
'Too many unanswered questions' in William Bryant's killing to make NCR ruling, judge says
An Ottawa judge has taken the rare step of asking counsel to expand on and clarify some evidence in the 2023 killing of an Amnesty International worker, and said that without it, she's unable to decide whether the man accused of murder should be found not criminally responsible (NCR) due to mental disorder.
Superior Court Justice Anne London-Weinstein told court last week there are still "too many unanswered questions" about the relationship between the victim and the accused, whether the accused might have known what he did was wrong, and whether he might have had a motive.
She also wants to be assured that a forensic psychiatrist who testified conducted a thorough review, and that the matter wasn't "rushed."
William Bryant, 74, was found dead in the stairwell of an apartment building on May 9, 2023. Ahmed Ismail, now 46, who lived in the building, was charged with second-degree murder.
Crown, defence agree on proposed NCR finding
"To state the obvious, this is a murder trial where a 74-year-old man — who, according to his friends, was a kind and gentle person who tried to help others — was brutally and senselessly slashed in the throat and left for dead in a public stairway," London-Weinstein said in court Friday as she explained the reason for her lack of a decision to a courtroom gallery that included people expecting a decision and prepared to give victim impact statements.
"The stakes could not be higher for Mr. Ismail or for the public, who are relying on the court to arrive at the correct conclusion."
Assistant Crown prosecutor Marie Dufort and defence lawyer Richard Addelman jointly proposed at a hearing in April that Ismail should be found not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder, and the Crown called an expert witness — forensic psychiatrist Dr. Joel Watts — to testify to that effect.
On Friday, London-Weinstein said she's satisfied that Ismail suffers from schizophrenia, resulting in psychosis and paranoid delusions, and added that there's a "significant body of evidence" that Ismail may have been not criminally responsible at the time of the killing because he was incapable of knowing his actions were wrong.
But Watts was not subjected to questioning under cross-examination, and therefore "no critical evaluation of [his] evidence could occur," London-Weinstein said.
Nature of relationship still unclear
The judge repeatedly said Dufort had the best interest of justice in mind by acting as she did in leading Watts's evidence, but that London-Weinstein's role as gatekeeper required her to reach this conclusion.
Things the judge is concerned about include, but aren't limited to:
That there was no explanation for why an original psychiatric opinion was deemed insufficient, requiring Watts to be brought in to provide his opinion.
That the nature of Ismail and Bryant's relationship remains unclear, and some circumstantial evidence suggests it may have been romantic (which, if true, could speak to motive).
That Watts didn't watch Ismail's "critically important" statement to police because the file was corrupted, and that Watts didn't appear to understand the significance of Ismail denying that he knew Bryant at all during that statement (which could speak to knowing that his actions were wrong).
That Watts didn't review other evidence, and that he met with Ismail only once for four hours in jail.
Judges can't order counsel to call specific evidence. An amicus curiae, or friend of the court, could be appointed to ask Watts questions under cross examination, but London-Weinstein said she'd give counsel time to think everything over and suggest how to "cure the deficiencies" in the record at a later date.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Three rescued mine workers on their way home
July 25, 2025 | The three rescued drillers are on their way home after 60 hours deep underground in a B.C. mine. Also, it's looking increasingly unlikely Canada and the U.S. will ink a trade deal by Aug. 1. And the Trump administration's meetings with Ghislaine Maxwell.


CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
B.C. biker clubhouse to become centre for addiction, mental health recovery
A former clubhouse for biker gangs on Vancouver Island is being transformed into a wellness centre. A building in Langford, B.C., once occupied by biker gangs is being transformed into a wellness centre for people recovering from addiction and mental illness. The building was previously used by the Savages Motorcycle Club, and before that, the Devil's Army — both of which police say are tied to the Hells Angels. The clubhouse went on the market last year, after it was raided by police during a drug trafficking and organized crime investigation. About two weeks ago, the Construction Federation of BC (CFBC) bought the property for $1.1 million. '(We're) basically taking the building from notorious to glorious,' said CFBC executive director Abigail Fulton. CFBC is a charity dedicated to supporting people in the construction industry. It plans on turning the space into a wellness hub for tradespeople, called The Forge. 'The building becomes a refuge, a place of hope and wellness for the community,' Fulton said. CFBC needs to fundraise $500,000 to refurbish the building and expand its footprint, she said. It's anticipated renovations will be completed by next summer. 'It's been a couple of decades where the neighbors have been pretty disappointed about the things that were happening at this facility, and now we get to change that script,' said CFBC philanthropy director Mike Manhas. Once the centre opens, the plan is to offer peer support, clinical counsellors, recovery coaching, and a social club. The Forge's services will not include treatment beds or harm reduction services. 'People get sent to treatment, get released, go back into the community and large numbers relapse,' Manhas said. 'When you've gone through the harm reduction piece — (and) there are lots of people providing those services — our job is to provide that recovery piece that no one's providing.' Manhas will help run the centre's programs, alongside carpenter and CFBC industry relations manager Trevor Bodkin. Both men are in recovery. 'The idea being that we take workers like myself with lived experience not only on the tools … but we train them in actually how to use their lived experience of mental health and substance use challenges and recovery to support other workers,' Bodkin said. The Forge team is hosting a ground breaking ceremony next Thursday.


CTV News
6 hours ago
- CTV News
Mother shares story of abduction attempt
A woman in Kirkland Lake says she was able to lock the doors of her vehicle just in time on Thursday to prevent a woman from snatching her baby.