logo
How 'high warmth' parenting works as shouting found to damage children's brains

How 'high warmth' parenting works as shouting found to damage children's brains

Yahoo30-04-2025
The Easter holidays are over for another year, and many parents may be breathing a sigh of relief at no longer having to juggle work and childcare. School breaks can be a pressure cooker for family tensions, and it's not uncommon for parents to resort to shouting when children act out and misbehave.
But while raising your voice might feel effective in the moment, new research suggests it could have lasting effects on children's wellbeing. Brain scans from University College London reveal that regular exposure to shouting can 'reshape' developing brains, increasing the risk of poor mental health later in life.
These findings were recently presented to MPs in Westminster by a panel of child development experts, in an event organised by the charity Words Matter.
The researchers warned that children subjected to verbal aggression may also struggle to experience joy and build healthy friendships, especially if they're shouted at on a regular basis.
In the UK, shouting is a common behaviour in many households, with two in five children experiencing verbal abuse, and over half of kids exposed to it weekly.
Shouting can range from raised voices to more extreme scolding, threatening and insulting from parents. The World Health Organization classifies the latter as emotional abuse, categorising it as a key form of violence against young people.
Experts have previously warned that regular shouting can have long-term effects on kids, increasing the risk of anxiety, depression, eating disorders, sleep problems, addiction and self-harm.
Studies have even suggested that verbal abuse may be as damaging as physical or sexual abuse, with one 2023 research paper linking shouting at with a greater risk of self-harm, drug use and imprisonment later in life.
If you're a parent, you'll probably familiar with this scenario: your child ignores your last warning not to misbehave, and the next thing you know, you're yelling at the top of your voice.
But parenting coach Olivia Edwards says that disciplining kids in this way rarely works, as it models shouting as a conflict-resolution strategy, and can often escalate small issues into full blown family rows.
"When parents shout, it's usually because they've been triggered into a fight-or-flight state," she notes. "For many, this response is learned from their own childhood experiences, which can lead to default reactions when children misbehave.
"We often revert to what we experienced growing up - how our parents reacted when we misbehaved," she reveals. "That's why the gentle parenting movement is so important, as it encourages us to parent differently from how we were raised, requiring us to rewire old habits."
Edwards says the first step is for parents is to build awareness, recognising when shouting is happening. From here, they can try the following tips to get back on track with calm and effective communication:
Between school runs, homework, cooking and bedtimes routines, parents rarely get the time to rest and reset their nervous system - the body's ability to maintain balance and adapt to stress. In this state, small frictions can easily tip parents into losing their cool.
"We all have triggers, but on the flip side, there are glimmers too - habits or hobbies that can take us out of a fight and flight response and into a relaxed rest and digest state," Edwards note.
Glimmers could be anything from going for a walk in nature, stepping outside for a few restorative breaths or listening to calming music - any activity and ritual that helps you feel calm and in control.
Shouting might feel like the right thing to do in the moment, but it rarely achieves the right result.
'When a parent's old wounds are triggered, they tend to go into a state of needing to shout to gain control. Or they look at punishments, such as threats or removal of privileges," says Edwards.
"But we want to avoid using both of these tactics," she warns, "because it's not really teaching children the value in feeling and moving past their emotions."
Rather than shouting, Edwards encourages what she calls a 'high warmth' parenting style.
"Many parents think gentle parenting means being lenient, but children actually need clear limits," she explains. "Their nervous systems feel safer when they know where the boundaries are, and that you're confident in holding them as their parent."
The goal is to be consistent, but also compassionate. "When a child tests a limit, it's important to hold it while offering understanding," says Edwards.
For example, you might say there won't be ice cream at the park today because they've already had sugary treats. "If they get upset, that's okay," she says. "It's normal for children to have big emotions. and we don't want to shut those down with shouting."
Instead, parents should stay calm and confident. "You can say, 'I know you're disappointed,' while still sticking to the decision."
After setting the boundary and validating their feelings, Edwards advises against getting drawn into negotiation with kids. "Sometimes it helps to gently redirect their energy, shifting the focus to something else to move past the tantrum," she says.
"It's fine to distract or move on, but only after you've acknowledged how they feel, because that's how they build emotional resilience over time."
While calming practices can take the edge off a particularly testing day, parents who find themselves blowing up regularly may need therapy to tackle unhealed wounds, so they can show up for their children without easily getting upset.
"If the root causes of those triggers are inherent feelings like, 'my child isn't listening to me,' 'that felt really disrespectful,' or 'my voice isn't being heard,' a qualified therapist or coach can help you understand the root cause of these emotions," says Edwards.
No parent is perfect, and Edwards says it's important to recognise when things didn't go as planned.
"For example, you might feel annoyed after shouting, but if you say, 'I'm sorry I shouted, but if you'd just listened…' the apology isn't valid, because it's still blaming the child. An effective repair means owning your mistake genuinely and not passing the blame," she says.
"Instead, you might say, 'I'm really sorry I shouted at you earlier. I was angry, and it's okay for me to feel angry, but it's not okay that I let that anger come out as shouting.'
"It's important to frame it this way so that the child understands anger is a natural emotion, but it's how we handle it that counts."
She adds that it's helpful to check in with children's feelings after shouting, as even if the comments weren't aimed directly at them, it can still be unsettling for them to witness.
Read more on parenting:
How much sleep do teenagers actually need? An expert explains (Yahoo Life UK, 6-min read)
What being the youngest, oldest or middle child could mean for your personality (Yahoo Life UK, 4-min read)
My 4-year-old son was too anxious to go to school for a year (Yahoo Life UK, 5-min read)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Southern China hit by outbreak of mosquito-borne infection chikungunya
Southern China hit by outbreak of mosquito-borne infection chikungunya

