Ford promises mining projects won't proceed without First Nations consultation after backlash
The meeting follows weeks of growing resistance to Bill 5, with First Nations leaders saying it was passed without meaningful consultation and warning the law violates treaty rights. Some have signalled potential blockades of roads, railways and mining sites if the province proceeds.
Ford had warned such actions would not be 'wise,' saying, 'They need to move on or they'll be dealt with appropriately,' but following his meeting, his tone shifted significantly.
In a joint press conference on Thursday with First Nations leaders, Ford said the meeting with the chiefs was 'productive' and added that critical mineral development — a key part of Ontario's economic strategy — cannot happen without partnership with Indigenous communities.
'Nothing moves without First Nations consultation — respecting the duty to consult and making sure we work together,' Ford said. 'We're going to get through this, and we're going to have a great collaboration.'
First Nations leaders who attended the meeting said the premier's apology was welcome, but did not change their position. 'Our nations remain opposed to Bill 5,' said Grand Council Chief Linda Debassige of the Anishinabek Nation. 'This was not a consultation — it was our first conversation.'
Ford also intends to visit First Nations communities to hear their needs directly — whether related to water, long-term care, or infrastructure. 'When First Nations prosper, Ontario prospers,' he said. 'And when Ontario prospers, Canada prospers.'
After meeting with 39 Anishinabek Nation chiefs, Ontario Premier Doug Ford reversed his position and pledged that no mining or development projects in First Nations communities will move forward without their consultation.
Ford also apologized for remarks he made on Wednesday, when he said First Nations were coming 'hat-in-hand' for money from his government while rejecting resource development.
At the heart of the legislation is a provision that allows the provincial cabinet to create 'special economic zones,' where selected projects and developers could be exempt from environmental regulations and planning laws — undermining First Nations consultation. The government has already signalled its intent to designate the Ring of Fire as a 'special economic zone' under the new law.
Tools for consultation
Debassige said the meeting focused on broader treaty responsibilities, but not on the legislative substance of the bill. 'Our First Nations have said, and continue to say, that we are not opposed to development; however, it must be done with us as true partners.'
She added that the Ontario government has now officially recognized that lands and resources are not theirs to give, exploit or regulate as economic corridors.
Laura Bowman, a lawyer with Ecojustice, says the Ford government's approach to consultation under Bill 5 falls far short of constitutional obligations. 'You can't fulfill the duty to consult after removing the tools needed to do it,' she said. 'The duty to consult requires more than just meetings … It requires information-sharing, clear regulatory frameworks and enforceable mechanisms to accommodate First Nations' rights.'
Bowman says by exempting certain projects from environmental assessments and planning laws, the province is depriving First Nations of critical information — such as how development may affect local wildlife, water or culturally significant lands — and removing the legal tools needed to negotiate protections or alternatives.
'The government has passed a law without telling communities how it will be used, what projects will be exempt or what safeguards will remain,' she said. 'That's not consultation — that's bypassing the entire process.'
Bowman told Canada's National Observer the province needs to change the special economic zone provision of the bill to include clear rules for consent, environmental oversight and real engagement.
Sara Mainville, an Anishinaabe lawyer, said many First Nations are exploring legal avenues to challenge the bill.
'Right now, the idea that we should just trust them is a non-starter for First Nations,' she said. 'There's no trust right now.'
NDP MPP: 'We are not stakeholders. We are treaty partners.'
Sol Mamakwa, the NDP MPP for Kiiwetinoong and the only First Nations member of the Ontario Legislature, said Ford's change in tone is welcome — but not enough.
'The premier seems to have realized that this can't move forward without First Nations,' Mamakwa said. 'But let's be clear — this wasn't consultation. And we're not stakeholders. We're treaty partners.'
Mamakwa told Canada's National Observer Bill 5 backs Indigenous communities 'into a corner' and warned that the only recourse left may be legal or direct action. 'If we're not part of the decision-making from the start, it's not reconciliation. It's just politics.'
Mainville told Canada's National Observer the government must be transparent about how it plans to fulfill its constitutional duty to consult First Nations and Métis peoples — especially since Bill 5 exempts major projects from key legislation that would normally trigger such consultation.
