Flood-damaged school furious and frustrated with 'crazy' timing of ERO report
Nuhaka School has flooded twice since February 2023, and while it waits for the entire school to be rebuilt, the more than 100 students have been taking their lessons at a nearby Mormon Church.
The entire school had to be rebuilt after flooding twice in the past few years.
Photo:
Supplied
Last week, as the school was packing up to move back to its new buildings, ERO conducted a review.
ERO has admitted to RNZ that it got it wrong, and is apologising to Nuhaka School about the timing of its review.
From the outside it looks like a regular church, but step through the doors and every room is crammed with school tables and chairs, whiteboards and stationary supplies. The floor is covered in colourful blue mats and among the boxes of sporting trophies and rows of school bags hanging on the wall, framed paintings of Jesus peer out.
The Mormon church where children have been going to school.
Photo:
RNZ/Jimmy Ellingham
As children help carry boxes out to the moving truck, Principal Raelene McFarlane tells RNZ how hard the past couple of years have been, and the struggle to get more resources.
"This has just been a fight. It didn't need to be this hard. I didn't need to lose staff through burnout," she said.
For most of the past 2.5 years, the students have been learning in makeshift classrooms - using the hall stage, offices, and meeting rooms to try and regain some sense of normalcy for the kids.
"The crowding is huge. It got quite heartbreaking at times when we had kids who had to crawl under tables to get out to the loo and you know, and if they didn't make it that was really upsetting for them, it was upsetting for staff and whanau.
"Without space you can't teach a quiet group, because the noise is just really compacted," said McFarlane.
Nuhaka School principal Raelene McFarlane.
Photo:
RNZ / Nick Monro
She said they were just weeks away from moving back into their newly rebuilt school site, when the Education Review Office, known as ERO, decided it was time to conduct a review.
McFarlane begged them to delay it by 10 weeks, so they would be settled back in their school buildings, but told RNZ that ERO would only shift the review by three weeks, to the last few days of term when they were still in the church.
"When I contacted them and said 'we are literally going to have boxes walking out the door, we can't even do a lesson for you, that's crazy'. We were just told that they'll be sensitive and that it was going ahead," she said.
Wairoa mayor Craig Little
Photo:
RNZ / Nick Monro
The local iwi and mayor also tried to get the ERO review moved, but mayor Craig Little said he was astonished when ERO went ahead with its inspection.
"These kids have absolutely gone through hell and back. And so now they're moving finally, thank God for the Mormon church. They've been in there and they're moving back to their school. But it's really hard and would you believe let's chuck an ERO report the same time they're moving.
"It's just crazy. I've been on school boards and the ERO report is the biggest thing that can disrupt your school ever. And you get one shot at it and everybody is under stress. ERO should be saying, 'hey, let's just sort of forget about that at the moment'," said Craig.
Flooding at Nuhaka School from Cyclone Gabrielle in 2023.
Photo:
Supplied
Instead, ERO visited the school last week while it was still operating out of the church buildings.
"At least come and see us in the right place - do the right compliance checks on the right buildings - that would make more sense to me.
"We don't understand, we feel pretty much... we don't know if it's targeted," said McFarlane.
ERO declined RNZ's request for an interview, but spokesperson Shelley Booysen told RNZ that where possible, they did their best to be flexible to meet the needs of schools.
"In this case, the School Review team made the decision to go ahead with the review following a number of rescheduled dates.
"In hindsight, the school's request for an extension during their move and until they are more settled into their new building was not unreasonable. We should have delayed the review. We got this one wrong and we sincerely apologise to the school and the community," she said.
ERO said it wished Nuhaka School 'all the best' in their new school building.
Flooding at Nuhaka School from Cyclone Gabrielle in 2023.
Photo:
Supplied
But Little worried the damage was already done.
"Why would you do that to people? I'm getting calls from the parents, not only the school teachers, just saying 'hey, we're really worried about what's happening here'.
"These teachers have been enough stress. Let's not put them under anymore," he said.
Nuhaka School will reopen on 14 July for the first day of the new term.
Nuhaka School students.
