Police chiefs call for cuts to number of forces in England and Wales
They believe a reduction from the current 43 forces would save money, cut overheads and boost crime-fighting efforts.
Law enforcement leaders told the home secretary, Yvette Cooper, last month at a roundtable on police reform that they were in agreement about the need for the change.
Cooper has already backed other police reforms, such as setting up a national centre for policing, and believes the way policing across England and Wales is organised is out of date. But a lack of money threatens to delay changes and some smaller forces may oppose the changes.
One source said any changes could start with smaller forces merging or being abolished. In the west, Gloucestershire and Wiltshire could merge. In the Midlands, Warwickshire could join with the West Mercia force or be absorbed by the much bigger West Midlands force.
In the east, the Norfolk and Suffolk forces could merge. The West Yorkshire, North Yorkshire and the South Yorkshire forces could also merge.
Gavin Stephens, the chair of the National Police Chiefs' Council, told the Guardian: 'Police reform is about restructuring policing so that it can keep up with modern criminality, retaining the bedrock of community policing whilst modernising our workforce to deal with national threats such as organised crime and violence against women and girls.
'Our current model of 43 different police forces in England and Wales has a wide range of geographical size, workforce size and operational capabilities. There is also real variation in financial resilience and the ability to invest, which means policing operates in subtly different ways with often incompatible technology, which leads to inefficiencies and inconsistency.
'A smaller number of police forces, supported by a national policing organisation, would enable us to make decisions far quicker and maximise funding to invest in technology and our workforce. Making improvements to our service once and for all, instead of in 43 different ways, would help to end the postcode lottery victims face when reporting crime.'
One senior source said: 'Everyone is in agreement we need fewer forces. It would create efficiencies and greater effectiveness.'
Another source with knowledge of discussions said: 'Chiefs of smaller forces are nervous but accept this is where the tide is going. We hope for a phased reduction over the next decade.'
No changes are expected to happen in this parliament, and any change of government after the next election could lead to the agreement to abolish police forces being scuppered.
Politically, it was believed a reduction in the number of forces would have to happen under Labour. MPs representing Conservative areas, which tend to be less urban, feared police would move from more rural areas to areas where crime tended to be higher.
One chief constable said that if their force absorbed a smaller force, people in more rural areas could be offered a guarantee about how many officers would be ringfenced to protect them.
As yet, no detailed plans have been drawn up or presented to the government, but Mark Rowley, the Metropolitan police commissioner, said he favoured a reduction to as few as 12 forces. It is understood that this is the number of forces senior police chiefs think should ultimately cover England and Wales.
In a piece for the Sunday Times, Rowley said: 'The 43-force model was designed in the 1960s and hasn't been fit for purpose for at least two decades. It hinders the effective confrontation of today's threats and stops us fully reaping the benefits of technology.
'We need to reduce the number of forces by two-thirds, with the new, bigger and fully capable regional forces supported by the best of modern technology and making better use of the limited funding available.'
In Scotland, forces have already merged into one organisation covering the entire country, which is the second largest in the UK behind the Met. Northern Ireland is also covered by a single force.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Drugs crisis in jails ‘worse than ever' as seizures by prison officers near record-high
The drugs crisis in prisons is the worst it has ever been, experts have warned, with the prevalence of illicit substances rendering jails ' almost impossible to run positively'. Ministers have been warned that an unacceptable level of criminality is rampaging unchecked in many prisons, as the most recent data shows annual drug seizures by prison officers returning to record highs of more than 21,000. New analysis by The Independent highlights how the ongoing crisis first exploded during the austerity years, as the prison service was hollowed out by cuts and staff layoffs. The warning comes as staffing levels remain on the brink at some prisons and as the government prepares for the largest overhaul of the system in decades to ease overcrowding and refocus the justice system towards rehabilitating offenders. 'We generally feel there is a bigger and more diverse and profitable drug market in prisons than there's ever been,' said Mike Trace, chief executive of the Forward Trust, a charity delivering drug treatment in 20 prisons. 'Obviously we can't itemise that in terms of GDP figures, but the feeling for most professionals on the wings is this is a bigger part of prison life than it's ever been before.' Warning that this 'makes prisons almost impossible to run positively ', Mr Trace – who previously served as a government drugs tsar under Tony Blair – also expressed concern that an influx of new synthetic drugs are posing a risk to safety, with fatally potent synthetic opioids feared to be 'in the mix'. Mr Trace told The Independent: 'A lot of the market in prisons now is liquids and powders that people receiving and taking them are not really sure what's in them. That means the risk of overdose or adverse reaction is heightened because people aren't in a good position to manage dose and potency.' 