US Justice Department 'weaponization' reviews spark calls to drop prosecutions
FILE PHOTO: United States Department of Justice logo and U.S. flag are seen in this illustration taken April 23, 2025. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo
WASHINGTON - As the federal public corruption prosecution of former Tennessee House Speaker Glen Casada neared trial this spring, his lawyers made one last effort to kill the case, by petitioning senior Justice Department officials that it was "weaponization," according to three people familiar with the matter.
Under President Donald Trump, the department in February created a "Weaponization Working Group" meant to identify improper politically motivated cases, a response to what the Republican says without evidence was the misuse of prosecutorial resources against him under his Democratic predecessor, Joe Biden.
In court filings, prosecutors said that Casada's lawyers met with a senior Justice Department official on March 24, where they alleged the "Deep State" had initiated a "weaponized" prosecution and they sought dismissal of the charges.
The plan almost worked, according to three people familiar with the matter.
With the Deputy Attorney General's office poised to kill the case, prosecutors in the Justice Department's Public Integrity Section pushed back, reviewing their evidence with the higher-ups, the sources said, adding that the Nashville U.S. Attorney's office and the Criminal Division also supported the case.
The request was rejected the next week, according to court filings. Both Casada and the DOJ declined to comment.
The case is among at least seven Reuters identified where defense attorneys or Justice Department officials have sought to have prosecutions reviewed for possible dismissal, citing Trump's "weaponization" argument or making other arguments about weaknesses in the cases.
In a Tuesday speech, Acting Assistant Attorney General Matthew Galeotti urged defense attorneys to be "conscientious about what, when and how" they appeal prosecutors' decisions.
"Seeking premature relief, mischaracterizing prosecutorial conduct, or otherwise failing to be an honest broker actively undermines our system," Galeotti said.
The increase in lobbying started not long after the Weaponization Working Group was created, and after the department's February decision to dismiss criminal corruption charges against New York City Mayor Eric Adams, six sources familiar with the dynamic told Reuters.
To date, the Adams case is the only one to be dismissed over 'weaponization,' three of those sources told Reuters.
The lobbying wave comes as the Trump administration has dramatically scaled back the Justice Department's Public Integrity Section, reduced the size of its foreign bribery unit and advised department attorneys that tax enforcement is "not a priority," two of the people familiar with the matter said.
A department spokesman said the DOJ will "continue to enforce our nation's tax laws."
Trump has said the changes are necessary to root out Justice Department lawyers he derides as 'hacks and radicals' for prosecuting him and some supporters while he was out of power.
NEW GROUP HAS BROAD REMIT
The working group is empowered to review any 'civil or criminal enforcement authority of the United States' exercised under Biden.
A lawyer for Robert Burke, a former Navy admiral who was convicted in May on bribery charges, wrote to the department ahead of trial raising concerns about witness credibility, which failed to convince prosecutors to drop the case.
Now the lawyer, Tim Parlatore -- a former Trump defense lawyer -- plans to seek a pardon.
"I would be crazy not to at least inquire about a pardon," Parlatore said.
Another example is a case involving billionaire Britannia Financial Group founder Julio Martín Herrera-Velutini, who is facing an August trial alongside Puerto Rico's former governor on bribery charges.
Herrera-Velutini is represented by former Trump defense attorney Chris Kise, who has sought to convince the Justice Department to dismiss or reduce the charges, though the outcome of such efforts is unclear, three people familiar with the case told Reuters. Kise did not return requests for comment, and Reuters could not determine what arguments he has made to the department about the case.
WEAPONIZATION REVIEW
While many of the reviews of cases are spurred by aggressive lobbying, some requests are coming from within the DOJ.
In early February, prosecutors in the department's Tax Division were ordered by senior Justice Department officials to write a memo explaining why the prosecution of Paul Walczak was not an example of "weaponization," two of the people familiar with the matter told Reuters.
Walczak, of Florida, pleaded guilty in November to not paying employment taxes and not filing his individual income tax returns, and the trial team was preparing for his sentencing.
Prosecutors were baffled, the people said, and only discovered after a few Google searches that Walczak's mother Elizabeth Fago was a Trump donor who, according to a New York Times report, hosted a political fundraiser where portions of a diary written by Biden's daughter Ashley were circulated.
