
N.B. codes of conduct allow for degree of council secrecy not possible under N.S. rules
In Strait Shores, in eastern New Brunswick, a councillor was temporarily suspended after an investigation that was kept from the public and was later found to have violated due process.
In the northern municipality of Heron Bay, which includes Dalhousie and Charlo, council suspended Mayor Normand Pelletier and, as Radio-Canada reported, has refused to publicly say why.
And in Sunbury-York South, the municipality has not publicly shared details of why Mayor David Hayward was suspended at a recent meeting.
Questions about due process have also arisen in Grand Lake, where a councillor was suspended in April following an investigation that never let her respond to the allegations she faced.
But if those four municipalities had been in Nova Scotia, recent legislation would have required details to be made public, following a clearly outlined due process for everyone involved in the investigations.
N.B. code has ambiguity, expert says
Last October, Nova Scotia adopted a new code of conduct for municipal elected officials, which acts as a blanket policy for all 49 municipalities in the province.
That's different from New Brunswick, where the Local Governance Act gives municipalities some guidelines that must be in their code of conduct but leaves it up to each council to create and implement their own version.
"The Nova Scotia code is clearer and avoids ambiguity like the one we have in New Brunswick," said André Daigle, a municipal law lawyer in Dieppe who's been working with municipalities and local planning commissions for more than 30 years.
Daigle said municipalities are left "in a vulnerable state because of the void that they have to fill themselves with the code of conduct."
Because of this, there are minor variations among the codes of New Brunswick councils.
The Nova Scotia code clocks in at 3,971 words, New Brunswick's has 898 words. Nova Scotia also mandates regular training on the new code for all elected officials, which is something the New Brunswick Union of Municipalities had called for.
For procedural fairness, the Nova Scotia code requires that a council member who is the subject of the complaint be given an opportunity to review and respond to information in an investigator's report. Details about who the investigator is and their contact must also be public.
And when imposing a sanction on a councillor, council must consider whether the member's contravention was intentional, a first-time offence, and whether the member has taken any steps to remedy the issue.
"And if they turn their mind to those factors, the hope, from what I can see, is that the sanctions will flow better," Daigle said. "And they'll be more measured if you take those things under consideration."
N.S. code includes clear outlines for transparency
Transparency is also a key focus of the Nova Scotia code. Once a council has acted on a complaint, it must publicly share what specific rule was broken, the investigator's recommendations and what sanctions were imposed.
In New Brunswick, a council must only make a report available to the complainant and the affected member of council. The council must review the report at a meeting and vote on a next step, but the meeting is allowed to be closed to the public if council deems the matter confidential.
"We're not really sure how to handle those investigations and at what point it becomes public and what details come out in public," Daigle said.
By comparison, he described the Nova Scotia regulation as having "a fantastic framework."
He said the New Brunswick code should speak more to the process of a code of conduct investigation. Currently, the code says that there must be "a fair and impartial process for investigation."
"What is a fair and impartial process for an investigation? Don't leave municipalities guessing how to draft these. We have 72 municipalities, you're going to have 72 versions of the bylaw."
CBC News requested an interview with the Department of Local Government but one was not provided.
When asked why New Brunswick doesn't have requirements similar to Nova Scotia's, a spokesperson did not answer the question and instead said it is up to the discretion of each province and territory to establish regulations "as they best see fit."
Local Government Minister Aaron Kennedy told CBC News in April that it's best for councils to handle their disciplinary process with little interference from Fredericton.
'We need to be held to a certain standard,' N.S. official says
Yarmouth Mayor Pam Mood, the president of the Nova Scotia Federation of Municipalities, said the association spent two years helping draft the new legislation.
She said it was important the code of conduct be the same across the province because it was confusing to have something be outlawed in one municipality but allowed in a neighbouring municipality.
"We're here to serve the public," Mood said.
"And so sometimes we need help, not because everybody's dishonest, but because we need to know what the rules are and where we can go."
Before the new policy was enacted, Mood said, she would hear about councils having code of conduct violations "all the time."
"You have people screaming at each other … at a table where they were elected together to be a team, treating each other like they're the enemy," she said.
"It's childish and there's no need for it. You know, that type of behaviour is not power. It's exactly the opposite."
As for the transparency provisions of the new code, Mood said the public deserves to know what their elected officials are doing.
