Sinn Féin TD denies taking 'tactical wee' during Special Criminal Court debate
A Sinn Féin TD has denied taking a 'tactical wee' in order to miss his opportunity to call a Dáil vote on the Special Criminal Courts.
Matt Carthy was absent from the Dáil chamber on Wednesday afternoon when a debate on the Special Criminal Court was passed without a vote.
Sinn Féin traditionally voted against the non-jury court when the legislation came up for renewal every year.
However, for the last number of years, it has abstained from the vote as new reforms were under consideration.
On Wednesday, the debate ended more an hour earlier than expected as there were no more speakers in the Dáil chamber.
Ceann Comhairle Verona Murphy stated that she had to call a vote on Sinn Féin's amendment but there was a 'difficulty in that Deputy Carthy has stepped out'.
Junior Minister at the Department of Justice Niall Collins, who had declined an opportunity to speak and conclude the debate, stated that 'that is the way it goes'.
A vote on the amendment was not called and those present in the Dáil Chamber then agreed to pass the legislation underpinning the Special Criminal Court without a vote.
Mr Carthy returned and asked if he could move his amendment and that he was absent as he 'had to take a call'.
However, the Ceann Comhairle told him that she 'did not know if you were coming back' and that it was too late.
Speaking on the Leinster House plinth on Thursday, Mr Carthy admitted that he had actually gone to the toilet and missed the end of the debate.
However, he denied that it was a 'tactical wee', a reference to the Australian children's TV show Bluey.
He said: 'It was just one of those occasions. There was a very long debate. I was there for the vast majority of it.
'There was a number of groups left to speak, including several independent TDs, a number of government speakers, and the Minister of State, Niall Collins, was to give a closing address.
'I stepped out to answer nature's call, to be quite frank about it. While I wasn't there, the minister saw an opportunity and didn't take his opportunity to give a closing address.
'The independents who were due to speak weren't present, and therefore he was able to ensure the passage of the legislation without any vote.
'I thought it was petty to be honest, but that is politics.'
He added: 'No, [it wasn't a tactical wee]. It was a tactical position on the part of the Minister of State. It was what we call an old fashioned political stroke.'
Government sources, however, denied that there was any 'stroke', arguing that there was also a Sinn Féin speaking slot that Mr Carthy and other TDs were not present for.
They also suggested that he 'effectively got rid of opposition speaking time' as the Sinn Féin slot was skipped and independent TDs missed their slots that were pushed forward as a result.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
12 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Plans to redevelop GPO a betrayal of history, says Sinn Féin
Plans approved by the Government to redevelop the GPO in Dublin city have been branded a shameful betrayal of Ireland's proud revolutionary history by Sinn Féin. Earlier this week the Government backed plans to redevelop the GPO into a mixed-use precinct, to include possible retail components, offices, the retention of a post office and significant cultural use. Sinn Féin said the Government wants to turn the GPO into a shopping mall and is turning its back on the rich revolutionary history associated with the building. On RTÉ's This Week, Louise O'Reilly said Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael cannot be trusted on this. "To take the Louvre in Paris for example, they protect and preserve their heritage," she said. "How we treat the GPO is a measure to how we respect and treat the history and culture of our capital city." "This is an issue that is very, very dear to Dubliners and to every person that lives on this island." "This will be resisted," added Deputy O'Reilly. "We're bringing a motion to the Dáil on Tuesday and I would encourage all people to engage with it. We need to preserve the GPO. It is a site of incredible historical importance." In response, Fine Gael's James Geoghegan said that it is the Government's intention that it "would be put into museum, cultural use" . "Of all manufactured rows Sinn Féin has been involved in, this one really takes the biscuit" he said. "The GPO is not the building of any political party," said Deputy Geoghegan. "The GPO is the most important building in the foundation of our state. It's a monument to the heroism of the most ordinary people in this country." "In the GPO, right now, there are 25 retail units along the Henry Street end of the building," he added. "The GPO building is an enormous building. In truth what the building has been, until relatively recent time, has been our general post office. "What we're talking about it how do we make the GPO a place that is filled with people again... and reflects the importance of that building to the foundation of the state."
