Creeslough: Planning permission refused for petrol station site of explosion in which 10 people died
An Coimisiún Pleanála
has overturned a grant of planning permission for a new filling station on the site of the explosion in
Creeslough
, Co Donegal, in which 10 people died.
Donegal County Council granted permission in February to Vivo Shell Limited to redevelop a service station and shop at the site.
The decision was appealed by a number of family members of those killed in the October 2022 blast.
An Coimisiún Pleanála on Friday turned down the application.
READ MORE
The planning authority said the proposed plan was 'out of character' with its surroundings in the village.
The body said 'Having regard to the existing character and the prevailing pattern of development in Creeslough, it is considered that the proposed development (as amended), by reason of its overall architectural treatment, scale and design, would be out of character with its surroundings, would seriously detract from the architectural character and setting of Creeslough and the streetscape and approach from Letterkenny generally.'
The authority said the proposed development would be contrary to the County Development Plan.
'To permit the proposed scheme (as amended) at this prominent location could have such a negative effect on the visual amenity and local character of Creeslough as to negatively impact on the wider, long-term regeneration and renewal of the village.
[
Creeslough: 'I can't get my head around how a site can be built on when there's a criminal investigation'
Opens in new window
]
'The proposed development would, therefore, seriously injure the visual amenities of the area and the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.'
The proposed rebuild had allowed for the demolition of the existing building and the construction of a new structure that includes a shop, post office, deli, off-licence, and fuel forecourt.
A memorial garden and light-based sculpture with 10 metal poles commemorating those who perished in the tragedy was also planned for the site.
Many of the families who lost loved ones in the tragedy, however, said this was an insult to their memory considering they died in the metal and rubble of the blast.
One bereaved family member said: 'This is terrific news. When we got the news yesterday that there
would not be an oral hearing
we were so disappointed and feared the worst.
'We simply do not want a new service station on the site in which our loved ones died.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
29 minutes ago
- Irish Times
SuperValu expands into pet cover in bid to be ‘one-stop shop' for insurance
SuperValu Insurance is expanding into the pet market in an attempt to become a 'one-stop shop' for customers' cover as part of a strategic expansion of its insurance division. 'There are about 500,000 pet insurance policies in the country,' said Garry O'Sullivan, head of SuperValu Insurance , 'but that only covers about 30 per cent of the number of pets that are owned in Ireland'. He noted a '70 per cent gap in pet owners that don't have insurance ' with the numbers taking out policies having grown following the Covid-19 pandemic. He said the small number of pet insurance providers in the sector allows SuperValu to 'give an extra choice to consumers'. SuperValu Insurance has partnered with global insurer Cover-More, with whom, Mr O'Sullivan said, they have 'tried to negotiate the best deals we can', which has allowed them to 'bring a best product to market'. READ MORE The company is expecting the launch of pet insurance to increase its overall insurance policies by about 1,000 in its first year, adding to an existing customer base of about 60,000 following 'incremental growth year on year'. The retailer's pet insurance offering will include lifetime cover for pets and vet fee cover for pets of up to €6,000, which SuperValu said is the 'highest level of veterinary cover currently available in the Irish market'. [ Pet insurance: Why owners must pay a price for peace of mind Opens in new window ] Mr O'Sullivan said bills for family pets 'can run up quite sizeably year on year' in cases where ongoing medical care is required. 'We cover all of that, so our product is well positioned to serve our customer,' he said. SuperValu launched its first insurance policies, travel cover, in October 2014 before later expanding into car and home insurance in May 2015. SuperValu made life and mortgage protection cover available last year and also offers a specialist learner driver insurance package. 'We want to be the one-stop shop for customers' insurance,' said Mr O'Sullivan. [ Pet insurance could save you a fortune, so know your options to care for your furry friend Opens in new window ] He said SuperValu 'will always look at opportunities to expand' into new insurance sectors based on interest from the customer base. He did not comment on what specific sectors it is considering but said the company will be 'exploring other avenues in 2026 and 2027″. As with all SuperValu insurance coverage, customers will be given a €40 shopping voucher when a new policy is purchased, which Mr O'Sullivan said is a reward for customer's loyalty to the brand. The cover will go beyond injury or illness and also provide access to a lost-and-found pet reward service. Cover-More Europe's chief product officer, Jason Whelan, said the underwriter is 'excited to work with SuperValu Insurance to ensure their customers have access to lifetime cover for their cherished pets'.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on trade and tax: the rules-based system is breaking down
As a small country, Ireland is best served by a stable international economic backdrop and a rules-based system governing areas such as trade and taxation. Unfortunately, the key institutions overseeing the international economic system are now under heavy pressure, as Donald Trump pursues his nationalistic economic agenda. The most recent demonstration of this came in recent days as the other G7 countries acceded to a US demand to rewrite a part of the global corporate tax deal that took years to put together under the aegis of the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD). The entire deal is now weakened and may even crumble completely. The issue for the US was a part of the agreement which would have allowed other countries, including Ireland, to collect top-up tax from American multinationals who were judged not to have paid the minimum rate of 15 per cent elsewhere. Washington saw this as an infringement of US tax sovereignty. The same issue lies behind new trade tensions between the US and Canada, What is notable is that the G7 countries agreed to unpick the agreement to meet the US demands, as was announced on social media by US treasury secretary, Scott Bessent. The other 140 plus countries who negotiated and signed the agreement are yet to be consulted. The big players are calling the shots. READ MORE In return, the US administration is asking Congress to withdraw a part of the new budget bill which would have given the US the power to levy punitive taxes on investors and companies from countries who were judged to be treating US firms unfairly. As in the field of trade, US threats are being met by significant concessions. The OECD's status as a mediator of the corporate tax deal has been undermined and the future of the whole agreement is now in serious doubt. In the same way, the World Trade Organisation looks on powerlessly as the rules of international trade are torn up. In this context, the suggestion last week from Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission president, that the EU investigates a new regime with a group of Asian countries who are part of a trade bloc – which the UK has also joined – was ill-judged to say the least. This new dominance by the big players and the tearing up of existing rules is worrying for Ireland. The previous government had hoped that by signing up to the OECD tax deal the controversy over the Irish system would be put to bed and there would be no further demands for change. Now this is all back in the melting pot. Meanwhile, Ireland has thrived under the rules-based trade system which brings certainty to those exporting from this country, whether multinationals or domestic businesses. Ireland needs to stick close to the EU to make it case and hope that Europe can find its voice on these issues more effectively than it has to date.
Irish Times
18 hours ago
- Irish Times
Is it worth my while to give half my inheritance to my husband to avoid tax?
I just want to confirm my understanding of the position around deed of variation/family arrangement with wills in Ireland. I am due to inherit €30,000 from my brother-in-law and I am wondering if it is worth my while to gift my husband half, in order to avoid tax ? Ms C.L. When someone draws up a will, they generally have two things in mind. First, they want to take care of those closest and dearest to them; second, they want to minimise how much of their estate gets taken in tax. READ MORE There's an industry of lawyers and tax advisers making a very good living servicing this demand – as evidenced by last week's article about wealthy individuals in Ireland buying farmland to avail of an inheritance tax loophole while it lasts. This can be a game of cat and mouse. New reliefs are introduced, advisers notice they can be used entirely legitimately but not in the way the Government originally intended to benefit their (generally) wealthy clients and, over time, amendments are brought in to try to restore the measure to its original purpose. But what you are talking about is a much longer established structure called a deed of variation, otherwise known as a deed of family arrangement. Anyone who has been in the UK might be more familiar with it as, in that jurisdiction, it can be a very useful way of effectively rewriting someone's will – at least in relation to any inheritance you are in line to receive – to take account of changed circumstances, such as the arrival of children, grandchildren or in-laws since the will was originally drafted. It can also be used in intestacy where the absence of a will might mean, for instance, that a cohabiting partner could otherwise be left with nothing. [ Wills and spouses: Why you cannot just cut a wife out of your will Opens in new window ] In the UK, such a deed of variation must be in writing and must be signed within two years of the original benefactor dying. One of the advantages is that rather than being seen as you inheriting and then passing some of that benefit onwards, the benefit you allocate to anyone else under such a deed is considered as coming to them directly from the person who has died. So what does that mean for you? Well, while there is a lot of similarity between the law here and in the UK due to our shared heritage, there are some significant differences too, not least in relation to inheritance. For instance, while, in the UK, the tax liability is on the estate of the dead person, in Ireland, the liability rests with the individual beneficiaries depending on the amount involved and the beneficiary's relationship with the dead person. In-laws are considered as 'strangers' in terms of inheritance. As such, they come under the lowest category C tax-free threshold And there is a key difference of approach also when it comes to deeds of variation. While there is nothing stopping you exercising a deed of variation to gift your husband half of what you are inheriting from your brother-in-law, it will have no impact on your tax liability. In Ireland, as Revenue has confirmed for me, as far as liability for Capital Acquisitions Tax (CAT or inheritance tax) is concerned, you will be considered to have taken the full €30,000 inheritance from your brother-in-law with your husband being seen as taking a subsequent €15,000 gift from you. Now, in practical terms, that raises no tax bill for your husband as gifts and inheritances between spouses are exempt from inheritance. But it could have tax implications for the recipient of your largesse if you were looking to have a friend benefit, for instance. And it does mean you will face a tax bill. In-laws are considered as 'strangers' in terms of inheritance. As such, they come under the lowest category C tax-free threshold – currently €20,000. So you will face a 33 per cent tax bill on at least €10,000 of this inheritance – €3,300. It could be more if, as would not be unusual, you previously received an inheritance – or, indeed a gift of more than €3,000 in one year – from a friend, in-law, cousin or more distant relation. They all come under category C and that €20,000 tax-free limit is a lifetime one extending back to cover any inheritance or large gift received since December 5th, 1991. That leaves you with two choices: you can accept the inheritance and pay the tax due on anything over your tax-free threshold, or you can disclaim the inheritance. However, that second option is an all or nothing one. You cannot just disclaim €10,000 of the €30,000 so that you stay within your tax-free limit. You will be giving all of it up. Nor have you any right, if you disclaim, to influence where the inheritance goes. That will be determined by the wording of the will. The money would most likely go to other beneficiaries under a residuary clause – a clause governing the distribution of any assets not specifically allocated to any person or institution. The bottom line is that, if the intention is to reduce your tax bill, a deed of variation will not do it and, of course, you will have incurred legal costs in getting advice on and drawing up any such deed. Please send your queries to Dominic Coyle, Q&A, The Irish Times, 24-28 Tara Street Dublin 2, or by email to with a contact phone number. This column is a reader service and is not intended to replace professional advice
