Elon Musk's X Corp loses Aussie legal fight against eSafety Commissioner
The US-based social media giant was handed a transparency notice by eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant seeking information about the measures the company was taking to address the proliferation of child sexual exploitation material on its platform.
The reporting notice required Twitter Inc to prepare a report on its compliance with basic online safety expectations between January 2022 and January 2023, with a response required by March 29, 2023.
Twitter Inc was bought by Elon Musk for $44 billion. Picture: Kirsty Wigglesworth / POOL / AFP
X Corp did respond, however the commission argued the reply was inadequate and incomplete, later imposing a $610,500 penalty in September that year.
The company challenged the penalty in the Federal Court of Australia arguing the compliance notice was issued to Twitter a month before that company ceased to exist, when Musk acquired the platform for $44 billion, and therefore was not obliged to respond.
The argument was struck down in October last year by Justice Michael Wheelahan who found the company failed to show that it was not required to respond.
However the case returned before a full bench of the Federal Court in March as the company appealed against Justice Wheelahan's judgment.
The case was heard in the Federal Court in Melbourne. Picture: NewsWire / Penny Stephens
X Corp's barrister Bret Walker SC argued the Judge made a mistake in ruling the obligation to respond adequately to the notice continued after the merger of Twitter Inc and X Corp.
He argued Justice Wheelahan had erred by not finding that at the time of the merger Twitter Inc 'ceased to exist' and the eSafety Commissioner would have been required to issue a new notice.
The case returned to court on Thursday as Justice Bernard Murphy delivered a judgment against the social media company.
Justice Murphy dismissed the appeal and ordered X Corp to pay the eSafety Commissioner's costs.
The full judgment is expected to be published online.
Australia's eSafety Commissioner, Julie Inman Grant, hailed the initial ruling last year. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman
After Justice Wheelahan's initial ruling last year, Commissioner Julie Inman Grant welcomed the Court's decision.
'Early last year, we asked some of the world's biggest technology companies, including Twitter, to report on steps they were taking to comply with the Australian Government's Basic Online Safety Expectations in relation to child sexual exploitation and abuse material on their platforms,' she said.
'Had X Corp's argument been accepted by the Court it could have set the concerning precedent that a foreign company's merger with another foreign company might enable it to avoid regulatory obligations in Australia.'
Read related topics: Elon Musk
Liam Beatty
Journalist
Liam Beatty is a court reporter with NCA NewsWire. He has previously worked in newsrooms in Victoria and Western Australia.
Liam Beatty
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
17 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Amazon technology tapped for regional broadband boost
Regional Australia is set for a connectivity boost, with a tech giant partnering with the National Broadband Network to deliver city-quality internet. About 300,000 rural and regional premises would benefit from Amazon's Project Kuiper filling gaps in the national network from mid-2026. A rival to Elon Musk's Starlink, Kuiper uses low-earth orbit satellite technology to provide internet from space. Government ministers labelled Tuesday morning's announcement as a "game-changer". The Amazon technology will be phased in across the next four years, transitioning from the ageing Sky Muster satellites set to be decommissioned in the early 2030s. "Whether you live in Sydney or on the edge of a regional town (or) on a remote cattle station, every Australian deserves secure, resilient, fast and affordable broadband," NBN Co chief executive Ellie Sweeney said. "Those Sky Muster satellites have served remote Australia with distinction over the last decade, but times change and technology evolves, and Project Kuiper is one of the finest examples we think of what's possible, where innovation meets that ambition." NBN Co will soon begin consulting with stakeholders including regional communities to shape what speeds will be offered and wholesale pricing options. Existing NBN satellite customers might be offered equipment and professional installation at no cost. The Amazon partnership would be funded by NBN Co and won't require any taxpayer funds, Ms Sweeney said. Communications Minister Anika Wells said regional communities would be consulted closely on the transition. "Being more connected means Australians living anywhere will be better off, whether that is working from home, managing a regional business, accessing telehealth, video conferencing or online learning," she said. Kuiper has launched 78 satellites since it kicked off in April, but is set to ramp things up with its initial 'constellation' to feature 3200. Bush advocates, including Better Internet for Rural, Regional and Remote Australia, said it was a major step in the right direction. "For people in the bush, connectivity isn't just convenient, it's critical," BIRRA head Kristy Sparrow said. "Choosing to live in regional Australia should never mean being excluded from accessing reliable and affordable telecommunications ... the deal introduces real consumer choice and brings much-needed competition and affordability." Starlink's satellite service has become increasingly popular in parts of regional Australia, where internet is provided through the slower copper network instead of fibre. But a regional telecommunications review released in December found the foreign ownership of systems such as Starlink raised questions about data security and sovereign risks. It prompted a $3 billion boost to complete NBN service upgrades to about 620,000 homes and businesses.