Photo:
RNZ / Nick Monro
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Weather: Wet winter not over yet for drenched Tasman region
Flooding in Waimea River, Tasman after heavy rain in June 2025. Photo: Samantha Gee / RNZ More wet weather is on the way for the top of the South Island, with MetService again issuing heavy rain warnings for Tasman - a region still recovering from recent storms. A weather front, moving east across the country, is expected to bring up to 180mm of rain to the region. There were orange rain warnings in place for Tasman east and south of Motueka, Nelson and Marlborough west of Havelock, and north of the Wairau River, through to Tuesday evening. Meteorologist Mmathapelo Makgabutlane told Morning Report on Monday there was a moderate chance of those upgrading to red. "We've just been under this period of those weather fronts moving through bringing heavy rain as well as strong winds. "And as we saw with the last one, those rainfall amounts maybe weren't the biggest, but they still had the potential to bring those impacts." Heavy rain and flooding hit the area in June , and the ground was still sodden when more rain arrived a week later, prompting evacutations , then again later in the July. "It is really tied to how much rain we're expecting and what the expected impact from that rain will be," Makgabutlane explained. Meteorologist Mmathapelo Makgabutlane. Photo: Screenshot "Even if it doesn't get upgraded to a red warning that area is still quite sensitive, looking at what's happened over the last couple of weeks, and definitely still want to keep a very close eye on." Forecasters should have a better idea later on Monday as more information was collected. "Tuesday is the day when we're expecting that front to move through. That warning starts around [2am], so yeah, that overnight early morning Tuesday and throughout the day as that weather system passes through." It should clear by the end of the day. In the North Island there were strong wind warnings across Northland, Coromandel and Bay of Plenty expected on Tuesday. Coromandel residents might also get heavy rain, with a high chance of it reaching warning level. A heavy rain warning was already in place for Taranaki Maunga and a heavy rain watch for the central mountain ranges, while strong winds were possible to the south. While it had been for the most part a warm winter, that comfort brought with it wetter conditions. "It's very similar to what we've been seeing over the last few weeks, and I'm sure people would have been feeling - apart from last week, it was quite cold last week - but prior to that, it was quite warm or relatively warm for this time of year," Makgabutlane said. "These northerly airflows [are] what we're feeling bringing those warmer temperatures as well as this moist airflow that's been bringing all of this rain."
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Holes in wall designed to keep polluted water out of Lake Rotoiti alarm locals
Large holes have formed in the sides of the Ōhau channel diversion wall, which was constructed to block the flow of more polluted water into Lake Rotoiti. Photo: Supplied There is growing discontent in Rotorua about the state of the Ōhau channel diversion wall, which was meant to protect the pristine waters of Lake Rotoiti. The wall was built in 2008 to divert polluted nutrient-rich water from Lake Rotorua, which otherwise flowed into Lake Rotoiti through a small channel. But the wall is corroding, and locals RNZ spoke to said the Bay of Plenty Regional Council wasn't fixing it fast enough, something the council disputed. Lake Rotoiti is one of the larger lakes in the region, and also one of the most popular. Lakes Water Quality Society chairman John Gifford said the Ōhau diversion wall was expected to last 50 years, but only six years after it went in, corrosion was noticed. Now large holes had opened up, and instead of a diversion wall it was more like a leaky bucket. Lakes Water Quality Society chairman John Gifford, at Lake Rotoiti. Photo: RNZ/ Libby Kirkby-McLeod "With holes in the wall of course there's the opportunity for water to move straight through the wall, contaminate and increase the nutrient-load of Lake Rotoiti and that's just totally inappropriate," Gifford said. However, Bay of Plenty Regional Council lakes operations manager Andy Bruere said it wasn't as bad as it sounded. "The wall is still there. Having some holes in it doesn't mean it's not doing its function," Bruere said. "It's continuing to function, but probably not quite as efficiently as it would if it had no holes in the wall." Lake Rotoiti Photo: RNZ/ Libby Kirkby-McLeod Bruere said that when the wall went in, the water quality of Lake Rotorua was very bad, but that wasn't so much the case now. "It's important to acknowledge that we have made very significant improvements to the water quality in Lake Rotorua and so that makes a difference to the impact of the wall, compared to 2008 when it was put in." This argument isn't very convincing though to locals such as Tim Manning, who wasn't happy with the regional