
Museums like the V&A shouldn't be allowed to return ‘looted' treasures
Hunt knew the law before he took the job
Hunt, director of the V&A since 2017, has declared the 1983 National Heritage Act which prevents him from returning artefacts to their country of origin, to be 'outdated and infantilising'. In fact, it is a key reason why collections, including the V&A's, have been maintained.
Britain is home to several thousand museums. Most, subject to the odd deed of trust and their constitutional obligations, are free to do as they please with the items under their care. But a handful are considered of such national importance that they are protected in law. Acts of Parliament such as the National Heritage Act, the Museums and Galleries Act 1992, and the British Museum Act 1963 strictly limit disposal of objects except in rare and carefully defined circumstances (none of which include the political motivations of a director).
Hunt appears to think that the law that prevents him from casting aside the V&A's long history, and 'return(ing)' items, is not fit for purpose. Among the treasures mentioned by Hunt during his speech at the University of Cambridge's Global Humanities Network last month are Tippoo's Tiger, a wooden tiger made for Tipu, Sultan of Mysore, and an Asante crown taken from Ghana. He is seeking an amendment to the law which would give museum trustees 'autonomy' over the fate of such items.
Conspicuously absent from this debate is any real reflection on the role that the claimant countries themselves play in these negotiations, and what that says about their commitment to contested objects.
In 2007, Ethiopia lodged a formal restitution claim for hundreds of objects now residing in the V&A, including a crown and gold chalice taken by the British in 1872. The request was denied due to the laws prohibiting restitution from the V&A. But after Hunt became director in 2017, a possible workaround was put forward: the ambassador was informed that 'the speediest way, if Ethiopia wanted to have these items on display, is a long-term loan.' This arrangement, first hinted at by Hunt in 2018, would have allowed the objects to be sent to Ethiopia on a long term or indefinite loan with an expectation that the arrangement would be renewed ad infinitum.
Ethiopia refused to play ball. 'The Ethiopian government, for perfectly understandable political reasons, took the view that…'You offering to lend stuff you stole from us' wasn't politically viable so we've reached a kind of impasse with these objects,' Hunt said.
Other countries have been more accommodating. Last year a number of Ghanian objects were sent to Kumasi from the V&A for display – an arrangement which will see the objects legally protected (from damage, loss, or sale), while permitting display in a country which values them.
A paper I co-authored for Policy Exchange earlier this year with Sir Trevor Phillips found that items returned unconditionally are often at serious risk. Benin Bronzes returned by museums across the world have disappeared into private collections. Some bronzes even seem to have gone missing from museums in Lagos and Benin City. Their fate remains unknown, but the story offers a stark reminder of the dangers of transferring artefacts into the ownership of other countries without question.
So why is a loan unacceptable to the Ethiopian government? If Ethiopia truly wishes to display these objects for public benefit, why reject a loan that guarantees just that? Their insistence on legal ownership – rather than public display – rather weakens the moral force of their claim.
The V&A is simply too historically significant to have its collection held hostage to the whims of a single, self-styled visionary. Hunt knew the law before he took the job. If he was so determined to spend his days dispatching artefacts abroad, there was no shortage of museums that would have indulged him. Instead, he accepted stewardship of one of England's great civic treasures – the first museum in the world to fling open its doors to the masses and truly democratise visual education. Cole famously installed gas lamps so that working men and women could visit after dark, helping to break the aristocratic stranglehold on art and culture.
Hunt risks undoing that work: gutting the V&A of its international collections and ensuring that the experience of world history is once again a privilege reserved for those who can afford the airfare.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

The National
9 hours ago
- The National
R&A must choose legacy over divisiveness for 2028 Open Championship
For the 50,171 members of the public who have signed our petition, and indeed, for many ordinary golf fans, the answer is clear: The Open Championship must not be handed to Trump Turnberry. (Image: Matthew McGregor is the CEO of 38 Degrees) 38 Degrees is a community of more than a million people who – in a moment away from their busy days – take small actions on issues they care about, which all add up to something bigger. We know that people power is one of the most effective ways to ensure decision makers listen. There's a growing chorus demanding that the integrity of our national institutions remain unblemished by divisive figures. To allow a Trump-owned course to host one of the world's biggest, oldest, and most respected golf tournaments would be to reward a divisive individual who condones war crimes and ethnic cleansing in Gaza and promotes racist, homophobic, and misogynistic messages around the world. It would signal support for a figure who ignores national and international law and undermines democratic values. The outpouring of passion for The Open Championship shows how important it is to our national identity. We want to see the world's best golfers compete on the most magnificent links courses, unburdened by external distractions. But the prospect of Donald Trump's ownership casting a shadow over the event threatens to wash that away. It hits at the very heart of what The Open Championship represents: unity, respect, and the sheer joy of the game. Whilst the R&A rightly focuses on the logistical challenges of hosting such a massive event, these challenges pale in comparison to the potential damage to The Open Championship's reputation. (Image: Trump Turnberry) The news over the last week or so that Turnberry is even being considered, despite the R&A's previous stance on ensuring the focus remains on golf and not the owner, sparks anger among those who believe the sport should rise above political entanglement and divisiveness. This decision seems unfair to the vast majority of people who simply want to enjoy the sport. 50,171 members of the public have told the R&A: Deliver on the promise of an Open that truly celebrates golf, free from the baggage of divisive figures, if you want to keep the trust of fans for generations to come. With Donald Trump in the country for the next five days, the gravity of this decision is even clearer. The integrity of the Open Championship is on the line. Do the right thing. #Saynototrump. Matthew McGregor is the CEO of 38 Degrees. To find out more about their work, go to:


