Defence at 5pc or learn to speak Russian? Spasibo, Mr Rutte
Had we not achieved a similar feat after the 'awakening' of 1940, we would now be talking German. The development of Hitler's Nazi Germany in the 1930s is so frighteningly similar to Putin's actions in the 2010s and 2020s as to make you think the same playbook is being followed.
Appearing to almost directly address Ms Reeves – ahead of her spending review on Wednesday – Rutte said: 'If you do not go to the 5 per cent, including the 3.5 per cent for defence spending, you could still have the NHS … the pension system, but you better learn to speak Russian. That's the consequence.'
Rutte means 3.5 per cent of GDP on defence – as opposed to Keir Starmer's only concrete target of 2.5 per cent – plus another 1.5 per cent on security and infrastructure.
In some respects Rutte is wrong. There will be no welfare state and no NHS if Putin takes over. Just look at the fate of ordinary people in Russia who can barely afford to eat, and both inflation and interest rates north of 20 per cent and rising. That shows what life might be like under a modern Warsaw Pact.
Mr Rutte realises that we cannot appease tyrants like Putin and the only way to scare them off is to show strength.
'We are deadly serious that if anyone tries to attack us, the consequences of that attack would be devastating – be it Russia or anyone else,' he said.
We must not repeat the mistakes of our forebears in the 1930s, who failed to rearm to the level of deterrence. If we had realised that only total domination of Europe would satisfy Hitler, we would have confronted pressing demands at home for more welfare spending and avoided war – not by letting the aggressor have his way, as was famously attempted by Neville Chamberlain, but by being strong enough that Hitler would have avoided a confrontation.
As history recalls, when Chamberlain returned from Munich saying he had chosen 'peace in our time', Winston Churchill rebuked him:
'You were given a choice between war and dishonour. You chose dishonour, and you will have war.'
If we look realistically at what Putin has been telling us for the last 20 years we will understand that only the re-establishment of the old Soviet Union will satisfy him. The fact that none of those countries want to be part of Putin's Russia, means only one thing, as we are sworn to defend them under Nato Article 5: war. If we abandon them, we will be dishonoured – and we will be next, facing an enlarged empire with even greater resources.
The Germans, realising belatedly the threat of another tyrant who wants to subjugate them, have issued a stark warning this week. Herr Bruno Kahl, head of the Federal Intelligence Service, said his agency had clear intelligence indications that Russian officials believed the collective defence obligations enshrined in the Nato treaty no longer had practical force.
'We are quite certain, and we have intelligence showing it, that Ukraine is only a step on the journey westward,' says Kahl.
Secretary General Rutte is spot on. This message from a former European liberal politician may get many backs up here, but we cannot ignore it. History tells us he's right. Sadly we do not appear to have a Churchill among our modern day politicians to lead us through the coming confrontation with Putin.
I know from comments added to my previous pieces on this subject in this paper that there appear to be some who want us to capitulate and give up without a fight. Most of them are clearly Russian bots, part of the massive Russian propaganda machine who would want us to do exactly that. But if people think life in Britain is bad now, look east and see the misery most Russians live under. Let us heed Rutte's warning, and in the immortal words of Donald Trump 'build baby build' military capability.
