Humans in the Loop explores how AI clashes with traditional belief systems
When Humans in the Loop's protagonist Nehma, a tribal data labeller at a centre in Jharkhand, is pulled up by her supervisor, she stands her ground and clarifies that the 'insect', which their Western client want to be labelled as a 'pest', is the one that protects the ecosystem by consuming rotten leaves. Nehma argues: 'AI is like a child. If you teach it wrong things, it will pick up those.' As the world is increasingly getting impacted by artificial intelligence (AI), Nehma represents traditional wisdom, rooted in nature.
Humans in the Loop, written and directed by Aranya Sahay, is a Hindi and Kurukh language movie that follows Nehma (essayed by Sonal Madhushankar), whose job at a data centre in a remote area in Jharkhand involves labelling data to train AI models. Nehma takes up this job after returning to her village with her daughter Dhaanu and toddler son Guntu following her separation from her husband. As part of her 'data labelling' job, she learns to tag images to help algorithms distinguish objects.
Even as Nehma struggles to learn the ropes of her job, the movie also highlights her internal conflict. Living close to a forest, she tries to reconnect with her tribal roots and nature. However, the differences between Nehma and Dhaanu seem to grow as the latter misses the comforts and ways of an urban life.
The movie is inspired by data labelling, which is carried out in certain indigenous regions of Jharkhand, West Bengal, Rajasthan and Telangana. Major AI firms outsource such tasks to remote regions of India, where labour is cheap. As the narrative unfolds, the feature also explores 'how human prejudices' are fed into AI systems and 'the unacknowledged consequences' for communities excluded from the tech revolution. The movie will be screened during the upcoming Indian Film Festival of Los Angeles and the New York Indian Film Festival.
In 2022, Mumbai -based Sahay came across an article regarding tribal women in Jharkhand working with artificial intelligence as data annotators ('Human Touch' by Karishma Mehrotra published in Fifty Two). He got curious about it since he has been familiar with tribal issues because of his mother Lakshmi Bhatia's work as a sociologist and researcher in tribal regions of India. The Film and Television Institute of India (FTII), Pune graduate saw this as an opportunity to develop a cinematic tale that explores 'the interplay between a traditional society and technologies of the future'.
Following a call by Storiculture, a network of film and content expertise, to develop stories about how technology and society overlap, Sahay worked on developing this story. 'The tribal data labellers go through thousands of photos and videos to make the algorithm understand the difference between something as basic as a chair and a table. This is very similar to the idea of parenting. Like how children learn to differentiate between colours and shapes. That became the central point of this film,' says Sahay, who has directed five short films earlier, including Songs for Babasaheb and Chait.
Before he wrote the screenplay, Sahay spent nearly eight months in Ranchi and villages close to a forest near Jonha falls in Jharkhand. His interactions with Biju Toppo, a national award-winning filmmaker, and his FTII senior Seral Murmu helped him understand that world better. Even though the subject sounds ideal for a documentary, he leaned towards a fictional narrative to make it more layered and engaging.
Though Sahay tried to tap into the talent pools of FTII and National School of Drama to find a suitable tribal actor, he was not successful. 'The entertainment world of Mumbai too is biased towards fair-skin actors,' he says. Then someone suggested Sonal for Nehma's role. Even though she is not a tribal but a Dalit, she seemed perfect, mainly because of her 'evocative gaze'. Sonal, who is from Gadchiroli district in Maharashtra, stayed with the crew for 10 days during the recce in Jharkhand and observed the people there for her role as Nehma.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
13 minutes ago
- Economic Times
She outearned top Bollywood stars, met a Hollywood hearthrob but grandmother's decision led to lonely death
Suraiya was one of the biggest stars of Bollywood's golden era, earning more than legends like Dilip Kumar and Ashok Kumar. A gifted singer and actress, she captivated audiences and even caught the attention of Hollywood icon Gregory Peck, who visited her during a trip to India. Her relationship with actor Dev Anand ended after her grandmother disapproved of their marriage. Suraiya never married, stepped away from films at just 34, and spent the rest of her life in solitude. She died in 2004, remembered as a star who gave up everything but remained unforgettable. