Martin Lewis investigation into Holland & Barrett prompts major change
The scheme allows shoppers to schedule regular delieveries of products at a discounted price. The customers get a fixed percentage off the standard price of the item, often between 20% and 45% off, as well as free delivery on orders over £10. However, research by MoneySavingExpert.com that took place over a five month period, revealed a number of faults, including that shoppers would have actually saved more without the scheme.
As a result, the health giant which has more than 700 stores in the UK, has said it will carry out a review of the scheme, in a major change. However, company bosses defended 'Subscribe & Save', highlighting that customers get consistently better prices than if they were to make one-off purchases.
Price checks of 10 products were carried out over 100 separate days between July 29, 2024 and January 17, 2025 and it was found that in 59% of the cases it was cheaper to buy the product as a one-off.
On top of that, the research revealed that customers would have actually lost out on savings of 75p right up to £3.50 and in worst cases, they could have overpaid by as much as a huge £39.99.
Holland & Barrett website states that the Subscribe & Save is 'the most convenient and cost-effective way' to shop, as well as that customers will be 'getting the best value'. Read More Thousands of pensioners could be missing out on free TV licence
However, it does not factor in any special offers or deals that may be available at the time of a delivery, such as 'buy one get one free', '3 for 2' or 'better than half price' sales. Therefore, as the subsription discount doesn't include various other promotions, those subscribing can sometimes end up paying more than those who buy the item as a one-off purchase.
Items that were found to always be more expensive in the Subscribe & Save scheme includes the Egmont Manuka Honey 1046+ MGO 250g, Holland & Barrett Goji Berries 210g, and Holland & Barrett Manuka Honey MGO 800+ 350g.
A 200ml bottle of Nivea Sun Kids Sensitive Protect & Care Suncream Lotion SPF 50+ was found to be cheaper to buy as a one-off product 67% of the time, while 899g of the Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey Protein powder in the flavour Double Rich Chocolate, was found to be cheaper as a one-off purchase 55% of the time.
Following the investigation, Holland & Barrett defended the scheme, arguing that it offers 'consistently great prices over the course of a year', with 'the convenience of an automated order' and the free delivery on orders over £10.
However, admitted that 'on rare occasions' that subscription customers 'may have paid more'. The retailer have told MoneySavingExpert.com that they will 'carry out a detailed review' to ensure that those using the Subsribe & Save scheme benefit from offers. They will also look to make the scheme's language and T&Cs clearer.
READ SOURCE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
42 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Trump paused student-loan forgiveness for nearly 2 million borrowers on income-based repayment plans
President Donald Trump's Department of Education quietly updated its guidance on student-loan forgiveness for borrowers on income-based repayment plans, which give enrolled borrowers monthly payments based on their income and family size with the promise of forgiveness after 20 or 25 years. According to Federal Student Aid data, just under 2 million borrowers were enrolled in IBR as of the second quarter of 2025. A notice posted on FSA's website said that ongoing litigation with former President Joe Biden's SAVE plan is preventing the administration from processing IBR forgiveness. "Currently, IBR forgiveness is paused while our systems are updated to accurately count months not affected by the court's injunction. IBR forgiveness will resume once those updates are completed," the notice said. The SAVE plan, which allowed for cheaper monthly payments and a shorter timeline to debt relief, has been blocked since July 2024. Forgiveness through other repayment plans, including income-contingent repayment, was also blocked due to the court order. However, the court order did not include IBR, which falls under a different congressional statute. The department's deputy press secretary Ellen Keast told BI that the IBR relief pause is to "comply with ongoing court injunctions." "Legal IBR discharges will resume as soon as the Department is able to establish the correct payment count," Keast said. "For any borrower that makes a payment after they became eligible for forgiveness, the Department will refund overpayments when the discharges resume." Keast referred to a SAVE provision that allowed certain forbearance periods to count toward loan forgiveness. She said that while the court does not prevent relief through IBR, it impacts the types of forbearances that can be counted toward IBR relief, requiring the department to pause the discharges until it can adjust payment counts. The department did not comment on when the pause will be lifted. It comes at a precarious time for millions of borrowers — the department is restarting interest on SAVE borrowers' accounts beginning August 1, meaning their balances will once again start growing after a year on pause. To prevent balance growth, the department recommended that enrolled SAVE borrowers switch over to an IBR plan to begin making payments again. Trump's spending bill, which he signed into law on July 4, eliminated existing income-driven repayment plans and replaced them with two options: a standard repayment plan and a new Repayment Assistance Plan that allows for forgiveness after 30 years. Those plans aren't set to go into effect until July 2026. Since the bill also eliminates the SAVE plan, the department said borrowers should enroll in IBR in the meantime.