San Francisco Chronicle​

time6 hours ago

  • San Francisco Chronicle​

Southern China hit by outbreak of mosquito-borne infection chikungunya

China is experiencing an outbreak of chikungunya, a mosquito-borne infection, with thousands of cases reported in the south. Chikungunya fever cases jumped to 4,014 on Friday, representing a rapid rise in numbers since authorities started tracking cases two weeks ago, according to public records released by health departments in districts in Foshan. The city in China's southern province Guangdong has been heavily impacted by the surge in infections. The chikungunya outbreak remains 'quite severe,' Sun Yang, deputy director of the National Center for Disease Control and Prevention, said at a news conference on Wednesday in Foshan. Chikungunya is spread to people by the bites of infected mosquitoes. It causes fever and severe joint pain, but deaths are rare, according to the World Health Organization. The Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention has issued various advisories on how to prevent chikungunya fever and dengue fever, a similar disease also spread by mosquitoes. Physical protection barriers, such as screen doors, mosquito nets for beds and mosquito repellent on exposed skin, was recommended. It said that the epidemic was 'imported' without specifying from where. The Chinese agency also called for people who have symptoms like fever, rash and joint pain to see a doctor. Shunde district in Foshan, where 90% of the cases are located, is famous for its Cantonese food, and sees many visitors each year. Patients who tested positive for chikungunya fever stayed in hospital beds covered by mosquito nets, according to photos shown on state-run broadcaster CCTV. Local media reports said on Thursday that local authorities had almost doubled the number of mosquito-proof isolation beds to 7,220 to meet the growing demand. Authorities in Guangdong are urging residents to make sure there's no standing water in their homes, such as in flowerpots, coffee machines or spare bottles. The Health Commission in Foshan stated on Thursday that a fine of up to 10,000 yuan ($1,400) could be applied if violations are found. The Beijing CDC said on Tuesday that the city occasionally experiences imported cases of chikungunya fever. There are two chikungunya vaccines that have received regulatory approvals in several countries and/or have been recommended for use in populations at risk, but the vaccines are neither widely available nor in widespread use, according to WHO.

