Cost blowout renews call to scrap council's Akaroa wastewater plans
Photo:
Supplied/Christchurch City Council
A Banks Peninsula residents' group has renewed calls to scrap council plans for a wastewater plant in the Akaroa township, following a cost blowout of more than $70 million.
Under the Christchurch City Council
proposal
, the existing sewage plant would be relocated and treated wastewater discharged onto farmland and native plants at Hammond Point and Robinson's Bay, instead of into the harbour.
For more than 60 years, Akaroa's sewage has been treated and discharged into the sea at the bottom of the culturally significant Takapūneke Reserve.
The new scheme was initially budgeted at $94 million, but that figure has ballooned to $167.3 million.
The council was also exploring an alternative discharge option of sending treated wastewater directly into the ocean, instead of first irrigating it through land, but this would still cost $148.7 million.
Friends of Banks Peninsula deputy chair Suky Thompson said the council's plan was flawed and she was not surprised the cost had blown out.
"Our geotechnical engineer at the [resource consent] hearings recommended that much more geotechnical assessment was needed prior to putting this whole proposal up for a consent," she said.
"Twenty million dollars of that blowout is to carry out more geotechnical work on the site proposed for the treatment plant, but we think it will still blow out further because much of the steep land which the council proposes to irrigate to saturation hasn't had any geotechnical assessment."
Thompson said the proposal did not address Akaroa's leaky pipes.
"Our concern is that the amount of wastewater going through the system is largely determined by the poor quality of these sewer pipes in Akaroa, so it's infiltrated by an enormous amount of stormwater.
"That means that at times when it's the most wet, when the land is soggy, that's when there's also the most water running through the system so then it has to be stored in enormous storage tanks and the council is planning to irrigate right through winter keeping the land at saturated level which is not suitable for the steep, slip-prone slopes of Banks Peninsula.
"In our view it's time for the council to start being more realistic about what it can afford for such a small place as Akaroa -there's less than 1000 sewer connections going into the system."
Thompson said the money would be better used overhauling the town's sewerage network. She believed the alternative option of discharging treated wastewater into the ocean would be met with more approval in Akaroa.
"It would be much less intrusive to develop, it would be much more resilient going forward, so it's about the detail it's about the treatment standard that would be put in."
Photo:
SUPPLIED
The council said the ocean discharging option would see a 15-16km wastewater pipeline running on the Akaroa Harbour floor, and wastewater discharged one to two kilometres beyond the harbour heads.
"The staff update showed operational costs of the ocean outfall would be approximately $380,000 per year, compared to $625,000 per year for land irrigation. Operational and construction risks were outlined, including challenges in identifying leaks and the limited options available for repairs. Staff also repeated their understanding that this option is repugnant to mana whenua.
Council head of three waters Gavin Hutchison said even though work was underway on investigating alternatives, no recommendations on a preferred future option would be made until the
government's law changes
around mandatory wastewater standards for discharge to water, land and overflows were implemented and the views of mana whenua sought.
"Having this information will help further inform potential future steps for the current application process. However, regardless of what the new standards permit, we still have a duty to consult under the Local Government Act and consider cultural and community impacts of any preferred option.
"Once we have an understanding of the impacts of the new wastewater standards, and have done further work, we expect to be able to brief the elected council on a preferred option for the future scheme in early 2026."
Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu declined RNZ's interview request.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
A-Z of Aotearoa: C is for Charles Upham
This is our sometimes-regular segment The A-Z of Aotearoa. So far we've covered Aviation & Billy T, so we're up to the letter C. Today we're looking at Captain Charles Hazlitt Upham, the Canterbury man who is New Zealand's most decorated soldier. For his efforts in WW2 he was awarded not one, but two Victoria Crosses, also known as the "VC" and "Bar". He was one of only three people world-wide to achieve the honour, and the only combat soldier.
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
Boats barred from mooring at Little Barrier Island after caulerpa discovery
Caulerpa covers rocks in Okipu Bay, on Great Barrier Island. Photo: Luka Forman All anchoring around Auckland's Little Barrier Island in the Hauraki Gulf has been stopped immediately after an invasive seaweed was discovered. Caulerpa has spread across northern New Zealand since it was first discovered four years ago. Biosecurity New Zealand's director of pest management John Walsh said the discovery of patches of the weed on the north and east coasts of the island was disappointing. The ban, known as a Controlled Area Notice or CAN, is to stop its spread further. He said the weed could be inadvertently moved when small pieces were caught on anchors, anchor chains, and fishing/dive equipment. Ngāti Manuhiri is placing a rāhui over the area. Meanwhile, Local Democracy Reporting reported the government was throwing more than $6 million at developing world-first industrial-scale technology to fight caulerpa as it was confirmed in the Bay of Islands for the first time earlier this year. It was found at six sites, Northland Regional Council confirmed in March. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
16 hours ago
- RNZ News
Gloriavale school fails second ERO audit
The Gloriavale compound on the West Coast. Photo: RNZ / Jean Edwards A private school run by the Gloriavale Christian community has failed an audit for the second time in as many years . The Education Review Office said in a report published on Wednesday that its review visit at the end of 2024 found the school had improved since a 2023 review , but it still failed three of eight registration criteria. It said the school did not provide suitable staffing for students with complex additional needs, suitable equipment for students with complex additional needs, or a physically and emotionally safe space. "At the time of the ERO onsite review phase, the school was supporting an enrolled student with extremely high and very complex needs that impact on full onsite engagement within the classroom," the report said. "An overarching goal of supporting full attendance and achievement at school is in place within the limitations of the school's isolation, the wishes of family and the severity of the complex needs." It said enrolled students with high and complex needs could not attend because there was insufficient equipment to support those needs. The report said about 40 percent of the 224 school-aged children in the Gloriavale community attended the school, while about half were home-schooled and the remainder were enrolled with Te Kura (formerly the Correspondence School). "Education provision in the Gloriavale Christian School is slowly improving. The school board and staff have worked extensively with board-contracted external support and Ministry of Education advice and guidance to develop capacity to provide high quality learning and teaching," the report said. The report said most children in home-schooling were taught "at least as regularly and well as in a registered school" and students studying through Te Kura felt well supported. The community's preschool was working towards fully implementing quality systems, processes and practices to enable the delivery of a responsive curriculum for all children. However, the report said "access to education across the community is inequitable" and course and NCEA choices were limited. "ERO is not yet assured that all learners' physical and emotional health and safety is closely, regularly and sufficiently considered and monitored across all schooling provisions. The inconsistent application of some policies and procedures poses risk to children given a history of unsafe practices within the Gloriavale community," the report said. It said the Teaching Council was investigating an allegation of staff misconduct and the school had been instructed to formally monitor the staff member. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
