Aadhaar Not Proof Of Citizenship Or Birth, Say ECI Sources Amid Bihar Voter List Review Row
On Friday, the poll body issued a statement that it is aiming to release the draft electoral rolls for Bihar on August 1 and the final version by September 30
As political parties question the exclusion of Aadhaar as a valid document during the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, sources in the Election Commission of India (ECI) clarified that the twelve-digit unique identity number is not proof of citizenship or birth but only establishes that the 10 fingerprints, photograph, and iris scan are those of the person named on the card.
An ECI official, speaking on condition of anonymity, told News18 that some political parties, including the Trinamool Congress, have strongly objected to linking Aadhaar with the Electoral Photo Identity Card (EPIC), citing legal and constitutional concerns.
'Aadhaar is merely a proof of identity—not of citizenship, date of birth, or place of birth—as clearly stated on the card itself," the official said.
Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) leader Tejashwi Yadav raised the question of the exclusion of Aadhaar through the media and also in a Hindi editorial earlier this week.
ECI sources, when asked, said that Aadhaar just defines identity.
'It is written on every Aadhaar card in bold that 'Aadhaar is proof of identity', not of citizenship or date of birth," they said.
Questions have also been asked about the pace of the revision process. Yadav, serving as the leader of the opposition in Bihar, also claimed that the last SIR in the state in 2003 took two years to complete, while the poll body is rushing the process this time.
The ECI official clarified that the SIR in Bihar follows the same 31-day schedule for form distribution and collection as the 2002 revision.
'Printing, distribution, and collection of enumeration forms during the last intensive revision in Bihar in 2002 was done between July 15 and August 14, or 31 days. The current SIR is also giving a 31-day window for printing, distribution, and collection of enumeration forms, between June 24 and July 26," the official explained.
The enumeration was carried out in 2002 with a qualifying date of January 1, 2003.
Earlier this week, News18 spoke with Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar, who assured that the SIR in Bihar was initiated to ensure that no eligible voter is excluded and no ineligible entry makes it into the rolls.
On Friday, the poll body issued a statement that it is aiming to release the draft electoral rolls for Bihar on August 1 and the final version by September 30.
So far, nearly 87% (6.86 crore) of Bihar's 7.90 crore voters have received enumeration forms during the SIR and 1.5 crore households have already been covered in the first round of visits by booth-level officers (BLOs).
The term of the Bihar assembly is ending in November, and an election is likely to be held before that.
First Published:
July 05, 2025, 01:16 IST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
43 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Investor apologises after MNS attack over remarks targeting Raj Thackeray
Five Maharashtra Navnirman Sena supporters were detained on Saturday for the attack on investor Sushil Kedia's office in Worli here over the latter's social media post about not learning Marathi and his "kya karna hai bol" dare to Raj Thackeray. Hours after the attack, Kedia apologised for the social post claiming he had overreacted and also professed admiration for Thackeray. Kedia said he had uploaded the post in a wrong state of mind under duress and stress and wished to correct it unequivocally after realising his mistake. "Having come under pressure mentally from the violence inflicted on those who do not know Marathi, I ended up over-reacting," Kedia said. "I realise I must take back my over-reactions and withdraw," he asserted. In his apology video, Kedia said, "Even after living for 30 years in Mumbai, the level of proficiency and fluency that a native Marathi born can have, we will not be able to achieve and for avoiding any embarrassments or confusions, one has been using Marathi language only in less than formal situations, with a casual atmosphere only before people very closely known to them." "It has not happened to me in the use of seven other Indian languages that I could learn over a period of time," Kedia added. Kedia said he has a deep sense of appreciation and gratitude towards Raj Thackeray for the strong issues he raises, the strength with which stands up in matters like the Hanuman Chalisa campaign (when Uddhav Thackeray was the chief minister), championing the cause of Hindutva and "rashtrawad" (nationalism). Kedia came into the crosshairs of the Raj Thackeray-led party on Friday. After some incidents of people getting thrashed over non-use of Marathi triggered by the controversy linked to the "imposition" of Hindi and three-language policy in state schools, Kedia had expressed his anger through a social media post targeting Thackeray. "I don't know Marathi properly even after living for 30 years in Mumbai & with your gross misconduct I have made it a resolve that until such people as you are allowed to pretend to be taking care of Marathi Manus I take pratigya I won't learn Marathi. Kya karna hai bol?" Kedia had posted on X. In response, MNS supporters, shouting slogans in support of Thackeray and Marathi, had thrown coconuts at the glass door entrance of Kedia's office this morning, with videos of the attack going viral on social media immediately. In the videos, security personnel posted at the site can be seen trying to thwart the attack in vain, while office staff attempted to down shutters to avoid getting hit by the coconuts. Five MNS supporters have been detained in connection with the attack and further probe into the incident is underway, a Worli police station official said. "They have been brought to the police station for questioning and further legal action," the official said. Incidentally, police had provided security to Kedia's office situated at Century Bazar after his post began generating a backlash from MNS supporters.
