logo
Families of victims upset with findings of report into South Korea's Jeju Air plane crash

Families of victims upset with findings of report into South Korea's Jeju Air plane crash

An investigation into a South Korean plane crash that killed 179 people has found "clear evidence" that the pilots shut off the engine, but families of the victims say they don't trust the report.
The Jeju Air flight crash-landed at Muan International Airport on December 29, 2024, skidding along the runway before hitting a wall and exploding.
Families of the crash victims said they did not accept the investigation's findings.
They have raised questions about the transparency of the report, which they said concluded the crash was an error on the part of the pilots.
The findings of the report have now been hushed, and its release date has been delayed.
Lawyers representing the families have objected to the publication of the report and said investigators needed to look at other contributing factors, in addition to the bird strike.
As a result, a planned press briefing was cancelled and the release of the report was postponed, according to The Korea Times.
Groups representing the victims' families and the Jeju Air pilots' union said the media release could not be trusted and hoped investigators would include their views, too.
South Korea's Aviation and Railway Accident Investigation Board (ARAIB) has been accused by the union of "misleading the public" by suggesting there was no problem with the left engine, given traces of bird remains were found in both engines.
The union also accused the ARAIB of trying to make pilots "scapegoats" by failing to provide scientific and technological grounds that the plane could have landed safely with only the left engine turned on.
On Sunday, a day before the report was due to be released, a briefing session for the victims' families was held at Muan International Airport.
During the session, the Air Traffic Commission announced the investigation found: "There was no engine defect, and there is circumstantial evidence that the pilot turned off the left engine, not the right engine, which was more severely damaged by the collision, after the bird strike," South Korea's Yonhap News reported.
On the same day of the briefing session, Jeju Air Pilots' Union also released a statement, saying: "We are strongly outraged by the unilateral announcement by the Air Transport Commission and the media reports that quoted it without filtering, and we resolutely reject the malicious framing that seeks to shift responsibility to the pilots."
In May, the families filed a criminal complaint against 15 people, including South Korean Transport Minister Park Sang-woo, and airline safety representatives.
In a statement released by the lawyers for the families, they alleged negligence in managing safety risks and violations of the Aviation Safety Act.
They called for a more thorough investigation into the decision to attempt to land straight after a bird strike, the aircraft engine's maintenance, and whether the construction of a runway embankment was appropriate.
A source told Reuters the investigators looked at the cockpit voice recorder and computer data.
The evidence also included a physical engine switch found in the wreckage, which showed pilots shut off the left engine instead of the right engine when taking emergency steps before it was meant to land, after the reported bird strike.
No pre-existing defects were present in recovered engines.
"The investigation team has clear evidence and backup data, so its findings will not change," the source told Reuters.
The exact release date of the report has not been set; however, under international rules, a final report is expected within a year of the accident.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Fourth Townsville police shooting since January prompts call for inquiry
Fourth Townsville police shooting since January prompts call for inquiry