Extra.ie
13 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Housing minister drops plans for €1m social homes
The government has been urged to abandon its 'expensive' approach to social housing and to fund councils directly after it emerged that the cost of building some local authority units has soared to more than €1m. Sinn Féin housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin was speaking after it emerged the Department of Housing pulled the plug on the construction of almost 500 social homes in Dublin, Wicklow, Kildare and Sligo after the cost of each home rocketed to over €1m. And the delivery of almost 3,000 new social homes – 2,000 of which are in the capital – will now be delayed after Housing Minister James Browne cancelled several projects about to begin construction over cost concerns. James Browne Pic: Gareth Chaney/ Collins Photos The Construction Industry Federation said the move could threaten the public-private partnership (PPP) model and have implications for major projects such as Metro North. Mr Ó Broin told 'As far back as 2019, Sinn Féin warned that the use of public-private partnerships for social housing delivery did not represent value for money.' The Dublin Mid-West TD said it is 'somewhat ironic that the Government is now collapsing PPP Bundle 3 on value-for-money grounds. 'As a result, up to 3,000 much-needed social homes are delayed'. Eoin Ó Broin. Pic: Niall Carson/PA Wire He added: 'The Government should never have used this model for social delivery. They should abandon this expensive approach entirely and fund the councils directly to deliver these 3,000 homes as a matter of urgency.' Housing Minister James Browne yesterday said he is 'determined to deliver' the social homes. He told 'We are assessing the quickest way to do this while ensuring value for taxpayers' money. I am cutting down on the jungle of red tape that is leading to delays and exceptionally high costs.' Rory Hearne. Pic: Niall Carson/PA Wire However, Social Democrats housing spokesman Rory Hearne said the Coalition 'has gone from incompetence to sabotage'. He told 'In a bizarre, almost GUBU moment, the Government has suspended a delivery project that was going to build almost 500 social homes, almost 200 of which are in my constituency, through public-private partnerships. They were ready to start on site in the coming weeks but the minister has pulled the plug on them. Almost 3,000 social homes are now in jeopardy. 'In fact, the Government spent €8m on developing these projects. Contractors had almost been appointed. The not-for-profit housing bodies had been brought on board. It is absolutely confounding as to how this decision was made. It is beyond comprehension.' Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín added: 'This is another example of drift in how we do housing. There is a need for urgent practical reform, such as ending VAT on houses, that will end this vicious cycle of indolent incompetence.' The latest housing setback comes as the Government is under increasing pressure to remove planning roadblocks that are hindering its pre-election promise to deliver 300,000 new homes by 2030. Pressure is switching from Mr Browne to Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers, whose Accelerating Infrastructure Taskforce is due to deliver its first report over the coming weeks. The Coalition is also under pressure over the delayed implementation of the 906-page planning reform legislation, the Planning and Development Act 2024. Figures supplied by Mr Browne in response to parliamentary queries from Mr Ó Broin reveal just 77 sections of the legislation have so far been introduced. It means that, eight months after the Bill passed, 560 sections of the legislation have still not commenced. Commenting on the chaotic planning, Mr Ó Broin said: 'The crazy thing is, the problem with the Planning Bill of 2000 was that it was too complex. The previous government's solution to this was to replace it with a 900-page Bill with 700 commencements, 200 of which were rushed through.' He added: 'It was all guff and spin. It has been progressing at a snail's pace since. We have ended up with a Frankenstein's monster of unworkable and contradictory legislation. We asked two years ago: will a Bill that is nearly 1,000 pages long resolve this? And we have our answer now.'