'That's why you get the large number of blue-light ambulances calling,' he said. Warning that 'blue lights are a normal part of prison life now', Mr Trace added: 'There are prisoners who need medical attention on a daily/weekly basis.' His warnings were echoed in a major watchdog report published last month, in which the Independent Monitoring Board described drugs as a growing problem 'endemic across the prison estate' – with 'a seemingly unstoppable flow' into many jails. The watchdog's annual report said: 'At some prisons the impact of drugs was inescapable: debt drove up violence and bullying, while prisoners frequently experienced medical emergencies, which added further disruption as staff resource was directed towards assisting them and providing hospital escorts.' That is despite intensified efforts to crack down on the flourishing illicit market, as staff in the crumbling prison estate battle against increasingly adept drone deliveries and hard-to-detect substances. Official data shows there were a total of 21,145 drug seizures in the year to March 2024 – a rise of 35 per cent on the previous year, and close to an all-time high of 21,575 hit four years prior. Of the seizures made last year, more than 7,200 drug finds in the year to March 2024 were logged as 'unknown' substances. Nearly 5,000 others were categorised as 'psychoactive substances' – which can include the synthetic cannabinoid spice – and more than 3,000 as 'other'. The Independent previously revealed that new super-strength synthetic opioids now infiltrating the UK drugs market had already claimed lives behind bars, with two deaths in June 2022 at HMP Lewes caused by overdoses of isotonitazene, a substance 250 times stronger than heroin. But experts warn that, in both prison seizures and post-mortem examinations, officials are still failing to test for these new opioids, which have been discovered in not just heroin but illicit vapes, diazepam and codeine pills. When nitazenes were discovered during a prison seizure in 2023, the government claimed the sample was deemed to be too dangerous for the private laboratory to handle. The Independent' s analysis of official data underscored the rapid explosion in the crisis during the austerity years led by the former Tory government, when funding cuts saw experienced officers laid off and drug treatment avenues diminish. There were an average of 3,813 annual drug seizures in prisons over the eight years to 2014, but this soared to a yearly average of 15,350 over the following decade. From 2014, confiscations skyrocketed from fewer than 4,500 to more than 21,000 just six years later. Mr Trace said 'massive austerity cuts' from 2012 onwards saw long-serving prison staff replaced with 'relatively inexperienced and poorly trained officers ' – resulting in the loss of 'an awful lot of prison craft experience' and handing 'much more freedom to prisoners to exploit laxer security to build up drug trade'. Simultaneously, the number of addiction treatment programmes in prisons, such as drug-free wings, were slashed from 110 in 2013 to around 15 just six years later, according to Mr Trace. It coincided with the arrival of spice – which is easier to produce and circulate behind bars than cannabis – and 'increased the incentives of drug dealing gangs to target prisons'. Now, the arrival of drones – which Mr Trace describes as the 'current front line in the arms race for dealing' – have taken the drugs trade to 'another level', with a single delivery capable of serving a prison for a month. Previously, piecemeal supplies came via family visits and corrupt officers which lasted only a matter of days. HM chief inspector of prisons, Charlie Taylor, told The Independent the effects of drugs, often brought in on drones, 'is the biggest challenge currently facing many of our prisons'. He said: 'Inspectors regularly smell drugs as they walk around the wings and random drug tests in some jails are regularly coming back more than 30 per cent positive. Where there are drugs, there is debt, which is one of the causes of increasing violence. 'It is simply not acceptable that these levels of criminality are going on, unchecked, in so many English and Welsh prisons.' Experts frequently warn that drugs and related debts are a major driver of violence behind bars, with assaults on staff hitting a record high of more than 10,000 in the year to March. Placing HMP Manchester into emergency measures last October, inspectors said 'catastrophic' levels of drugs were 'clearly undermining every aspect of prison life, particularly safety', fuelling the highest rates of serious assaults of any jail in the country. HMP Winchester followed suit days later to become the ninth jail put in emergency measures in just two years, with inspectors also citing drugs and violence as serious issues. A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: 'This government inherited a prison system in crisis – close to collapse, with drugs and violence rife. 'We take a zero-tolerance approach to drugs and are cracking down on illicit items using X-ray body scanners and drone-restricted fly zones – measures that are making a clear impact.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
BREAKING NEWS Man, 23, is charged over crash that killed a four-year-old girl and injured three others
A man has been charged after a four-year-old girl was killed in a fatal car crash. Mayar Yahia died after being hit by a silver Vauxhall Corsa in April 2024 in Birmingham on Upper Highgate Street at around 9.45pm. Three other people suffered injuries which were not serious. Javonnie Tavener, 23, has been charged with causing death by careless driving, causing death whilst driving uninsured and two counts of causing serious injury by careless driving. The young man appeared at Birmingham Magistrates Court on Wednesday and has been remanded in custody to appear at the city's Crown Court on July 30. At the time of Mayar's tragic death, her heartbroken father spoke out in a statement released via West Midlands Police. He said: 'It is with profound sadness and a heavy heart that we share the devastating loss of our cherished daughter, Mayar. 'She was an extraordinary young girl, only four-years-old, full of life and joy, and her absence leaves an irreplaceable void in our lives. 'Among all, she held a special place in my heart. 'Words fail to capture the depth of our grief and the magnitude of this loss. 'However, we find solace and strength in the unwavering support and compassion shown by the police officers, our community, family, and friends. 'We extend our heartfelt gratitude to each and every one of you who have stood by our side, offering your love, prayers, and support during this incredibly difficult time.'
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Brighton assault leaves man in hospital in serious condition
A man is in hospital in a serious condition after an assault in Brighton city Police officers were called to Western Road at about 02:30 on Saturday to reports of a fight between two groups of incident is thought to have started outside Buddha Nail Studio in Western Road before continuing opposite McDonald's, police force said a man in his 30s was treated at the scene by the ambulance service before being taken to hospital where he remains. Det Insp Ed Neve said: "This was a serious assault that has left a man with significant injuries."We know there were a number of people involved and multiple witnesses in such a central location, so we are asking anyone with information or relevant video footage to contact us online or via 101, quoting Operation Axle."