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads A Hollywood Encounter That Made Headlines Love, Defiance, and Heartbreak Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Early Exit from Fame and a Lonely End In the golden era of Hindi cinema, when male superstars ruled the industry, Suraiya emerged as a rare female icon who eclipsed even the biggest names of her time. During the late 1940s and early 1950s, she commanded higher fees than legends like Dilip Kumar and Ashok Kumar, earning her the reputation of being the highest-paid actress of her generation. Known for her graceful screen presence and soulful voice, she was referred to as Malika-e-Husn (queen of beauty) and Malika-e-Adakara (queen of acting).Suraiya didn't set out to become an actor. Born in Lahore in 1929 and raised in Bombay, she was introduced to the film world at a young age thanks to her maternal uncle, actor M. Zahoor. She first gained attention as a child singer on All India Radio, which led to her playback debut at the age of 12. Her acting career began by chance when she was cast as young Mumtaz Mahal in the film Taj Mahal (1941). From there, she became a household name with hits like Pyar Ki Jeet (1948), Badi Behen (1949), and Dillagi (1949).In 1952, Suraiya's popularity crossed international borders. When Hollywood director Frank Capra visited India for the first International Film Festival, Suraiya gave him a signed photograph for actor Gregory Peck, whom she deeply admired. Much to her surprise, Peck later visited her home in Mumbai. The two chatted for over an hour, and their meeting became fodder for headlines, with the media fueling speculation about a budding romance. Though the rumors were unfounded, the encounter added a new chapter to Suraiya's already star-studded most talked-about relationship was with Dev Anand, a rising star at the time. Their love story began on a film set and quickly turned serious. Dev Anand even proposed to her, buying a diamond ring despite financial constraints. However, their relationship faced fierce opposition from Suraiya's maternal grandmother due to religious differences. Her grandmother not only rejected the match but went so far as to throw the engagement ring into the sea and demand romantic scenes between the two be removed from Dev Anand's willingness to leave the industry to be with her, Suraiya ultimately ended the relationship. She later admitted she lacked the courage to go against her family, even as she continued to carry the emotional weight of that decision throughout her life. She never breakup with Dev Anand marked a turning point in both her personal and professional life. Her subsequent films underperformed, and despite a brief comeback with Mirza Ghalib (1954)—a role praised even by Jawaharlal Nehru—her film Rustam Sohrab (1964) flopped. Disheartened, Suraiya chose to retire from the industry at just remained away from the limelight and lived with her mother until her passing. After her mother's death, Suraiya became increasingly isolated. She made no public appearances, never returned to playback singing or acting, and stayed out of media attention entirely. She passed away in 2004 at the age of 74 due to chronic health her life ended in solitude, Suraiya's legacy as a pioneer for women in Indian cinema remains unmatched. At a time when few actresses had bargaining power, she stood as a figure of strength and success.
India Today
39 minutes ago
- India Today
Revisiting Umrao Jaan: Why Rekha's musical still resonates with audiences today
Actor Rekha's epic-drama 'Umrao Jaan' (1981) returned to the theatres on June 27, much to the delight of audiences reliving nostalgic memories of yesteryear's Hindi films. From its soulful performances and engaging storytelling to its poetic lyrics, the film truly honours the legacy of the golden era of Indian timeless appeal of the Muzaffar Ali directorial makes it a compelling watch for not just the 80s generation, but even the millennials and Gen Z movie enthusiasts. While there have been many other films on similar themes, here's a look at why 'Umrao Jaan' has aged well and stays relevant even after 44 characters 'Umrao Jaan', based on Mirza Hadi Ruswa's 1899 Urdu novel 'Umrao Jaan Ada', blends realism with poetic storytelling. The film captivates audiences with its music and aesthetics, like a painting exploring all aspects of art. The movie convincingly portrays how the dark past and overwhelming pain of the protagonist doesn't fade her soulful beauty.'Umrao Jaan' neither goes too dark nor too flashy while showing the lives of 19th-century courtesans. However, the heartbreak, social stigma, treachery and greed have been amicably portrayed in the film. Amid all the chaos and unpredictable lives of women, the human connection and empathy among all characters resonates with Umrao, aka Amiran, is a poet at heart, who finds solace in poetry and music even in her misery. Her poetic yearning amid tragedy is a metaphorical testament to her resilience and compassion despite grief and uncertainty. Umrao's relationship with Nawab Sultan (Farooq Shaikh) and her brief yet intense bond with Faiz Ali (Raj Babbar) shows her ability to love and be compassionate irrespective of Mirza (Naseeruddin Shah), Khanum Jaan (Shaukat Kaifi), Husseini (Dina Pathak) and Maulvi Saheb (Gajanan