LoC isn't key
Predictably, Pakistan responded on Thursday to India's retaliatory measures post the Pahalgam terror attack. Unsurprisingly, given that Pakistan has very few cards to play, its responses don't amount to much. Take the statement that all bilateral agreements, including the 1972 Simla accord, will be in abeyance. But the accord didn't prevent Kargil or multiple ceasefire violations by Pakistan. Pakistan's army has repeatedly violated the sanctity of LoC. So, if Islamabad is now saying there's no recognising an LoC anymore, it hardly makes any material difference to India. True, suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty by New Delhi has limited near-term punitive power. But as one of our OpEd columnists points out, suspension of the treaty can potentially be very costly for Pakistan. That's not the case with India vis-à-vis anything Pakistan threatened. What'll happen from here on is impossible to predict. But whatever happens GOI has an urgent job at hand.
It needs to get to the bottom of the intelligence/security lapses that gave free entry and exit to Pahalgam terrorists. The point is not that there should be additional army boots on the ground in J&K. It's impossible to post security personnel in every tourist attraction or bazaar in Kashmir. The only thing that can thwart Pahalgam-style attacks is an intelligence network that feeds credible information to security forces. The best intelligence systems still rely on quality human intelligence or HUMINT. For that, any force needs some level of connect with at least some sections of locals. It's relevant here to note that many Kashmiris have openly and clearly condemned the Pahalgam terror attack. Pakistan's terror planners had clearly hoped that the incident would engender communal discord and reopen fissures in J&K. Instead, from north to south Kashmir, schools, colleges and shops remained closed in protest against what they termed as 'murder of Kashmiriyat'. But this message needs to be reciprocated by the rest of India – govts everywhere must take the strictest of actions against groups that harass Kashmiris.
To the extent this shows that more Kashmiris today are becoming genuine stakeholders in the normalisation process, it's good news for Indian intelligence agencies. Note here that Kashmiriyat thrives only in democratic India, not in PoK where Islamabad has carried out ethnic cleansing and engineered demographic change. Therefore, GOI and the entire security apparatus must leverage this moment to quietly seek the support of Kashmiris to strengthen HUMINT. If Kashmiris' response to Pahalgam stays as it is, the battle against terrorism may get just a little easier.
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email
This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
33 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Pakistan says it's close to US trade deal, Washington gives no timeline
Pakistani Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said on Friday the United States and Pakistan were 'very close' to a trade deal that could come within days, but comments from the US after Dar met with Secretary of State Marco Rubio mentioned no timeline. 'I think we are very close to finalizing a deal with US Our teams have been here in Washington, discussing, having virtual meetings and a committee has been tasked by the prime minister to fine-tune now,' Dar said in a discussion at the Atlantic Council think tank in Washington. 'It's not going to be months, not even weeks, I would say (just) days,' he said. Under US President Donald Trump, Washington has attempted to renegotiate trade agreements with many countries that he threatened with tariffs over what he calls unfair trade relations. Many economists dispute Trump's characterization. The Deputy Prime Minister/Foreign Minister, Senator Mohammad Ishaq Dar @MIshaqDar50, met with the U.S. Secretary of State, Marco Rubio @SecRubio, today in Washington D.C. The two sides acknowledged the positive trajectory of the Pak-U.S. bilateral relations. They discussed and… — Ministry of Foreign Affairs – Pakistan (@ForeignOfficePk) July 25, 2025 The US State Department and Pakistan's foreign ministry, in separate statements after Rubio's meeting with Dar, said the two stressed in their discussion the importance of expanding trade and ties in critical minerals and mining. A post by Rubio on X after the meeting and the State Department's statement mentioned no timeline for finalizing a trade deal. Met with Pakistani Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister @MIshaqDar50 today to discuss expanding bilateral trade and enhancing collaboration in the critical minerals sector. I also thanked him for Pakistan's partnership in countering terrorism and preserving regional… — Secretary Marco Rubio (@SecRubio) July 25, 2025 The Pakistan foreign ministry also said Dar 'appreciated the pivotal role' by Trump and Rubio 'in de-escalating tensions between Pakistan and India by facilitating a ceasefire.' The State Department statement did not mention India. Trump has repeatedly taken credit for the India-Pakistan ceasefire he announced on social media on May 10 after Washington held talks with both sides. India disputes Trump's claims that the ceasefire resulted from his intervention and trade threats. India's position is that New Delhi and Islamabad must resolve problems directly with no outside involvement. The April 22 terrorist attack in Kashmir's Pahalgam claimed the lives of 26 civilians, sparling heavy cross-border fighting between the nuclear-armed neighbors in the latest escalation of a decades-old rivalry. India struck Pakistan on May 7 under 'Operation Sindoor' and the two nations exchanged hostilities, killing dozens across three days. The ceasefire was declared on May 10. New Delhi blamed the April attack on Pakistan, which denied responsibility and called for a neutral investigation. Washington condemned the attack but did not blame Islamabad.
India Today
10 hours ago
- India Today
Ties strong enough: India shrugs off anti-Modi post by Muizzu's brother-in-law
Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri on Friday brushed aside media queries about a now-deleted social media post by Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu's brother-in-law regarding Prime Minister Narendra Modi, ahead of the latter's visit. Misri said India is more focused on strengthening its positive relationship with the Maldives, nearly 10 months after Muizzu visited said that rather than looking back, India prefers to focus on the future, dismissing the now-deleted critical post about PM Modi by Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu's brother-in-law as mere "passing remarks."advertisementDismissing recent criticism from Muizzu's brother-in-law, Misri said, "Our ties are strong enough to withstand some of these passing remarks that have been made and have also withstood the test of time...I would prefer to look going with everything that has happened today and especially in the past 9-10 months since President Mohamed Muizzu visited India, the future is undoubtedly and unquestionably bright." The statements were made in response to a deleted social media post by Abdullah bin Mohammed Ibrahim, who referred to PM Modi as a "terrorist". PM Modi's visit to the Maldives resulted in several key agreements, including an extension of India's Line of Credit (LoC) to Rs 4,850 crore and kickstarting negotiations for an India-Maldives Free Trade Agreement (IMFTA).Highlighting the importance of security cooperation in the Indian Ocean, Misri said, "Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu expressed his commitment to the importance that the Maldives attaches to security-related issues and the commitment of the two sides to continue to work together.""For us, it is always friendship first," PM Modi said in his media statement earlier today, adding the "roots of our relations are older than history, and as deep as the ocean."During his third official visit to the island nation, PM Modi also took part in the 60th Independence Day celebrations in the Maldives. He was warmly received by President Muizzu and other senior visit saw the inauguration of various development projects, including the handing over of 3,300 social housing units in Hulhumale and the launch of roads and drainage projects in Addu City. These projects reflect India's commitment to supporting infrastructure development in the gratitude for the warm reception, PM Modi said, "India and the Maldives are making significant efforts to further strengthen their mutual relations."PM Modi also handed over 72 vehicles and equipment for use by the Maldives National Defence defence ministry building is a "concrete building of trust" and it is a symbol of our "strong partnership", the prime minister said."India will continue to support Maldives in the development of its defence capabilities. Peace, stability and prosperity in the Indian Ocean region is our common goal," he comments came against the backdrop of New Delhi's concerns over China's attempts to expand its influence over the his remarks, Modi said the Maldives holds an "important place" in both India's "Neighbourhood First" policy and its MAHASAGAR (Mutual and Holistic Advancement for Security and Growth Across Regions) vision."India is also proud to be the most trusted friend of Maldives. Be it a disaster or a pandemic, India has always stood by as a 'first responder'," he said.- EndsInputs from PTIMust Watch
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
'Constant watch on all developments': India slams China-Pakistan-Afghanistan meet, says CPEC expansion 'unacceptable'
NEW DELHI: The government on Wednesday reiterated its strong objection to the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor ( ) and termed any expansion or third-party involvement in the project "unacceptable." Tired of too many ads? go ad free now In a written reply in the Rajya Sabha, minister of state for external affairs Kirti Vardhan Singh confirmed that the Government of India is aware of a recent trilateral meeting between China, Pakistan, and Afghanistan held in Beijing. India-Pak Clash At UN Security Council: Cross-Border Terrorism Charge Triggers Diplomatic Firestorm "The government's position on CPEC is clear and consistent. We have consistently protested to the concerned parties over the inclusion of the so-called CPEC as a flagship project of One Belt One Road/ Belt and Road Initiative (OBOR/BRI), as it passes through parts of the Indian Union Territories of Ladakh and Jammu & Kashmir under illegal occupation by Pakistan," Singh said. On recent involvement of Afghanistan, Singh stressed that India has categorically opposed any proposed participation of third countries in the CPEC and has communicated its objections to the concerned parties. "Any proposed participation of third countries or expansion of the so-called CPEC projects to third countries is unacceptable. The government has consistently conveyed this position,' Singh reiterated. The minister also stated that India keeps a constant watch on all foreign developments that could impact its security and takes "all necessary measures" to safeguard its sovereignty and territorial integrity.
