Municipalities in fiscal turmoil as appropriations committee scrutinises financial mismanagement
Image: Supplied
The Standing Committee on Appropriations has raised an alarm over the dire financial state of metropolitan municipalities during a recent engagement with the Mangaung Metropolitan Municipality in the Free State, as part of discussions surrounding the 2025 Division of Revenue Bill.
The committee's session focused on the pressing fiscal challenges exacerbated by unfunded mandates and poor financial management practices that continue to plague these vital urban areas.
One of the major points of contention was the late submission of critical documents by the City of Johannesburg, which arrived a mere 30 minutes before the meeting commenced, limiting the committee's ability to review and discuss its contents thoroughly.
In response, the committee has resolved to reconvene with Johannesburg next week in hopes of addressing these concerns in detail.
Particular emphasis was placed on the financial practices at the Mangaung Municipality, where several directorates are reportedly overspending their approved annual allocations by an alarming 10 to 12 per cent.
Much of this overspend can be traced back to bloated employee costs and outsourced contracted services. Committee members expressed their alarm at the continuing trend of outsourcing fundamental municipal responsibilities, arguing it undermines institutional capacity and invites potential misuse of funds by service providers.
Committee chairperson Mmusi Maimane did not mince words, highlighting the pervasive threat of corruption that continues to inflate service delivery costs.
'What should cost one rand ends up costing three, four or even five rands due to corrupt practices,' he emphasised.
The committee is firmly of the view that addressing corruption is essential to restoring financial integrity and ensuring that funds are used effectively for public services.
In a stern reminder of the consequences of mismanaged resources, the committee pointed to Mangaung's failure to achieve unqualified audit outcomes for the last three consecutive years.
The Auditor-General's reports have consistently pointed to significant financial management deficiencies, including weak internal controls and governance failures that undermine public trust.
Members of the committee urged Mangaung to clarify its outstanding debts to Eskom, emphasising the urgency of reporting on any progress made in tackling these fiscal obligations.
Maimane further lamented the broader decline of metropolitan municipalities across the country, particularly focusing on the deteriorating conditions in inner-city areas.
He warned that such decline leads to a profound loss of housing opportunities and vital economic infrastructure, exacerbating already strained urban living conditions.
As part of its discussions, the committee issued a pointed reminder to municipal officials to prioritise basic service delivery, which includes repairing potholes, installing traffic lights, ensuring reliable water access, and maintaining clean sanitation facilities in informal settlements.
IOL
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
The anatomy of decline: Unemployment and South Africa's structural crisis
Ban Ki-moon, former UN Secretary-General, reminds us that 'addressing unemployment is not just an economic imperative, it is a moral and social one that defines the future of peace and progress Image: AFP In 1994, South Africa emerged from apartheid with global goodwill, democratic legitimacy and the promise of shared prosperity. Yet three decades later, that promise remains unfulfilled. With an overall unemployment rate of 31.9% and youth unemployment at 59.6% (Q4 2024, Stats SA), the country faces a structural crisis that is eroding its economic base and social cohesion. This is not an isolated issue but a national reckoning that follows a pattern common to both collapsing companies and declining states. Jim Collins, in How the Mighty Fall, outlines five stages of institutional decline: hubris, undisciplined growth, denial of risk, superficial solutions and eventual stagnation. These stages offer a sobering framework for understanding South Africa's current position. 'Denial is the most dangerous stage of decline,' Collins warns, 'because it blinds leaders to reality.' Stage 1: Hubris Born of Triumph Between 2000 and 2008, South Africa enjoyed average GDP growth of 3.5%, buoyed by favourable commodity cycles and post-apartheid optimism. The country asserted its geopolitical presence, joined BRICS and positioned itself as a regional hub. But early success bred complacency. Rather than address long-standing structural inequalities or invest in productive capacity, economic momentum gave way to inertia. The Gini coefficient remained high at 0.67 while labour market rigidities discouraged job creation. State-owned enterprises, particularly Eskom, were allowed to expand without accountability. By 2024, public bailouts for Eskom had surpassed R500 billion. Argentina's early 20th-century trajectory offers a striking parallel: a commodity-rich economy that ascended rapidly only to decline due to internal mismanagement and premature confidence in global status. South Africa's early economic positioning masked unresolved domestic vulnerabilities. While attention turned outward to summits and regional diplomacy, the foundations beneath were quietly eroding. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Stage 2: The Undisciplined Pursuit of More South Africa's expansion of redistributive programmes, especially through social grants and state employment schemes, was not matched by corresponding economic productivity. The social grant system, projected to cost R259.3 billion by 2026, has been essential for poverty relief but increasingly burdens fiscal sustainability. Meanwhile, core infrastructure suffered. Transnet's freight efficiency declined sharply and energy supply instability continued to constrain investment. The World Bank reports average GDP growth of just 0.7% between 2014 and 2024. Yet state-led expansion persisted, often detached from output and institutional readiness. This pursuit of scale without returns mirrors firms that chase growth for its own sake. Public employment expansion - while well intentioned - has in some cases reinforced dependency. The logic that more 'boots on the ground' equals delivery has led to overstaffing, rising wage costs and limited institutional agility. Government visibility has been confused with public value. Climate risks have compounded the challenge. Extended droughts have reduced employment in agriculture and mining, weakening resilience in rural provinces. Without adaptation strategies, the employment impacts of environmental shocks will only intensify. Stage 3: Denial of Risk and Erosion of Trust Despite mounting evidence of institutional and economic strain, reforms have lagged. The Zondo Commission exposed over R500 billion in procurement-related losses, yet implementation remains slow. Labour market mismatches have worsened, with 42% of jobless individuals now classified as discouraged workers - those who have ceased to seek employment entirely. Total Factor Productivity has declined for over 15 years according to the International Monetary Fund, yet public discourse often defaults to rebranding or extending existing models. Persistent mismatches between the education system and labour market needs further entrench youth unemployment. Over a million students are enrolled in post-secondary institutions annually, yet far fewer graduate with skills aligned to economic opportunity. Technical and vocational education remains underfunded despite strong global evidence of its employment in government has declined. According to the Edelman Trust Barometer, only 22% of South Africans express trust in government compared to 62% in business. Many young people are now cycling through training schemes with no connection to employment. For them, the crisis is not theoretical - it is lived daily through delayed adulthood and social alienation. Stage 4: Superficial Solutions and Fiscal Pressure Short-term relief measures have become the norm. The Social Relief of Distress Grant and other temporary interventions offer necessary support but are not substitutes for structural employment generation. Public debt now stands at over 74% of GDP, edging towards unsustainable territory. The 2024 Budget Review confirmsdebt service costs are rising faster than allocations to education and infrastructure. Some initiatives under Operation Vulindlela and the Just Energy Transition Investment Plan show intent but require stronger execution and sustained adds further pressure. McKinsey estimates that automation could displace one in four jobs in South Africa by 2030, especially among low-skilled workers. Without a reskilling strategy, digital transformation may reinforce unemployment rather than resolve it. The African Development Bank warns that the continent adds 10 million job seekers to the labour force annually but creates only 3 million jobs. Grants and temporary schemes cannot bridge this gap. They must be paired with pathways into the formal economy - particularly for youth, women and small private sector must also adapt. Hiring practices, investment in entry-level talent and support for smallenterprises are necessary components of a functioning labour market. Stage 5: Recovery or Regression? South Africa remains at a critical juncture. Continued economic stagnation if unaddressed could normalise exclusion and dampen democratic participation. But recovery is not out of reach. Post-crisis recoveries in South Korea and post-war Germany show what is possible when discipline, targeted investment and reform align. In South Africa, green shoots exist. TymeBank has expanded financial inclusion through low-cost digital banking. Harambee Youth Employment Accelerator has supported over a million workseekers using demand-driven matching. AfCFTA implementation offers a strategic lever. If logistics and regulatory reform accompany it, the agreement could boost Africa's income by $450 billion (R7.9 trillion) by 2035. For South Africa, increased participation in regional manufacturing and agri-processing could transform employment patterns - particularly in secondary cities andrural districts. The informal economy, where most African employment resides, cannot be ignored. It requires accessible microfinance, simplified registration and recognition as a legitimate growth engine. Development cannot occur if the majority of economic activity is treated as marginal. None of this is possible without confronting inefficiencies in how public funds are deployed. While social grants and public employment programmes are essential lifelines for vulnerable populations, they have not translated