Southern China hit by outbreak of mosquito-borne infection chikungunya
Southern China hit by outbreak of mosquito-borne infection chikungunya

Hamilton Spectator

time6 hours ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

Southern China hit by outbreak of mosquito-borne infection chikungunya

China is experiencing an outbreak of chikungunya, a mosquito-borne infection, with thousands of cases reported in the south. Chikungunya fever cases jumped to 4,014 on Friday, representing a rapid rise in numbers since authorities started tracking cases two weeks ago, according to public records released by health departments in districts in Foshan. The city in China's southern province Guangdong has been heavily impacted by the surge in infections. The chikungunya outbreak remains 'quite severe,' Sun Yang, deputy director of the National Center for Disease Control and Prevention, said at a news conference on Wednesday in Foshan. Chikungunya is spread to people by the bites of infected mosquitoes. It causes fever and severe joint pain, but deaths are rare, according to the World Health Organization. The Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention has issued various advisories on how to prevent chikungunya fever and dengue fever, a similar disease also spread by mosquitoes. Physical protection barriers, such as screen doors, mosquito nets for beds and mosquito repellent on exposed skin, was recommended. It said that the epidemic was 'imported' without specifying from where. The Chinese agency also called for people who have symptoms like fever, rash and joint pain to see a doctor. Shunde district in Foshan, where 90% of the cases are located, is famous for its Cantonese food, and sees many visitors each year. Patients who tested positive for chikungunya fever stayed in hospital beds covered by mosquito nets, according to photos shown on state-run broadcaster CCTV. Local media reports said on Thursday that local authorities had almost doubled the number of mosquito-proof isolation beds to 7,220 to meet the growing demand. Authorities in Guangdong are urging residents to make sure there's no standing water in their homes, such as in flowerpots, coffee machines or spare bottles. The Health Commission in Foshan stated on Thursday that a fine of up to 10,000 yuan ($1,400) could be applied if violations are found. The Beijing CDC said on Tuesday that the city occasionally experiences imported cases of chikungunya fever. There are two chikungunya vaccines that have received regulatory approvals in several countries and/or have been recommended for use in populations at risk, but the vaccines are neither widely available nor in widespread use, according to WHO. China had its first chikungunya spike in 2010 with 253 cases in Dongguan, a nearby city in the same province, according to the Guangdong provincial CDC. Several cases were found in years since then, but they weren't widespread. The country's first case was imported in 1987, according to research papers and media reports.

Here's How Greece Is Tackling Its Childhood Obesity Epidemic
Here's How Greece Is Tackling Its Childhood Obesity Epidemic