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
Trump paused student-loan forgiveness for nearly 2 million borrowers on income-based repayment plans
Student-loan forgiveness just got more complicated. President Donald Trump's Department of Education quietly updated its guidance on student-loan forgiveness for borrowers on income-based repayment plans, which give enrolled borrowers monthly payments based on their income and family size with the promise of forgiveness after 20 or 25 years. According to Federal Student Aid data, just under 2 million borrowers were enrolled in IBR as of the second quarter of 2025. A notice posted on FSA's website said that ongoing litigation with former President Joe Biden's SAVE plan is preventing the administration from processing IBR forgiveness. "Currently, IBR forgiveness is paused while our systems are updated to accurately count months not affected by the court's injunction. IBR forgiveness will resume once those updates are completed," the notice said. The SAVE plan, which allowed for cheaper monthly payments and a shorter timeline to debt relief, has been blocked since July 2024. Forgiveness through other repayment plans, including income-contingent repayment, was also blocked due to the court order. However, the court order did not include IBR, which falls under a different congressional statute. The department's deputy press secretary Ellen Keast told BI that the IBR relief pause is to "comply with ongoing court injunctions." "Legal IBR discharges will resume as soon as the Department is able to establish the correct payment count," Keast said. "For any borrower that makes a payment after they became eligible for forgiveness, the Department will refund overpayments when the discharges resume." Keast referred to a SAVE provision that allowed certain forbearance periods to count toward loan forgiveness. She said that while the court does not prevent relief through IBR, it impacts the types of forbearances that can be counted toward IBR relief, requiring the department to pause the discharges until it can adjust payment counts. The department did not comment on when the pause will be lifted. It comes at a precarious time for millions of borrowers — the department is restarting interest on SAVE borrowers' accounts beginning August 1, meaning their balances will once again start growing after a year on pause. To prevent balance growth, the department recommended that enrolled SAVE borrowers switch over to an IBR plan to begin making payments again. Trump's spending bill, which he signed into law on July 4, eliminated existing income-driven repayment plans and replaced them with two options: a standard repayment plan and a new Repayment Assistance Plan that allows for forgiveness after 30 years. Those plans aren't set to go into effect until July 2026. Since the bill also eliminates the SAVE plan, the department said borrowers should enroll in IBR in the meantime. Collections on defaulted student loans also restarted in May after a five-year pause, and the department said that wage garnishment will begin later this summer.
Associated Press
18 hours ago
- Associated Press
What's happening with forgiveness for student loans on income-based repayment plans?
NEW YORK (AP) — Amid a federal overhaul of student loan plans, many borrowers have been left wondering what it means for their hopes of loan forgiveness. In particular, those who are enrolled in a repayment plan known as income-based repayment, or IBR, have wondered if forgiveness will still be available to them. A recent update from the Education Department said forgiveness through the IBR plan is paused while systems are updated. 'IBR forgiveness will resume once those updates are completed,' the agency said. IBR is not affected by a federal court's injunction blocking former President Joe Biden's Saving on a Valuable Education, or SAVE, plan. The IBR plan was created by Congress separately from other existing repayment plans, including those known as PAYE and ICR. It's also exempt from some changes coming from President Donald Trump's tax and spending bill. Here's what to know. Which income-driven repayment plans are affected by the court's injunction? Following a court injunction last summer, loan forgiveness for the SAVE, Income-Contingent Repayment, or ICR, and Pay As You Earn, or PAYE, plans is currently paused because those plans were not created by Congress. The legal action called into question whether student loan forgiveness was authorized under the federal statute that governs those plans. The IBR plan was created under a different authority. IBR, created by Congress, reduces monthly payments for borrowers with lower incomes. It also invokes a statute that authorizes student loan forgiveness of the balance at the end of a 20- or 25-year repayment term. When will IBR forgiveness resume? The Education Department hasn't given a timeline for when its system update will be complete and forgiveness will resume. Should a borrower continue to make IBR payments in the interim? Borrowers enrolled in IBR who have reached the threshold for forgiveness but who are not seeing their loans discharged as a result of the pause may continue to make payments with the expectation that the Education Department will refund the excess payments. The plan offers forgiveness after 240 or 300 monthly payments, depending on when borrowers enrolled. Borrowers can also request forbearance from their loan servicer. In that case, interest would continue to accrue on any remaining balance. What changes are coming from Trump's 'big beautiful bill'? Trump's tax and spending law will eventually phase out the ICR, PAYE and SAVE plans, replacing them with the Repayment Assistance Plan. IBR plans will continue to exist and to provide forgiveness after 20 or 25 years. RAP, in contrast, will require 30 years of repayment before forgiveness is granted. ___ The Associated Press receives support from Charles Schwab Foundation for educational and explanatory reporting to improve financial literacy. The independent foundation is separate from Charles Schwab and Co. Inc. The AP is solely responsible for its journalism.
