logo
Families of victims upset with findings of report into South Korea's Jeju Air plane crash

Families of victims upset with findings of report into South Korea's Jeju Air plane crash

An investigation into a South Korean plane crash that killed 179 people has found "clear evidence" that the pilots shut off the engine, but families of the victims say they don't trust the report.
The Jeju Air flight crash-landed at Muan International Airport on December 29, 2024, skidding along the runway before hitting a wall and exploding.
Families of the crash victims said they did not accept the investigation's findings.
They have raised questions about the transparency of the report, which they said concluded the crash was an error on the part of the pilots.
The findings of the report have now been hushed, and its release date has been delayed.
Lawyers representing the families have objected to the publication of the report and said investigators needed to look at other contributing factors, in addition to the bird strike.
As a result, a planned press briefing was cancelled and the release of the report was postponed, according to The Korea Times.
Groups representing the victims' families and the Jeju Air pilots' union said the media release could not be trusted and hoped investigators would include their views, too.
South Korea's Aviation and Railway Accident Investigation Board (ARAIB) has been accused by the union of "misleading the public" by suggesting there was no problem with the left engine, given traces of bird remains were found in both engines.
The union also accused the ARAIB of trying to make pilots "scapegoats" by failing to provide scientific and technological grounds that the plane could have landed safely with only the left engine turned on.
On Sunday, a day before the report was due to be released, a briefing session for the victims' families was held at Muan International Airport.
During the session, the Air Traffic Commission announced the investigation found: "There was no engine defect, and there is circumstantial evidence that the pilot turned off the left engine, not the right engine, which was more severely damaged by the collision, after the bird strike," South Korea's Yonhap News reported.
On the same day of the briefing session, Jeju Air Pilots' Union also released a statement, saying: "We are strongly outraged by the unilateral announcement by the Air Transport Commission and the media reports that quoted it without filtering, and we resolutely reject the malicious framing that seeks to shift responsibility to the pilots."
In May, the families filed a criminal complaint against 15 people, including South Korean Transport Minister Park Sang-woo, and airline safety representatives.
In a statement released by the lawyers for the families, they alleged negligence in managing safety risks and violations of the Aviation Safety Act.
They called for a more thorough investigation into the decision to attempt to land straight after a bird strike, the aircraft engine's maintenance, and whether the construction of a runway embankment was appropriate.
A source told Reuters the investigators looked at the cockpit voice recorder and computer data.
The evidence also included a physical engine switch found in the wreckage, which showed pilots shut off the left engine instead of the right engine when taking emergency steps before it was meant to land, after the reported bird strike.
No pre-existing defects were present in recovered engines.
"The investigation team has clear evidence and backup data, so its findings will not change," the source told Reuters.
The exact release date of the report has not been set; however, under international rules, a final report is expected within a year of the accident.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

23yo Aussie found dead in Thailand
23yo Aussie found dead in Thailand

News.com.au

time12 hours ago

  • News.com.au

23yo Aussie found dead in Thailand

A young Australian man has been found dead in a Thai hotel room reportedly one day before he was set to return home. According to local outlet 'Phuket News', police found the 23-year-old man in his hotel bed in Tambon Thepkrasatths wearing a black T-shirt and still holding his mobile phone. Phuket News reported there were no signs of a disturbance, no evidence of a break-in, and no visible injuries indicating foul play, although police did observe that his elbow and wrist had been bandaged. Friends told authorities these injuries were the result of a recent motorbike accident. An investigation officer with the local station received a call at around 10am from a nurse at Thalang Hospital, reporting the death of the 23-year-old. Officers later identified the man and confirmed that he had checked into the hotel on Sunday July 20 and was scheduled to check out on July 24. Police said the Australian Consulate in Phuket had been notified and a forensic doctor attended to examine the scene. The man's body was taken to Vachira Phuket Hospital for a post-mortem examination to determine the cause of death. Police said they were continuing their investigation. The Phuket News is withholding the man's name pending confirmation that his next of kin have been notified. Australia's Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said they were unable to comment until those further details were released.

Insane amount of CCTV footage in Joshua Bishop murder case
Insane amount of CCTV footage in Joshua Bishop murder case

News.com.au

time14 hours ago

  • News.com.au

Insane amount of CCTV footage in Joshua Bishop murder case

The body of missing man Joshua Bishop was allegedly found in a garage used as the bedroom of the man accused of his murder, a court has been told. Brandon Watts, 27, was charged with murder after human remains were found at a home on Erinbank Crescent in Melbourne's northwest in June following an investigation into Mr Bishop's disappearance. Mr Watts appeared in Melbourne Magistrates Court on Wednesday as police requested more time to prepare a hand-up brief of evidence. Prosecutor Sharn-Adelle Coombes told the court police were requesting an additional 10 weeks to review CCTV footage – including one clip more than 300 hours long – from more than 42 sites. Detective Acting Sergeant Charles Thompson said 13 mobile phones had also been seized from a variety of witnesses. Mr Watts' lawyer Martin Amad questioned Sergeant Thompson about an affidavit by lead investigator Detective Senior Constable Rebecca Cameron in support of the extension. 'It is mentioned in the affidavit of Ms Cameron that investigators located the deceased in the garage which is used exclusively by Mr Watts as his bedroom,' he said. 'Do you know what the evidence is that the garage was used exclusively by him?' Sergeant Thompson responded saying he believes Mr Watts' mother had made a statement. The extension for an additional 10 weeks was granted by magistrate Michelle Mykytowycz, with police now required to hand over their case on October 6. 'Having regard to the affidavit and the forensic material that has been referenced in the affidavit, it would be clearly in Mr Watts' interest that all of that is disclosed prior to the committal mention,' Ms Mykytowycz said. Mr Watts will return to court on November 17.