into economic inclusion. Expanding headcounts in state departments is sometimes used as a proxy forperformance, yet without addressing institutional inefficiencies, this risks reinforcing dependency. Employment must become the central metric of public accountability. Conclusion: The Stakes and the Path Forward Failing to address unemployment is not a challenge that can be deferred without consequence. Beyond economic metrics lie the very fabric of social stability, public trust and democratic legitimacy. South Africa's experience offers a warning to all emerging and developing economies: the cost of delay is measured not only in GDP but in fractured communities and lost futures. Ban Ki-moon, former UN Secretary-General, reminds us that 'addressing unemployment is not just an economic imperative, it is a moral and social one that defines the future of peace and progress.' South Africa is not alone. Across emerging economies, unemployment, fiscal strain and youth disillusionment are converging into systemic risk. The lessons embedded in this crisis - about political will, economic realism and institutional reform - are applicable far beyond one nation's borders. The foundations for recovery exist but require clear-eyed leadership and a willingness to prioritise structural reform over symbolic intervention. South Africa's story will be determined not by its past but by how decisivelyit addresses the challenges of today. Nomvula Zeldah Mabuza is a Risk Governance and Compliance Specialist with extensive experience in strategic risk and industrial operations. She holds a Diploma in Business Management (Accounting) from Brunel University, UK, and is an MBA candidate at Henley Business School, South Africa. Image: Supplied
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Latest petrol price increase puts SA consumers on backfoot again
With a fuel price increase hot on the heels of increases in rates and taxes in the metros, there seems to be no way out for consumers. The latest petrol price increase puts struggling South African consumers on the backfoot again after a few months of softer fuel prices, which also led to lower inflation as well as lower interest rates. Now geopolitical issues in the Middle East sent the oil price soaring again and South African consumers are paying the price. Hot on the heels of the small decrease in the price of petrol in June this year, the news of a substantial hike in the price of petrol from 2 July came as a shock to motorists across the country. South Africans were counting on a little relief at the pumps in July to ease the financial burden that has driven millions of households to the edge of despair. The July increase pushes the price of 95 Unleaded petrol up by 55 cents to R21.87 per litre and 93 Unleaded up by 52 cents to R21.79, while diesel increases by between 82 and 84 cents per litre. ALSO READ: Motorists warned to brace for hefty petrol price hike from midnight Major geopolitical factors that impacted the department of petroleum and mineral resources decision included the political seesaw that led to the Israel/Iran conflict and spiked the price of Brent crude oil by as much as 13% in the aftermath, leading to increases at the pumps. Thankfully, the rand remained surprisingly resilient in the face of the resultant market turbulence. Fuel price hike on top of increase in rates and taxes As if this is not enough reason to dash any last hope of a respite, Tuesday 1 July marked the start of the municipal financial year when local authorities increase rates and taxes. This means households in major metros across the country will see increases to monthly rates for electricity, water, sanitation, refuse removal and property rates they pay. South Africans can expect above-inflation hikes this year as cities continue to operate under strained conditions and energy experts are warning that households could see their bills shoot up anywhere between 30% and 80%, especially if their consumption is typically low. This is largely due to a new tariff structure being implemented by Eskom, which aims to align prices with the cost of supply and to reduce subsidies. ALSO READ: Here's how to manage household electricity usage as municipal tariff increases kick in Against this grim backdrop, the latest 2025 Energy Market Projections report, compiled by Cresco in collaboration with Standard Bank Corporate and Investment Banking, shows that while load shedding may have taken a backseat temporarily, a new energy crisis is looming if the country fails to build new capacity. According to the report, South Africa is not adding new energy generation capacity fast enough to prevent another severe electricity crisis when Eskom begins decommissioning its coal plants. Behind this is the fact that the country is not increasing its energy supply at a sufficient rate to facilitate faster economic growth, which means that any sharp pickup in activity will result in demand outstripping supply. Living increases force struggling consumers to use credit Neil Roets, CEO of Debt Rescue, warns with no end in sight to the volley of living cost increases, coupled with consumers already cutting back as much as they can, the latest fuel price increase will cut deeply into the little disposable income people still have left, if they have any to spare at all. 