The department let the case proceed, and Walczak was sentenced to 18 months in prison. Trump in April spared him any prison with a pardon, which according to the New York Times, was handed down shortly after Fago attended a $1 million fundraising dinner for Trump.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment on the pardon.
An attorney for Walczak said he was unaware of any interactions by the defense team with the Weaponization Working Group. In a statement, the Fago and Walczak families said media reports have painted an "incomplete and inaccurate" picture of the pardon application, and that Trump had "ample grounds to grant the pardon on the merits."
Although no criminal prosecutions have been dismissed, prosecutors are bracing for impact since Trump in May named Ed Martin, a supporter of Trump's false claims that his 2020 election defeat was the result of fraud, to lead the working group and serve as pardon attorney.
Martin has already successfully encouraged Trump to approve pardons for some of the president's supporters, according to his social media posts.
Casada, who was convicted at trial in May on multiple counts of fraud, money laundering and bribery, is now expected to seek a pardon, a person familiar with the matter said.
"We've also been getting more folks coming forward within the government as well as outside, saying, 'Can you look at this? Can you look at that?'" Martin recently told reporters.
"It's a problem that seems to be growing faster than we can capture it." REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
Japan auto trade ‘unfair', could buy more US oil, Trump tells Fox News
JAPAN engages in 'unfair' automobile trade with the United States and should increase its imports of US energy resources and other goods to help reduce the US trade deficit, President Donald Trump said in an interview broadcast on Sunday. Tokyo is scrambling to find ways to get Washington to exempt Japan's automakers from 25 per cent automobile industry-specific tariffs, which are hurting the country's manufacturing sector. Japan also faces a 24 per cent so-called reciprocal tariff rate starting on July 9 unless it can negotiate a deal. 'They won't take our cars, and yet we take millions and millions of their cars into the United States. It's not fair, and I explained that to Japan, and they understand it,' Trump said in an interview on Fox News' Sunday Morning Futures with Maria Bartiromo. 'And we have a big deficit with Japan, and they understand that too. Now we have oil. They could take a lot of oil, they could take a lot of other things.' The automobile sector accounted for about 28 per cent of the total 21 trillion yen (S$185 billion) worth of goods Japan exported to the US last year. REUTERS
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Can donors fill the major budget holes that colleges face under Trump?
Harvard University saw a surge in donations in the spring after its president pushed back against the Trump administration PHOTO: SOPHIE PARK/NYTIMES WASHINGTON - The T.H. Chan School of Public Health at Harvard University has not been disguising its plight. 'With Harvard's federal funding frozen, we are relying on philanthropy to power our research and support our educational programs,' the school's donation website says. 'Your ongoing engagement is vital to keeping our mission on track.' The Trump administration's decision to block billions of dollars in research money to certain colleges is forcing administrators and their fundraising teams to scrounge for cash. As schools across the country contemplate layoffs, lab shutdowns and other drastic steps, they are weighing how much the gaps can be plugged by private philanthropy – and how pointedly political their pleas for donations ought to be. A handful are wagering that the financial rewards of trying to leverage donors' concerns about the federal cuts will outweigh the risk of antagonising the White House. In an April 30 note to alumni, Brown University President Christina H. Paxson said about three dozen of its grants and contracts had been cancelled, and that the government had stopped funding many research grants. She said news reports stated that the Trump administration had threatened an additional US$510 million (S$650.5 million) in grants and contracts to the university. The moves, she wrote, represented 'a significant threat to Brown's financial sustainability'. She urged alumni to lobby lawmakers about the issue and added links for making donations to the university, including to support research whose federal funding was cancelled or delayed. (Brown said data was not yet available for release about whether giving had increased as a result.) Many other institutions have opted for more caution. Mr Ted Mitchell, president of the American Council on Education and a former leader of Occidental College, suggested that some schools may be worried about turning off right-leaning donors who may agree with President Donald Trump's opinion that academia has tilted too far to the left. Some schools would like to emphasise the political attacks in their fundraising appeals, Mitchell said, 'but their donor base is at least purple, if not red, and it's tough for them to make a really anti-Trump statement and keep their donor base.' A White House spokesperson, Mr Harrison Fields, said colleges and universities should address their financial problems by tightening their belts. 