"Tell us if somebody's misbehaving, did I elect that person?" she said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
40 minutes ago
- CTV News
Justice minister wants answers on removal of Saskatchewan's top Mountie
Assistant commissioner Rhonda Blackmore, commanding officer of the Saskatchewan RCMP, speaks during a news conference in Regina on Thursday, June 6, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Liam Richards Saskatchewan's justice minister says he wants answers on why the RCMP's commanding officer in the province was abruptly removed. A spokesperson for Tim McLeod's office said in a statement Friday the minister has requested Ottawa provide further information and rationale on the decision involving Rhonda Blackmore. 'Minister McLeod has indicated that Rhonda's removal was surprising and disappointing,' Matthew Glover said. Glover said the minister initially made the comment in letters this week to constituents concerned about Blackmore's removal. In a letter obtained by The Canadian Press, McLeod said the decision came at a time when the province was under a state of emergency fighting wildfires. 'Saskatchewan remains committed to a strong and collaborative relationship with the RCMP and the Government of Canada to ensure the safety and well-being of our communities,' he wrote. 'We believe continued transparency and open dialogue are essential to supporting and sustaining that partnership.' Blackmore was abruptly out of the job in early June and replaced by an interim commanding officer until a new one could be selected. Media reports have cited an email from Blackmore saying she was removed due to anonymous complaints against her. The same day she was relieved of her duties, she was hired as a national assistant commissioner of Indigenous and support services for the RCMP. McLeod said in the letter that Blackmore was professional and had earned the trust of government, Indigenous leaders, citizens and staff. She advocated for the well-being of officers, he added. '(She has) raised critical concerns about the operational pressures faced by RCMP officers across Saskatchewan,' McLeod wrote. 'Her leadership reflects a clear understanding of the province's unique public safety challenges.' The federal justice department declined comment, saying questions should go to the RCMP. Mounties did not immediately provide a response Friday and have previously declined to comment on any complaints about Blackmore. The Federation of Sovereign Indigenous Nations in Saskatchewan and a petition have called on the RCMP to explain Blackmore's removal and undertake an external review. Blackmore took command of the Saskatchewan RCMP in April 2021, after serving various posts across Canada for 30 years. In 2022, she launched the RCMP's first unit aimed at recruiting Indigenous people to ensure Mounties represent the communities they serve. She was also the public face of the force after the mass killings on James Smith Cree Nation in 2022. -This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 4, 2025.


Toronto Star
an hour ago
- Toronto Star
Carney's first big miss: the backdown on the digital services tax
Personally, I prefer 'Over the boards!' to 'Elbows Up' as a catchword for Canadian combativeness and refusal to back down. They're from the same era. I learned it from a hockey-playing pal from Sudbury. It's when everyone on the bench vaults onto the ice to back up their embattled mates, rather than Gordie Howe going into the corner alone, arms flailing, and decimates the other side. I can see why Mark Carney opted for Elbows UP (EU) — aside from the subtle reference to diversifying our trade partners). He's spent his whole career going mano a mano with other top dogs. Despite that he managed to inspire a national team effort by vocalizing a firm stand. Canadians felt it deeply and hopped over the boards by cancelling long-planned trips to the U.S. or diligently inspecting the shelves for 'Made in Canada' stuff.


CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Most OQLF complaints related to service in Montreal
The offices of the Office québécois de la langue francaise (OQLF) are seen in Montreal on Nov. 21, 2024. (Christinne Muschi/The Canadian Press) New data published by the Office québécois de la langue française (OQLF) shows most complaints it received are related to being served in a language other than French in Montreal establishments. The French-language watchdog reported receiving 10,371 complaints between April 1, 2024 and March 31, 2025, a new record in the last decade. Since the Coalition Avenir Quebec was elected in 2018, complaints to the OQLF have been steadily rising while the government ramps up French-language protections through legislation like Bill 96, adopted in 2022. Between 2016 and 2017, the OQLF received 2,973 complaints. The number was relatively stable until 2021-2022, when the OQLF received 6,292 complaints. In 2023-2024, that number jumped to 9,125 before this year's all-time high. Of those, 40 per cent were related to service language, 24 per cent concerned commercial documents including websites and job postings, and 18 per cent had to do with signage. Only six per cent of complaints were connected to language used in the workplace and five per cent fell under 'others.' The vast majority of complaints (75 per cent) came out of Greater Montreal, which includes Montreal, Laval, Lanaudière, the Laurentians, and the Montérégie. Stéphane Beaulac, professor of constitutional law at the Université de Montréal and the Directeur de l'Observatoire national en matière de droits linguistiques, said it's typical for Montreal to see the most complaints as cities attract more people from outside Quebec. The number of complaints out of the metropolis have been relatively stable over the years. Eight per cent of complaints came out of Quebec City, three per cent from the Eastern Townships, and four per cent from the Outaouais. The rest of Quebec's regions account for four per cent of complaints and another six per cent came from outside Quebec. Bill 96's impact The OQLF notes that 22 per cent of complaints were unfounded and 36 per cent of cases were resolved. A quarter of all complaints necessitated an 'incentive intervention,' and 10 per cent warranted a warning. The organization says that francization processes were started in three per cent of cases and that it had to drop four per cent of complaints. CTV News requested clarification on which complaints were unfounded and resolved but did not hear back at time of publication. Beaulac said the OQLF's data means Quebec's common language reforms are working. He notes that though the total number of complaints went up, the rest of the breakdowns have been consistent over the years. 'One would think that with those extra incentives to protecting the French language, that there would be less complaints, but at the same time, Bill 96 provided more teeth to the system,' he said. 'It has actually provided the means for regular folks for anyone in regard to some of the obligations imposed by the scheme, the legislation to take action and actually file in complaints.' But Beaulac stresses that having more complaints doesn't mean the law isn't being respected. He points out that no complaints ended up before the Director of Criminal and Penal Prosecutions (DPCP), unlike in 2017-2018 when two per cent ended up before the DPCP. He says despite using the notwithstanding clause to push Bill 96 forward, the government is enforcing a 'soft power' as most cases end up getting resolved. 'The incentive and the scheme for implementation and enforcement actually means that it never comes push to shove,' said Beaulac. 'It is resolved beforehand, you know, upstream and not downstream to a penal procedure. So for me, it's extremely good news.'