WATCH: Mobile network operators grilled by MP's over data costs
Mobile network operators (MNO) Vodacom, MTN, Cell C, Telkom and Rain have come under fire over poor connectivity and their pricing and expiration for services such as data.
The mobile network operators appeared before the Communications Committee on Friday to provide an update on the challenges and progress made in achieving universal connectivity.
Members of Parliament (MPs) grilled the MNOs relating to the cost of data and called for them to consider measures to further reduce the cost of communication and prioritise rural connectivity.
While the CEOs of the MNOs told the committee that they've made major strides in expanding coverage, especially in the 5G network space, MPs questioned their data pricing and the issue of expiring data.
Data costs
EFF MP and national spokesperson Sinawo Thambo riaised concerns about data and airtime expiry.
Thambo challenged the logic behind data and airtime expiry, questioning whether it was a purely capitalist scheme designed to exploit consumers.
He argued that since data and airtime are not perishable goods, their expiry policies are unjust and violate consumer rights by allowing mobile operators to profit unfairly.
'I don't doubt there is a logical financial explanation for the expiring mandates of data and airtime…Which may be logical to you, but continues to undermine access to information for ordinary South Africans and their ability to live in this country.'
WATCH Colleen Makhubele in Parliament
This week at a glance: 'You have become loan sharks to the poor. Instead of cutting data costs, you are advancing it – loaning them.' – Chief Whip Hon. Colleen Makhubele raising concerns about network service providers and their exhorbitant pricing for products such as data and… pic.twitter.com/e3Jw8ufkSB — MK Party in Parliament (@MKParliament) June 14, 2025
ALSO READ: Malatsi takes action to lower smart devices and phone costs in SA
'Loan sharks'
MK party MP Colleen Makhubele accused the operators of preying on the poor.
'You have become loan sharks to the poor. Instead of cutting data costs, you are advancing it – loaning them.'
Political parties also noted the high salaries paid to some of the CEOs of the network operators, calling on them to help contribute to uplifting poor and rural communities.
Engagements
Chairperson of the committee, Khusela Sangoni Diko, stated that all the information received will be useful when the committee meets to deliberate on the budget of the Department of Communications and Digital Technologies in the coming weeks.
Diko said the committee also called for increased engagement on the issue of prepaid data expiration.
'I think we may have to engage more on this topic, especially because people buy this data, and it cannot simply disappear on the basis of MNO-determined timelines.'
♦️Must Watch♦️
EFF MP @Sinawo_Thambo delivers a scathing critique in the Portfolio Committee on Communications and Digital Technologies, calling out the 'revolving door' culture between regulators and mobile network operators.
Commissar Thambo questions the ethics of former… pic.twitter.com/cwix7aMpMH — Economic Freedom Fighters (@EFFSouthAfrica) June 13, 2025
Competition
In the interest of national security and technology sovereignty, the Committee called on the MNOs to consider mobilising their own resources to build the country's own satellite for communication.
MTN SA CEO Charles Molapisi told the committee that outside South Africa, the operator has partnerships with non-terrestrial and satellite players such as Starlink.
Molapisi said he welcomed Starlink to South Africa, as MTN would welcome all competition.
'I always say we are not fixated on one key player, Molapisi said. 'We see satellite players as one bundle. I'm sure the committee is aware that in some of our markets outside South Africa, we've already done partnerships with the likes of Starlink.'
ALSO READ: Fibre, cheaper data and weaver birds: Ramaphosa promises innovation
Regulatory requirements
Vodacom CEO Sitholizwe Mdlalose told the committee that the MNO was guided by President Cyril Ramaphosa's recent remarks, which stated that Starlink had not been discussed in meetings with the US government, and by Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Ronald Lamola's remarks that the government's commitment to attracting foreign direct investment did not refer to Starlink.
'Vodacom recognises satellite networks as complementary to mobile and fixed networks/ We believe they play a role in accelerating digital inclusion and bridging the connectivity divide, especially in hard-to-reach areas.
'Our position has consistently been that there must be a level playing field for all market participants. This is not specific to Starlink, but a matter of principle. Any new entrant to the South African telecommunications sector should be subject to the same regulatory requirements that govern licensed operators,' Mdlalose said.
Starlink
In May, South Africa took a step closer to obtaining Elon Musk's Starlink satellite internet service after Communications and Digital Technologies Minister Solly Malatsi published a policy direction to provide alternatives, paving the way for the service in the country.
The proposed policy direction was published in the Government Gazette.
'It provides applicants with a workaround to rules on who can acquire a licence to provide electronic communications services or to operate an electronic communications network in the Electronic Communications Act (ECA) that require a minimum of 30% shares to be in the hands of historically disadvantaged individuals.
'These regulations currently prevent companies, regardless of whether they are large international firms that typically do not sell shares to local partners, from qualifying for individual licences under the ECA, even if they can contribute to South Africa's transformation goals through means other than traditional ownership.