Quite frankly if we fail to defend ourselves now, everything else vexing people at the moment will become horrifically irrelevant.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
20 minutes ago
- CNN
How Trump came around to a novel plan to send weapons to Ukraine
When President Donald Trump won last year's election, European officials quickly began discussing how to sustain US weapons shipments to Ukraine under a leader who had vowed to pull back American support. Eight months later, the results of that plan are coming into view, with Trump on board with a novel idea to sell US weapons to European nations that will then transfer them to Kyiv. The president is expected to announce the plan around a meeting with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte on Monday. In addition to Patriot missile batteries — the top item on Kyiv's wish list and one Trump said Sunday was vital to Ukraine's defenses — the US could also sell short-range missiles, Howitzer rounds and medium-range air-to-air missiles to NATO members, which would then be transferred to Ukraine, a person familiar with the deliberations said. The thinking behind Trump's decision is multifold, officials said. By selling weapons to European nations, rather than transferring them to Ukraine itself, Trump hopes to insulate himself from political criticism that he is reversing a campaign pledge to reduce the US role in the years-long war. He is also expecting a financial windfall: each Patriot missile system costs roughly $1 billion and he has already touted the profits for the US as part of the scheme. American officials also noted it would be quicker to get the Patriot systems to Ukraine if they are already in Europe as opposed to moving them from the United States or producing them new at a US factory. And, at least in the view of some US officials, providing Ukraine with a surge in new weaponry could send a signal to Moscow that Trump is serious about his frustrations with Russian President Vladimir Putin, who the US leader accused of peddling 'bullshit' last week. 'He's seriously frustrated with Putin,' a US official said. 'He wants to show he's serious about ending the war, and maybe this will show Putin it's time to start negotiating.' The plan was discussed in earnest around last month's NATO summit in the Netherlands, where Trump met with European leaders and the Ukrainian president for talks described by people familiar as surprisingly productive. But its origins actually came months earlier, after Trump won last year's election — thrusting US support for Kyiv into fresh doubt. European officials, at that stage, began conceiving of a way to allow for continued weapons support to Ukraine even if Trump pulled back Washington's role, as he had promised as a candidate. For the last two weeks, officials in the US and Europe have been working on the details of how the plan would operate. NATO does not itself dispatch weapons to Ukraine, but rather acts as a clearinghouse, coordinating deliveries from individual countries. The mechanism for transferring the weapons could include European nations transferring weapons already bought from the United States and backfilling them with new purchases. Or they could purchase new US weapons for immediate transfer to Ukraine. Among the countries already on tap to participate are Germany and Norway. Officials said at least four other countries are likely to join. Trump spoke last week to German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, and Merz said on the call he was looking for the US to deliver the systems to Germany so they could be transferred to Ukraine, a person familiar with the call said. He also spoke on Thursday with Rutte to discuss the initiative and lay plans for the secretary general's visit to the White House on Monday. Rutte later spoke with top US military officials, including Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Gen. Dan Caine, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, to delve further into the details of the plan. On that call, Rutte said he'd received several messages of interest from European nations looking to join in, a person familiar said. Ukraine has said it needs 10 new Patriot systems to protect itself against Russia's increased onslaught of missiles and drones. At last month's NATO meeting in the Netherlands, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky presented Trump and other leaders with a list of weaponry he said his country needs to stave off Russia's invasion, according to a US official. Trump has signed off on some of the items.
New York Post
23 minutes ago
- New York Post
Trump to make major announcement on Russia — as Ukraine Envoy Keith Kellogg arrives in Kyiv at height of Putin's brutality