Police call off search for Julian Story's remains, but divers continue Melissa Trussell investigation
Police call off search for Julian Story's remains, but divers continue Melissa Trussell investigation

ABC News

time14 hours ago

  • ABC News

Police call off search for Julian Story's remains, but divers continue Melissa Trussell investigation

SA Police has provided an update on separate searches for the remains of two suspected murder victims believed to have been killed decades apart. Warning: This story contains content some readers may find distressing. Searches around the Port Lincoln area for the missing remains of 39-year-old Julian Story, whose dismembered body was found on June 19, have been called off — a move that will allow his family to make preparations for his funeral. In a separate matter, divers have returned to waters off Garden Island in Adelaide's north-west to conduct further investigations in relation to the cold case disappearance of teenager Melissa Trussell and a submerged vehicle that could be linked to her suspected murder. SA Police's Major Crime Investigation Branch today issued a public update on the state of both cases. Detective Superintendent Darren Fielke said police had "exhausted all the areas of interest" that had been identified in relation to the missing remains of Mr Story. He said police had kept in close contact with Mr Story's family, who had been "completely understanding" about the decision to end the search. "They are also very keen to lay Julian to rest and have his funeral so they can start to move on. If we ultimately provide or locate remains down the track they're aware of how that might reinvigorate their grief. "We will, however, go back and search if we receive specific information about where Julian's remains might be — but in terms of general searching in Port Lincoln, that has now stopped." Mr Story's 34-year-old partner — former Beauty and the Geek contestant Tamika Chesser — has been charged with his murder, and appeared in court last month. Superintendent Fielke said it remained unclear when police would be able to interview her. "We're not in a position yet to be able to talk to Tamika. She's currently detained in James Nash House and we don't have the opportunity at this point in time to interview her," he said. Police on Wednesday told the ABC that they had found an Elvis T-shirt, a drink bottle and a wristband in scrubland. Superintendent Fielke said those items were potentially linked to the case and had been seized, including for potential DNA testing, to determine whether there was a connection to Mr Story's alleged murder. "It was just a very unusual thing to find in that location. What we do know is that both Tamika and Julian were Elvis fans, which kind of sparked our interest a little bit more given what was on the T-shirt," he said. "That's why all those items have been seized for further testing." Meanwhile, police have continued to conduct underwater searches for the remains of 15-year-old Melissa Trussell, who is believed to have been killed in a suspected double murder in Adelaide's north 25 years ago. Melissa and her 33-year-old mother Rosemary Brown were last seen in Blair Athol about 2:30am on Saturday, May 13, 2000. Ms Brown's body was found weeks later in mangroves at Garden Island in Adelaide's north-west, but Melissa's body has never been found and police believe she was also murdered. "We're conducting a very active investigation in relation to Melissa's disappearance and Rosemary's murder," Superintendent Fielke said. Last week, police launched a new search for the body of the 15-year-old in a previously unsearched area of water and mangroves. Police divers returned to Garden Island today. A submerged vehicle found towards the southern end of the island has been described as being "of interest to the investigation" at this point in time. But Superintendent Fielke said further work, including potentially lifting it to the surface, would have to be conducted to determine whether it was connected to the case. "Divers will be back there periodically for the next few weeks," he said. "Trying to ascertain exactly what that vehicle is will have its challenges. The vehicle has been described as being "not structurally very sound" and "submerged in quite a deep volume of water". "We're trying to establish make, year, model of that vehicle," he said. Melissa's father Barry Trussell and her sister Kayla this month spoke of their need to secure justice for the 15-year-old, as well as answers about how she disappeared. "Any little bit of information you've got can help, no matter how small — it can be what breaks the case," he said. Earlier this year, SA Police released a new image of Melissa in a bid to prompt public interest in the unsolved crime. According to Crime Stoppers SA, Rosemary was evicted from the Windsor Gardens Caravan Park on May 3, 2000 and moved around in the days before her disappearance. Her handbag was found in Stirling Street at Northfield at the time of her disappearance, but it was not handed into police until May 23 after a public appeal about the missing mother and daughter. Ms Brown's body was discovered by two siblings, Sarah and James Fidock, who had gone to Garden Island to fish with their father. The sister and brother recently spoke out about their wish for grieving relatives. "There's a family that don't know where she is and who need her home," Sarah said. "We do hope that they find the missing piece of this, and I hope they do get closure."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store