Medscape

time10 hours ago

  • Medscape

Here's How Greece Is Tackling Its Childhood Obesity Epidemic

The Mediterranean diet is rich in whole foods and healthy fats, including vegetables, fruits, whole grains, nuts, fish, and olive oil. It has numerous health benefits largely centered around heart health, weight management, and cognitive function and is associated with a lower incidence of childhood obesity. Despite this, Greece now has one of Europe's highest rates of childhood obesity. In 2019, the Hellenic Statistical Authority found that 37.5% of children aged 2-14 years were overweight or obese. In 2022, the World Health Organization's (WHO's) European Regional Obesity Report ranked Greece among the top positions in Europe for childhood overweight and obesity: third among children younger than 5 years (1 in 8), second among those aged 5-9 years (38.5%), and first among those aged 10-19 years (32%). So what has gone wrong? Shifting Diet and Lifestyle Clinical dietician and nutritionist Eleni Pavlidou, PhD, who specializes in obesity and eating disorders, said that lifestyle and cultural shifts have ultimately led to the 'gradual loss of connection with the Mediterranean way of eating.' Eleni Pavlidou, PhD Her recent research found that more than 40% of 5188 preschool children had low compliance to the Mediterranean diet, with traditional diets increasingly replaced by ultraprocessed foods. Another recent study found that ultraprocessed foods accounted for 39.8% of the total daily calorie intake of 443 Greek children with an average age of 9 years. 'Children are increasingly consuming snacks high in sugar, saturated fat, and salt….Many families don't have the time or energy for traditional cooking, and convenience foods are everywhere, and they're heavily marketed to children,' she told Medscape Medical News . 'At the same time, economic pressures have made some families rely on cheaper processed foods that are energy-dense but nutrient-poor.' This, she said, was coupled with a major cultural shift: fewer shared family meals, less cooking at home, and less emphasis on seasonal, local ingredients. Greece's Alternative (Deputy) Minister of Health, Eirini Agapidaki, MSc, agreed. Eirini Agapidaki, MSc 'The community-centered everyday life that was the main societal model for decades in Greece has altered to a more parallel living model,' she told Medscape Medical News . 'Citizens live in the same building but have never met. Children coexist in the schoolroom but do not share a feeling of belonging to the school community. Healthy nutrition is not just about individual dietary choices but building social relationships.' Action Against Childhood Obesity In 2023, the Greek Ministry of Health, in collaboration with the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), launched a national action plan to reduce the childhood obesity rate to 24.5% by the end of 2025. It aimed to do this by implementing targeted interventions in schools, at health services, and in the wider community, while simultaneously trying to change the environment that leads to obesity. The initiative has included, among other interventions, integrating nutritional education programs into school curricula, healthy cooking lessons, and physical activity opportunities in the community. It has also involved free, early screening for obesity and online dietician sessions supported by psychologists, pediatricians, endocrinologists, and physical activity educators. 'A family can attend 12 online sessions over a period of 6 months, making this service fully accessible to people living in remote areas,' Agapidaki said. 'Families receive personalized guidance to improve their daily habits, as well as a tailored plan considering the needs of each child and family.' As part of this, UNICEF child protection specialist responsible for coordinating the initiative, Antigoni Angelaki, MA, explained that pediatricians have been guided on how best to support a family's nutrition. Resources have been developed in collaboration with experts on behaviors that help prevent childhood obesity. These are being disseminated through a network of universities set up across the country, she told Medscape Medical News . Greece has one of the highest child obesity rates in Europe, largely due to a shift away from the Mediterranean diet. But equally important to addressing what children eat is providing them ample opportunity to partake in physical activity, she added. 'It's not just the diet that children follow, but it's also about how much opportunity they have for physical activity,' she said. Angelaki explained that this is the first program at the European level that has looked at all the different drivers of obesity. 'This program is looking at how we can reform the reality on the ground. Perhaps we can increase the number of physical activity hours done at school or make schools accessible in the afternoons because many municipalities don't have spaces available for physical activity.' Pavlidou said this was crucial, as increased screen time, safety concerns, and a lack of public spaces have all contributed to the obesity epidemic. Changes to Legislation In 2010, the World Health Assembly adopted the WHO set of recommendations on the marketing of foods and nonalcoholic beverages to children, urging countries to reduce the impact of marketing of highly processed foods and beverages that are high in fat, sugar, and salt on kids. In 2022, the 'Greek Pledge,' a voluntary initiative where food and beverage companies commit to improving how they advertise to children younger than 13 years, was launched. It's unclear what impact this has had. Angelaki said UNICEF was reviewing current advertising legislation to identify gaps. One important step, Agapidaki said, is that Greece's National Nutrition Committee revised the legal framework on canteen guidelines to ensure they only provide nutritious snacks and meals. 'According to the latest national data available, we see that our approach is already having meaningful changes in children's behaviors, especially when parents are engaged,' she said. She did not offer additional data on obesity rates. Applying Lessons Learned More Broadly There are now hopes that the program will be expanded to other parts of Europe. 'Greece is no longer just trying to address the main factors contributing to childhood obesity — we are generating public health solutions that are also meaningful and efficient for other countries,' Angelaki said. 'Several countries have reached out to request guidance on replicating our program. We've been invited to share our tools and frameworks, especially around digital early detection, school and community integration, and whole-system governance.' Pavlidou welcomed new approaches to tackle the epidemic but warned 'We need more.' 'We need stronger policies on marketing to children, better food labeling, nutrition education schools, and greater support for families to access healthy options,' she said. 'Despite the challenges, I remain optimistic. The Mediterranean diet is not just a way of eating — it's a cultural heritage rooted in balance, seasonality, and community. If we invest in educating families, empowering children, and building healthier environments, we can absolutely reverse these trends.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store