ABC News

time6 hours ago

  • ABC News

Fourth Townsville police shooting since January prompts call for inquiry

Police have shot four people in Townsville in the past year, but the state's police union is resisting calls for a review into the way shootings are investigated. A 29-year-old man remains in a critical condition after being shot by officers in a shopping centre loading dock in the western Townsville suburb of Thuringowa Central on Sunday. Police said officers from the Special Emergency Response Team were called in as the man was wanted for alleged "serious criminal offences". However, Queensland Police did not share what those alleged offences were or the circumstances leading up to Sunday's shooting, as a police ethical standards investigation was underway. It comes after an officer shot and killed an armed man in the Townsville suburb of North Ward two weeks ago. Police also shot a 17-year-old girl in the abdomen after she allegedly threatened them with a knife in June, and a first-year police officer shot a man "experiencing a mental health episode" three times in January. The Queensland Council for Civil Liberties has repeated calls for a systematic review into police shootings. President Michael Cope said it was "simply not good enough" for the shootings to be referred to the Ethical Standards Command, which only reviewed individual incidents. "We accept that there unfortunately are circumstances in which police have to use their guns," he said. Mr Cope said a royal commission or the Crime and Corruption Commission could conduct such a review. "This may not be anything to do with police conduct, we just simply don't know what the causes are," he said. "It seems to me that any member of the public would want to know why police shootings in Queensland the last few years seem to have been extraordinarily high in comparison with the rest of the country." Queensland Police Union president Shane Prior said every police-involved shooting should be examined individually. "This just demonstrates that police are operating in a work environment that has never been as dangerous as it is right now," he said. "You need to look at each individual incident on its own merits. The fatal shooting in Townsville last week will be referred to the Queensland Coroner. In recent years, multiple people experiencing a mental health episode have been fatally shot by Townsville police, including the case of Steven Angus, who was shot dead hours after hospital discharge. A spokesperson for the Coroners Court of Queensland told the ABC last week it was in discussions with the Queensland Mental Health Commission and the Queensland Police Service about ways to examine systemic issues associated with police-related deaths. Queensland Police would not comment on whether the man shot in Townsville on Sunday was armed. But Mr Prior said the man shot did threaten officers. "I understand that he was hiding underneath a stairwell," he said. "It will be alleged that he made certain threats towards police when he was confronted." Mr Prior added that the male officer who fired the shot had five years' experience in the Special Emergency Response Team. Queensland Police media also declined to comment on the circumstances of the shooting. The Queensland Crime and Corruption Commission will have oversight of the Ethical Standards Command investigation.

Shocking moment Ryanair passenger sobs and hits door after being stopped from boarding
Shocking moment Ryanair passenger sobs and hits door after being stopped from boarding

News.com.au

time13 hours ago

  • News.com.au

Shocking moment Ryanair passenger sobs and hits door after being stopped from boarding

This is the shocking moment a female Ryanair passenger was left sobbing on her knees after being banned from boarding her flight. The tearful woman was left hitting a door in an emotional outburst as airport staff reportedly told her that her hand luggage was too big. Chaos unfolded at Sofia Airport in Bulgaria when the woman was left screaming, sobbing and venting her frustration over Ryanair's strict baggage policy. A packed flight was due to board a bus to their plane when the female passenger was stopped in the queue. Nikolay Stefanov, a witness to the shocking ordeal, said the woman was told she had to pay for extra baggage because her luggage didn't fit in the holdall. The woman refused to pay as she explained her bag could in fact fit. Footage shows her trying to force her bag into the luggage rack by slamming it in. The bag does eventually fit but the staff still refuse to let her board. She then breaks down in tears as she pleads with a member of the border police and takes a video of the bag which is now wedged inside the rack. Dozens of the passengers were seen watching on from behind a glass door which was all that separated them from the weeping woman. Determined to board, she then starts to bang on the door and ask for help as Mr Stefanov films the sad ordeal. More staff quickly surround the woman as her begging grows louder. At one point she even drops to her knees before placing her hand on the door as tears roll down her face. Mr Stefanov said the whole situation 'escalated quickly'. 'She was pleading with us not to leave, but we were threatened that the entire flight would be cancelled if we didn't get on the bus, so passengers became frightened and left,' he said. Mr Stefanov said many onlookers were also shocked by how the staff treated her with next to no compassion. It has also been claimed that another passenger stood behind the woman in line was removed from the flight. A Ryanair staff member allegedly said that they couldn't let him on because 'reopening the gate risked the woman trying to get on the bus'. The viral footage soon caught the eye of Bulgaria's parliament. Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Transport Grozdan Karadjov has reportedly ordered an inspection of the airport's security cameras. Mr Karadjov is even said to have described the behaviour of employees in the video as 'outrageous', reports. He has assured people that the main ground operator will be found and given the 'highest fine' and a verbal warning. In response, Goldair Handling Bulgaria insisted their employees acted 'professionally and without any physical contact with the passenger'. The handling company released a statement to BNT News that read: 'All rules regarding passengers' baggage, its permissible size and the fees payable for baggage are determined solely, entirely and unilaterally by the airlines. 'Goldair Handling Bulgaria OOD is solely obliged to monitor compliance with these rules by the airlines. 'This also applies to hand luggage, as Goldair Handling Bulgaria OOD is obliged to monitor the dimensions of this baggage and collect excess baggage fees. '[Staff] acted professionally and without any physical contact with the passenger.' It comes as Ryanair's CEO is considering increasing bonuses paid to staff for spotting oversized luggage. The budget airline currently pays staff approximately €1.50 (AU$2.66) for stopping passengers with oversized bags from boarding the aircraft. Currently, staff bonuses for doing this are capped at €80 (AU$143) a month. Passengers who are unlucky enough to get caught out by the airline's staff are charged a fee of up to €75 (AU$134) for bringing luggage that is larger than they paid for while booking their journey.