News18
an hour ago
- News18
‘Hit But Don't Shoot Video': Raj Thackeray's Blunt Advice To MNS Workers Amid Marathi Row
Last Updated: Raj Thackeray also advised against recording the video of the incident, saying that let the victim tell that he has been beaten up. Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) chief Raj Thackeray on Saturday issued a fierce advice to his party workers amid the ongoing row over alleged assault of a Mumbai shopkeeper for not speaking in Marathi. While addressing a joint rally of MNS and Shiv Sena (UBT) along with his cousin, Uddhav Thackeray, Raj Thackeray advised against violent enforcement of language use and said, 'Be it Gujarati or anyone else, they must know Marathi. But there is no need to beat people for not speaking Marathi. [But] if someone creates unnecessary drama, you must hit below their eardrums." Mumbai, Maharashtra: MNS chief Raj Thackeray says, 'In the Mira-Bhayander incident, some Hindi channels showed that MNS slapped a Gujarati shopkeeper. They did not slap him because he is Gujarati. Non-Marathis need to learn Marathi, okay? They can learn. And I want to tell you… — IANS (@ians_india) July 5, 2025 He also advised against recording the video of the incident, saying that let the victim tell that he has been beaten up. 'And I want to tell you all, don't slap anyone if they don't understand. If you beat someone, don't make a video of the incident. Let the person beaten up tell that he has been beaten up; you don't need to tell everyone," he said. During the rally, his now reunited cousin, Uddhav Thackeray defended 'Marathi pride" saying, 'Yes, we are goons if we have to do hooliganism for justice." Referring to Fadnavis' statement on the assault of a shopkeeper by MNS workers that 'hooliganism" in the name of Marathi would not be tolerated, Uddhav Thackeray said they would keep doing 'hooliganism" if they don't get justice. goondagiri," he said. Slap Row In Maharashtra Earlier today, the MNS workers vandalised a businessman's office in Worli after he challenged Raj Thackeray, while asserting that he would not learn Marathi. The party workers and 'goons" of MNS assaulted a Mumbai shopkeeper for not speaking Marathi this week. The attackers have yet to be arrested, despite having filmed the assault and posted it online. The MNS has refused to apologise or even reprimand those involved in either attack. Sandeep Deshpande, the party's Mumbai unit boss, claimed the vicious slaps rained on Babulal Khimji Chaudhary were because the 48-year-old, whose shop has been a fixture in the Mira Road suburb for 20 years, had 'insulted' Marathi. 'If there is an attempt to insult Marathi, we will respond. It will not be tolerated." Earlier in March this year, Raj Thackeray had said that his party would not refrain from 'slapping" people if they refuse to speak Marathi in the state. He had cited the Tamil Nadu language row and had said that they 'dared" to say 'no to Hindi". Meanwhile, five MNS supporters were arrested in connection with the attack and further probe into the incident is underway, a Worli police station official said. Incidentally, police had provided security to Kedia's office situated at Century Bazar after his post began generating a backlash from MNS supporters. Amid the row, Fadnavis on Friday said that the state government would not tolerate 'hooliganism in the name of language." (With inputs from agencies) First Published:
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Raj Thackeray spoke for Marathi, Uddhav for power: Eknath Shinde
Maharashtra deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde on Saturday said Raj Thackeray spoke in Marathi's interests but Uddhav Thackeray showed his desperation for power at the cousins' rally to celebrate the government's retreat on the issue of teaching Hindi in Uday Samant, who belongs to the Shinde-led Shiv Sena, similarly sought to distinguish between the two cousins, slamming only Uddhav who leads the rival Shiv Sena (UBT).Earlier in the day, the hitherto estranged Thackeray cousins shared public stage after two decades at a victory rally in Mumbai to celebrate the withdrawal of two government resolutions seeking to introduce Hindi as a third language from Class 1 in state to reporters, Shinde, without naming Uddhav Thackeray, said his desperation for power and jealousy were on display at the rally, and he should answer why the Marathi manoos (native Marathi speakers) were driven out of Mumbai in all these years."One expressed desire for the good of Marathi, the other spewed bile for power. Some people had said (before the rally) that there will be no party flag in the victory celebration. One speaker (Raj) followed it, the other (Uddhav) conveyed his agenda. This is the difference," Shinde who rebelled against Uddhav Thackeray and split the Shiv Sena in June 2022, noted that the song 'Jai Jai Maharashtra Majha' which was played at the start of the rally was given recognition as the `state song' when he was chief it was during his tenure that the Centre granted the classical language status to Marathi, he Thackeray was making a desperate attempt to improve his prospects with another person's (Raj) help, Shinde said, adding that it was Uddhav who, as chief minister, accepted the R A Mashelkar committee report which recommended that Hindi be made mandatory in state present government removed the word mandatory, Shinde there was speculation in recent weeks about the Shinde-led Shiv Sena trying to woo Raj Thackeray's Maharashtra Navnirman Sena for a tie-up for the coming civic elections in leader Uday Samant, who is the minister for Marathi language, echoed Shinde, stating that "one speech (by Raj) was for the good of Marathi and second (by Uddhav) was for achieving power in Mumbai.""People have seen that the second speech was for power," Samant said.- EndsMust Watch advertisement