KYIV, Ukraine — President Trump is expected to announce decisive action on Russia — which could include arming Ukraine with powerful new weapons — as Special Presidential Envoy Keith Kellogg arrived in Kyiv at arguably the height of Moscow's brutality. Trump is expected to make a major announcement Monday about Russia's war on Ukraine, after he already announced Sunday that the US would sell critically needed Patriot air-defense systems to the country. 7 Trump is expected to make a major announcement Monday about Russia's war on Ukraine. Advertisement Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) on Sunday added that the Monday announcement could include new military aid for Ukraine. 'In the coming days, you'll see weapons flowing at a record level to help Ukraine defend themselves,' Graham said. 'One of the biggest miscalculations Putin has made is to play Trump. And you just watch, in the coming days and weeks, there's going to be a massive effort to get Putin to the table.' Advertisement As part of the administration's efforts to end Putin's war machine, Kellogg is in Ukraine this week for discussions with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and other leaders. 'We discussed the path to peace and what we can practically do together to bring it closer,' Zelensky said of a meeting with Kellogg in a post to X early Monday. 7 Head of the Office of the President of Ukraine Andrii Yermak (left) greeting Special Presidential Envoy Keith Kellogg (right). 7 Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky (L) with US Special Envoy for Ukraine and Russia Keith Kellogg (R) prior to their talks in Kyiv. UKRAINIAN PRESIDENTIAL PRESS SERVICE/AFP via Getty Images Advertisement 'This includes strengthening Ukraine's air defense, joint production and procurement of defensive weapons in collaboration with Europe.' 'We hope for US leadership, as it is clear that Moscow will not stop unless its unreasonable ambitions are curbed through strength.' A retired Army general who served as chief of staff to Trump's first-term National Security Council, 81-year-old Kellogg arrived in Kyiv on Monday. A Post reporter was on board with him as he showed no fear when the train pulled away from a station in eastern Poland, bound for the heart of the war — and just Advertisement 'Eh, we'll be in a big city. Don't worry about it,' he told The Post, when asked if he was nervous about entering Ukraine days after Moscow launched its largest drone barrage yet, with more than 700 in a single night. 7 Russian President Vladimir Putin chairs a meeting on social issues, in Moscow, Russia. via REUTERS It's this stalwart leadership and stoicism that binds both the envoy and his boss. Kellogg said that in a phone call a day before the trip, Trump said the US must be 'strong' in the face of Putin's increasing savagery and unwillingness to listen to American sensibility, the envoy said. 'I spoke to the president yesterday morning and I said, 'Hey, sir, I'm not afraid,'' the general said of his trip. On Sunday night, Trump told reporters he would let Ukraine buy Patriot air-defense systems from the US because Putin 'talks nice but then he bombs everybody in the evening.' But even the big cities in Ukraine have been hammered throughout this nearly 3.5-year-old war — and particularly so within the past week and a half. What's more, there remained a good 12 hours before the train would even reach Kyiv. With the skies over Ukraine contested, the only way to the capital is by land. Advertisement 7 A retired Army general who served as chief of staff to Trump's first-term National Security Council, 81-year-old Kellogg arrived in Kyiv on Monday. That means chugging along the train tracks winding through the entirety of western Ukraine — with a brief stop near Lviv, a major city slammed with incessant drone strikes just two days prior in a barrage that included more that 500 drones in one night. Taking an overnight train meant risking travel during Russia's favorite time to attack Ukraine. Still, the retired general was undeterred. 'They live with this every day,' he said of Ukrainians who have remained in the country, continuing their lives as the largest war in Europe since WWII rages through their homeland. Advertisement As the evening progressed, there was a sense that something may be shifting in the US' game plan for handling Putin. While Trump nobly committed the first sixth months of his second term in office to finding a diplomatic end to the war, it has become increasingly clear to the White House that the Russian dictator does not seek peace, officials tell The Post. Putin also made that evident in a phone call with Trump earlier this month, according to sources familiar with the call. While the president largely leaned on his diplomats and Special Presidential Envoy Steve Witkoff early on to push Moscow toward peace, Trump took matters into his own hands recently, hoping his longstanding relationship with Putin could sway the dictator to lay down arms. Advertisement 7 White House special envoy Steve Witkoff (R), Donald Trump Jr. (center) and Bettina Anderson (L). AP But when Trump personally asked Putin to agree to a cease-fire — something to which the president successfully got Ukraine to agree roughly four months ago — the Russian president refused, sources familiar with the call told The Post. Trump has since made his growing frustration with Putin known through multiple recent statements — notably calling him out for 'bulls–tting' the American people. 