‘Sweetest angel': Tragedy as beloved young mum and 2yo daughter killed in fiery car crash
‘Sweetest angel': Tragedy as beloved young mum and 2yo daughter killed in fiery car crash

News.com.au

time3 days ago

  • News.com.au

‘Sweetest angel': Tragedy as beloved young mum and 2yo daughter killed in fiery car crash

A young mother and her toddler have been killed in a horror single-vehicle crash after their vehicle hit a tree and burst into flames in New South Wales, with bystanders claiming there was 'no possible way' to save them. Jendaya Stewart, 26, and her daughter Lillyannah, two, were travelling along Hat Head Road, in the tiny coastal town of Hat Head on the state's mid-north coast, about 9.40am on Thursday July 10 when their car smashed into the tree. Emergency services rushed to the scene and found the vehicle engulfed in flames. Fire and Rescue NSW crews extinguished the fire before police discovered the pair's bodies inside the vehicle. One local woman posted on social media that a friend was one of the first to see the crash and tried to save those inside. 'They tried to rescue them with a few others and sadly there was no way possible before the car went up,' she wrote. 'They are gutted.' Ms Stewart, affectionately known as 'Jen' or 'Jenny, was a proud Biripi and Thunggutti woman who had a passion for conservation and had worked with National Parks Conservation Association, The Green Army, and as an agricultural farm assistant at Orara High School over the years. The 26-year-old was remembered by her family as a 'loving mother' and 'beloved daughter', in a notice shared by Keith Logue & Sons funeral service on social media. 'Forever loved and deeply missed by all her family and friends,' the notice read. Her family said Lillyannah, nicknamed Lily, was 'beloved, adored and protected' by Ms Stewart, who welcomed her in September 2022. '(She was) nanny's sweetest angel and poppy's best mate,' the notice read. 'Loved to the moon and back by all her family. We will miss her sunshine and gorgeous smile in our lives'. Ms Stewart had shared a number of posts and photos of her daughter on social media 'Teaching my baby how to do the shuffle is so adorable,' she wrote in one post. Jo-Anne Dacker, Stewart's mother, told 7News her daughter had an 'immeasurable' love for Hat Head – the town where the crash occurred. 'She was so protective of the environment there,' she said. The small Hat Head community of 365 people expressed an outpouring of sympathy on social media following news of the crash. 'There has been an incredibly sad update on yesterday's crash on Hat Head Road,' an admin wrote on a community Facebook page earlier this month. 'The HHC Admin Team's deepest sympathies go to those in the car, and their friends and family. 'And to everyone in Hat Head and close by, we hope you all find the strength to get through this horrible event.' The federal MP for the region Pat Conaghan also shared the 'tragic news' on social media. 'My thoughts go to family and friends who are dealing with this unimaginable event,' the Nationals MP said at the time. 'To our community, a reminder to stay safe on our roads this holiday season, don't take risks, drive to the conditions and ensure your vehicle is maintained to safety standards. 'Any life lost on our roads is one life too many.' Ms Stewart and Lily will be farewelled in a funeral service at Coffs Harbour on August 2. Police are investigating the cause of the crash. A report will be prepared for the coroner.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store