Musk not black
Talks on launching Starlink in South Africa stalled earlier this year after South African-born Elon Musk and US President Donald Trump ramped up public rhetoric against policies such as the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) laws, which mandate that foreign-owned telecoms companies allocate at least 30% of local equity to historically disadvantaged groups, primarily black South Africans.
Musk claimed Starlink was barred from operating in South Africa because he is not black, an allegation South African officials refuted.
ALSO READ: WATCH: Starlink not debated with Trump, Ramaphosa says
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
2 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Hlabisa urged to punish delinquent mayors and municipal officials
The DA has slammed the co-operative governance and traditional affairs ministry for neglecting oversight work at the coalface of service delivery centres. The DA made these remarks before the passing of the Cogta budget. 'It is due to this allowance of municipal top brass existing unchecked for the poor decisions that they make, that have resulted in dysfunctional municipalities and dilapidated services,' the DA said. In the National Council of Provinces, the DA's Dr Igor Stefan Scheurkogel led the charge, saying the collapse of local government stemmed from a crisis in political leadership. 'Of 116 municipalities, 68 have submitted unfounded budgets for three consecutive years. The auditor-general warned parliament that this fiscal recklessness has become systematic. 'Unfounded budgets are illegal under the Municipal Systems Act, which requires all municipal budgets to be based on a realistic anticipated revenue. These illegal budgets continue with zero accountability. The collapse of local government stems from political leadership. It simply doesn't care.' He told Cogta minister Velenkosini Hlabisa that he now has a chance to turn things around. The DA suggested the problems can be solved by going back to the basics. The party argued that real-time monitoring of revenue collection, early warning systems for deficits and cash flow issues, professionalisation of senior financial management roles and direct political accountability for overspending and irregularities were key to turning municipalities around. 'This is not a funding crisis. The crisis is of political will. The solution does not lie in a new funding model, it lies in the government crisis. Municipalities cannot continue with these illegal budgets, warning and evading consequences. What is missing is leadership, more for financial management and not policy smokescreens.' Scheurkogel told the NCOP that it was time municipal officials faced the music for their glaring failures. 'South Africans deserve budgets that deliver real services, roads that can be driven on, taps that deliver clean water, electricity that stays on, infrastructure that works and not politically convenient fiction. 'Yet, CFOs, HODs, have not been dismissed for unauthorised expenditure, no mayor has been held accountable, no measurable improvement has been seen. Instead, we see a government that knowingly budgets for failure and abandons communities to suffer the consequences.' He called the review of the white paper on local government a step in the right direction, saying, 'we must now commit to making local government work, because it is the sphere of government that touches the lives of South Africans every single day'. Hlabisa highlighted the comprehensive review of the 1998 White Paper on local government as a key focus area of his ministry, saying that it marks a crucial step towards a focused and fit for purpose local governance structures and that will result in efficient service delivery. 'This review is a testament to our collective commitment to addressing the challenges facing local governance and shaping a future that aligns with the aspirations of all South Africans. 'The review emphasises the need for local governments to adapt to a changing world characterised by urban growth, climate challenges, youth unemployment, and digital transformation, while embracing collaborations with traditional and Khoi-San leadership institutions. Hlabisa announced that he expected major collaboration across society as the review will function to influence governance, community engagement, and socioeconomic development. 'It reflects the government's commitment to improving local governance and service delivery, which are vital for effective democracy and citizen satisfaction. We prioritise inclusive engagement by ensuring all voices, especially those historically silenced, are heard. We aim to provide marginalised groups, like informal traders, women, youth, traditional and Khoi-San leaders, and rural communities, with the opportunity to participate.' He said the review aims to create a modern local governance structure that fosters capable, ethical and innovative municipalities, ultimately improving lives and strengthening democracy. The department has announced it has buckled to requests for more engagement, which has resulted in an extension of the deadline to July 2025. 'Our goal is to develop a responsive local government system that meets the needs of all South Africans and delivers quality services. We have made progress in implementing targeted interventions in distressed municipalities. These interventions include infrastructure maintenance and development support, enabling municipalities to address basic service delivery backlogs in water, electricity, roads and sanitation. 'We are also advancing critical policy and legislative reforms that lay the foundation for long-term stability and improved governance. Our interventions are guided by careful assessments of municipal needs, and we are committed to ensuring that our support is effective and sustainable.' According to the minister, his department's budget strategy introduces a package of targeted and differentiated interventions, guided by careful assessments of municipal needs. He said the department had identified 30 priority municipalities requiring support and intervention. Hlabisa said the department's focus areas include the Municipal Infrastructure Grant (MIG) which will accelerate critical infrastructure projects, ensuring value for money. He added the ministry allocated R493.8m to support this initiative in priority municipalities. 'Second, integrated urban development for growth nodes will enhance urban planning and infrastructure investments. To support these initiatives, we have reallocated R244.7m from the MIG to the Integrated Urban Development Grant (IUDG).' The third priority is the strengthening of municipal systems and the District Development Model (DDM) which is expected to enhance intergovernmental planning and budgeting. Its figure will rise from R151.1m in 2025/26 to R165.3m in 2027/28, supporting municipalities in improving their systems. 'We're finalising a municipal debt relief framework with the National Treasury to help municipalities manage debt and enhance financial sustainability,' pledged the minister. Gauteng Cogta MEC Jacob Mamabolo said Hlabisa has made his job easy, showing full support for the budget vote. He said it will be very strange if any party or member were to deviate from a 'very profound address made by the minister'. 'This is a very strategic and correct line taken, that we as Gauteng embrace and endorse. We have launched a province wide turnaround strategy in October 2024 and we are pleased to report remarkable and significant progress in the municipalities.' Hlabisa announced that his department's budget amounts to R410.9bn — with 96% majority earmarked for intergovernmental transfers and entities. He believes this significant investment will enable his department to implement criticalinitiatives that deliver tangible and measurable improvements in the lives of citizens. The department has allocated traditional affairs R195,530m, with a portion earmarked for transfer and subsidies.
