Families of 737 crash victims urge rejection of Boeing deal
NEW YORK – Family members of people killed in two fatal crashes of Boeing's 737 Max jets urged a federal judge to reject a proposed deal the company reached with US prosecutors that would allow the planemaker to avoid a criminal charge.
Lawyers for 15 families argued Boeing should stand trial for criminal conspiracy as the government had originally planned, to hold the company more accountable for the deaths of 346 people, according to a court filing on June 18. Some family members asked the judge to appoint a special prosecutor to oversee the case.
'The conspiracy charge against Boeing has been pending now for more than four years,' the families' lawyers said. 'Boeing has admitted all the facts necessary to prove it is guilty. And yet, the government now moves to dismiss the charge.' They added, 'It is difficult to imagine a case more deserving of a public trial than this one.'
The US Justice Department in May asked US District Judge Reed O'Connor in Fort Worth to dismiss the case as part of a proposed settlement reached with Boeing. Under the deal, the planemaker agreed to pay more than US$1.1 billion (S$1.41 billion) in fees and fines, while taking steps to strengthen internal quality and safety measures.
In return, the company will avoid criminal prosecution.
Prosecutors have argued that the deal 'secures meaningful accountability' and ensures Boeing faces penalties and oversight, an outcome they say would not be guaranteed if they took the case to trial.
Asked to comment on the relatives' objections, a Boeing representative pointed to a May 29 company statement. 'Boeing is committed to complying with its obligations under this resolution, which include a substantial additional fine and commitments to further institutional improvements and investments,' the company said.
In June 18's filing, lawyers for family members who oppose the agreement said it would essentially allow the company to 'buy its way out of a criminal conviction'.
The families also claimed language in the deal would obligate the government to not prosecute Boeing even if Mr O'Connor rejects the motion to dismiss the case, which would skirt full judicial review.
'If this court approves the parties' maneuver in this widely publicised case, then this unprecedented approach will likely become the blueprint for all future dismissal motions in federal criminal prosecutions,' they said in the filing.
In a separate filing, some family members asked the judge to appoint an independent prosecutor to 'restore integrity to these proceedings and ensure that justice – rather than politics – guides the resolution of this matter.'
Relatives of crash victims have spent years fighting for harsher penalties for Boeing following the two fatal crashes of its 737 Max jet in 2018 and 2019. Both crashes were linked to a flawed flight control system on the jets.
The families said the fatal Air India crash earlier this month involving a Boeing 787 Dreamliner shows that 'the stakes for aviation safety are very high'. The cause of the crash remains under investigation.
To be sure, some families support the settlement. But those who want Boeing to go to trial said the company had dangled money 'in front of the families, apparently hoping that it will lead them to back off their efforts to hold Boeing accountable for killing their loved ones. And Boeing's offer appears to have had the desired effect, at least with respect to a few families'.
If Mr O'Connor agrees to a dismissal, it would end the long-running criminal case against Boeing over the crashes. But it would also mark a notable reversal in the proceedings. Just in 2024, Boeing had agreed to plead guilty to the pending criminal conspiracy charge under a deal that was ultimately rejected by Mr O'Connor.
Under the new settlement Boeing will admit to the underlying accusation of 'conspiracy to obstruct and impede the lawful operation of the Federal Aviation Administration Aircraft Evaluation Group,' but that admission does not constitute a guilty plea.
The government said it could refile criminal charges against the company if Boeing is accused of violating the terms of the two-agreement. Some family members dispute that claim, saying the statute of limitations has already expired.