'Without a clear regulatory path, what's left is political promises,' she said, 'and First Nations have seen how those can shift.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
4 hours ago
- National Observer
College adds programs for nuclear workers to meet expected demand
Humber Polytechnic is partnering with the Canadian Nuclear Association (CNA) to help train the next generation of nuclear workers. This comes as the Ford government invests billions in nuclear energy — including large-scale refurbishments and new small modular reactors (SMRs), the first of which is already under construction at Darlington and is expected to be running by 2029. In an interview with Canada's National Observer, Francis Syms, associate dean at Humber's faculty of applied sciences and technology, said the country faces an urgent talent crunch. 'Canada is going to run out of energy by 2040 if we don't do something about it — and nuclear is one option to help fill that gap,' Syms said. 'We expect to build another 10 to 15 nuclear reactors over the next 20 to 25 years, and that means tens of thousands of new jobs.' That's why training more nuclear workers is becoming urgent, Syms said. He expects the roles will mostly be in skilled trades and applied sectors like artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, welding, and reactor operations — areas where colleges and polytechnics like Humber play a big role. As Canada grows its nuclear energy sector — with Ontario massively expanding its nuclear capacity — experts say the country will need up to 30,000 new skilled workers over the next two decades. And nearly 30 per cent of today's nuclear workforce are over the age of 50, many are expected to retire soon. As Canada grows its nuclear energy sector — with Ontario massively expanding its nuclear capacity — experts say the country will need up to 30,000 new skilled workers over the next two decades. Currently, Canada's nuclear industry employs approximately 89,000 people, an increase of 17 per cent over the past five years. With 89 per cent of jobs classified as high-skill, replacing retiring workers won't be easy, Syms added. The partnership includes creating nuclear-specific academic credentials, supporting applied research, and fostering experiential learning, in collaboration with First Nations, government and industry. 'This collaboration represents an important step forward for the nuclear industry as a whole,' said George Christidis, president and CEO of CNA, in a statement. 'By working together to help build a highly skilled workforce, we're not only supporting the success of future nuclear projects, but also helping to ensure Canada remains a global leader in nuclear technology development.' Syms said Humber is also helping build a national network of colleges and polytechnics to support nuclear training across the country. 'Whether you're a welder in Alberta or a student in Ontario, you should be able to access nuclear workforce pathways — ideally without having to leave your community.' He added nuclear training must include Indigenous knowledge and leadership, especially for projects in those communities. Humber is also working with international partners, including the Philippines, Romania, Japan, and South Korea. Syms said the goal is to make Canadian-developed training programs adaptable for global use while staying focused on Canada's energy needs. 'This is a nation-building effort,' Syms said. 'It's not just about jobs. It's about keeping the lights on, reducing emissions, and building economic and energy sovereignty.' Demand is rising, so is enrolment Canada has abundant uranium and a long history of generating electricity with nuclear power since the early 1960s. Seventeen reactors in three provinces currently produce about 15 per cent of the country's electricity, with most located in Ontario. The province has long depended on nuclear power, which supplies more than 50 per cent of the province's electricity. The Ford government says new investments in nuclear power will create tens of thousands of jobs in the sector and help meet growing electricity demand, which is expected to rise 75 per cent by 2050. But critics warn the plan misses key opportunities to scale up renewables, puts energy affordability at risk, and increases Ontario's dependence on foreign energy supplies. The federal government is investing hundreds of millions in SMRs and sees nuclear power as a key part of a diverse, sustainable energy mix. It says, when properly managed, nuclear power can meet current and future energy needs while supporting climate goals. As nuclear investments ramp up, so does interest from students. Syms said Humber has seen increasing enrolment in nuclear-related programs, and graduates are already landing jobs at companies like Bruce Power and Ontario Power Generation. The industry is also hiring for roles in data, AI and cyber defence — not just trade, he added. Syms said with Ontario and the federal government pouring billions into nuclear energy, the real challenge isn't building the reactors — it's making sure Canada has enough trained people to run them. 'As we look to meet our country's growing energy needs, the demand for skilled professionals in the nuclear sector has never been greater,' said Ann Marie Vaughan, Humber president and CEO. 'Together, we are preparing a new wave of nuclear talent who will lead with technical excellence and expertise while championing innovation for a sustainable future.'
