cross-subsidisation regime should be preserved, with traders being required to contribute to a subsidy pool or municipal support levy. It is not yet clear whether Nersa and the five traders will oppose Eskom's application. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
