logo
The Afghan data breach has already cost millions. What happens next?

The Afghan data breach has already cost millions. What happens next?

Times16-07-2025
The fallout from the Afghan data breach will have ripples across the world.
People named on a leaked dataset that officials feared could become a Taliban 'kill list' must make life or death decisions: whether to move house or, for those who may have already left the country, whether to send their families running.
At least 18,500 Afghans have already been secretly flown to Britain and more are expected to arrive in the coming days.
Back in the UK, the government is having to grapple with the issues of accommodation for the Afghans whose lives they put in danger more than three years ago, in February 2022, when their data was leaked in a massive blunder.
A flurry of legal action is expected as dozens of judicial reviews involving Afghans who have been blocked from coming to the UK are upended, law firms seek compensation for those affected and previously rejected applicants launch appeals.
Here is what to expect next:
Untested system costing £360,000 a month
All of those Afghans affected by the data breach should have been sent proactive notifications to tell them they were among the victims, although the Ministry of Defence (MoD) may be relying on out-of-date information.
An information service centre will also be established to notify individuals affected by the incident. Inquiries around the world will be directed here. The service, which costs £360,000 a month, has never been tested at scale before.
It will provide advice on what has happened and how individuals can take actions to protect themselves. A follow-up notification will then be sent advising them what to do next.
The centre will provide an online self-checker capability; a reactive email service aimed at individuals both in the UK and abroad who are concerned they or their family members are affected. There will also be an automated telephone capability plus a 'limited' call-handling service, which costs £30,000 a month.

Those answering the phones will not be able to tell those calling whether they have been affected or not. Calls will be taken in English only and calls from Afghanistan are discouraged.
According to a government plan for 'break glass' — the moment news of the data breach is revealed — prepared in the weeks leading up to the lifting of the superinjunction, 'there remains a risk that we incorrectly email unaffected persons and the self-checker wrongly informs persons if they are likely to be affected or not'.
More than 3,000 principal applicants on the list — plus their family members, taking the total to about 18,500 — have so far been allowed to come to Britain under the secret Afghan Response Route, which has been shut down.
More than 5,000 more Afghans affected by the breach who have received invitation letters already to come to the UK will be flown to Britain. This will take the total to almost 24,000 Afghans affected by the breach being brought to the UK. The remaining affected Afghans — potentially 76,000 people when taking into account family members — will not be allowed to come as the three Afghan schemes have been shut down.
A gigantic lawsuit and 'substantial payments'
Hundreds of Afghans all over the world are in the process of launching a claim against the government for leaking their personal data as part of a massive lawsuit that could end up costing taxpayers more than £250 million.
The lawsuit is being prepared by Barings Law, a Manchester-based firm that had already signed up some 1,000 clients while the superinjunction remained in place, even though the individuals did not know why they were agreeing to take legal action.
Adnan Malik, head of data protection at Barings Law, told The Times his clients had suffered 'real and ongoing harm' and 'live with the fear of reprisal against them and their families, when they were owed a duty of care for their dangerous work'.
'We would expect substantial financial payments totalling five figures for each claimant,' he said. 'While this will not fully redress the harm they have been exposed to, it will enable them to move forward and rebuild their lives.'
Thousands more Afghans are likely to join the legal fight for compensation once they are able to determine whether or not their name is on a 19,000-strong list of principal individuals whose data was breached in February 2022. About 19,000 applicants were on the list, but the MoD feared as many as 100,000 individuals were put at risk by the leak when taking into account family members.
Each Afghan could end up with at least £50,000 each and Barings believes they could have as many as 5,000 clients in the coming months. Thousands of family members may also be able to claim compensation because their names were on the list, which included phone numbers and addresses.
Malik said the leak was an 'incredibly serious breach which the MoD has tried to hide from the British public … It involved the loss of personal, identifying information about Afghan nationals who have helped British forces to defeat terrorism and to support security and stability in the region.
'By allowing their information to be leaked, the MoD has put multiple lives at risk, damaged its own reputation and put the success of future efforts in jeopardy by diminishing trust in its data security protocols.'
Malik said the 'lifting of a superinjunction which kept this data breach a secret is crucial in exposing the failings so that lessons can be learnt'.
Those Afghans suing the MoD are in the UK, Afghanistan, America, Turkey and Australia, as well as African nations. Until now the law firm had been unable to tell their clients why exactly they may be owed compensation without breaching the superinjunction.
Messages circulated on WhatsApp groups urging Afghans to sign up to the legal case on the expectation they would be given huge sums of money, without knowing the true extent of why.
Housing strain over rescued Afghans
Thousands of hotel rooms are being earmarked for new Afghan residents as councils 'creak under the pressure' of having to find houses for them alongside British citizens and an influx of refugees, court documents have disclosed.
Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, announced a pledge to stop using hotels to accommodate asylum seekers by the end of the current parliament — expected in 2029 — as part of her spending review last month. But the government is likely to increasingly rely on hotels as hundreds of vulnerable Afghans a month are rescued from the clutches of the Taliban.
Behind the scenes, 2,200 beds have been made ready at three hotels and a pilot site to make way. More than 1,000 rooms on MoD bases are being taken up by rescued Afghans and at one point 20 per cent of the defence estate was being used to house them.
By September, the government will have run out of 'transitional' accommodation in the form of hotels, serviced accommodation and pilot projects already available, documents released to the court state, raising questions about where all the Afghans will go.
One Afghan in a family of four will cost taxpayers about £1.25 million over three years if they are put into MoD transitional accommodation, including a hotel.
It costs half that amount if social housing is found for them instead, according to government figures, but officials have pointed out local government is 'creaking under current pressures' and in March 2023 there were 1.29 million households on social housing waiting lists.
At one point the problem with finding room for the Afghans was deemed so severe that officials asked ministers to consider asking foreign governments, including the US, to see if they would take them. Officials under the previous Conservative government debated the costs for what was described as a 'Rwanda-style' scheme.
The Afghans who are being rescued are not asylum seekers, having come to the UK legally and been given indefinite leave to remain.
Misinformation and threat of riots
The government has been concerned about the impact on public disorder of the data breach and its handling of it. This is especially so given the superinjunction has been lifted in the summer, when the risk of unrest is deemed to be higher.
Court documents disclosed how MoD officials discussed ways to 'provide cover' for the numbers of Afghans arriving last year. Rather than announce there would be large numbers of future arrivals, the government agreed to put out an 'agreed narrative that provides context for the increased numbers without disclosing information relating to the incident'.
However, their arrival in large numbers — at a time the real reason why many had been rescued was covered up — has been linked to unrest in the UK.
CHRISTOPHER FURLONG/GETTY IMAGES
In May, Bracknell Forest council responded to 'misinformation circulating regarding our new Afghan families' after a rumoured assault on a girl that turned out to be fake. After a Facebook user posted in multiple groups their daughter had been attacked the council issued a statement that 'we want to make sure all our residents have the facts' and that it 'would like to reiterate that our new families are not illegal immigrants, asylum seekers or refugees'.
'They have indefinite leave to remain and so are now UK residents,' it added. 'The new families are part of the national Afghan Resettlement Programme, which offers relocation and resettlement to Afghan citizens, and their immediate family, who worked for or with the UK government to support the UK mission in Afghanistan [and] are considered vulnerable or in danger from the Taliban.'
MoD documents also referred to the summer riots of 2024, in which asylum seekers and Muslims were targeted, and which were described by officials as 'the worst outbreak of racial violence in the UK for decades'.
Officials noted that 15 of the 20 primary disorder hotspots were in the top 20 per cent of local authorities with high numbers of supported asylum seekers and Afghan resettlement arrivals. They said that 'this underlines the importance of mainstreaming community cohesion considerations throughout our resettlement approach'.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Auto-enrolling young people on voting register being explored
Auto-enrolling young people on voting register being explored

The Independent

time4 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Auto-enrolling young people on voting register being explored

Young people could be automatically enrolled on the voting register under plans being explored by the Government, a minister has told Parliament. Labour former minister Lord Beamish argued 'the only way we're going to get young people and other people on the registry is auto-enrolment'. Responding, communities minister Lord Khan of Burnley said the Government will 'take steps to move towards' this, but added that electoral law is 'complicated'. 'We intend to actively explore and test new and more automated methods of registration, including better use of data to identify people who are eligible, and integration with other Government services to make it easier for people to register,' he had earlier told the upper chamber. The minister also revealed the Government is 'looking at' placing 16 and 17-year-olds on the electoral register at the same time they are given their national insurance numbers. This came in response to Liberal Democrat peer Lord Rennard, who said: 'Will the Government now implement the unanimous cross-party recommendation of the House of Lords select committee and automatically include 16 and 17-year-olds on the electoral registers at the same time as they are given their national insurance numbers?' Lord Khan replied: 'This is a major change in the electoral franchise, and we need to get it right. Changes to the electoral law of this magnitude require careful planning and should not be rushed. 'On the question in relation to national insurance, we are looking at different options for ensuring young people can be easily and accurately registered to vote, and ways to enable people to register when they interact with other government services. 'So the (Lord Rennard) keeps pushing. I'm going to give (Lord Rennard) good news … to say we are looking at that as well.' Plaid Cymru peer Baroness Smith of Llanfaes called for a national register to vote day for schools. She said: 'Will this Government consider a national register to vote day for schools, where young people are encouraged to register to vote online in their registration classes?' Lord Khan said this was 'a very strong point, and I will take that away'. He added: 'We'll take all measures to ensure that we can (to) make sure people can participate comfortably and positively.'

Tesla sees European sales collapse by one-third after boss Elon Musk stirs up controversy and suffers EV subsidies blow
Tesla sees European sales collapse by one-third after boss Elon Musk stirs up controversy and suffers EV subsidies blow

Daily Mail​

time5 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Tesla sees European sales collapse by one-third after boss Elon Musk stirs up controversy and suffers EV subsidies blow

Tesla has seen its European sales collapse by one-third this year as the carmaker's boss Elon Musk stirs up controversy across the Continent. Figures published by the European Automobile Manufacturers Association (ACEA) showed Tesla sold 109,879 vehicles in Europe between January and June. This was down 33 per cent from the 164,569 vehicles it sold over the same period in 2024 across the EU, EFTA countries and the UK. Mr Musk, the world's richest man, has been blamed for making Tesla unpopular in Europe due to his political interventions. He previously allied himself to US President Donald Trump - prior to a dramatic falling-out - and has regularly championed Europe's far-right political parties. The South African-born billionaire has voiced support for Alternative for Germany (AfD) and National Rally, led by Marine Le Pen, in France. Mr Musk has also involved himself in British politics and launched a barrage of attacks on Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer over issues such as grooming gangs. He briefly flirted with donating some of his vast riches to Reform UK, but later publicly told party leader Nigel Farage he 'doesn't have what it takes'. In the US, Mr Musk and Tesla have suffered a blow after Mr Trump scrapped tax credits that lowered the cost of electric vehicles in America. Despite having thrown his support behind Mr Trump's election campaign last year, Mr Musk has since dramatically turned on the US President. He has been a fierce critic of Mr Trump's 'Big Beautiful Bill', which slashed the electric vehicle support, and also the US President's imposition of trade tariffs. Mr Musk also last month claimed Mr Trump appeared in files relating to the disgraced paedophile financier Jeffrey Epstein. Mr Trump is under increasing pressure from his own supporters to deliver on a campaign promise to release all files related to Epstein. The US President has accused his voters of falling for what he called a 'radical left' hoax by his opponents to discredit him. Tesla shares slumped in pre-market trading in the US on Thursday after Mr Musk warned of a 'few rough quarters' ahead for the vehicle manufacturer. As well as a backlash to Mr Musk's political views and cuts to electric vehicle support in the US, Tesla is facing increasing competition from low-cost rivals in China. Daniel Binns, global CEO at brand consultancy Elmwood, said: 'Musk is the face of Tesla, and for many people, the brand can't exist outside of his influence. 'So, when his credibility and trust decline, so does the equity of the Tesla brand. 'In parallel, we've seen the EV market rapidly mature and Tesla is no longer the shining star.'

'No plans' for bank holiday if England win Euros
'No plans' for bank holiday if England win Euros

BBC News

time5 minutes ago

  • BBC News

'No plans' for bank holiday if England win Euros

There are "no plans" for an extra bank holiday should England win Euro 2025, says the prime minister's Minister Sir Keir Starmer called the team "an inspiration to the nation" after their dramatic extra-time victory over Italy in the semi-finals on will face Spain in the final on Sunday, with a 17:00 BST licensing hours will be extended to 01:00 BST after the match for those wishing to celebrate there and the government said the Lionesses would be celebrated on their return - no matter the the Liberal Democrats have called for the government to mark "the talent, success and historic achievement" of the team by granting a public bank holiday. Their culture, media and sport spokesperson Max Wilkinson told BBC Sport: "Fans and patriots across the country deserve the chance to celebrate the talent, success and historic achievement of this amazing team."A bank holiday would also give our hospitality industry a much-needed assist and boost."There was no bank holiday when England won the Euros for the first time in 2022. Starmer - then leader of the opposition - backed the calls, proposing a "proper day of celebration".He repeated that belief when England reached the World Cup final in 2023, writing on X that "there should be a celebratory bank holiday if the Lionesses bring it home".BBC Sport asked the government to respond to that apparent change of stance, but they did not wish to comment further. This article is the latest from BBC Sport's Ask Me Anything team. What is Ask Me Anything? Ask Me Anything is a service dedicated to answering your want to reward your time by telling you things you do not know and reminding you of things you team will find out everything you need to know and be able to call upon a network of contacts including our experts and will be answering your questions from the heart of the BBC Sport newsroom, and going behind the scenes at some of the world's biggest sporting coverage will span the BBC Sport website, app, social media and YouTube accounts, plus BBC TV and radio. More questions answered... From ball girl to England hero - who is rising star Agyemang?When will the WSL fixtures be released?Why did Norway get a penalty when Hegerberg was offside?

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store