National Observer
4 hours ago
- National Observer
National power grid needed to fend off Trump and build clean economy: advocates
Days after Mark Carney's Liberal government passed its controversial major projects legislation that allows it to bypass environmental laws and Indigenous consultation, more than 100 organizations across Canada are calling for a nation-building project that might begin to rebuild goodwill with those offended by Bill C-5. In an open letter published Thursday, the 105 environmental, labour, Indigenous and community groups urge federal officials to fund an east-west power grid that prioritizes renewable energy, Indigenous and community ownership and energy efficiency as 'key projects in the national interest.' 'Better integrating Canada's electricity system is crucially important for energy security and economic competitiveness in the near term, but it is also a no-regret investment for the long-term prosperity of everyone living in Canada,' the letter reads. Upgrading power grids could create more than 300,000 jobs over the next 25 years, it adds. A national power grid mega-project could also drive clean economic growth, and if materials like aluminum and steel are procured in Canada, it could also support those sectors under pressure from US tariffs, advocates say. The groups argue that federal leadership is required to pull off a project of this scale due to challenges related to permitting, funding and interprovincial trade barriers. A study published in the Osgoode Hall Law Journal in 2022, found that more interprovincial transmission lines could boost interprovincial trade of renewable power by connecting privately owned wind, solar and other power sources to more customers. The Liberals' 2025 platform included a commitment to build out an east-west electricity grid. The platform explicitly says the project will be developed with provinces, territories, Indigenous partners and stakeholders and 'will unleash clean growth across the country.' The Prime Minister's Office did not return a request for comment. A national power grid mega-project could also drive clean economic growth, and if materials like aluminum and steel are procured in Canada, it could also support those sectors under pressure from US tariffs, advocates say. A coast-to-coast high voltage direct current (HVDC) line could be built in under five years, at a cost of roughly $24 billion, according to a study from the David Suzuki Foundation — $10 billion less than the recently completed Trans Mountain expansion project. 'Building an east-west electricity grid across Canada is a huge opportunity that will improve our energy security and create thousands of jobs,' said Stephen Thomas, clean energy manager with the David Suzuki Foundation, in a statement. 'With demand for power going up, our electricity system needs to be powered by renewable energy, not fossil fuels. 'A renewable-backed electricity grid will lower people's energy bills while limiting environmental harm and pollution.' A briefing note prepared for a meeting between federal and Ontario officials in December that Canada's National Observer received through a federal access to information request describes the process leading up to the federal clean electricity regulations. The document notes that Environment and Climate Change Canada 'made significant changes to relax the regulations in the final design,' following 'substantial stakeholder feedback.' Those relaxed regulations, published in December, allow fossil fuels to be used to generate electricity as far into the future as 2050, despite originally intending to be net-zero by 2035. The rules will still push provinces and utilities to transition to clean electricity — a widely recognized prerequisite to decarbonize other sectors like transportation, buildings and heavy industry — but 'flexibilities' to allow gas-fired power plants to operate well past 2035 are now baked into the country's decarbonization efforts. The 105 groups behind Thursday's letter want the federal government to achieve a net-zero power grid by updating Canada's electricity strategy. They also call for upholding legal rights for Indigenous communities, including the right to free, prior and informed consent; labour supports like prevailing wage requirements and training capacity; and upgrades to both transmission and generation in line with affordable, reliable, clean electricity. Last year, then-energy and natural resources minister Jonathan Wilkinson told Canada's National Observer that some provinces were eager to collaborate on expanding the power grid — with the notable exceptions of Alberta and Saskatchewan. Even though a nationwide grid has long been discussed, a likely starting point is strengthening regional tie-ins between provinces with significant hydro resources and those still reliant on fossil fuels to better manage supply and demand. A bit of geographic luck has already positioned Canada relatively well for this approach. Each province that still depends on burning coal, oil or gas to generate electricity has a neighbour with hydropower that can lend a hand. Some like British Columbia, Manitoba, Quebec and Newfoundland and Labrador have massive hydro resources, while others like Alberta, Saskatchewan, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia still rely on fossil fuels.
Global News
12 hours ago
- Global News
Second candidate joins BC Greens leadership race
The BC Green Party says a 24-year-old advocate for climate justice and Indigenous solidarity has joined the party's leadership contest. Emily Lowan is the second person to announce their candidacy in the race after Comox town councillor and physician Jonathan Kerr. The candidates are seeking to replace Sonia Furstenau, who had been leader since 2020 but announced she would step down after failing to be re-elected in the last provincial election. 0:33 Comox councillor running for BC Greens leader Lowan says in a news release that her campaign will focus on 'stopping major projects that ignore Indigenous rights, implementing vacancy control, lowering the cost of living, and taxing the ultrarich.' Story continues below advertisement She says those changes would allow the province to invest in affordable housing, free public transit and 'good green jobs.' Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The party says it will release the names of other contestants in the coming days. It says a town hall will be held in August before a contestant debate in September. Voting by party members will run from Sept. 13 to 23, with the results to be announced on Sept. 24.