Jagirdar) never lose their human element in the dark world governed by greed. The shades of grey in Mirza, Khanum and Husseini characters are integral to the story's progression rather than glorifying misery or cruelty. Rekha's charm as soul of 'Umrao Jaan'Rekha carries the weight of the film on her shoulders while staying fully committed to the titular character. Her ability to convey emotions without any words showcases her dedication to the craft. The unspoken pain of Umrao, linked to her silence and eyes, gives a vivid image of her inner actor's on-screen chemistry with Shaikh and other co-actors reflects on her efforts to internalise the psyche of the protagonist. Farooq Shaikh, Naseeruddin Shah, Raj Babbar, Shaukat Kaifi, Dina Pathak and Gajanan Jagirdar do a commendable job as the supporting cast. Their screen presence and acting prowess elevate the emotional journey of Umrao and her character Ali's soulful directionAli's direction never loses pace throughout the film. The two-hour, 41-minute movie keeps the audience thoroughly engaged as it never loses its heart. As the story moves forward, one feels completely invested in Umrao's journey. While the uncertainty and grim realities about the courtesan's life don't make for a fairytale, the audiences root for the protagonist to have filmmaker hits the bull's eye by integrating poetry through captivating visuals. Khayyam's music and Shahryar's lyrics play a crucial role in reinforcing the lyrical and tragic elements to the story. Ali's use of music as part of the narrative gives an edge to the character's aspirations, inner conflict, relationships and depiction of Umrao as a passionate lover, soulful poet, forgiving sister and compassionate human adds to the universal theme of the story, making it resonant across decades. The film touches upon every emotion and initiates conversations around relationships and hard-hitting social realities around women's agency and empowerment. Actor Rekha's 'Umrao Jaan' was re-released on June 27. (Credit: Instagram/pvrcinemas_official) An ode to classical music'Umrao Jaan' honours classical Indian music. The evergreen 'Dil cheez kya hai' based on Rag Yaman as well as the melodious 'In ankhon ki masti me', based on Rag Bhairavi is a tribute to Hindustani music's rich legacy. The film's usage of ghazals in order to stay true to Umrao's poetic spirit, brings out the sophistication of India's musical the West takes pride in its music, the musical legacy of India, especially in classic Hindi films, did not get the necessary promotion. However, in the present-day digital age and globalisation of cinema, 'Umrao Jaan' has the potential to resonate with modern-day audiences.'Umrao Jaan' resonates with cinema-goers even today as it conveys human emotions and relationships through the lens of a courtesan. The 19th century social realities of India narrated in the film also introduce views across various generations to the historical advancement of society and of the time period, 'Umrao Jaan' remains a timeless masterpiece which is relevant to students of cinema.- Ends
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Madhoo reacts to why she turned down a film with Amitabh Bachchan and moved to South India: 'It felt odd to return to projects that lacked sincerity'
Madhoo was one of the leading names in Hindi cinema during the early 1990s, but she gradually faded from Bollywood, giving more importance to South Indian films. Her sudden absence from Hindi cinema raised many eyebrows, and some even questioned why she had turned down major films, including those starring . Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Madhoo has now finally responded to her decision to step away from Hindi cinema. Madhoo about leaving Bollywood behind Grateful to Juhi Chawla for introducing me to organic farming: Madhoo Shah In a recent interview with Lehren Retro, the Roja actress admitted that by the late 1990s, she had begun to feel increasingly disconnected from the kind of work she was being offered in Bollywood. 'By 1997, I had started feeling discontented. I wasn't excited about my work anymore. After working with authentic, passionate directors in the South, it felt odd to return to projects that lacked that sincerity. I began sulking before going to sets. The thing I had once desired most — being on a film set — started to irritate me,' she shared. Madhoo about getting married to Anand Shah Madhoo met her future husband, businessman Anand Shah, around the time she was considering leaving the film industry. 'Just when I realised I didn't want to continue with films, love entered my life. I got married, and I walked away from acting completely,' she said. She turned down 'Sooryavansham' with Amitabh Bachchan during that period, and the film later featured as the female lead. Her marriage had been fixed at the time, and she asked her manager to drop the project. Madhoo's Kannappa She was last seen in 'Kannappa', directed by Mukesh Kumar Singh. The film starred Manchu, Mohanlal, Prabhas, Akshay Kumar, , and Preity Mukhundhan in key roles.