Extra.ie
13 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Outgoing TDs claimed €750 phone allowance - just weeks from election
Three former high-profile Fine Gael TDs applied for a €750 mobile phone allowance in their final weeks in the Dáil after declaring they would not be seeking reelection, can reveal. Former senior ministers Charlie Flanagan and Michael Creed, as well as ex-Minister for State Brendan Griffin, all made claims under the Direct Purchase Scheme last November, just ahead of the general election. And their former party leader, Leo Varadkar, also sought to be reimbursed €750 in mobile costs just days after he stepped down as Taoiseach, and was therefore eligible to avail of the scheme as a backbench TD. Leo Varadkar. Pic: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin Under the scheme, TDs and senators can purchase a mobile phone and car kit from a provider of their choice with the option to claim back the cost, up to €750 over an 18-month period. However, the move by retiring Dáil deputies – all of whom will enjoy lucrative State pensions – to avail of the scheme as they were heading for the exit doors of Leinster House was described as 'shameless' this weekend. Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín called on the former TDs to 'repay what they received immediately'. Peadar Tóibín. Pic: Collins The Meath West TD told 'Acts like this seriously compromise the moral authority of TDs, especially when it comes to auditing excess across Government.' A spokesperson for Labour leader Ivana Bacik also said it was 'not an appropriate use of public resources given that the then [Oireachtas] members were retiring'. They added: 'It doesn't look like a mistake, and it's difficult to defend. It should go without saying that this ought not have happened, and it would be advisable that they cover the costs of the devices themselves.' Figures obtained under Freedom of Information legislation confirm that Mr Flanagan, a former Minister of Justice and Minister for Foreign Affairs, issued a claim on November 6 to be reimbursed under the Direct Purchase Scheme for mobile phone expenditure of €773.89. This was just over a month after the then Laois-Offaly TD announced on September 26 that he would not be contesting the election. Michael Creed. Pic: Sam Boal/ On November 1 – a week before the election was called – former Agriculture Minister Michael Creed issued a claim after he spent €970 on a mobile phone handset and screen protector. This was just more than a full six months after the ex-Cork NorthWest TD declared he would not be running for the next Dáil. And the pair's party colleague and former Minister of State for Tourism and Sport, Brendan Griffin, issued a claim for expenditure of €1,489 under the scheme on November 8, the day the general election was called. Brendan Griffin. Pic: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin The former Kerry TD had stated as far back as January 31, 2023, that he intended to quit politics. Other retiring TDs also benefited from the €750 allowance in the final months of their Dáil careers. Louth Independent Peter Fitzpatrick – who announced his intention not to seek re-election on August 30 last year – issued a claim on October 21 after providing a receipt for €767.99 expenditure under the scheme. Leo Varadkar. Pic: Leah Farrell/ On July 8, as he was readjusting to life on the backbenches, former Fine Gael leader Leo Varadkar issued a claim for €750. Eight days later – on July 16 – Mr Varadkar confirmed his intention to quit politics altogether. His former deputy party leader and ex-Housing, Foreign Affairs and Enterprise Minister, Simon Coveney, issued a claim of €299.89 for a handset on April 12, 2024. The then Cork South Central TD officially called time on his political career three months later, on July 10. Chartered accountant and political expenses campaigner Enid O'Dowd said the actions of retiring TDs who claimed the taxpayer-funded perk just weeks before they exited the Dáil 'may be technically legal, but it is shameless'. 'It is also unnecessary. Politicians get substantial goodbye money when they leave, significant payments, and ample pensions; they do not need an allowance to get a mobile phone, something everyone else manages to acquire without an allowance.' Ms O'Dowd said that, as 'significant public figures, they should be setting a much better example'. She added: 'How can politicians have the moral authority to deal with issues like the bicycle shed when they set this sort of example? It compromises their authority when dealing with overspending and un-necessary perks in other organisations.' In response to our Freedom of Information request, Paul Moore of the Oireachtas One Stop Shop which co-ordinates TDs and senators' salaries, staffing, allowances and audit procedures, confirmed the total cost of the Direct Purchase Scheme between June 2024 and April 2025 was €30,713.04. The Direct Purchase Scheme is just one of the many perks and expenses that TDs are entitled to claim on top of their basic €115,953 salary. Senators, who are paid €79,614 for what is essentially a part-time role, are also entitled to claim back mobile phone expenditure under the scheme. However, senior cabinet ministers who earn a basic salary of just over €210,000 and junior ministers – who are paid €162,799 – are not eligible. Politicians clawing back their mobile costs must 'certify that the expenses claimed have been actually and necessarily incurred by me in relation to my membership of Dáil Eireann and Seanad Eireann' on the Oireachtas claim form. A total of 33 TDs and 19 senators applied for the €750 allowance during the period from June 26 last year until April 2. Defending his decision to avail of the €750 perk just weeks before he departed the Dáil, Brendan Griffin told 'My work phone broke when I was moving out the boxes and files from my office in Leinster House. My work didn't stop then; we had two further months of work in my office, concluding live cases and files for constituents and community groups right into the new year.' Charlie Flanagan said he 'spoke to the authorities before and got the green light'. Leo Varadkar said: 'I needed a new phone to continue my work as a TD for so long as I was one. I had to return all my government devices to the Department of the Taoiseach.' Peter Fitzpatrick said: 'Well, I was due a new mobile phone so I just applied for it.' Former ministers Creed and Coveney did not reply to requests for comment. An Oireachtas spokesperson said all claims under the scheme are 'subject to an application with receipts and proof of expenditure (by credit card receipt, extract from bank statement or bank processed cheque) for all the expenditure incurred. Proof of purchase and payment should confirm that the purchase and payment was made by the Member'.