council. "Its job is to keep the diversion going for 50 years and its mandate is environmental. It made me think maybe [Minister for Regional Development] Shane Jones got it right that these regional councils are so far out of touch they maybe shouldn't be there," he said. Manning had lived on Lake Rotoiti for 35 years, and also owned the local hot pools. He said the lake was awful before the diversion wall went in. "There was algal blooms, there was discoloured water, there was smells, there were people being sick," he said. One of the holes in the wall, underwater. Photo: Supplied The difference after the Ōhau diversion wall went in was stunning - for a time. "The last five or six years, every year, it goes backwards. "It's discolouring more, there's more algal blooms cropping up - not quite to the extent it got to 15 years ago - but every year it's getting worse," he said. Both John Gifford and Tim Manning said the regional council was not doing enough to stop Lake Rotoiti from becoming polluted again. But Andy Bruere said that wasn't the case. "We have a strategy around managing the wall which we put in place in 2015, so we are monitoring the corrosion every three years and that is very intensive and detailed monitoring," he said. Bruere pointed out that the council put in a beam to strengthen the wall and was trailing ways to repair the holes. "And then also we are currently looking at a range of options around what could be done to repair the holes and repair the wall in a short-term way or in a long-term way." He said that it was important that any improvements had a positive effect, and the council also needed to consider the level of impact climate change might have in the future. Whether this will satisfy unhappy locals was still to be seen. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Weather: MetService issues wind, rain warnings and watches to start week
MetService said there was a front moving east across the country which was expected to bring heavy rain and strong north to northeast winds. Photo: MetService In a gloomy start to the week several severe weather warnings have been issued, with high winds and heavy rain expected from late Monday into early Wednesday. MetService said there was a front moving east across the country which was expected to bring heavy rain, and strong north to northeast winds. Orange rain warnings were in place for the Tasman region from Motueka westwards, Tasman east and south of Motueka, Nelson and Marlborough west of Havelock and north of the Wairau River, Taranaki Maunga and the ranges of the Westland District. The warning for Tasman from Motueka westwards would be in place from 2am to 6pm on Tuesday, 29 July, and had a moderate chance of upgrading to a red warning. People in the region were to expect between 130mm and 150mm in a strong northerly flow. Rainfall intensities could reach 15 to 20mm per hour, especially from mid-morning until early afternoon, MetService said. Tasman east and south of Motueka, Nelson and Marlborough west of Havelock and north of the Wairau River would be under orange warning from 5am on Tuesday until 9pm, again with a moderate chance of becoming red. There, 100mm to 130 mm of rain in a strong northerly flow was expected, with rainfall intensities of 15mm per hour possible, especially during the afternoon. The Nelson Tasman region has already been gutted by two major floods since late last month and is in an official recovery period. Residents were advised to clear their drains and gutters to prepare for heavy rain, and to avoid low-lying areas and drive cautiously, MetService said. Taranaki Maunga was under orange warning from 7am on Tuesday to 1am Wednesday, while the ranges of Westland District were under the same from 1am to 5pm Tuesday. Both warnings had a minimal chance of upgrading to red. Heavy rain watches would also be in place for many regions around the motu between Monday and Tuesday, and in some cases through to Wednesday. Watches for the Coromandel Peninsula, Bay of Plenty and an area about and within 15km east of the Divide from Arthur's Pass to the Dart River had a high chance of upgrading to a warning, while those for for the Central North Island mountains, Northland and Auckland, including Great Barrier Island, all had a moderate chance of upgrading. Along with their rain watches, Northland, Auckland and Great Barrier Island would be under a strong wind watch from Monday evening, with both watches given a moderate chance of upgrading to warnings. Strong wind watches would also be in place for The Coromandel Peninsula, eastern Waikato and the Bay of Plenty for most of Tuesday, and about and south of the mountains and high-country from Taranaki to the Central Plateau from late Monday evening through to Tuesday evening. The Coromandel Peninsula, eastern Waikato and the Bay of Plenty had a moderate chance of upgrading to a warning, while the areas about and south of the mountains and high-country from Taranaki to the Central Plateau had a high chance of upgrading, MetService said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
