Broadway is in a bizarre uproar over the race of an actor playing a robot
But show people can't have that!
They always need, as Betty sang in the recently shuttered 'Boop! The Musical,' something to shout about.
And their something has finally arrived in the form of a piping hot controversy at this year's Best Musical Tony Award winner, 'Maybe Happy Ending.'
It's a doozy.
Some members of the theater industry are hollerin' 'It's a scandal! It's a outrage!' over the race of an actor who's been cast to play — believe it or not — a robot.
'Maybe Happy Ending,' by the writing team of Hue Park and Will Aronson, is a sweet little science-fiction romantic-comedy that's set in Seoul, South Korea, during the year 2060.
The main characters are Oliver and Claire, played by Darren Criss, who's half Filipino, and Helen J. Shen, who's Chinese.
Oliver and Claire are robots.
5 There's a controversy brewing over at Broadway's 'Maybe Happy Ending.'
Getty Images
But the nuts-and-bolts duo have become defunct, so they embark on a quirky adventure to find Oliver's old owner.
It's perhaps the nicest show to ever come to Broadway.
Or it was. Until this latest fracas.
The happiness dimmed when the wonderful, Tony-winning Criss's replacement was announced: actor Andrew Barth Feldman, the fantastic 'No Hard Feelings' star who's also Shen's boyfriend. He's white.
Uh oh!
In private, many on Broadway are largely OK with that. The most common refrain I've heard is: 'Well, they're robots.'
But social media, as it does best, has poured gas on the fire.
5 Andrew Barth Feldman takes on the role of Oliver in September.
WireImage
Playwright and actor BD Wong, who was a strong voice in 1991 against British actor Jonathan Pryce playing the Eurasian Engineer in 'Miss Saigon' (Wong was absolutely right about that), wrote an essay slamming the choice.
And the Asian American Performers Action Coalition came out against it, too.
What do the creators have to say?
They didn't write the roles to be culturally specific.
Because they're robots!
Robots don't have a culture.
Well, except the Terminator, of course. He loves schnitzel and strudel.
5 'Maybe Happy Ending' won the Tony Award for Best Musical.
Christopher Sadowski
After the backlash, Aronson and Hue — kind and humble as it gets — explained on Instagram that they set out to create 'a modern 'Fantasticks,' able to be comfortably performed by anyone, anywhere — yet distinctly set in Korea.'
Fair enough.
Oliver and Claire, they said, are 'products created by a global company' who are 'ethnically undefined.'
That makes a lot of sense. Because the characters are robots.
The production said in a statement to the Times, 'We are proud to have created a show where every role can authentically be portrayed by an Asian actor, although the roles of the robots were not envisioned to always be cast that way.'
5 Darren Criss won a Tony for his performance.
Bruce Glikas/WireImage
And that openness has been true throughout the 'Maybe Happy Ending' journey.
Aronson told the LA Times back in March that during an early workshop, the parts were taken on by Denée Benton, who's black, and Corey Cott, who's white.
See? There's lots of flexibility when casting robots.
Look, it's Hue and Aronson's show. They wrote it. Who's to tell them what they can and cannot do and what their intentions were?
5 'Maybe Happy Ending' is the rare musical about robots.
CBS via Getty Images
The fact is 'Maybe Happy Ending' is the only Broadway musical I am aware of in which the leads are made of metal. (Although I've seen plenty of shows where it sure seemed like they were). It's an extremely unusual circumstance, and hardly one to draw broad conclusions from.
In works about Asian humans, like the Imelda Marcos musical 'Here Lies Love,' something like this would never happen anymore.
Feldman, who was nothing short of sublime in last season's 'We Had A World,' starts performing at the Belasco Theatre on Sept. 2.
The uproar should die down well before that.