'If these higher education institutions were serious about lowering costs,' he said in an emailed statement, 'they would cut the bloated salaries of their faculty and stop wasting money on useless programs that do little to advance education.' Universities have been grappling for months with sudden losses of research funding that cumulatively threaten thousands of jobs and an array of carefully planned projects. Relationships with donors can be fickle and fleeting, and many of the wealthiest donors have complex financial pictures with overlapping interests. And while universities collectively pull in billions of dollars in gifts each year, some of their causes are easier sells than others. Student financial aid, for instance, is a reliable attraction for donors. Scientific research, on the other hand, is a notoriously tricky target in fundraising efforts, though some of the biggest gifts are tied to the sciences. Even if appeals to bolster threatened research could raise millions of dollars, it might not be enough to replace the hundreds of millions or even billions that colleges and universities stand to lose in the federal cuts. Harvard, for example, said that in its 2024 fiscal year, it received about US$528 million in current-use gifts. In that same period, the university received about US$687 million from the federal government for research. Harvard received a surge in donations this spring after its president wrote a scathing letter to the Trump administration, according to the university's student newspaper, The Crimson. The university did not provide data on donations for this article. Even so, private fundraising by colleges and universities seems unlikely to be enough to fill the void. 'I think we can be sure that the amount of money would not come close to replacing what has been suspended,' said Mr Lee C. Bollinger, who has served as president of Columbia University and the University of Michigan. 'You're not going to make that up with donations.' One task for college leaders is to discern how much they should emphasise politics in their appeals, whether in public solicitations for money or private meetings with their biggest givers. Referring to the Trump administration's funding cuts, Mr Bollinger said, 'I think universities, broadly speaking, have been very clear in saying this is an overreach and an assault and intrudes into areas of academic decision-making and is part of a broader effort to break down the norms.' Still, he added, 'I don't need to go in and talk to a donor and make the case that we're up against authoritarianism and we really need your help. I think it can be much more delicately handled than that.' One looming question for higher education is whether this burst of government hostility, however long it lasts, will force a wholesale rethinking of how to fund universities. Mr Bollinger has found himself wondering whether institutions should routinely designate a portion of the contributions they take in as 'a fund to support freedom of the university when it's under assault'. Such a strategy, he conceded, would have limits. 'Over time, you could build up a substantial reserve – a rainy-day fund, but for these kinds of assaults,' he said. 'But it would only get you through a period of time.' Trump administration officials, among others, have urged universities with multibillion-dollar endowments to tap them to replace lost federal money. But there are often restrictions on how a university may use its endowment money. In many instances, donors have attached conditions to their contributions, specifying that the money go toward a specific discipline or department. And now a Republican-backed bill moving through Congress may increase the taxes that universities pay on their endowments. NYTIMES Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Idaho firefighters shot at while responding to blaze, governor says
The firefighters were responding to a small brush fire that broke out in the Canfield Mountain nature area when they came under gunfire. PHOTO: KEVIN DALTON/X Idaho firefighters shot at while responding to blaze, governor says BOISE, Idaho - Multiple firefighters were attacked on June 29 when responding to a fire in north Idaho, Governor Brad Little said, asking people to stay away from the area. 'This is a heinous direct assault on our brave firefighters. I ask all Idahoans to pray for them and their families as we wait to learn more,' Mr Little said in a post on X. He did not give further details on any casualties or how the incident unfolded. 'As this situation is still developing, please stay clear from the area to allow law enforcement and firefighters to do their jobs,' Mr Little added. Local news reports citing police scanners stated that multiple firefighters had been shot - but this could not be immediately confirmed by Reuters. Calls to the Kootenai County Sheriff's Department, along with the Coeur d'Alene Fire Department, city police and Idaho state police were not returned. The Kootenai County Emergency Management office issued an alert for citizens in nearby areas to shelter in place. Kootenai County Sheriff's Lieutenant Jeff Howard told ABC News that firefighters were responding to a small brush fire that broke out in the Canfield Mountain nature area on the eastern side of the city when they came under gunfire from somebody in a nearby wooded area. Mr Howard said that officials were investigating whether the fire was deliberately set. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