'A lot of people are dying and it should end,' he said July 8. 'We get a lot of bulls–t thrown at us by Putin, if you want to know the truth.' Advertisement 'He's very nice all the time, but it turns out to be meaningless.' Kellogg acknowledged the president's frustration Sunday night, telling The Post that Trump does not stand for being 'played' or strung along. 'I think he now realizes that Putin is not a business partner,' he said. 7 But when Trump personally asked Putin to agree to a cease-fire — something to which the president successfully got Ukraine to agree roughly four months ago — the Russian president refused. For months, Trump has hinted at Putin being less than genuine in his dealings with Americans — notably revealing in April that it felt as if Russia was 'tapping [him] along.' But recently, his narrative has begun to shift. 'We will send [Ukraine] Patriots, which they desperately need, because Putin really surprised a lot of people,' Trump said of his plans to help Kyiv counter Russia's refusal to obey calls for a cease-fire. 'I don't like it.' 'We basically are going to send them various pieces of very sophisticated military equipment. They are going to pay us 100% for that, and that's the way we want it.' It comes after he described a phone call he had on July 4 with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky as having been 'strategic' — a call Zelensky described as the 'best' he'd had in recent memory. Then last week, he said he would have an announcement to make on Monday regarding US efforts to end the war. On Friday, he told a reporter who asked about Moscow's recent targeting of a Ukrainian maternity hospital that he would be taking action. 'Oh, I know. You'll be seeing things happen,' he shot back at the reporter. Kellogg said he looked forward to hearing what Trump would say Monday, but did not disclose whether he knew what was to come. 'There's a lot more we can do,' he said. In addition to military aid, the US could also target Russia's main source of income — oil exports — with a bill pending in Congress that would levy 500% tariffs on any country that purchases it from Moscow.
Hamilton Spectator
35 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
The Latest: Trump promises a ‘major statement' on Russia-Ukraine war as he hosts NATO leader
NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte will be in Washington today and tomorrow for talks with President Donald Trump, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth as well as members of Congress. Trump said Russian President Vladimir Putin ''talks nice and then he bombs everybody' as he confirmed the U.S. is sending Patriot missiles to Kyiv and plans sell NATO allies weaponry to pass on to Ukraine. Trump has teased a 'major statement' on Russia on Monday. Over the weekend, Trump threatened new 30% tariffs against Mexico and the European Union to be implemented Aug. 1 despite ongoing negotiations . Last week, he also threatened a 35% tax on many Canadian goods and warned of a 50% tax on Brazil in an attempt to impact the criminal trial against former president Jair Bolsonaro . And a federal judge ordered a halt Friday to indiscriminate immigration stops and arrests in seven California counties, including LA, after plaintiffs including two U.S. citizens who were detained, accused the administration of systematically targeting brown-skinned people. Here's the latest: Europe forges response to Trump's surprise tariffs threat European trade ministers are meeting in Brussels following Trump's surprise announcement of 30% tariffs on the European Union. 'We should prepare to be ready to use all the tools in the toolbox,' said Denmark's foreign minister, Lars Løkke Rasmussen, told reporters ahead of the meeting. 'So we want a deal, but there's an old saying: 'If you want peace, you have to prepare for war.'' If Trump makes good on his tariff threats against dozens of countries, it could have ramifications for nearly every aspect of the global economy. ▶ Read more about the European Union on Trump tariffs talks The European Union is suspending Monday's retaliatory tariffs ″This is now the time for negotiations,'′ European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen told reporters in Brussels on Sunday after Trump sent a letter announcing new 30% tariffs on all EU goods starting Aug. 1. The America's biggest trading partner and the world's largest trading bloc had been scheduled to impose ″countermeasures'' starting Monday at midnight. ″We have always been clear that we prefer a negotiated solution,'′ she said. If they can't reach a deal, she said that ″we will continue to prepare countermeasures so we are fully prepared.'′ Trump to meet with NATO leader Mark Rutte, the NATO secretary general, is visiting to meet with Trump. Their meeting is scheduled for 10 a.m. ET in the Oval Office. Trump is expected to move forward with a plan to sell weapons to European allies who can then transfer the weapons to Ukraine. The president has grown frustrated with Russia's Vladimir Putin and has promised a 'major statement' on Monday. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