And then fall on Broadway can resume being 'Happy.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
13 minutes ago
- New York Post
Browns reporter takes savage shot at Bill Belichick-Jordon Hudson romance in Hall of Fame speech
Browns beat reporter Mary Kay Cabot took a brutal jab at Bill Belichick's highly publicized romance with 24-year-old girlfriend Jordon Hudson on Friday when she accepted the Bill Nunn Memorial Award during the Pro Football Hall of Fame Gold Jacket Dinner in Canton, Ohio. Cabot, who began covering the Browns in 1991, the same year Belichick, 73, took over as coach in Cleveland, first joked about going through the wringer with the future Hall of Famer. 'Bill Belichick was the first Browns coach I ever covered,' Cabot began, as covered by Awful Announcing. 'You see, if you start out with Bill Belichick, no one can rattle you after that. If Bill didn't like something I wrote, he'd call and yell at me. If you asked a dumb question, he'd call you out. Eventually, I had to learn to stand up to him. During one of those yelling matches, I told him, if you don't have the 'footballs' to say that to the guys, then don't say it to me. Bam.' Advertisement 4 Bill Belichick's relationship with Jordon Hudson was referenced in Mary Kay Cabot's speech in August 2025. Getty Images That's when Cabot's speech pivoted to the UNC coach's widely scrutinized personal life. Advertisement 'But now, I totally understand why Bill gave me such a hard time. I was 28 at the time, and he just couldn't relate to a woman that old,' Cabot said as the audience roared with laughter. Although many on social media also chuckled over Cabot's zinger, the remarks didn't appear to please everyone. 4 Mary Kay Cabot speaks at the 2025 Pro Football Hall of Fame Gold Jacket Dinner on Aug. 1, 2025. Scott Galvin-Imagn Images 4 Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson went public with their relationship in 2024. Getty Images Advertisement On Saturday, Hudson's X account reposted a message from a separate user that read: 'Not much of a 'laugh.' No wonder so many have contempt for the media, especially those who want to be the story rather than [report] on the story.' Belichick's romance with Hudson was first revealed in June 2024. 4 Bill Belichick is preparing for his first season as football coach of the Tar Heels. AP Their relationship has largely been under a microscope following a disastrous 'CBS Sunday Morning' interview in April, when Hudson pushed back on a question intended for Belichick about how they met. Advertisement Amid speculation about her role in Belichick's personal and professional endeavors, the eight-time Super Bowl-winning coach made it clear in May that Hudson does not 'have anything to do with UNC football.' Belichick and the Tar Heels open the 2025 season against TCU on Sept. 1.
New York Post
43 minutes ago
- New York Post
Sister of Liam Neeson's late wife Natasha Richardson reacts to his ‘budding romance' with Pamela Anderson
Liam Neeson's new love appears to have his former sister-in-law's approval. Pamela Anderson took to Instagram on Friday, August 1, to share a carousel of sweet photos of herself posing with Neeson to promote the release of their new movie together. 'The Naked Gun is finally in theatres!' Anderson, 58, wrote. 'Bring your friends, family, lovers… whoever… just go and have a laugh… It's good for you! I'll see you there.' Advertisement 9 Pamela Anderson and Liam Neeson attend the US premiere of 'The Naked Gun' in New York City on July 28, 2025. AFP via Getty Images 9 Vanessa Redgrave, Liam Neeson, Natasha Richardson and Joely Richardson at the 10th anniversary benefit for the Christopher Reeve Paralysis Association in New York City on November 14, 2000. Getty Images Natasha Richardson's sister, Joely Richardson, then shared seven red heart emojis in the comments section of Anderson's post. Advertisement Joely's apparent support for Neeson's rumored romance with Anderson excited many of the former 'Baywatch' star's fans, and several took to the comments section to share their reactions. 'Classy and loving as always,' one person wrote underneath Joely's comment. 'Very sweet of you,' added another, while a third commented, 'Okay, this is everything.' 9 Joely Richardson at the Hope 93 Gallery on July 9, 2025, in London, England. Getty Images Advertisement 9 Pamela Anderson and Liam Neeson at SiriusXM Studios on July 30, 2025, in New York City. Getty Images for SiriusXM Neeson, 73, married Joely's sister, Natasha Richardson, in 1994 after the pair met and worked together on the Broadway revival of 'Anna Christie' one year earlier. Before striking up a relationship with Richardson, the 'Taken' star had dated Helen Mirren and Barbra Streisand. Neeson and Richardson went on to welcome two sons together: Micheál, now 30, and Daniel, now 28. Advertisement 9 Natasha Richardson and Liam Neeson at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. FilmMagic But tragedy struck in March 2009 when Richardson passed away from a traumatic brain injury she suffered during a skiing accident in Quebec. The beloved 'Parent Trap' actress was 45. Neeson later opened up about his wife's passing and the grief he endured during an interview with '60 Minutes' in 2014. 'Grief hits you. It's like a wave,' he told host Anderson Cooper at the time. 