'In fact, along with the soaring electricity prices and the municipal rate hikes in July, millions of households will be forced towards financial disaster. This is a red flag that should not be ignored. Along with this, the salaries of South Africans fail to keep up with rising living costs, leading many to turn to debt simply to survive each month and buy the basics they need to survive.' This is echoed by insights from the latest BankservAfrica Take-home Pay Index (BTPI), which tracks approximately 3.8 million salary earners in South Africa. It revealed that the nominal average take-home pay decreased to R17 296 in May 2025, 1.3% lower than the R17 532 registered in April. ALSO READ: Take-home pay slides for third month with grim job opportunities and earnings South Africans can't afford to set money aside Roets points out that this marks a third consecutive month of decline in average nominal take-home pay, reflecting a muted economic environment with stalled growth and global shocks affecting investment decisions and confidence levels. Unsurprisingly, he says, this is also a major contributor to the country's escalating consumer debt crisis, with a recent Debt Rescue survey, conducted to measure the real plight of indebted consumers, showing that half of the participants polled (50%) cannot afford basic necessities like food, electricity, or fuel due to a lack of available funds. A full 50% said they have had to turn to credit to pay for these everyday needs in the past 12 months. Roets says this reflects the vicious cycle of poverty and debt that has become a way of life for millions of South African consumers, seriously impeding their and their families' survival. 'It is a bitter irony that this coincides with National Savings Month, a time meant to promote saving, yet many South Africans can barely cover essentials, let alone set money aside.'
IOL News
2 days ago
- IOL News
Eskom cracks down on fraudulent electricity tokens with new security upgrades
Eskom intensifies efforts to secure its prepaid electricity token system following the OVS breach, aiming to restore public trust and strengthen operational resilience. Image: Timothy Barnard /Independent Newspapers Eskom has announced decisive new actions to protect its customers following a major breach of its Online Vending System (OVS), which was exploited to generate and distribute fraudulent prepaid electricity tokens. The breach, revealed in Eskom's full-year 2024 financial results released in December, exposed critical weaknesses in both the physical and cybersecurity layers of the utility's infrastructure. The fraudulent activity, which threatened to undermine public trust in Eskom's prepaid electricity system, prompted an immediate and robust response from the state-owned utility. 'We uncovered weaknesses in physical and cybersecurity components on our OVS system,' said Monde Bala, Eskom's Group Executive for Distribution. Eskom has since launched a comprehensive review and intervention strategy to address these security gaps and strengthen its operations against future threats. 'Earlier this year, Eskom successfully strengthened the protection of its current systems against potential threats. All system enhancements are managed through a robust Change Management process that spans all divisions, ensuring consistent oversight and control,' explained Len De Villiers, Eskom's Chief Technology and Information Officer. To address the vulnerabilities that allowed the token fraud to occur, Eskom has reinforced its physical infrastructure and limited both physical and digital access points. Eskom has also strengthened internal controls to combat electricity theft and enhanced monitoring capabilities to ensure greater transparency and timely detection of suspicious activities. In parallel, Eskom has been working closely with law enforcement agencies to support ongoing investigations and ensure accountability. As part of this effort, internal employees who have been implicated have been placed on precautionary suspension pending further review. Furthermore, Eskom has engaged an external IT firm to strengthen in-house capabilities and improve risk management. The utility has also fast-tracked the acquisition of a new, secure vending system designed to replace the compromised OVS and prevent similar incidents in the future. Throughout this process, Eskom has maintained regular reporting to its board, which continues to provide oversight of all remediation efforts. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading 'We are fully aware of the challenges that have emerged within the OVS environment, and we have taken clear steps to address them. Our focus is on restoring trust, strengthening our systems, and ensuring that our customers can rely on a secure and efficient service," said Eskom's Group Chief Executive, Dan Marokane. "This is not just a technical fix, it is part of a broader commitment to transparency, operational excellence and accountability.' While the investigation into the token fraud continues, Eskom has pledged to share the findings once the process is concluded and the appropriate time for disclosure has been determined. In the meantime, the utility has called on customers and stakeholders to remain vigilant and report any suspicious activity related to prepaid electricity tokens. As Eskom moves forward with its efforts to protect its infrastructure and rebuild public confidence, it reassures South Africans that their electricity, and their trust, remain top priorities. IOL