ABC News
17 minutes ago
- ABC News
Queensland forensics lab in 'sustained crisis', with 'failure in leadership' leading to toxic culture, report finds
A toxic culture at Queensland's state-run forensics lab has exacerbated delays, impacted police investigations and put the community at risk, a second scathing report in as many days has revealed. The troubled Forensic Science Queensland (FSQ) was the subject of two commissions of inquiry in 2022 and 2023, which found evidence may have been compromised and could have led to miscarriages of justice. On Monday, a report led by forensic biologist Dr Kirsty Wright identified that victims of serious crimes like rape and murder were waiting well over a year for vital DNA test results, which should have taken just 10 days. A separate independent report released on Tuesday, led by former Forensic Bureau of Investigations (FBI) expert Dr Bruce Budowle, described the lab as being in "sustained crisis". "The challenges facing FSQ seem to the Review Team to be multi-faceted and include failures in leadership and organisational culture and systemic failures in foundational areas like quality assurance and operational capability and capacity," the report noted. Do you know more about this story or have you been impacted by the DNA delays? We want to hear from you As of this week, about 13,000 DNA samples need to be retested due to failures at the lab. That process is expected to take years to complete and to lead to years-long delays in the courts. Dr Budowle found the backlog was having a "significant negative impact on police investigations and safety". "Delays between a crime and apprehension can be exacerbated, or identification of persons of interest may not occur at all if the investigative process cannot use DNA to develop investigative leads," he wrote. "And thus result in a failure in providing safety and security to the victims, their families, and their communities." Dr Budowle found there was a culture of "poor communication, a lack of empowerment, and resistance to change" at FSQ. "During interviews, many people reported raising operational and/or quality issues and receiving responses like 'it's not your concern' or 'stay in your lane' or 'pick your battles'," he wrote. The report noted significant staffing pressure at the lab, which was short-staffed by 80 full-time employees – something Dr Budowle said was an "extraordinary predicament for any organisation". "The Review Team accepts that finding qualified and experienced management and staff for FSQ is a real challenge given the limited pool of talent in Australia from which to draw and that recruiting to a laboratory in crisis is not an incentive to attract sufficient talent," he wrote. Dr Wright's report also detailed environmental contamination at FSQ, labelling it a "dirty lab". He said this had been raised in quarterly meetings for two years, but these concerns went "unheeded". With a massive backlog of work and a huge number of recommendations from previous inquiries to be implemented, Dr Budowle said management was working in a "reactive, crisis management mode". A clear lack of strategic direction contributed to "instability, resource wastage, staff burnout, and the erosion of staff's trust in management", he wrote. One example of shifting priorities detailed in the report involved a visit from Attorney-General Deb Frecklington. "For example, renovating a currently unused laboratory room became a high priority after a visit by the Attorney-General, who noted that the space should be renovated," the report read. Former director of the facility, Dr Linzi Wilson-Wilde, resigned last month following the identification of "contamination issues". The two reports have made a total of 32 recommendations, which the government said it would consider over the coming months. The government has appointed former NSW police commissioner Mick Fuller to head a new expert team to overhaul operations at FSQ.
ABC News
17 minutes ago
- ABC News
Video allegedly shows police officer pushing woman to the ground outside Bungendore High School during arrest
New South Wales Police says it's reviewing a video circulating on social media of an incident outside a Bungendore school in which an officer appears to push a woman to the ground. The mobile phone footage shows the woman hitting her head on a post as she falls. The ABC has chosen not to publish the video. In a post on social media, the Bungendore woman says she suffered severe concussion, a fractured rib and a cut on her ear during the incident, which allegedly happened on July 22. In a statement, police did not directly address the incident, but said that they were attending Bungendore High School on Majara Street at around 2:50pm that day, after reports a 15-year-old boy was allegedly threatened. Police say that while they were inside a building, another 15-year-old boy allegedly threw a rock at a car driving past, shattering a passenger window. After stopping and getting out of the car, the female driver was then allegedly threatened and chased by the boy and a 32-year-old woman known to the boy. Police and members of the public intervened and the boy was arrested. During the arrest, police allege the woman known to the boy became aggressive and tried to physically intervene. While the boy was being placed into a police car, police allege the woman again threatened the other woman. Police say the senior constable then returned and arrested the 32-year-old woman. The boy has been charged with stalking/intimidating, contravening an AVO, and destroying/damaging property. The woman has been charged with hindering/resisting a police officer in the execution of duty, and two counts of stalking/intimidating. Both were granted bail and are due to face Queanbeyan Local Court next week. In a statement, police said they are "reviewing footage circulating on social media about an incident involving a NSW Police officer on Majara Street, Bungendore, about 2.50pm, on Tuesday 22 July 2025".