'You just get this profound feeling of instability. You feel like a three-legged table. Just suddenly, the Earth isn't stable anymore.' 9 Natasha Richardson and Liam Neeson during the NYC premiere of 'Asylum' in 2005. WireImage 'And then it passes and becomes more infrequent, but I still get it sometimes,' the 'Star Wars' actor added. Then, in October 2024, Neeson claimed that he was done dating. 'No, in a word,' he told People last year. 'I'm past all that.' Advertisement 9 Natasha Richardson and Liam Neeson at a screening of 'Seraphim Falls' at the Tribeca Grand Hotel in New York City. FilmMagic But that appeared to change when the Oscar-nominated actor and Anderson met and began working together on Seth MacFarlane's 'The Naked Gun' reboot. 'With Pamela, first off, I'm madly in love with her,' Neeson, also in October 2024, said. 'She's just terrific to work with.' 'I think I have a friend forever in Liam, and we definitely have a connection that is very sincere, very loving, and he's a good guy,' Anderson told Entertainment Weekly last month. Advertisement 9 Liam Neeson and Pamela Anderson in a scene from 'The Naked Gun.' AP The pair both brought their sons to the NYC premiere of 'The Naked Gun,' and then pretended to make out on live TV during a July 29 appearance on 'Today.' Insiders have since claimed that Neeson and Anderson are dating and 'enjoying each other's company.' 'It's a budding romance in the early stages,' a source told People in July. 'It's sincere, and it's clear they're smitten with each other.' Advertisement 9 Pamela Anderson and Liam Neeson attend the UK premiere of 'The Naked Gun' on July 22, 2,025 in London, England. Getty Images 'It's very sincere how they feel,' another insider told Page Six. 'That is the truth.' 'They're not going to show up on the red carpet and be adorable just to be fake, that's not either of them,' they added. 'This is happening in real time, here and now, so I don't know what things look like moving forward.' The Post has reached out to Neeson and Anderson's reps for comment.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Prince Harry responds to claims he had bloody brawl with Prince Andrew over Meghan Markle remarks
Prince Harry has firmly denied ever rolling up his sleeves to confront his uncle, Prince Andrew, over alleged comments about his wife, Meghan Markle. The Duke of Sussex, 40, was said to have left the disgraced Duke of York with a 'bloody nose' following a 'heated argument' more than a decade ago, according to an excerpt of Andrew Lownie's new book, 'Entitled: The Rise and Fall of the House of York,' obtained by the Daily Mail. Lownie, who wrote the book about Prince Andrew and his ex-wife, Sarah Ferguson, claimed that Harry lost his cool after his uncle uttered a comment about the 'Suits' alum, 43, 'behind Harry's back.' 4 Prince Harry has firmly denied ever rolling up his sleeves to confront his uncle, Prince Andrew, over alleged comments about his wife, Meghan Markle. Getty Images The royal author alleged that Andrew had called the former actress an 'opportunist.' 'I can confirm neither of those things are true,' the Invictus Games founder's rep told Us Weekly of the alleged altercation. 'Prince Harry and Prince Andrew have never had a physical fight, nor did Prince Andrew ever make those comments about the Duchess of Sussex to Prince Harry.' The excerpt further alleged that 'punches were thrown' and that Andrew — who has recently won his yearslong fight to stay at the Royal Lodge — emerged from the fight with a bloody nose. 4 The disgraced Duke of York was said to have been left with a 'bloody nose' following a 'heated argument' with Harry more than a decade ago. Getty Images The Post has reached out to reps for the Sussexes for further comment. It's no secret that the Sussex camp has been embroiled in a yearslong feud with the Windsor clan since quitting royal life in 2020 and moving across the pond. The pair, who wed in 2018, have been totally estranged from the royal family for more than half a decade as they continue to live in Montecito, Calif., while raising son Archie, 6, and daughter Lilibet, 4. 4 The royal author alleged that Andrew had called the 'Suits' alum an 'opportunist.' Getty Images for W+P However, in recent weeks the 'Spare' author had proved he's serious about reconciling with his estranged family members by offering to share his diary dates with the royal family to ensure total transparency. 'Harry has shifted into a new way of thinking. The tone is now all about 'deconflicting' with his family,' a source recently told the Daily Mail. 'That's why his household agreed to draw up a 'grid' of his activities and share them with Buckingham Palace, and by extension with Kensington Palace.' What's more, the offer has reportedly also been extended to the Prince and Princess of Wales, who have not spoken to the Sussexes in years. 4 The Sussexes tied the knot in 2018 — just two years before quitting royal life and moving to the US. POOL/AFP via Getty Images The gesture came just weeks after Harry sent his aides to London where they met up with the monarch's communications secretary. Still, it's said that Charles is 'cautious and wary' of his estranged son's overdue attempt at gluing the family back together.