The agreement requires Boeing to pay a total of US$1.1 billion in assorted fines and fees. The total includes:
US$487.2 million for a criminal penalty, half of which the company already paid to the government during an earlier phase of the case
US$444.5 million for a new 'crash-victims beneficiaries fund' that will be divided evenly by crash victim
US$455 million in investments to bolster its compliance, safety and quality programs
Boeing would be required to retain a so-called independent compliance consultant to oversee its efforts to improve the effectiveness of its anti-fraud compliance and ethics program. The consultant will be expected to make recommendations for improvements and report their findings directly to the government. BLOOMBERG
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Independent Singapore
2 days ago
- Independent Singapore
SIA CEO's annual pay fell 13.5% to S$7m despite record profit
Photo: Facebook/Singapore Airlines SINGAPORE: Singapore Airlines (SIA) chief executive officer Goh Choon Phong's annual salary fell by 13.5% to S$7.01 million for the financial year ended March 31. According to Singapore Business Review, Mr Goh's pay package included a base salary of S$1.46 million, S$3.12 million in bonuses, and S$2.44 million in shares and other benefits. In July last year, Mr Goh received a salary of S$8.11 million, 20.5% higher than his salary the previous year , thanks to a post-pandemic travel boom. Mr Goh's annual salary dropped this year even though the group recorded a net profit of S$2.78 billion for the year ended March 31, up from S$2.68 billion the year before. Eligible SIA staff will also see slimmer takings with a 7.45-month bonus for FY2025, slightly lower than the 7.94 months awarded the previous year. The group's profit was boosted by a one-off non-cash gain of S$1 billion after the Air India–Vistara merger was completed in November 2024. See also DBS: S-REITs will continue to be net outperformers in 2024 In November, Singapore Business Review reported that SIA completed the Vistara–Air India merger, giving it a 25.1% stake in the expanded Air India. The group, which includes budget airline Scoot, also posted record revenues after carrying a record 39.4 million passengers. However, the group's operating profit fell 37% as passenger yields declined amid growing competition, though both remained above pre-pandemic levels. In a letter to shareholders, SIA's chairman Peter Seah credited SIA's performance to effective cost management through the company's digital and staff productivity initiatives amid rising expenses. He noted, 'In a year marked by rising geopolitical tensions, supply chain constraints, cost inflation, and an increasingly uncertain macroeconomic landscape due to global tariff wars, the Singapore Airlines (SIA) Group successfully delivered another impressive performance.' Looking ahead, Mr Seah added, 'While aviation landscape is rapidly evolving, the SIA Group is in a strong position to not only withstand these changes but to shape them.' /TISG Read also: Sheng Siong CEO Lim Hock Chee's FY2024 pay rises 20.6% to S$7.06M on bigger bonus See also What We Demand in Return for Fare Hikes
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
India denies entry to UN aviation investigator in Air India crash probe, say sources
NEW DELHI - India would not allow a UN investigator to join a probe of a crashed Air India jet that some safety experts had criticised for delays in analysis of crucial black box data, two senior sources familiar with the matter told Reuters. Earlier this week, the United Nations aviation agency took the unusual step of offering India one of its investigators to provide assistance following the Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner crash killing 260 people in Ahmedabad on June 12. Previously, the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) has deployed investigators to help with certain probes, such as the downing of a Malaysian plane in 2014 and a Ukrainian jetliner in 2020, but those times the agency had been asked for assistance. ICAO had asked for the investigator who was in India to be given observer status, but Indian authorities refused the offer, the sources said. The news was first reported on June 26 by the Indian news channel Times Now. India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB), which is leading the probe into the world's deadliest aviation accident in a decade, did not return a request for comment. ICAO was not immediately available for comment. India's civil aviation ministry said on June 26 that investigators downloaded flight recorder data around two weeks after the crash. Previously, safety experts had questioned a lack of information about the probe, including the status of the combined black box unit recovered on June 13, along with a second set that was found on June 16. A police officer standing in front of the wreckage of the Air India aircraft that crashed during take-off from an airport in Ahmedabad, India on June 12. PHOTO: REUTERS Questions were also raised on whether the recorders would be read in India or in the US since the National Transportation Safety Board is participating in the investigation. The Indian government held only one press conference on the incident, and no questions were taken. Under international rules known throughout the industry by their legal name 'Annex 13', the decision of where to read flight recorders should be made immediately in case the evidence obtained could avert future tragedies. Earlier this week, an Indian aviation ministry official who declined to be named said the department has been 'following all the ICAO protocols.' The official added that media representatives have made updates on important events. Most air crashes are caused by multiple factors, with a preliminary report expected about 30 days after the accident. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
CNA
4 days ago
- CNA
SIA CEO's annual pay falls nearly 14% to S$7 million despite record profit
SINGAPORE: The chief executive officer of Singapore Airlines (SIA) Goh Choon Phong received an annual salary of S$7.01 million (US$5.47 million) for the latest financial year ended Mar 31, according to the national carrier's annual report released on Wednesday (Jun 25). This marked a 13.5 per cent drop from the S$8.11 million salary package that he took home in the previous year. Mr Goh's annual remuneration for FY2024/25 comprises a base pay of S$1.46 million, bonuses of S$3.12 million, as well as shares and benefits amounting to S$2.44 million. SIA reported a record annual net profit of S$2.78 billion for the financial year, up from S$2.68 billion a year earlier. The airline attributed this to a one-off gain of about S$1.1 billion from the merger of Air India and Vistara. Its operating profit fell 37 per cent from a year earlier to S$1.71 billion, as passenger yields - a proxy for airfares - dropped by 5.5 per cent due to stiff competition as airlines globally added capacity. Nevertheless, SIA rewarded eligible employees with a profit-sharing bonus of 7.45 months. This was slightly below the 7.94 months' worth of profit-sharing bonus it issued in the previous year, the highest in the airline's history. In a letter to shareholders, chairman Peter Seah said the airline had delivered 'another impressive performance' despite a year marked by rising geopolitical tensions, supply chain constraints, inflation and an increasingly uncertain macroeconomic landscape due to a global tariff war. 'While aviation landscape is rapidly evolving, the SIA Group is in a strong position to not only withstand these changes but to shape them,' he wrote in the annual report.