Glasgow Times
9 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
R&A must choose legacy over divisiveness for 2028 Open Championship
For the 50,171 members of the public who have signed our petition, and indeed, for many ordinary golf fans, the answer is clear: The Open Championship must not be handed to Trump Turnberry. (Image: Matthew McGregor is the CEO of 38 Degrees) 38 Degrees is a community of more than a million people who – in a moment away from their busy days – take small actions on issues they care about, which all add up to something bigger. We know that people power is one of the most effective ways to ensure decision makers listen. There's a growing chorus demanding that the integrity of our national institutions remain unblemished by divisive figures. To allow a Trump-owned course to host one of the world's biggest, oldest, and most respected golf tournaments would be to reward a divisive individual who condones war crimes and ethnic cleansing in Gaza and promotes racist, homophobic, and misogynistic messages around the world. It would signal support for a figure who ignores national and international law and undermines democratic values. The outpouring of passion for The Open Championship shows how important it is to our national identity. We want to see the world's best golfers compete on the most magnificent links courses, unburdened by external distractions. But the prospect of Donald Trump's ownership casting a shadow over the event threatens to wash that away. It hits at the very heart of what The Open Championship represents: unity, respect, and the sheer joy of the game. Whilst the R&A rightly focuses on the logistical challenges of hosting such a massive event, these challenges pale in comparison to the potential damage to The Open Championship's reputation. (Image: Trump Turnberry) The news over the last week or so that Turnberry is even being considered, despite the R&A's previous stance on ensuring the focus remains on golf and not the owner, sparks anger among those who believe the sport should rise above political entanglement and divisiveness. This decision seems unfair to the vast majority of people who simply want to enjoy the sport. 50,171 members of the public have told the R&A: Deliver on the promise of an Open that truly celebrates golf, free from the baggage of divisive figures, if you want to keep the trust of fans for generations to come. With Donald Trump in the country for the next five days, the gravity of this decision is even clearer. The integrity of the Open Championship is on the line. Do the right thing. #Saynototrump. Matthew McGregor is the CEO of 38 Degrees. To find out more about their work, go to:


The Herald Scotland
a day ago
- The Herald Scotland
R&A must choose legacy over divisiveness for 2028 Open Championship
For the 50,171 members of the public who have signed our petition, and indeed, for many ordinary golf fans, the answer is clear: The Open Championship must not be handed to Trump Turnberry. (Image: Matthew McGregor is the CEO of 38 Degrees) 38 Degrees is a community of more than a million people who – in a moment away from their busy days – take small actions on issues they care about, which all add up to something bigger. We know that people power is one of the most effective ways to ensure decision makers listen. There's a growing chorus demanding that the integrity of our national institutions remain unblemished by divisive figures. To allow a Trump-owned course to host one of the world's biggest, oldest, and most respected golf tournaments would be to reward a divisive individual who condones war crimes and ethnic cleansing in Gaza and promotes racist, homophobic, and misogynistic messages around the world. It would signal support for a figure who ignores national and international law and undermines democratic values. The outpouring of passion for The Open Championship shows how important it is to our national identity. We want to see the world's best golfers compete on the most magnificent links courses, unburdened by external distractions. But the prospect of Donald Trump's ownership casting a shadow over the event threatens to wash that away. It hits at the very heart of what The Open Championship represents: unity, respect, and the sheer joy of the game. Whilst the R&A rightly focuses on the logistical challenges of hosting such a massive event, these challenges pale in comparison to the potential damage to The Open Championship's reputation. (Image: Trump Turnberry) The news over the last week or so that Turnberry is even being considered, despite the R&A's previous stance on ensuring the focus remains on golf and not the owner, sparks anger among those who believe the sport should rise above political entanglement and divisiveness. This decision seems unfair to the vast majority of people who simply want to enjoy the sport. 50,171 members of the public have told the R&A: Deliver on the promise of an Open that truly celebrates golf, free from the baggage of divisive figures, if you want to keep the trust of fans for generations to come. With Donald Trump in the country for the next five days, the gravity of this decision is even clearer. The integrity of the Open Championship is on the line. Do the right thing. #Saynototrump. Matthew McGregor is the CEO of 38 Degrees. To find out more about their work, go to: