logo
Elon Musk sees humanity's purpose as a facilitator of superintelligent AI. That should worry us

Elon Musk sees humanity's purpose as a facilitator of superintelligent AI. That should worry us

Irish Times26-04-2025
During an interview published earlier this month on the website Vox, the American technologist and writer
Jaron Lanier
came out with one of the more unsettling remarks I've encountered recently. Lanier is one of the more interesting of Silicon Valley's in-house intellectuals. He was an early developer of virtual reality technologies in the 1980s, and is often credited (and credits himself) with coining the term to describe that technology. He's a genuine believer in the human possibilities and social benefits offered by information technology, but also a trenchant and vehement critic of the anti-human tendencies within the culture of Silicon Valley.
Lanier's value as a public intellectual has always struck me as being somewhat limited by his tendency, common among Silicon Valley thinkers, to see social and political issues as primarily engineering problems. But he is generally worth reading and listening to as a tech industry insider whose critiques are motivated by both a love of technology and a deep liberal humanism – a love, that is, for technology as a human art form that is inseparable from a love of humanity itself.
The remark in the Vox interview that I found especially unsettling was one in which Lanier addressed the ascendancy of precisely the opposite tendency within the elite of Silicon Valley. He is, he says, constantly talking to people who believe that we need to put everything into developing superhuman
artificial intelligence
, recognise its status as a higher form of intelligence and being, and simply get out of its way.
'Just the other day,' he says, 'I was at a lunch in Palo Alto and there were some young AI scientists there who were saying that they would never have a 'bio baby' because as soon as you have a 'bio baby,' you get the 'mind virus' of the [biological] world. And when you have the mind virus, you become committed to your human baby. But it's much more important to be committed to the AI of the future. And so to have human babies is fundamentally unethical.'
READ MORE
In one sense, I should not find this anecdote especially unsettling. I have written fairly extensively about this particular constellation of ideas, and the tech industry milieu within which it exists. In writing my first book, which explored this anti-human veneration of machines, I met many people who advanced some or other variation of the ideas Lanier sketches here. But artificial intelligence, though it was certainly an article of faith among the people I spoke to, was at that point largely an abstract concept for society at large.
There was no real sense, in 2014 and 2015, that we would so quickly come to live in a world so defined and deformed by this technology. The ideas Lanier speaks about – that humanity is in its last decadent days, and that the role of technologists was to bring about the advent of the superintelligent machines that will succeed us – were at the time niche, considered fairly eccentric within the context of radical Silicon Valley techno-optimism. As Lanier points out, this attitude is now a very common one in the circles in which he moves.
The idea, or perhaps more accurately ideology, is known as 'effective accelerationism'; its adherents advocate for the rapid advancement of machine learning technology, unfettered by any kind of regulation or guardrails, in an effort to hasten the advent of AI superintelligence. The more utopian versions of this idea see such a superintelligence as a means toward the solution of all human problems – economic abundance for all, the curing of every known disease, solutions to
climate change
, and so on. In its darker inflections, it envisions such an intelligence as vastly superior to humanity, and destined to overthrow and replace us entirely.
[
Mark O'Connell: It's degrading to have to take anything Elon Musk says seriously, but he's right about one thing
Opens in new window
]
As an idea, it's most associated with the English philosopher Nick Land. As a professor at the University of Warwick in the 1990s, Land was a central figure of an influential circle of rogue academics who embraced the utopian ideas around early internet culture; he went Awol around the turn of the century and resurfaced, in Shanghai, as an enigmatic and fugitive thinker whose increasingly anti-human and anti-democratic writing advocated a kind of techno-fascism in which all human life would be subordinate to, and ultimately obliterated by, the supremacy of AI. 'Nothing human,' as he memorably and chillingly put it, 'makes it out of the near future.'
In a sense there is nothing very new about this kind of thinking: the fascists of the interwar years combined a great enthusiasm for new technology with a contempt for Enlightenment values of liberal democracy and humanism. The Italian Futurists fetishised machinery, speed and violence, glorifying war as 'the only hygiene of the world'.
Land remains a niche figure, but he has his constituency, and his ideas have been influential in Silicon Valley. The disturbing ideology Lanier encountered at that Palo Alto lunch are clearly derived from his writing. And then there's
Elon Musk
, who is himself unquestionably among the most influential people on the planet. Just a few weeks ago, Musk made the following statement on X, the social network that he owns and on which he is the most followed account: 'It increasingly appears that humanity is a biological bootloader for digital superintelligence.'
[
Mark O'Connell: Elon Musk makes being a billionaire plutocrat look profoundly uncool
Opens in new window
]
A bootloader, to be clear, is a piece of code that initiates the start-up of a computer's operating system when it's powered on. In other words, humanity, in the view of the world's richest and arguably most influential man, is important only as a necessary facilitator of superintelligent AI. I wouldn't want to bet that Musk has read Land – my sense of it is that the extent of his reading is the cry-laughing emojis posted by sycophants under his bad jokes on X – but his invocation of the biological bootloader notion suggests the extent to which Land's ideas have filtered through. And it's hard to think of a more damning indictment of our time than the fact that people with such an openly anti-human worldview, who hold humanity itself in such contempt, have been granted such unprecedented wealth, power and cultural influence.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Tesla opens 'retro-futuristic' American diner
Tesla opens 'retro-futuristic' American diner

Extra.ie​

time2 days ago

  • Extra.ie​

Tesla opens 'retro-futuristic' American diner

Elon Musk is branching Tesla out into a very new area as the company combines its electric cars with some classic American dining. The Tesla Diner has opened up in Hollywood, California and is described as a 'retro-futuristic diner and drive-in charging experience.' With 250 seats, the diner is split into two levels. The lower level features the main serving area, while the upper level, called the 'Skypad', allows diners to enjoy views of Los Angeles or enjoy another unique feature. The diner features an outdoor drive-in movie experience. Pic: Tesla Just outside, there are two 66ft LED megascreens for people to park their cars in front of and watch a movie. Tesla explained: 'Located in Hollywood, California, Tesla Diner is a Supercharging station, classic American diner and drive-in experience all wrapped up into one. 'With retro-futuristic design influences, this location offers Tesla and non-Tesla drivers alike with charging access along the historic Route 66 highway.' Kids meals are served in a small CyberTruck box. Pic: Tesla Open 24/7, the Tesla Diner is located on Santa Monica Boulevard – one of the main roads running through West Hollywood. The company continued: 'Solar canopies offer shade to the west charging lot, helping to reduce the site's carbon emissions by about 26.6 million pounds of CO2 per year—making charging even more sustainable.' It is the largest urban Supercharging station in the world, featuring 80 V4 Supercharger stalls. Members of the public at the opening of the retro-futuristic diner. Pic: Jim Ruymen/UPI/Shutterstock They added: 'Place your order in advance or when you arrive through your vehicle's touchscreen or dine inside.' The menu is split into six sections – Breakfast, Burgers & Sandwiches, Kids' menu, Sides, Desserts, and Beverages. However, the food will not come cheap. Breakfast options include a $12 Egg Sandwich, $11 Breakfast Tacos, or $15 Biscuits and Red Gravy, while the Burgers & Sandwiches include a $13.50 Tesla Burger, a $14 Tuna Melt, and a $13 Hot Dog. Kids can choose between a $9 Grilled Cheese, a $13 Kids Burger or a $13 Chicken Tenders Combo. They are all served in a small CyberTruck box. Tesla drivers can see what movie is playing next on the outside screens by using their vehicle's touchscreen. The diner has 250 seats for dining. Pic: Tesla Finally, there is a gift shop where those with some extra cash can buy exclusive merchandise. This includes a Tesla Bot action figure, a Hollywood Retro Diner T-shirt, gummy sweets and a Diner trucker hat. After officially opening its doors on Monday, the diner has received mixed reactions across social media. One user tweeted: 'These need to be everywhere', with another adding: 'This is the coolest place in LA ATM. Will definitely become a tourist attraction IMO.' It has received mixed reviews on social media. Pic: Tesla On the other hand, one person shared: 'I feel sorry for those who live in the neighboring building and have had all possibility of seeing anything outside their homes blocked, so that now all that remains for them is to open a window and be confronted by the back of the giant screen you installed right in front of their faces.' Another said: 'Tried to go with the family. The absence of plant based options in a city like Los Angeles is crazy. 'Even the avocado toast has eggs in the bread and the fries are cooked in beef. Had to pass unfortunately.'

Author interview: Finding new life among the hidden worlds at the ‘Ends of the Earth'
Author interview: Finding new life among the hidden worlds at the ‘Ends of the Earth'

Irish Examiner

time6 days ago

  • Irish Examiner

Author interview: Finding new life among the hidden worlds at the ‘Ends of the Earth'

During the late 1960s, John H Mercer set out on an epic adventure: To map the sequence of rock formations in Reedy Glacier, in West Antarctica. On his field trip, the British glaciologist noticed a strange phenomenon: There were layers of sediments typical of those found at the bottom of lakes. It led Mercer to come up with a new working hypothesis: Approximately 120,000 years ago, the high-altitude site where he was carrying out his research held lakes instead of glaciers. Mercer's logic implied that during warm periods, the West Antarctic ice sheet melts completely, only to re-form during cold periods. Mercer explored this idea further in a scientific paper he published in 1968, but nobody paid attention. A decade later, Mercer published another paper in the science journal Nature. 'If the global consumption of fossil fuels continues to grow… atmospheric CO2 content will double in about 50 years,' he wrote. 'Climatic models suggest that the resultant greenhouse-warming effect will be greatly magnified in high latitudes… and could start rapid deglaciation of West Antarctica, leading to a 5m rise in sea level.' The scientific community denounced Mercer as an attention-seeking alarmist. From 1978, until his death nine years later, the British scientist struggled to get grants to support his research. Mercer was a visionary, but his ambitious ideas did not fit with a commonly held consensus among climate scientists. Up until the beginning of the millennium, most of them believed that Antarctica — the Earth's fifth largest but least populated continent — was a stable bulwark against changes in ice. Today, American palaeontologist and evolutionary biologist Neil Shubin describes Mercer as 'an amazing field geologist'. 'Mercer said the world is at a tipping point, and if we keep increasing global temperatures, we are setting ourselves up for dramatic changes with the ice in West Antarctica, and by extension, global sea levels,' the 64-year-old scientist explains from his office at the University of Chicago — where he is currently a professor of Organismal Biology and Anatomy. 'Mercer's peers thought Antarctica was very stable. Unfortunately, though, as research continued over time, it turns out Mercer was probably right. 'Three decades ago in Antarctica, we were losing, say, 80 gigatons of ice per year. But now we are losing about 280 gigatons per year.' Moving ice shapes the world Shubin's book examines how moving ice shapes the world. He notes, for instance, that polar regions encompass 8% of the total surface of the Earth and that almost 70% of all the planet's fresh water is frozen in ice. Expeditions to the polar regions are now a matter of urgency. 'The Arctic is heating five to seven times faster than the rest of the globe, and there are now open spaces of water where ice was previously,' he says. 'In Antarctica, melting ice is less visible to the naked eye.' In fact, Antarctica is witnessing the slowest temperature rise on Earth, but for complex reasons. As the oceans warm, Antarctica's surface temperatures stay relatively cool. This disparity in temperature amplifies a wind current, which swirls around Antarctica and carries 170 times more water than all of the Earth's rivers combined. With that water comes heat. The change in the circumpolar current brings more warm seawater to the coast of Antarctica, causing the coastal glaciers to melt from below, where the ice meets the ocean. The glaciers then fragment and collapse into the sea. Shrinking glaciers, of course, mean rising seas. The British Antarctic Survey along with the US Antarctic Program, have collaborated on research to help us understand those glaciers in West Antarctica. 'Specifically, with robots looking underneath the ice, and with satellite images, and with studies of the ice, both in the air and in the water. They confirm that in West Antarctica there is a lot to worry about,' says Shubin. Drilling in ice in Antarctica has also shed light on another idea geographers and scientists have been speculating about since the mid-19th century: Underneath the ice of the region sit entire worlds sealed off from Earth's surface. We now have a detailed understanding of these hidden worlds, via decades of research that has been carried out by scientists from numerous countries at Lake Vostok. The largest subglacial lake in Antarctica has a surface area of more than 14,000sq km and a depth of more than 800m. Glaciologists have reasons to believe that Lake Vostok may have been separated from the world above for over 15m years, Shubin explains. During the late 1990s, a group of Russian, French, and American scientists set off on an international science trip to drill a core to get down to Lake Vostok. On that occasion, though, the team stopped drilling about 400ft above where they expected liquid water. But even at that depth, the ice samples they recovered displayed special properties. John Priscu, from Montana State University, later received one of those samples. Putting them under high-powered microscopes, Priscu surmised that there were about 100,000 microbes per millilitre of ice. Those findings inspired Priscu to hunt for more life elsewhere in Antarctica. For logistical reasons Priscu decided to move his research to Lake Whillans: A subglacial lake in Antarctica that sits 480km from the South Pole. Using a drill sterilised by UV light and hydrogen peroxide, Priscu and his team sampled the waters of Lake Whillans, which were then examined back in the lab. DNA sequencing revealed nearly 4,000 species living in Lake Whillans under the ice. The subglacial microbes were diverse, thriving, and part of a complex web of ecological interactions. 'These are living creatures that have been separated from the sun, for millennia, if not millions of years,' Shubin explains. And these creatures exchange information with other lakes underneath. 'We don't know much about these worlds and how these creatures survive. There is probably a wide diversity of microbial lifeforms that we can barely imagine under there.' If life can thrive and survive under the ice in Antarctica, it might also be possible it can thrive in extraterrestrial environments too. Shubin mentions Europa, the fourth largest of Jupiter's 95 moons, and, Saturn's moon, Enceladus: A small icy world that has geyser-like jets spewing water vapour and ice particles into space. 'Both of these places have ice on the exterior and fresh water underneath the ice, which make them two promising candidates for places in our solar system to expect microbial life,' Shubin explains. 'Understanding life under the ice in Antarctica gives us a model to think possible alien life outside our own planets.' Closer to home, however, there are more urgent matters to be concerned about, Shubin warns. Global warming means our planet is undoubtedly entering an era of uncertainty. Shubin cites one scientific study which estimates that sea levels could rise as much as 10ft globally in the next century, if the planet warms more than three degrees Fahrenheit. 'Geological engineering is one option we might have to peruse if we cannot, as [a global community] get carbon emissions under control,' says Shubin. 'But the reality is that the choices we make for the future will make a difference. Not just for us. But for future generations. 'We need to keep global conversations alive and international science collaboration going,' Shubin concludes. 'Antarctica and the Arctic are warming, and polar treaties are straining as fast as ice melts and species disappear. 'Our fragile window for understanding the cosmos, the planet, and ourselves is closing, so we need to act now.' Read More Book review: Revealing the dangers and thrill of polar exploration leaves a deadly chill

Over €10m knocked off asking price of Sandyford office block
Over €10m knocked off asking price of Sandyford office block

Irish Independent

time16-07-2025

  • Irish Independent

Over €10m knocked off asking price of Sandyford office block

It had been part of Colony's Irish portfolio, after the US company became involved with four Dublin properties owned by UK developer U+I. Colony was led by Tom Barrack, a close confidante of American president Donald Trump, and was one of the first US companies to enter the Irish property market after the financial crash when it teamed up with Irish developer Johnny Ronan. Colony helped finance the Ronan family's property interests out of the National Asset Management Agency (Nama), including Connaught House on Burlington Road in Dublin and Bewley's coffee house on Grafton Street. It also was a partner with Ronan Group Real Estate (RGRE) on the development of Facebook's planned headquarters at Fibonacci Square in Ballsbridge. However, Colony decided to exit the Irish market and wrap its share of Irish joint ventures into a sale of $2.7bn of international real-estate assets to New York-based Fortress Investment Group. Colony had been also been involved with U+I in four of its Irish properties through a firm called Spectre whose properties included The Hive, Carrisbrook House, Ballsbridge, and Donnybrook House. In 2022 Colony sought €34.4m for The Hive but failed to secure it. Subsequently Grant Thornton was appointed receiver to the building, and it has now put the property on the market at the reduced price. Extending to 6,785 sq m across four floors, The Hive was comprehensively refurbished by U+I in 2019. Agent HWBC says that its €24.2m guide price would deliver a net initial yield of 7pc, with the potential to exceed 8pc through upcoming lease events and income growth. The building generates annual rental income of €1.95m, with a weighted average unexpired lease term of 8.2 years to expiry, underpinned by what is described as a high-calibre tenant line-up. Existing tenants include Grafton Group, the owner of Woodies and Chadwicks; NTR plc, a quoted infrastructure investment company managing over €3bn in sustainable assets; and Cubic Telecom, a software firm valued at over €900m. The building is 86pc let and the agents are quoting €28 per sq ft for the remaining vacant space. It also comes with 114 car parking spaces, 96 cycle spaces and 12 EV charging stations.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store