
US judges skeptical of Trump ending Venezuelan migrants' legal status
A three-judge 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel in Pasadena, California, heard arguments in the administration's appeal of a March ruling that blocked the cancellation of temporary protected status (TPS) for Venezuelans pending a challenge by advocacy group National TPS Alliance.
The U.S. Supreme Court in May stayed that ruling by U.S. District Judge Edward Chen in San Francisco pending the 9th Circuit appeal. The Trump administration would likely immediately appeal a 9th Circuit ruling against it to the Supreme Court.
TPS is a humanitarian program that allows individuals to live and work in the United States temporarily due to unsafe conditions in their home countries, such as armed conflict or environmental disaster. The administration of Democratic former President Joe Biden first granted TPS to Venezuelans in 2021, citing high levels of crime due to political and economic instability.
On Wednesday, all three judges on the 9th Circuit panel expressed concerns about the manner in which Noem abruptly eliminated TPS status for Venezuelans days after taking office in January, and just two weeks after the Biden administration had extended the program until October 2026.
'How can the country conditions have changed so drastically in that two-week period and the review by the new administration have been done so quickly?' Circuit Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw, an appointee of Democratic President Bill Clinton, said to Drew Ensign of the U.S. Department of Justice.
Ensign pointed to Noem's comments that the Biden administration's reasoning in extending the program was "thin and inadequately developed" and violated legal requirements for the TPS program.
'Agencies have the inherent authority to reconsider decisions as long as it's done in a timely manner,' Ensign said.
Circuit Judge Anthony Johnstone countered that if the Biden-era policy was legally flawed it could be challenged in court.
'If it's a legal concern have the lawyers deal with it,' said Johnstone, a Biden appointee. 'But what you can't do is disguise that as a policy reason when there's not otherwise authorization to do so.'
And Circuit Judge Salvador Mendoza, also a Biden appointee, questioned whether racial animus motivated the decision. He pointed to comments by Noem and Trump, which he said "arguably are racist," that Venezuela had intentionally sent people to the United States from prisons and mental health facilities, and Noem's comments in a television interview that Venezuelan immigrants were "dirtbags."
Chen in his March ruling had cited the same comments in finding that the decision to cancel TPS protections for Venezuelans "smacks of racism."
Ensign on Wednesday said most of the comments came before Trump and Noem took office in January and so were not close enough in time to when the decision to eliminate TPS was made to bear on the case and that Noem had only referred to Venezuelan gang members as dirtbags.
Ahilan Arulanantham, who represents the TPS Alliance, told the panel that the federal law creating the TPS program does not allow for determinations to be revisited once they are made except to fix minor typographical or factual errors.
'This scheme was designed to give stability and some amount of certainty for refugees,' he said.
TPS status had been granted to about 250,000 Venezuelans in 2021 and 348,000 more in 2023. Chen's ruling only applies to the latter group because their status was set to expire in April. The other recipients could lose their legal status and associated benefits in September if the policy change survives court challenges.
At least four other lawsuits have been filed challenging Noem's termination of TPS protections for Venezuelans and Haitians.
The case is National TPS Alliance v. Noem, 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 25-2120.
For the plaintiffs: Ahilan Arulanantham of UCLA School of Law Center for Immigration Law and Policy
For the government: Drew Ensign of the U.S. Department of Justice
Read more:
Judge blocks Trump administration from stripping deportation protections for Venezuelans
US Supreme Court lets Trump end deportation protection for Venezuelans
US judge blocks Trump from invalidating 5,000 Venezuelans' legal documents
Trump is targeting Temporary Protected Status. What is it?
US judge blocks Trump from ending Temporary Protected Status for Haitians
Court rejects Trump bid to end Venezuelan migrants' legal status
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
19 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
BREAKING NEWS Ghislaine Maxwell 'didn't hold back' about over '100 people' linked to Epstein during secret Trump DOJ meeting
Jeffrey Epstein associate Ghislaine Maxwell 'didn't hold back' in answering every question President Donald Trump's Justice Department threw at her over the last two days. Maxwell, 63, completed a second day of interviews with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche on Friday afternoon. Attorney David Oscar Markus claimed that his client spoke with Blanche about '100 different people' related to Epstein's child sex trafficking ring. 'They asked about every possible thing you could imagine – everything,' Markus insisted. He also said Maxwell is being used as the 'scapegoat' in the entire Epstein case and has been 'treated unfairly for the last five years.' Blanche flew down to Florida on Wednesday as President Donald Trump 's administration continues to take heat for the alleged 'cover-up' of the Epstein files review. The No. 2 at the Justice Department met at the courthouse in Tallahassee, Florida on Thursday with Maxwell, who is serving a 20-year sentence for her crimes. After their meeting, he announced on X that he would have a second day of meetings with Maxwell and her attorney on Friday. Markus said on Friday that Maxwell has not asked for anything in exchange for speaking with the government about what she knows. 'No offers have been made,' he assured. 'We haven't asked for anything.' 'She literally answered every question,' Markus went on. 'She was asked maybe about 100 different people, she answered questions about everybody and she didn't hold anything back.' It's not clear when the DOJ will release what was learned in the meetings. Markus said Maxwell is grateful to have met with Blanche. She is continuing to appeal her sex trafficking conviction. The latest effort was opposed by the DOJ last week as she sought for the Supreme Court to take up the case, arguing that she shouldn't have been charged due a 2008 plea deal Epstein struck with the court. On Thursday after their meeting with Blanche, Markus said that Maxwell answers every question the deputy AG had for his client. President Donald Trump was about a potential pardon for Maxwell on Friday morning amid Blanche's meetings. 'I'm allowed to do it, but it's something I haven't thought about,' the president responded. Outside the courthouse in Tallahassee on Friday a plane flew overhead with a banner reading: 'Trump and Bondi are protecting predators.' Markus detailed the poor conditions he says his client has experienced over the last five years since Epstein's death in prison on August 10, 2019. He said Maxwell was 'treated like an animal' in prison and 'woken up every 15 minutes.'