Eyewitness News
2 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Simelane lashes out at detractors, says she's been tried in court of public opinion
Lindsay Dentlinger 2 July 2025 | 15:34 Department of Human Settlements Thembi Simelane Democratic Alliance (DA) Human Settlements Minister Thembi Simelane during debate on the budget of the department in Parliament on 2 July 2025. Picture: Parliament/Zwelethemba Kostile CAPE TOWN - Human Settlements Minister Thembi Simelane has lashed out at her detractors, saying she's been tried in the court of public opinion. She was responding to the Democratic Alliance (DA) during the budget debate of her department on Wednesday afternoon, as its MPs sought to drive home the party's view that she should be fired. On Tuesday, the party said it had been informed that an investigating officer had been assigned to probe corruption allegations against Simelane, following its complaint at the Cape Town Police Station last year, when it emerged that Simelane had loaned money from an intermediary linked to the defrauded VBS Bank to buy a coffee shop. ALSO READ: • Final leg of national budget process in peril amid DA's plans to boycott budgets of compromised ministers • MKP, EFF reject transport dept's budget, say it lacks vision for transforming public transport • Nkabane: Parties rejecting budget of Higher Education Dept punishing SA students • Majority of political parties in NCOP reject higher education dept's budget, call for Nkabane's axing The DA's Luyolo Mphithi said that having been removed as justice minister and moved to human settlements in response to corruption allegations, Simelane could not be trusted with over R30 billion in public funds. In line with a party resolution over the weekend, the party's MPs said on Wednesday that it would not vote in favour of a budget where Simelane was in charge. But Simelane addressed the matter head-on. "Yes, you stand in the dock before a judge when you are charged. I'm not amazed that you don't know this because I'm undergoing trial without charges. You are trying me in the public air, because you think it's the only way to degrade the work that I'm doing." Opposition parties, the uMkhonto weSizwe Party (MKP) and Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), also objected to the budget vote, saying the department was inadequately funded to house millions of South Africans. ActionSA, meanwhile, said that while the allegations against the minister were worrying, the party was rejecting the budget because of the department's failures to provide enough housing and a lack of accountability for those involved in wrongdoing at entities linked to the department.
Eyewitness News
2 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Malema's private member's bill to nationalise SARB gets mixed reaction during public hearings
Babalo Ndenze 2 July 2025 | 11:33 FILE: EFF leader Julius Malema in Parliament. Picture: Parliament/Phando Jikelo CAPE TOWN - Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) leader Julius Malema's private member's bill aimed at nationalising the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) has a received a mixed reaction during public hearings. Some organisations like labour federation, COSATU, voiced support for Malema's South African Reserve Bank Amendment Bill, while others warned that it could have serious repercussions for the economy if the current model was tampered with. COSATU, the National Treasury and other organisations made submissions before the Standing Committee on Finance on Wednesday, seven years after the bill was first introduced in Parliament. The Standing Committee on Finance continued public hearings on Malema's private member's bill, which was submitted in bill aims to amend the South African Reserve Bank Act and proposes changes to the appointment of the bank's directors. The bill also wants the state to be the sole shareholder of the central bank, which has two million shares held by private and foreign investors. COSATU's Tony Ehrenreich said that they supported this move. "The ownership of the South African Reserve Bank must only be vested with the state in line with international norms." But Christopher Axelson, National Treasury's deputy director-general for tax and financial sector policy, said they don't support the bill, warning that it could have serious implications. "The governance arrangements could also be weaker and may negatively impact the independence of the SARB and so we don't support the bill." The committee will now further process the submissions before a motion on the bill's desirability is considered.