Daily Mail
19 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Biden's ex-chief reveals Hillary Clinton approached him with worries about Joe's decline a year before the election
Senior Democrats close to Joe Biden told his former chief of staff that the then-president was on the decline, a source revealed to Daily Mail. Ron Klain, who was Biden's chief of staff for the first two years of his presidency, told lawmakers on Capitol Hill how Hillary Clinton and Biden's former National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan told him that the president was not 'politically viable' in 2024, a source said. Klain, 63, sat for a transcribed interview on Thursday with the House Oversight Committee, as part of Chairman James Comer's probe into whether former Biden officials intentionally hid signs of the president's decline. A source familiar with the interview told the Daily Mail that Klain, in his testimony, said both Clinton and Sullivan raised concerns to him in 2023 and 2024 about Biden's political chances for a second term. 'Mr. Klain stated President Biden's memory got worse,' over the course of his presidency, the source said, adding the former chief of staff admitted that 'Biden was less energetic and more forgetful but he still had the acuity to govern.' Additionally, 'Sullivan told Klain that Joe Biden was less effective in 2024 compared to 2022.' Clinton did not serve in Biden's administration. But Sullivan was in near daily contact with the then-president in his role as Biden's principal foreign policy aide. A spokesperson for Clinton did not respond to the Daily Mail's request for comment but did not dispute Klain's account to CNN, telling the network Clinton was concerned with how the question of Biden's age was being handled politically in light of the attacks and questions he was facing. Biden dropped out of the race in July of last year after his disastrous debate with Donald Trump in June 2024, where he froze on stage and struggled to answer questions. A spokesperson for Sullivan pushed back on Klain's account of the timing of their conversation. 'Jake did not have a conversation with Ron about Joe Biden running for president before the debate,' Adrienne Watson, a representative for Sullivan, told Daily Mail. Klain, unlike other Biden staffers, did not plead the Fifth amendment and answered the lawmakers' questions in his appearance before the House Oversight committee. The interview took placed behind-closed doors. Despite leaving government service after two years in the White House, Klain had an up close view of Biden in the final years of his presidency and was considered a key outside adviser. He was among the aides who helped prepare Biden for that infamous debate, running 'debate camp' at Camp David. Biden's struggles during that debate supercharged questions about his health and mental well-being that had been circulating for months. Several Democratic leaders - including Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi - questioned his ability to remain as the party's nominee and moved to push him out of the race. Hunter Biden, the former president's son, told a podcast earlier this week that his father had been given the sleep aid Ambien ahead of the debate because of a harrowing travel schedule that preceded that contest. 'I know exactly what happened in that debate,' Hunter Biden told YouTube creator Andrew Callaghan on Monday. 'He (Joe Biden) flew around the world, basically the mileage he could have flown around the world three times. He's 81 years old.' 'They give him Ambien to be able to sleep. He gets up on the stage and he looks like he's a deer in the headlights,' the younger Biden added. But Klain said he was unaware whether Biden took Ambien the evening before the June 2024 presidential debate and relayed that 'the president appeared tired and ill before the debate.' There are more interviews with Biden's former staff on the docket as Republicans probe a possible coverup of the president's health and Comer has threatened to use a subpoena to entice testimony. Comer's witness list includes the most powerful figures in the Biden White House, such as aides with unfettered access to the residence where the president lived with Jill Biden and those who handled Biden's daily schedule. Several have already appeared before the lawmakers - and many invoked their Fifth Amendment right to decline to answer questions. Annie Tomasini, Anthony Bernal, Jill Biden's top aide and Dr. Kevin O'Connor, Biden's personal physician, all pleaded the Fifth Amendment.


The Independent
20 minutes ago
- The Independent
Education Department says it will release billions in remaining withheld grant money for schools
The Trump administration is releasing billions of dollars in grants to schools for adult literacy, English language instruction and other programs, the Education Department said Friday. President Donald Trump 's administration had withheld $6 billion in funding on July 1 as part of a review to ensure spending aligned with the White House's priorities. Officials later said the department would release $1.3 billion of the money for after-school programs, days after 10 Republican senators sent a letter imploring the administration to allow frozen education money to be sent to states. The Education Department said Friday the administration had completed its review of the programs and will begin sending the money to states next week. ___ The Associated Press' education coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at